Puffy Mattress Review

The Mattress Nerd’s Take: The Original Puffy Mattress was created to accommodate as many different sleepers as possible. The mattress is well balanced, without being too firm for side sleepers. It’s also plush enough to relieve pressure. This two-layer mattress has gel-memory foam, and high-density foam that minimizes motion transfer relatively well. If you and your partner have completely different sleeping preferences or styles, the Puffy is a nice compromise. Puffy claims that its mattress is like sleeping on a cloud, and we think it is a great memory foam mattress that won’t overheat and provides support for all average-weight sleepers.

Who Is the Puffy Mattress Best For?

1 = Very poor     2 = Not good     3 = Fair     4 = Good     5 = Excellent

Back Sleepers:

 The dense layer of polyfoam supports even weight distribution across the mattress. Lightweight and average-weight back sleepers will be supported by the pressure relieving foams and work against lower back pain. Those that already suffer lower back pain will find less pressure build up as you sink into the softer upper foam layer. 

Stomach Sleepers:

For the most part, stomach sleepers will need a firmer, more supportive mattress to prevent their hips from sinking and avoid spinal misalignment. As the hips sink too far, you may experience uncomfortable neck pain, especially heavier sleepers. 

Side Sleepers:

Strict side sleepers will find the medium-firm Puffy to provide pressure relief and a gentle hug around their hips and shoulders. The upper layers of the Puffy will cradle pressure points and conform around the natural curves of the body, making it a great mattress for side sleepers. 

Combination Sleepers:

The responsive nature of the Puffy and conforming foam layers will provide a balanced sleeping surface for combination sleepers. Depending on your sleeping position for the majority of the night, will determine if the Puffy is a comfortable mattress for you. For those that spend a majority of the night on their stomachs, the Puffy can best support lightweight sleepers in this category. However, for sleepers who shift from their backs to sides, they should find the transition layer

How Does the Puffy Feel? 

Responsiveness, Bounce and Ease of Movement 

The Puffy’s cloud-like feel will still provide some support and stability so sleepers do not feel like they are sinking into the mattress. Lightweight sleepers will avoid feeling stuck and can move around easily. 

As a memory foam mattress, indentions in the foam layers may take a little longer to return to normal, but the Puffy is still relatively responsive to changing positions. If you are looking for more bounce and less conforming, consider an innerspring mattress. 

How Firm is this Mattress?

The medium-firm nature of the Puffy makes it great for balancing pressure relief without sacrificing durability. The top comfort layer cradles the body while dense polyfoam prevents sleepers from getting stuck in the foam layers. Because of this support foam, we rate the Puffy at a 6/10 on our firmness scale. On our scale a 1 is the softest mattress and a 10 will be the most firm. 

Does it Sleep Hot?

Memory foam mattresses tend to sleep hot when compared to innerspring or hybrid mattresses. This is simply because thick foam layers trap the heat and don’t have anywhere for the air to flow. The first two layers of the Puffy are infused with cooling technology. The comfort layer is “cooling cloud” foam for increased airflow and the transition layer of ClimateComfort foam attempts to reduce humidity. While the Puffy may sleep temperature neutral, it still won’t sleep cool. Check out our Best Cooling Mattresses for more suggestions to sleep cool. 

Is the Puffy Mattress Good For Couples? 

While foam beds can lack temperature cooling, they are usually great at isolating motion between co-sleepers. As a memory foam mattress, the Puffy layers will absorb motion and prevent one partner from being disturbed by the other. Puffy will allow couples to change positions, shift and move out of bed easily. 

How’s the Edge Support?

The 6 inches of polyfoam provide a sturdy base layer for decent edge support. Sitting on the edge support may cause the mattress to compress some and heavier sleepers who tend to sleep near the edge may find the edges sink too much. Couples who want to maximize their sleepable space on the Puffy may want to consider the amount of edge support they need. Overall, the Puffy should maintain a balanced feel with some sinking when a majority of your weight is on the edges. 

Construction: What’s Under the Surface? 

The Puffy is an all-foam mattress with three layers dedicated to providing superior pressure relief and providing a “cloud-like” sleeping experience. With softer upper layers that cradle around the body and a dense polyfoam base layer, sleepers should find a soft cloud-like feeling without sinking and getting stuck in the transition layer. 

