Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

Sealy Posturepedic 2016 Comparison Guide

As you may have noticed, it’s difficult to comparison shop for mattresses between retailers because they often have different names for what seems to be the same exact mattress. Or, the retailer will claim their mattress is an exclusive, or their model has some feature that nobody else has that makes it different. How then will you take advantage of the price match guarantees that so many places offer? We’re here to help!

(Note: The 2015/16 models have been discontinued and replaced as of early 2017. Click here for the 2017 models).

Have you considered an online brand?  Here are some of our favorites, or if you’d prefer scroll down to view the comparison chart.

Sealy Posturepedic is one of the biggest name brands of mattresses around. They come out with new models roughly every year or two. The new models came out in early 2015, so this guide will help compare 2015 Sealy Posturepedic models among several of the biggest retailers.  As you may have noticed (and as I’ve talked about before on this site), mattress retailers try to make it difficult to comparison shop by giving their mattresses different names than what the same thing will be at another retailer.

The following is a chart that compares the names of the mattresses at various retailers. You’ll notice there are a few levels of Posturepedic. The two biggest categories are “Posturepedic” and “Posturepedic Plus.” The “Plus” models have an upgraded coil system. (You’ll also notice two lower end models at the top of the chart as well; those are better for guest rooms and the like). This will help you comparison shop for the lowest price so you don’t pay a penny more than you have to.

This table is out of date. See this link for the 2017 Sealy models

 US MattressSearsMattress FirmMacy'sCostco
638 Classic CoilsInland Greens-Ashlin FirmKirby Hill Firm-
Posturepedic 704 CoilsSanta Paula Firm-Caversham Firm--
Santa Paula Plush----
Paula Firm Eurotop--Clearbrook Cushion Firm Eurotop-
Santa Paula Plush Eurotop-Caversham Eurotop--
Cooper Mountain Firm---Aldercrest Firm
Cooper Mountain Cushion FirmChargrove Cushion Firm-Grant Park Cushion Firm-
Cooper Mountain PlushChargrove PlushChaleigh PlushGrant Park Plush-
Cooper Mountain Cushion Firm EurotopChargrove Cushion Firm Pillowtop-Grant Park Cushion Firm Pillowtop-
Cooper Mountain Plush EurotopChargrove Plush Pillowtop-Grant Park Plush PillowtopAldercrest Plush Eurotop
Posturepedic Plus (825 coils)Archer Glen FirmHearst Firm---
Archer Glen Cushion Firm-Deveraux Cushion Firm--
Archer Glen Plush----
Archer Glen Cushion Firm Eurotop---Meadowdale Cushion Firm Euro Pillowtop
Archer Glen Plush Eurotop-Deveraux Plush Pillowtop-Meadowdale Plush Euro Pillowtop
Warrenville Ultra FirmLeola Ultra Firm-Market Street Ultra Firm-
Warrenville FirmLeola Firm-Knotty Pines Firm-
Warrenville Cushion FirmLeola Cushion Firm--Ashton Cushion Firm
Warrenville Plush--Market Street Plush-
Warrenville Cushion Firm Euro PillowtopLeola Cushion Firm Pillowtop-Knotty Pines Cushion Firm Euro Pillowtop-
Warrenville Plush Euro Pillowtop--Knotty Pines Plush Euro Pillowtop-
-Glenborough Firm---
Barrett Court Cushion FirmGlenborough Cushion FirmSedgebrooke Cushion Firm--
Barrett Court Plush----
Barrett Court Cushion Firm Euro PillowtopGlenborough Cushion Firm Pillowtop--Charter Pointe Cushion Firm Euro Pillowtop
Barrett Court Plush Euro Pillowtop-Sedgebrooke Plush Pillowtop--

Some notes about this chart:

  • It’s possible that some of the models aren’t exact comparisons. Companies sometimes put some kind of small “exclusive feature” in their mattress like an anti-microbial cover, or they change a layer of foam slightly. These should be considered “comparable models,” not necessarily exact
  • Make sure you’re comparing the prices for the same size and whether or not a boxspring is included
  • The price of the mattress shouldn’t necessarily be your only concern. Consider exchange/return policies, delivery fees, and delivery time in your decision.
  • This is only a few of the biggest retailers. I don’t have the time or the space to include ~100 different retailers across the country. So, if you tried out something at a local store that you want to compare, contact me through my free comparison shopping service and let me comparison shop for you. 

There are several things you can do with this chart. If you saw something you liked in a store, you can find a cheaper price online. Then, either get the local store to match or beat that price, or just buy it online and save money. Or, if you were shopping online for a mattress, but you wanted to try it out in a store first, you can see which stores have it to try out.

