Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

Mattress Comparison Shopping

There is one main goal with the Mattress Comparison Charts…find you the best price.  If you saw something you liked in a store, you can probably find a cheaper price online.

Retail mattress stores often make it difficult to comparison shop mattresses. Each retailer will have a different name for the same (or almost the same) product. Here are some tables to help compare brands and find the best price.

Please note the following before using the comparison charts:

  • It’s possible that some of the models aren’t exact comparisons. Companies sometimes put some kind of small “exclusive feature” in their mattress like an anti-microbial cover, or they change a layer of foam slightly. These should be considered “comparable models,” not necessarily exact.
  • Make sure you’re comparing the prices for the same size and whether or not a boxspring is included.
  • The price of the mattress shouldn’t necessarily be your only concern. Consider exchange/return policies, delivery fees, and delivery time in your decision.

This is only a few of the biggest retailers. There may be some other options, but these are the sites that I have found to be the most competitive.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Comments (232)

  1. Any answer yet as to my question regarding Stearns and Foster pillow top, Villa Ascoli? Need to purchase as soon as possible.

    • Hi Arline,
      Are you just looking for something comparable but cheaper? Or is there a specific retailer you would like to purchase from and trying to find the name under that store?

      • Not looking for cheaper. Just want to know if it is comparable to estate palace or any other Stearns and Foster.

      • Yes. Trying to buy it from Value City Furniture. Wondering if it is comparable to
        Stearns and Foster Estate Palace.

  2. I wish your mattress quiz was a little more flexible. I’m a back sleeper, but my wife is a side sleeper. Both of us are over 200 lbs. Our current mattress is a Sealy Posturepedic “Lore” model (which I can’t seem to find any details about online, so I think it may be a discontinued model) that we’ve had for about 3 years, and has some indenting on my side.

    Do you have any recommendations? We are open to most anything, moderate price range, and also considering adjustable bases.

    (The current mattress is under warranty, and I think the indentations are deep enough to qualify for a replacement, but I’m also guessing that the store will fight us, as this one is itself a warranty replacement for a previous model)

  3. Dear Jack,

    I have been looking for a mattress and box spring for our spare room and ran across a queen size Sealy Posturepedic “Harrington Ltd. plush” that looks and feels like a brand new mattress. I’m trying to find out what level and firmness it was classified as but can’t find any information on it. I’d like to send you a picture of the label but can’t seem to attach one here.
    I don’t see or feel any issues along the edges like what you would expect from a person sitting on the edge or end over the years. It also feels uniform from side to side and in the middle. It quite frankly feels like no one has ever slept on it. Do you know anything about this line?

    Thanks and Happy New Year!

  4. The sleep center store in my city has a Stearns and Foster there are calling a trailwood. I don’t not see this on your list.
    What is it comparable to?

  5. I’m trying to find a mattress comparable to the IHG St. Chappelle mattress at Holiday Inn Express. Can you assist me? Queen with Box spring bottom.

  6. I am trying to find a comparable mattress and box springs to a Restonic Queen . The Lexington Pillowtop is the model in the Comfort Care Line. The closest retailer to where I live is 300 miles , so I am trying to find a comparable product closer to my town. The skeu # ME 66750 as listed on the Restonic site.
    I would appreciate any information

  7. Can you do a comparison guide to the mattresses at Costco with the same beautyrest models since I found that they have the best prices on the mattresses most of the time.

  8. So, looking for the national model name for the MattressFirm Beautyrest Black “Tolliver”. OR the direct compatible since the Hybrid is only MattressFirm.
    TY

  9. We purchased a bed from MattressFirm in July, 2009 and we have LOVED it. The only problem… it’s a queen and we’ve decided we need a king! Could you advise which current mattress from the Beautyrest line would be most comparable. And if possible, where we could a good price. It’s a Beautyrest Medalist, Parr Plush, 13″, 980 coil count, memory foam. It appears to me Thanks!

  10. We purchased a bed from MattressFirm in July, 2009 and we have LOVED it. The only problem… it’s a queen and we’ve decided we need a king! Could you advise which current mattress from the current Beautyrest line would be most comparable. And if possible, where we could a good price. It’s a Beautyrest Medalist, Parr Plush, 13″, 980 coil count, memory foam. It appears to me Thanks!

  11. We purchased a Beautyrest from MattressFirm in July, 2009 and we have LOVED that bed. The only problem… it’s a queen and we’ve decided we need a king! Could you advise which current Beautyrest would be most comparable. It’s a Beautyrest Medalist, Parr Plush, 13″, 980 coil count, memory foam, with a 10 yr warranty, Thanks!

  12. Hi. Saw a Sealy cedar Ave twin size at ramour and Flanigans. Wondering what other names that mattress goes by.

  13. I am interested in the Serta I comfort hybrid blue fusion tight (not pillowtop 200 from Macys. What is holding me back is the sides are not reinforced. I must sleep on my side with a pillow between my knees as I have back and disk problems. What would you suggest? Thank you for your advice. Also, is Sterns and Foster a hard mattress in general and worth the money?

  14. I want to purchase a Sealy Blue Mesa Plush Pillowtop Mattress from Ashley Furniture, but their delivery options don’t work. I’m looking at 1-800 mattress that doesn’t seem to carry Sealy, and US mattress but can’t figure out what their name for this mattress would be. Can you help? thanks!

  15. Saw a Stearns and Foster Estate model called Scarborough which is not listed on your comparison chart. Are you aware of alternate names for this mattress? Also the store owner referred to numerical levels for Stearns and Foster and I’m confused as to what the numbers mean. ( 1 through 4 I believe). Thank you

  16. Costco has a Stearns and Foster Hope Bay mattress and I can’t find any comparisons. So what can you compare it to and what kind of rating do you give it?

  17. Any idea how to find a mattress comparable to the Stearns and Foster Rose Night? My boyfriend and I slept on one in his sister’s guest room, and it was the best night of sleep either of us had ever had. I know it’s discontinued, but tell me there’s something close that we can find now! Thanks so much!

  18. Any idea about Costco’s Sealy posturpedic Response Premium West Salem Cushionfirm Queen Mattress and Foundation?

  19. Need a mattress/bed option for my 84 yr old mom with copd, swollen ankles she needs to elevate. Needs to be a full or queen and be able to add an easy bed rail. I’m so stressed out trying to find a bed for her that is safe, comfortable and easy to get in and out of.
    Any recommendations? Note, she can use a remote as long as it is simple.
    Thank you!

  20. Hello,
    I bought the Westin Heavenly Bed about 15 years ago and loved it. Gave it to my sister when I moved out of state. I would like to find a comparable bed (plush, with a pillow top) for far less money. Any suggestions?

  21. Good Morning =)
    My name is Lisa J and I bought a mattress at Mattress Firm. A Queen size Dream Bed Lux 510 for $ 1,877.81 and I was wondering if it is being sold for less than what I was sold to for? How can I found out? How do I compare it to others? Please help plus is this really a good mattress?
    Thanks
    Lisa J

  22. I want a foam top and coil innerspring with cooling comfort. I have been to mattress firm and want to know how I shop at sam’s club or sears and which would be better “Sealy, Serta, or beautyrest or if they are the same?
    I also am heavier and do not shop on line…. so looking for supportive queen that will be slightly better for pain etc..

By continuing to browse or by clicking “OK” you agree to the storing of first- and third-party cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Privacy Policy.

OK