Best Mattress Guides

Best Mattresses for Lower and Upper Back Pain

Is back pain keeping you up at night? In this guide, I’ll help you find the best mattress to provide pain relief and get a good night’s sleep every night.

By Daniel Grogan

Mattress Nerd consulted Vivian Eisenstadt, MAPT, CPT, MASP to ensure that this article met our editorial standards

If you’re getting the recommended 7 to 8 hours of sleep per night, you’ll spend one-third of your life in bed. That makes the mattress you choose one of the most important factors in the quality of your life. If your sleep quality is suffering, and not providing you pain relief, the importance of investing in the right mattress increases drastically.

In this guide, I will review the most important factors to consider when purchasing a new mattress for back pain relief. I will also dive into the specifics of each of our top picks, and help you decide which might be the best choice for you. So, if you have a bad back, explore our top picks for the best mattress for back pain in 2021, and discover which may aid in your pain relief!

Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

Best Mattresses for Back Pain in 2021

Editor’s Pick: Layla

Layla

Editor's Pick
The original Layla memory foam mattress features two sides with different firmness options: one soft and one firm. Its copper-infused foam helps to cool the mattress and increase recovery times.
Score
4.7 / 5.0
Firmness

Soft Side & Firm Side

Trial period

120 days

Warranty

Lifetime Limited Warranty

If at first, you don’t succeed…flip it over.  That’s definitely not Layla’s official slogan, but it’s what I like most about a flippable mattress.  

Stomach sleeping is finicky.  It’s often touted as the worst sleeping position.  But…it’s comfortable. So how can we make it as harmless as possible?  Find a mattress that supports the proper way and doesn’t put undue stress on your back.  That typically means a firmer mattress.

Layla has a firmer and softer side, to appeal to many, but the reality is, this is all relative depending on the person.  I’m confident that between the two sides, you’ll find one that is a good fit for a stomach sleeper. Layla is also one of our picks for the best bed in a box

See our full Layla Mattress Review to learn more!

Best Mattress for Back & Neck Pain: Bear Hybrid

Bear Hybrid

Best for Back & Neck Pain
The Bear Hybrid mattress captures all the most coveted features in a mattress and jam packs them into this state-of-the-art hybrid. The cooling gel memory foam continuously carries away heat, promising you a cooler, more restful night’s sleep.

Often times if you suffer from back pain, you may suffer from neck or hip pain as well. Many mattresses have cracked the code to remedy back pain, but the Bear Hybrid was constructed to also accommodate those with neck pains. This mattress is especially good for sleepers who live an active lifestyle since it combines support, piano relief and comfort all in one bed.

The Bear Hybrid is good for heavy sleepers, couples, and every sleeping position. It is a thicker than average mattress, so if you like a taller bed you will be a big fan of the hybrid version of the Bear.

See out full Bear Hybrid Mattress Review to learn more. 

Best Mattress for Side Sleepers with Back Pain: Helix Midnight Luxe

Helix Midnight Luxe

Best for Side Sleepers
We rank the Helix Midnight Luxe among our best mattresses for side sleepers. Zoned support provides the hips, shoulders and neck with just the right amount of cushion to keep the spine aligned and ensure you wake up pain-free. Plus, it's 2 inches thicker than the standard Midnight.
Score
4.8 / 5.0
Firmness

6

Trial period

100 nights

Warranty

15-year warranty

Helix does an incredible job of being inclusive with their products.  They have a variety of customized options so shoppers can find what’s just right. So it’s no surprise they have a model that fits the bill for back and hip pain. We recommend the firmer options for individuals with back pain, but if you prefer a more cradling feeling, one of the medium-firm options may work well for you.  Helix also comes with a 10-15 year warranty. 

Read our full Helix Midnight Mattress Review to learn more!

Best Mattress for Lower Back Pain: Saatva Classic

Saatva Classic

Best for Lower Back Pain
Saatva is one of the first direct-to-consumer online mattress companies. The Saatva mattress is not a “bed-in-a-box” company, because it doesn’t come in a box at all. It’s a regular innerspring mattress delivered to your door by delivery professionals.
Score
4.7 / 5.0
Firmness

Available in soft, luxury firm and firm

Trial period

180 nights

Warranty

15 year

If you’re a fan of a more classic-style mattress, but still want relief from low back pain, the Saatva mattress might just be the right fit for you. The Saatva mattress has the innerspring base of a traditional mattress but with the newer, hybrid technology of wrapped coils, a plush pillow top, and memory foam. 

