Mattress Warehouse Review: Top Picks and Buyers Guide

Mattress Warehouse Overview

Mattress Warehouse is a brick-and-mortar mattress retailer based out of Frederick, Maryland that has stores across the eastern seaboard of the United States. It’s their mission to provide guests with a relaxed and educational buying experience that results in improved quality of sleep through the best products at the best prices. 

They carry a variety of quality brand name mattresses from manufacturers like Serta, Sealy, Tempur-Pedic, Aireloom, and more. If you’re on the lookout for a new mattress and plan to shop at a Mattress Warehouse store near your town, this guide should help. We’re revealing our top five mattress brands available at Mattress Warehouse along with a brief guide to shopping at this popular mattress retailer. 

Top 5 Mattresses at Mattress Warehouse

• Tempur-Pedic: Best Luxury
• Stearns & Foster: Best for Couples
• Sealy: Best Variety
• Aireloom: Best Ultra-Luxury
• Kingsdown: Best Hybrid

Reason to Buy

If you’re shopping for a master bedroom or have an expansive budget for your mattress, look no further than Tempur-Pedic. The company offers multiple firmnesses, thickness, and composition options, and all Tempur-Pedic mattresses have superb durability. Their motion isolation makes them excellent for couples, and side, back, and stomach sleepers will experience pressure relief on most models. Keep in mind that Mattress Warehouse may update which of Tempur-Pedics are available in various stores and on the company’s website from time to time, so speak with a Mattress Warehouse representative to make sure you’re informed as to which options are available. All Tempur-Pedic mattresses sold by Mattress Warehouse come with the manufacturer’s 10-year warranty.

Reason to Buy

Mattress Warehouse offers a selection of Stearns and Foster’s hybrid mattresses, such as the Hurston, Rockwell, Polluck, and Hepburn. These mattresses outpace almost all others in terms of noise, edge support, motion isolation, and conforming properties. They lack in the category of durability, but their competitive pricing in comparison to other luxury models may allow some shoppers to overlook this. Sterns and Foster mattresses purchased at Mattress Warehouse come with a 10-year warranty.

Reason to Buy

Sealy mattresses are a safe bet if you’re unsure of the type of mattress you’re looking for. If you plan to stop into a Mattress Warehouse store, a salesperson should be able to guide you toward the Sealy option that suits your needs and budget. Sealy has an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau, and according to sites like Amazon and Consumer Affairs, shoppers are generally very satisfied with their purchases. Sealy mattresses come in sizes Twin to California King, range from as low as $299 to as much as $2,500 in price, and come with Sealy’s 10-year warranty. 

Reason to Buy

If you have no qualms about spending thousands on a mattress, you’ll enjoy this brand’s selection. Online, Mattress Warehouse offers seven Aireloom mattresses, and more models may be available in-store. Most Aireloom mattresses feature a cooling Tencel cover or quilt layer, comfort layers with Aireluxe foam, and a support system of individually wrapped coils. Unfortunately, limited information about Aireloom mattresses is available online, so you’ll need to visit a Mattress Warehouse store to learn more.

Reason to Buy

Kingsdown was founded over a century ago, but they’ve created an innovative bedMATCH system that creates a personal profile for buyers to select the proper mattress. They’re affordable for a luxury brand, with Kingsdown Queen size mattresses with a starting price point of roughly $1,300 and a maximum price of roughly $2,500. However, some customers note that a few models only last three to four years due to sagging, with the thicker pillow-top models being the most troublesome. If you opt for a Kingsdown from Mattress Warehouse, consider a two-sided model to improve durability and longevity. 

Mattress Warehouse Shopping Experience

The details of the shopping, delivery, setup, and payment experience are just as important as picking out the mattress. Here’s what you need to know about shopping at Mattress Warehouse.

They offer free in-store pickup, or you can pay $99 for local delivery. National delivery is available for $199, and whether you’re charged $99 or $199 will depend on your home’s distance from a Mattress Warehouse location. Tempur-Pedic deliveries are free regardless of where you reside.

