Tempurpedic vs Sleep Number Mattress Review

Tempurpedic vs Sleep Number Mattress Review 

Tempurpedic and Sleep Number are two of the most well-known mattress brands on the market. While both of these companies are recognized for creating excellent products, there are many factors that determine which type of bed is best for each individual.

That’s why we’ve created this helpful guide that compares the benefits of Tempurpedic and Sleep Number beds, from the materials and firmness rating, all the way down to the shipping and warranty policies. Read on to find out which mattress is best for you.

Mattress Highlights

Tempurpedic 

Who Should Buy this Mattress? 

The most popular option of the Tempurpedic mattresses, the Tempur-Adapt, is offered in memory foam and hybrid models. The all-foam model is ideal for heavier side sleepers and memory foam lovers, while the hybrid model is great for back and stomach sleepers, hot sleepers, people with back pain, and people who prefer support coils.

Read our full Tempur-Adapt mattress review to learn more.

Materials

You’ll find slight variations in the construction of the different types of Tempurpedic mattresses. The Tempur-Adapt uses a combination of dense poly foam, memory foam, and spring coils (in the hybrid version) to ensure maximum comfort, making it one of the best memory foam mattresses.

Firmness

Tempurpedic has mattresses ranging from soft to firm, but the Tempur-Adapt is rated as medium-firm, which equates to a 6.5 out of 10 on the firmness scale. 

Trial Period

Tempurpedic mattresses come with a 90-night trial period, completely risk-free. 

Warranty

There is a 10-year limited warranty on all Tempurpedic mattresses. If you notice any covered defects within that time period, they will repair or replace your mattress.

Price 

Depending on the size and materials of your mattress, the Tempur-Adapt can range between $1,699 and $3,398.

Nerd Score 

The Tempur-Adapt has a Nerd Score of 4.8 out of 5, and is considered a top-rated cooling mattress.

Sleep Number

Who Should Buy This Mattress? 

Sleep Number creates a variety of models to accommodate a wide range of sleepers. The most popular option, the 360 i8, is best suited for side or back hot sleepers who want one of the best cooling mattresses.

Materials

The Sleep Number 360 Smart Bed consists of a blend of polyester, polypropylene fabrics, making them soft and breathable. The top of the i8 mattress is a 6” foam comfort layer with two different types of foam to promote contouring, support, and pressure relief.

Firmness

Sleep Number beds utilize a function called a Sleep Number, which ranges from 0 (softest) to 100 (most firm). Via the Sleep Number app, you can control the firmness of your mattress with ease. The average firmness for Sleep Number users is between 30 to 60.

Related: Best Firm Mattresses

Trial Period

All Sleep Number mattresses come with a 100-night trial period.

Warranty

Sleep with peace of mind knowing that all Sleep Number beds are backed by a 25-year limited warranty.

Price

The Sleep Number 360 i8 ranges in price from $2,549 for the Twin XL, to $4,299 for the FlexTop California King. 

Nerd Score

The Sleep Number 360 has a Nerd Score of 4.7 out of 5, and is considered a top-rated mattress.

Tempurpedic vs Sleep Number

Key Differences 

• Tempurpedic mattresses utilize memory foam while the Sleep Number incorporates comfort foam.
• Sleep Number beds come with integrated air chambers, making them ideal for couples with different sleeping preferences. 
• Tempurpedic beds offer a hybrid option, which accommodate sleepers with heavier frames.
• Sleep Number mattresses can measure various sleeping patterns and habits, then customize their firmness to best suit the sleeper.

Key Similarities

• Both offer white-glove delivery and impressive warranty and trial periods
• Both come with a wide variety of options in terms of construction and materials
• Both are considered luxury mattresses

Tempurpedic vs Sleep Number Mattress Construction 

Tempurpedic Construction

Tempurpedic’s construction consists of a top cover made of premium knit fabric. The comfort layer comprises Tempur-ES foam to provide support and contouring, making it one of the best mattresses for side sleepers. The next layer incorporates adaptable TEMPUR foam. The final layer is a thick supportive section made of high-density foam to provide additional stability and durability. Tempurpedic mattresses range from 11” to 13” in thickness.

Sleep Number Construction

Sleep Number mattresses are made of a blend of polyester/polypropylene fabrics, making them soft and breathable. On the i8 model, the cover is a Duvet pillow top with 2” of Hypersoft Quilting Foam that provides surface temperature control technology.