If you have any questions, or want to share a success story, leave it in the comments below!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Comments (155)

    • Is that a very old one? The only place I see that on a google search is somebody selling an old used one, and then a blog post from 9 years ago.

  1. Seally premium mattress there are circles with symbols inside them I think 4or5 must be the features but one looks like a card with star looking things on upper corner what feature is that

  2. Hello,
    Could you please tell me what Sealy mattress is comparable to the Sealy Posturepedic Auburn plush?
    Thank you,
    Colleen

  3. I bought a Sealy Kelburn outlet mattress from Mattress Firm. They delivered the box springs today but not the mattress, that will come in 3 days. I’m afraid the box springs don’t belong with it , just has number 612086 on it. Is that compatible with the Kelburn? Total was 900.00 I’m also afraid if it sags on me that I’m stuck. No returns. Any advice?

  4. Is Sealy mattress posturepedic, king size, Ashton MFG stay in form well? Anybody have experience on this, please? There’s MFG discount of $100.00 at Costco this week. Thank you. Jill

  5. Can you tell me the difference between the Sealy posturpedic select hybrid peacefield king mattress set and sealy posturepedic grant park limited 14 inch cushion firm pillow top mattress set?

  6. We would like to replace our current sealy posturepedic, sterling enchantment ultra plus pillow top with something similar. California king. Open on brand. Has been a great bed but well over 10 years old. Thank you

  7. We stayed at a hotel on the borderline of Indiana while visiting Chicago and their mattress was totally amazing! My problem I’d like to purchase one for my home but the problem is I can’t find it anywhere. Can you please help, it’s a Sealy Posturepedic Artesia HD cushion firm mattress?

  8. Is the Costco —
    Sealy Posturepedic® Plus Series Ashton Cushion Firm Mattress Item #1022154 also 13″ $579.99 mattress only

    the same mattress as

    Sealy Posturepedic Plus Deveraux 13″ Cushion Firm Mattress at Mattress Firm?

    I see really mixed reviews on the Costco one, some people love it, others hate it.

    Thanks

    • We were looking at the Deveraux firm with pillow top. We loved it. It’s on sale right now for 1499 at matrresfrim and it’s 1099 in Costco ( well I think it is). Would love to know too? Such mixed reviews. I can’t picture this mattress dipping in the middle. Wonder if they are mattress firm employees?

  9. I’m confused. I want to buy a new mattress for our guest room for my mother-in-law. She went to the place she bought her mattress and likes the “Posturepedic Plus Devereaux 14″ pillow top” mattress. I’ll buy her whatever she wants. When I look at your chart, does it mean that the laterally listed mattress are comparable or the same?? Please advise.
    Thanks
    Amy

  10. I work in the industry and thoroughly enjoy this website. It does appear that you have some issues with specialty retail stores. Please keep in mind that the name game existed long before there were mattress only retail stores. You also have little to say about license agreements, distribution, and warehousing differences between retailers. To me, the most important factor to ensure customer satisfaction is that they receive a factory fresh new mattress that was handled and stored properly. Most online retailers are way behind the curve in that regard.

  11. I’m trying to find a comparable replacement for a Sealy PP Bellezza Plush #6872 that was bought in 2012. Do you know if it was a posturepedic or a posturepedic plus? Some Google results have said it’s the same as the peppermill drive or the Cooper mountain, but I’m not sure if that’s true or not.

  12. A lot of bad reviews for the stearns abs foster mattresses regarding sagging prematurely. Loved how they feel in the store but the reviews make me concerned. When I asked a sales person at the store they said they revamped the mattress and corrected the problems, do you know if this is true?

    • It’s tough to tell without waiting a few years for the complaints to come in, but I just don’t trust S&F. They put all of their effort into picking materials that “sound luxurious,” but don’t necessarily increase the quality of the mattress.

  13. Two years ago, we looked for a mattress and were nearly sold on the Larkin Lane from Macys. Then we went to Sears and saw the mattresses were all much cheaper for what appeared to be comparable models, but we couldn’t figure out which one was most like the Larkin Lane, and the customer service at Sears was unbelievably bad. We decided we just couldn’t justify spending $1000K on a mattress at Macys when we had other financial priorities (student loans, saving up for a downpayment on a house, and a baby on the way), and we did not feel comfortable making a major purchase from Sears. In the end, we became burned out and frustrated by the mattress buying process. We’ve stuck it out on that horrible mattress for two more years and are now looking for a mattress once again. We still really like the Larkin Lane. Which of the current models do you think would be most similar?

    • None of the new ones will be the same. Sealy overhauled their Posturepedic lineup in 2015, so none will be exact. They’d be vaguely similar to the ones in the rows that begin with Cooper Mountain, but it is by no means the same mattress. (By the way, there were 3 Larkin Lanes… firm, firm pillowtop, plush pillowtop. I don’t know which one you mean).