Cover: The cover consists of standard polyester that has some stretch across the surface. As a thinner cover, it should not feel too warm to the touch. 

Layer #1:  The top layer of the Puffy mattress is made of two inches of Cooling Cloud foam with gel infusions. It is meant to pull heat away from your body and promote airflow so you don’t get too hot. It’s also built to cradle your body so you don’t feel undue pressure on the curvier body parts like hips or shoulders.

Layer #2: This layer is made of two inches of Climate-Adaptive Foam intended to help add consistency to heat regulation. This layer incorporated advanced temperature and humidity-resistance materials to limit heat fluctuations throughout the night. 

Layer #3: Next comes 6 inches of the Firm Core Support Layer, which provides structure and durability. Puffy attempted to build this foam layer to be a little firmer than normal foam mattresses. Somehow it still contours to the shape of your body so you’re not sore or feeling like you’re tossing about to find a better sleep position through the night.

How Much Does A Puffy Mattress Cost? 

Check out our Puffy Mattress Coupons to see if the Puffy is in your budget!

How Do the Policies Measure Up?

Puffy Trial, Warranty, Unboxing & Shipping

Puffy offers a 101-night trial period. If it doesn’t work for you, you can return it for a full refund before your 101-night sleep trial expires. Puffy will arrange for a representative to come to your home to pick up your mattress and donate it to a local charity. Puffy does ask that you give it a good 30 nights before you make a decision.

That’s sage advice especially if you have never slept on a memory foam mattress. They require you to sleep on it at least 14 days before you are eligible to return it, but 30 days is a good round number to get used to it and assure the mattress is properly broken in.

The Puffy mattress comes with a lifetime warranty. The company guarantees your mattress will be free from material or workmanship defects for as long as you own it. For the lifetime of the mattress, if anything is amiss, they’ll replace it for free. They’ll waive any shipping fees if they can verify the defect.

The Puffy comes compressed rolled in a box that is 19″ x 19″ x 42”. The Puffy ships for free and is made in the USA. Expect it to arrive within 2-5 business days. Take it out of the box and remove it from the vacuum-sealed covering. It will immediately take shape. It will take about 10 minutes to fully expand. The Puffy bed can be placed on any bed frame or surface, and may have some off gassing as a memory foam mattress.

Comparing the Puffy Mattress

Puffy vs Puffy Lux

The Puffy Lux is two inches thicker than the Puffy, with a softer feel and many of the same features as the Puffy. Both include the same temperature regulating materials and pressure relieving qualities. Both mattresses will support back sleepers but the Puffy Lux will provide even better relief for side sleepers. 

See our full Puffy Lux Mattress Review to learn more.

Puffy vs Puffy Royal

The Puffy is 14” compared to the 10” of the Puffy. With two more layers than the original, the Puffy Royal is right in line with Puffy’s “cloud-like” feel when sleeping. It is the least firm of the mattress, having a medium firm feel. We recommend the Puffy Royal for lighter sleepers or those who want to sink into their mattress. 

See our full Puffy Royal mattress review to learn more.

What’s the Bottom Line?

Puffy’s original, three-layer foam mattress may be the right new mattress to improve your sleeping experience. With cooling gel infused memory foam and quality motion isolation, the Puffy can provide couples with a quiet bed that should provide cooling measures. For side sleepers, the Puffy’s contouring layers will prevent pressure build-up around the hips and shoulders. Average weight back sleepers may also find the Puffy’s firmness level can balance their weight on top of the mattress and prevent lower back pain.  

FAQs 

Will I experience off-gassing with the Puffy? 

With all-foam beds, you will almost certainly experience some smells once you unbox the new mattress. The Puffy is not any worse than any of the other beds-in-a-box and the smell should be gone within a few days.

How much weight can the Puffy mattress support?

The Puffy can support 350 lbs per side of the bed, or 700 lbs total, so this mattress can accommodate a wide variety of body types and weights.

Does Puffy remove your old mattress?

Puffy doesn’t remove old mattresses, but does encourage donating your old mattress to a local donation center. You can also call 1-(800)-GOT-JUNK for a pickup service to get rid of your old mattress for a small fee.

See more FAQs at puffy.com