Underneath the cover is the Comfort Layer, which is 6” of comfort foam that includes seven zones that contour to your body. The next level is where the air chambers are located, further providing cool temperatures for sleepers. Finally, there is a 1” base pad.

Who the Tempurpedic Mattress is Best For 

Best For…

• Combination sleepers with heavy frames
• People who want hybrid options  
• People who want white-glove delivery with lower shipping costs

May Not be Best For…

•  Hot sleepers
• Budget shoppers

Read our full Tempurpedic mattress review to learn more! 

Who the Sleep Number Mattress is Best For 

Best For…

• People who want flexible and adjustable sleeping options
• People who do not mind paying extra for comfort
• Back or side hot sleepers

May Not be Best For…

• People who prefer memory foam mattresses
• Couples that sleep close together

Read our full Sleep Number mattress review to learn more! 

Things to Consider When Picking A Mattress

Firmness / Feel

Sleep Number beds can be adjusted to multiple levels of different firmness, but most people find comfort in the medium firmness range. The comfort foam layer plus the collection of air chambers incorporated into the mattress make this ideal for hot sleepers who like to rest on their sides and backs.

Motion Isolation

Couples that share a bed find it frustrating when their partner tosses and turns because of the motion transfer. Tempurpedic beds, which incorporate memory foam, are known for their motion isolation, meaning less disturbance for sleeping couples. Sleep Number beds make some of the best mattresses for couples by allowing them to personalize their firmness on each side with 2 separate mattresses, so motion transfer is almost nonexistent. 

Edge Support

Edge Support is an important factor to consider for people who have trouble getting in or out of bed. Tempurpedic beds with spring coils have much more spring support than their pure memory foam counterparts, providing great edge support. Sleep Number mattresses can vary with their edge support depending on the level of inflation in the air chambers, but beds with thicker top layers tend to have less-than-favorable edge support.

Pressure Relief 

Tempurpedic mattresses and their memory foam construction have excellent contouring properties, meaning reduced pain in pressure points and increased pressure relief. Sleep Number beds with thicker comfort layers have been reported as offering better responsiveness and relief from pressure points, but Tempurpedic is ultimately the better option.

Spine Alignment 

Tempurpedic mattresses’ responsiveness promotes healthy spine alignment, resulting in less stress on pressure points and a much better sleep. Sleep Number’s customizable firmness allows for optimal spine alignment. 

Durability 

Both mattresses come with long warranties, but Sleep Number surpasses Tempurpedic’s 10-year warranty with a 25-year period. The specialized memory foam used in the Tempurpedic construction prevents your mattress from sagging over time, while Sleep Number’s adjustability also allows for an increased level of durability. Tempurpedic’s hybrid option is ideal for heavier sleepers due to the incorporated spring coils, which will prevent sagging in the long-term.

Temperature 

Tempurpedic’s memory foam mattresses offer exceptional comfort, but it can also cause sleepers to feel wrapped up in the material, making it difficult to stay cool through the night. Sleep Number’s mattress construction, which includes a layer of air chambers, makes it a better option for hot sleepers.

Sizing & Price Comparisons 

Shipping and Returns 

There are several prominent differences when it comes to shipping and returns between Tempurpedic and Sleep Number mattresses. Tempurpedic beds have a $25 shipping fee, which includes white-glove delivery. You can also request an old mattress removal, which is included in the shipping fee.

Sleep Number beds come with standard shipping for $89.99, or white-glove delivery for $199. If you choose the white-glove delivery option, your old mattress is taken away at no extra cost. With both mattress companies, customers are responsible for return shipping costs.

Other Models Available

Tempurpedic also offers a line of hybrid mattresses with extra support from coils. The biggest difference between memory foam and hybrid mattresses is that the latter is ideal for heavier sleepers who prefer a higher firmness level, more bounce, or just more support overall. 

Sleep Number beds are divided among three variations: Classic, Performance, and Innovation. The Classic comes with SleepIQ and Responsive Air technologies, while the Performance goes the extra step and provides additional relief for pressure points. The Innovation series also delivers a temperature balancing sleep surface to absorb excess heat and keep you cooler throughout the night.

Conclusion 

Both Tempurpedic and Sleep Number produce high-quality mattresses, but they each have strengths that accommodate different types of sleepers. For those who want better motion isolation, memory foam options, and accommodation for almost any type of sleeping position, the Tempurpedic is your best bet. If you are a hot sleeper who wants to be able to control and change their firmness, we recommend the Sleep Number bed.