This store is relatively accessible, with hundreds of locations across the eastern United States. They offer a price match guarantee on all their products and financing options if you’re unable to pay for a mattress in full on the day of purchase. Mattress Warehouse also sells a variety of bedding accessories, so if you’re upfitting you’re entire bedroom, it’s a one-stop shop.

Mattress Warehouse offers no sleep trial with its mattresses, and products are not returnable. However, the friendly customer service in stores tends to all but guarantee that shoppers wind up with a mattress they’re pretty satisfied with. Any mattress you purchase will come with the manufacturer’s warranty.

Online Alternatives

Internet retailers have become a major player in the mattress industry. You can buy directly from the mattress company or from an online retailer, like Amazon. The main advantage to shopping online is that you can easily comparison shop and review prices, customer feedback, specs, and more. 

If you’ve already pinned down the mattress you want, consider buying your mattress from Amazon. They offer a 30-night sleep trial unless otherwise stated with any mattress purchase (while brief, this is better than Mattress Warranty’s complete lack of a sleep trial). Refunds and exchanges are also available, and some customers will be eligible for free delivery depending on their Prime account membership status and the mattress they purchase. Other major online retailers to explore include CostCo, Walmart, Sam’s Club, and Overstock.

If you’d rather buy directly from the mattress company online, just know that you’ll be paying a premium. Some shoppers enjoy knowing that there’s no middle man, and some mattress companies even offer competitive advantages to incentivize buying through their websites, like free shipping, 100+ night sleep trials, and more. For example, Tempur-Pedic offers free delivery, a $300 credit, financing, and more for mattresses purchased directly from TempurPedic.com.

Pro and Cons of buying In a Store vs. Online

It’s a great day and age to be a mattress shopper. You have a wide range of stores and websites to choose from, including brick-and-mortar stores and online marketplaces. What’s the right method of mattress shopping for you? Review these pros and cons to find out. See: Mattress store comparisons

When buying online, you’ll have the option to buy directly from the mattress company or through a retailer. As we mentioned, the major advantage of online shopping is how quickly you can comparison shop. Open endless browser tabs to review prices, customer comments, policies, and more. Additionally, many mattress companies offer free shipping, trials, add-ons, and other benefits when you buy directly from their website. Online retailers may not offer as many benefits, but they make comparison shopping especially easy with things like search filters, reviews and star ratings, and comparison tools. Additionally, some coupons and discounts are only eligible online. 

The main disadvantage of online shopping is that you can’t test out the mattress you’re leaning toward. This can be a big gamble, especially if you’re selecting an expensive luxury mattress for the first time. If it’s your first rodeo, heading into a brick-and-mortar store might be your best bet. You’ll get the full tactile experience of lying on a mattress, pressing into its comfort layers, and speaking with a salesperson about recommendations and any questions you have about brands, materials, and firmness ratings. 

On the downside, retail stores have more overhead costs, like rent and sales personnel, so they tick up the cost of their mattresses to account for this discrepancy. Additionally, salespeople, who are paid on commission, can be pushy, leading to an uncomfortable shopping experience. Lastly, buying from a brick-and-mortar location requires visiting the store in person, which can be an inconvenience if you’re in a remote location or don’t have access to transportation. 

For the best approach, we recommend combining the two. Head into a mattress retailer to test out a variety of beds. Try various brands, firmness levels, and types and then head home to comparison shop once you’ve narrowed the search down to two or three favorites.

Conclusion

While Mattress Warehouse doesn’t necessarily offer anything special for customers, they do have a nice selection of brands and mattress models, and their A- Better Business Bureau rating means they’re worth a shot, in our opinion. If you have a Mattress Warehouse store in your town and you’re interested in the brands they carry, consider it a safe stop along your mattress shopping journey, whether it becomes the place where you try a few on for size or the place where you make your final decision and purchase.