The Saatva mattress is designed to provide additional support to the middle third of the mattress where your lumbar region (i.e. lower back) would be. Additionally, an added foam layer of “visco-elastic” memory foam supports the areas most commonly associated with pressure points. It comes in a plush soft, luxury firm, and firm option. 

Whether you require extra support to relieve your chronic lower back pain, or simply prefer the firmness of a traditional-style mattress and the added benefits of pain-free sleep, the Saatva mattress is a great option.

See our full Saatva Mattress Review to learn more! 

Best Cooling Mattress for Back Pain: WinkBed

WinkBed

Best Cooling Mattress for Back Pain
WinkBeds is a family-owned operation that focuses on details to attract customers to their luxury mattresses, which are made to order in Wisconsin. The company believes so strongly in their mattress quality, that they attach a lifetime warranty to them.
Score
4.7 / 5.0
Firmness

Varies

Trial period

120 nights

Warranty

Limited lifetime warranty

The WinkBeds Original Mattress is an excellent choice for stomach sleepers with back pain. This mattress is available in four firmness levels; softer, luxury firm, firmer, and plus. We recommend the firm option for stomach sleepers with back pain, so the hips will not sink too much. The mattress is complete with a proprietary lumbar layer; this mattress is engineered to keep the spine aligned in every sleeping position, the WinkBed will ease all your aches and pains. What’s more, the WinkBed mattress includes a Triple Layer Heat Disperse technology system that includes a cooling Tencel cover and breathable coils.

The mattress is also equipped with a 3-step back relief system, meaning it has zoned support throughout the length of the mattress. It will fill in areas of the back that need more support and give comfort to the areas which need more cushioning.

See our full WinkBeds Mattress Review to learn more. 

Best Mattress for Upper Back Pain: Brooklyn Bedding Signature

Brooklyn Bedding Signature

Best For Upper Back Pain
The Signature Hybrid mattress comes in three firmness options and is made with a slew of proprietary materials. Brooklyn Bedding know their mattresses.
Score
4.7 / 5.0
Firmness

5

Trial period

120 days

Warranty

10-year limited warranty

You’ve probably read it elsewhere on the site…I like Brooklyn products a lot.  They also offer quality goods thanks to their rigorous quality assurance process.

Brooklyn offers its Signature in soft, medium, and firm options.  While they’re not the only brand to do this, it’s still somewhat rare.  The beauty of this is that if you like the mattress materials, but it’s not quite the right feel, you can opt for a different firmness that fits your body type.  This is a fantastic option if you’re looking to relieve some pressure.

Combine the power of choice with Brooklyn’s 1024 premium wrapped coils and you have one supportive mattress.  Enjoy!

See our full Brooklyn Signature Mattress Review!

Best Medium-Firm Mattress for Back Pain: Amerisleep AS2

Amerisleep AS2

Best Medium-Firm
The best mattress from Amerisleep for stomach and back sleepers who like a medium-firm firmness level. This mattress is made to appeal to a wide range of sleepers and comes with a reasonable price point.
Score
4.8 / 5.0
Firmness

6

Trial period

100 nights

Warranty

20 years

Ranging from the A1 to the A5 model, these mattresses increase in price as you ascend. They are very transparent about the differences between each model, and which model is best suited for each type of sleeper. They have thought of everything from overheating, to pain relief, to overall comfort and have designed each of their mattresses with these concerns in mind. With free shipping in the U.S. and helpful customer support, Amerisleep is a great choice for a hybrid mattress!

The AS2 is their best model for back and stomach sleepers, and is one of their best selling models. Pain is not universal, so the ability to choose the firmness level you prefer all while still receiving the pain relief and support that you need is an amazing feature of Amerisleep mattresses. The AS2 is the perfect balance of firm and soft to keep you supported and comfortable. 

Check out our full Amerisleep Mattress Review to see which one may be best for you!


Back Pain and Sleep

If you have any experience with back pain, then you likely know the struggle of trying to fall asleep. The smallest movement can cause a jolt of pain that yanks you right out of a restful mindset. 

Unfortunately, we cannot claim that a better mattress will fix your back pain. If possible, we recommend you visit a doctor who can provide a treatment tailored to your specific situation. That said, your mattress may be one of many factors contributing to your condition, and replacing may not just make falling asleep easier, but may also lead to less pain throughout your days.