  14. Hi MattressNerd,

    We need help! We slept on our in-laws guest bed recently and fell in love with the mattress. We want to have it at our house. The retailer in Kentucky is called Sleep Outfitters and the mattress was a Sealy Posturepedic Lewisburg Cushion Firm. Where we live in NC there are no Sleep Outfitters. Could you tell us what this is called at Sears or Mattress Firm or somewhere else?

    Thanks!

    • we are particularly wondering if it’s the same as Sears’ “Sealy Posturepedic PLUS Leola Cushion Firm Tight Top Queen Mattress”

  15. Thanks for your prompt reply! I totally agree with you but please comment on the Sealy Posturpedic Cherry Hill Cusion Firm Eurotop (it wasn’t on your list- may have replaced Clearbrook that is no longer available). The price for this is significantly different than the Hartfield/Mona BeautyRest so I wanted your opinion if the Beautyrest is that much better, since laying on them, they seemed the same.

    THANKS!

  16. Thanks for all your help! All comments very helpful. I’m buying a bed for my 14 yo, upgrading to a full.
    Thought I decided on a Beautyrest Harfield from Mattress Firm that is $808 out the door with delivery and tax but went to Macy’s to compare with Mona that is $789 plus tax and delivery and I think it is the same. Then I notice a Sealy Posturpedic Cherry Hill Cusion Firm Eurotop (it wasn’t on your list- may have replaced Clearbrook that is no longer available) that I really like the comfort. It was much less expensive ($489). What should I do? How do I compare them?

    Thanks!
    I’d love not to spend $800 If I don’t have to .
    So confused.
    Lisa

    • To decide on which one is better for you, you have to lie down on the mattress and see how it feels on your side and on your back. You don’t want it so firm that it causes pressure to your body, soft enough that it contours to you, but not so soft that you sag into it like a hammock.

  17. Thank you for all of the helpful information on your site. I’m trying to decide between the Sealy Posturepedic Charter Pointe from Costco or the Sealy Posturepedic Hybrid Silver from Sears. I believe that the Hybrid is from Sealy’s Premier line versus the Plus from Costco but is it worth the large price difference?
    I am a side sleeper and my wife sleeps on her side and her stomach.
    Please advise.
    Thank you

    • The difference is also in the surface layer. The Silver is in the hybrid line, which means it has a thinner “quilt” layer and you’re closer to the foams. If you tried that one and liked it, I’d recommend that one.

  18. What difference between firm and cushion firm, e.g. Knotty Pines Firm at Macy’s vs. Ashton Cushion Firm at Costco?

  19. Saw the Hawthorne at Costco for 399 for the full set on sale and Wynstone cushion firm eurotop at Sam’s for 389 for mattress only. Looking for a full size for son to carry to college. Not looking to spend a fortune but want something decent. Any opinions about these two?

  20. I am looking to buy something comparable to the Sealy Posturepedic Santa Ana Plush from either Sears or Penneys and am having trouble. Thank you!!

    • That’s a model that came out in 2013 and almost nobody sells that anymore, other than Sleepy’s and its online sister companies. The Posturepedic lineup underwent a major overhaul in 2015, so the new models you’ll find at Sears won’t be the same as the Santa Ana.

  21. I liked the Sealy Plush Pillow Top Deveraux at Mattress Firm because it seems pretty firm underneath–which I want. The reviews reflect that it is firmer than its name suggests. The Costco Meadowdale Plush Euro Pillowtop, cross referenced in your chart, is deeply discounted this week and Costco has a favorable return policy. However, their reviews say it is softer than expected and lots of people are returning it. So what’s the difference between them that they get such drastically different reviews?

    • There is no difference between them, and in any case, Mattress Firm has a price guarantee. Take the Costco price to them and have them beat it by 10%. If they claim it’s not the same mattress, have them explain to you what the difference is, since you can see that the layers match up exactly. If they give you a hard time and refuse to price match, then maybe you can go to Costco.

      The Costco reviews don’t make a lot of sense, because they have never tried the mattress. You can’t really try them in Costco, so if the mattress is softer than what they expected, it’s because they have no clue what to expect. It was a completely blind purchase.

      • Thanks. I was thinking of purchasing at Costco because their return policy appears better than Mattress Firm’s. Costco’s satisfaction guarantee is unconditional so if the mattress is a dud in the first year or so (within reason) then perhaps one won’t have to prove the body impressions are deep enough for a warranty claim plus they offer a full refund. Is Costco’s satisfaction guarantee really that good?

By continuing to browse or by clicking “OK” you agree to the storing of first- and third-party cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Privacy Policy.

OK