We’ll start off by briefly discussing different kinds of back pain before going into ways in which your mattress and your sleeping situation might be able to help back pain sufferers.

Types of Back Pain

It’s important to note that back pain comes in different forms. Once you are able to better classify your back pain, it may become easier to find a solution for it.

Chronic vs. Acute Back Pain

If you have noticed a recent onset of back pain that immediately followed a determinable event, such as lifting something heavy, overexerting yourself playing sports, or falling down, then it is likely acute back pain. Acute pain, as the name would suggest, is quite sharp and may not last as long as chronic pain, if properly treated. 

Chronic pain can occur when acute back pain is not properly managed. Though the symptoms are similar, chronic back pain can cause persistent discomfort in addition to the unexpected jolts of pain that are associated with acute back pain. Though it is not necessarily time dependent, if you have been experiencing back pain for several months then it has likely developed from acute pain into chronic pain.

Location of Back Pain

Lower Back Pain

Lower back pain, the most common type of back pain reported in the U.S. can be caused by a variety of factors and can range greatly in severity. This affects the region of the back that naturally curves in on most backs, also known as the “lumbar region.” This condition is made most manageable by a mattress or pillow that fills in the lower back and allows it to be aligned with the rest of the spine.

Middle Back Pain

Middle back pain is caused by many of the same triggers for lower and upper back pain, it just manifests itself differently depending largely on a person’s body weight and lifestyle. People with this condition often have more feelings of “overall” back pain, and can benefit from using techniques for both lower and upper back pain together.

Upper Back Pain

Upper back pain is the second most common type of back pain. Upper back pain can be caused by several things; poor posture, muscle overuse, injury, herniated discs, and much more. This type of pain can also impact the shoulders, and cause overall pain in the top parts of the body. If you are sleeping with this condition, make sure your neck and spine are aligned, and that your body is properly supported.

Proper Spinal Alignment

It cannot be stressed enough how important proper spinal support is in keeping your back pain free. A mattress that excels this will contour to your body in such a way that keeps your spine resting in its naturally curved position. If your spine gets thrown out of whack as you sleep, then you will likely wake up with aches as a result. 

Vivian Eisenstadt, CPT, explains, “…many times low back pain originates in the tight muscles of the low back, so full spinal support is imperative to a good night sleep where all the muscles in your back can rest and rejuvenate and heal you for the day ahead.”

There are a number of reasons why your spine might not be properly aligned as you sleep, it isn’t just a result of the quality of your mattress. Rather, your sleeping position, preferred mattress material, and your body type should all be taken into consideration when looking for the perfect mattress to keep your spine healthy.

Mattress Firmness

Mattress firmness should always be at top of mind when you are shopping for a new bed, regardless of whether or not you have back pain. How firmness works is, companies will grade each of their mattresses on a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being extremely soft and 10 being extremely firm. 

No firmness is inherently better than another one, but your personal preference as well as your particular situation will play a part in which firmness is most compatible with you. Firmness varies from person to person and mattress to mattress. You might prefer a firm mattress or a medium-firm mattress. You may want a combination of both. Perhaps a firm, supportive mattress with an added top comfort layer would be the perfect solution for you. For back pain, there isn’t one ideal firmness level. However, there are firmness levels that work better with different sleeping positions

Read our mattress firmness guide for more information.

Sleeping Positions

While it is not the end-all-be-all, sleeping position can absolutely have an effect on your back pain. The good news is that there are ways in which each sleeping position can improve your sleep, and hopefully help your back pain. 

Side Sleeping

Side sleepers put a lot of pressure on their shoulders and hips when they lie down, as these are the heaviest areas of their body that make contact with the bed. If you sleep on your side, you should look for a mattress that is on the softer end of medium-firm

At this firmness level, your shoulders and hips will sink just far enough into the mattress, but not so far that your spine gets thrown out of alignment. Not only can this help prevent or reduce back soreness, it can also help with shoulder pain. Take a look at our best mattresses for side sleepers article for more great options.

Back Sleeping

Back sleepers need something a bit firmer than side sleepers. Somewhere between 5 and 7 on the firmness scale tends to be right for them. It allows their shoulders to remain supported and their lower back to sink just far enough to maintain the natural curve of the spine. Also, it is still soft enough to help relieve pressure.

If you sleep on your back, a tip from Vivian Eisenstadt, CPT, is, “For Low back pain, you can sleep supine with a pillow half way under your buttocks to tilt your pelvis so your low back is more in connection with the mattress.”

Related: Best Mattresses for Back Sleepers

Stomach Sleeping

Stomach sleepers tend to need a mattress with a very firm feel, around the 7.5 or 8 range. That is because sinking into the mattress even slightly too much can lead to improper spinal support. 

Another problem that stomach sleepers might contend with is that they usually have to twist their head at an awkward angle in order to make comfortable contact with their pillow. Though it is far up on the body, this twisting can still have a negative impact. Vivian Eisenstadt, CPT, suggests, “For stomach sleepers, you can use a body pillow to hug so your neck isn’t rotated too much.”

Related: Best Mattresses for Stomach Sleepers

Different Mattress Types for Back Pain

Hybrid 

Hybrid mattresses are made of layers on top of a coil base. These are some of the best mattresses for those with back pain because they have a good amount of contouring to the body along with adequate support. Depending on what these mattresses are topped with, they have a decent amount of bounce and are easy to move around on. Our list of best hybrid mattresses has some of our favorite of this type of bed

Memory Foam

Memory Foam mattresses range in how they feel more than just about any other mattress. They have a great amount of give for the body to have a close contour in many spots. As long as memory foam mattresses are not too soft, they are usually good options for those with back pain, especially lower back pain since it can fill in the lumbar region. These mattresses are also typically good for those with hip and neck pain as well. Take a look at our best memory foam mattresses page for more info.

Innerspring

Innerspring mattresses are often referred to as “traditional” mattresses. They are made up of a coil base and are have a comfort top layer that is thinner than a hybrid mattress. These mattresses are very supportive and provide a lot of back pain relief. See our best innerspring mattress list if you’re interested.

Latex

Latex mattresses have gained popularity for their “all-natural” qualities, and their pressure point relief. Latex is naturally breathable and offers very sturdy support, making it good for those with all types of back pains. Head over to our best latex mattresses roundup for a more comprehensive look.

Other Things To Consider When Sleeping With Back Pain

While relief from chronic back pain may be your primary concern, there are other factors you’ll want to consider before you make your final decision. Here are some other components you may want to look for in a mattress when you’re narrowing down your options.

Body Type

Make sure you keep your body type in mind when looking for a mattress to help with your back pain. As mentioned above, the firmness of your bed can affect the quality of your sleep depending on your preferred position. Well, your weight plays a part in how firm a mattress feels to you. What feels soft to a larger person may feel uncomfortably firm to a petite person. Our heavy sleepers guide has more information that may prove useful in your buying journey.

Mattress Durability

As is the case for any mattress shopper, you’ll want to make sure you are investing in a quality product. The higher the quality, the likelier it is that your mattress will have high durability and be able to hold up under your weight for many years. If you get a mattress that begins to sag prematurely, this could contribute to worsened back pain.

Conclusion

Since you will spend a third of your life in bed, your mattress should be a good investment, particularly if you suffer from back pain. The right mattress can provide good support, relieve chronic back pain, and provide the restful sleep you need to be productive and energetic.

Choose a mattress that is specifically designed to treat your type of pain whether it is upper back, lower back, or hip pain. And while that may be the most important factor, it isn’t the only factor. You’ll also want to take into account your preferred sleep position and mattress type.

I’ve recommended mattresses that I feel could help with back problems, but your experience may be different from mine. The good news is that most mattress companies now offer sleep trial periods so you can be sure it’s the best match for you. If you are not ready to buy a new mattress yet, but still want to relieve some stubborn back pain, check out our picks for the best mattress toppers for back pain.

If you want to learn more about how and when to purchase a mattress, check out our Best Mattress Buying Guide.

Recap: Best Rated Mattresses for Back Pain

Mattress Award Nerd Score
Layla Editor’s Pick 4.7/5
Bear Hybrid Best for Back and Neck Pain 4.7/5
Helix Midnight Luxe Best for Side Sleepers 4.8/5
Saatva Best for Lower Back Pain 4.7/5
WinkBeds Best Cooling Mattress for Back Pain 4.7/5
Brooklyn Bedding Best for Upper Back Pain 4.7/5
Amerisleep AS2 Best Medium-Firm Mattress 4.8/5

Vivian Eisenstadt is part of our panel of medical expert contributors on the subject of sleep health. They provide important perspectives on the topics we discuss to help make our content as accurate and dependable as possible. They do not personally endorse any products, nor are they associated with any brands featured in our review content.


Comments (0)


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *