Puffy Mattress Review

Is the Puffy Mattress for You?

Who’s Going to Love the Puffy Mattress

• Lightweight side sleepers
• Combination sleepers
• Sleepers wanting a conforming mattress

Who Should Steer Clear of the Puffy Mattress

• Stomach sleepers—For more firmness, check out some of the best mattresses for stomach sleepers.
• Heavyweight sleepers—Instead, take a look at the best mattresses for heavier sleepers.
• Hot sleepers—If you sleep hot, check out the cooling DreamCloud Premier mattress.

Want the bottom line? Skip to the Nerd’s Take below.

Video Review

Want to see the Puffy put to the test? Join Loren in the Nerd Lab to learn more about the ins and outs of this mattress:

Puffy Mattress Firmness & Feel

Puffy Mattress Firmness

If you’ve been shopping for mattresses, you know they come in all levels of firmness. At Mattress Nerd, we keep mattress firmness simple with our 1–10 scale, where a 1 is Puffy like a cloud and a 10 is like napping on concrete.

That said, we’re putting the Puffy mattress at a 5.5 on our scale—true neutral. This mattress should feel soft but supportive to most sleepers, especially lighter sleepers. However, if you’re a heavier sleeper or a stomach sleeper, you might want a mattress with some more firmness.

What Does the Puffy Feel Like? 

The Puffy has a balanced yet responsive foam feel. This makes the bed easy to move around on, meaning it’s a good choice for combination sleepers who move around at night. With a three-layer foam construction, you’ll get a soft and supportive feel rather than feeling “stuck” in the mattress.

What Sleeping Position Is the Puffy Mattress Best For?

Body Type:	Back Sleepers	Stomach Sleepers	Side Sleepers
Lightweight< 130 lbs:	4	3	5
Average-weight130–230 lbs:	3	3	4
Heavyweight> 230 lbs:	2	2	3

1 = Very poor     2 = Not good     3 = Fair     4 = Good     5 = Excellent

Back Sleepers

If you’re a back sleeper, then the best mattresses for you support the natural curve of your spine and cushion your back. 

The Puffy’s dense base layer supports even weight distribution across the mattress. Lightweight and average-weight back sleepers are best supported by the pressure-relieving foams. Many heavyweight sleepers, however, may not get enough support with the Puffy mattress.

Lastly, those who already suffer from lower back pain will find less pressure buildup as they sink into the soft upper foam layer. You can also check out the best mattress for back sleepers and the best mattress for back pain.

Side Sleepers

The best mattresses for side sleepers deliver pressure relief in key areas: the shoulders and hips.

Lightweight and average-weight side sleepers will find the medium-firm Puffy to provide pressure relief and a gentle hug around their hips and shoulders. The upper layers of the Puffy will cradle pressure points and conform around the natural curves of the body. Although, if you’re a heavyweight side sleeper, you might need a mattress with less “sinking.”

Stomach Sleepers 

Stomach sleepers usually feel most comfortable on firmer mattresses that keep the hips elevated. Whether you’re a lightweight, average-weight, or heavyweight stomach sleeper, the Puffy mattress will likely not be firm enough.

For the most part, stomach sleepers will need a firmer, more supportive mattress to prevent their hips from sinking too deep into the foam, which causes spinal misalignment. When your spine is out of alignment, you’re more prone to uncomfortable back and neck pain, especially heavier sleepers. For other options, see the best mattress for stomach sleepers.

Combination Sleepers 

Combination sleepers usually move around throughout the night but stick to one or two preferred sleeping positions. The responsive nature of the Puffy and conforming foam layers provide a balanced sleeping surface for combination sleepers. 

Your dominant sleeping position will determine if the Puffy is a comfortable mattress for you. For example, if you’re a lightweight or average-weight sleeper who spends the majority of the night on your side, the Puffy should be a good fit for you. On the other hand, if you’re a heavyweight stomach sleeper, the Puffy might not be for you. 

To learn more, take a look at the most supportive mattresses for combination sleepers.

Puffy Mattress Performance

Is the Puffy Mattress Cooling? 

Memory foam mattresses usually aren’t the best at beating the heat, and since the Puffy is made entirely of foam, there isn’t much room for airflow through the mattress. Puffy does, however, infuse the top memory foam layer with gel, which helps to neutralize some of the heat retention. They also use humidity resistant memory foam for the second layer, which they claim keeps the foam breathable.

Overall, it’s not one of the best cooling mattresses, but it does regulate temperature better than an old school memory foam mattress.

Edge Support 

Think of edge support as how well your mattress can hold (and keep up) weight at its edges. Usually, foam mattresses usually aren’t the best choice for edge support, but the Puffy mattress comes in at around average. That said, while the Puffy mattress does have some sinking around its edges, it has enough stability to lie on the edges.

Responsiveness

A responsive mattress is one that bounces and keeps sleepers from “sinking” down into it. For a foam mattress, the Puffy is super responsive, and you shouldn’t have any issues moving around and changing positions throughout the night.

Motion Isolation: Is it good for those who share a bed?

Motion isolation is how well your mattress “captures” any unwanted movement—like your partner getting in and out of bed. Similar to many other foam mattresses, you can expect your Puffy mattress to have decent moton isolation.

See more: Best Mattresses for Couples

Noise

Foam mattresses are usually a good choice for couples and light sleepers looking to avoid creaking and loud coils. If that’s you, then the Puffy’s silent foam layers will be a great fit.

Pain Relief

The Puffy mattress is a lot like sleeping on a cloud; however, some sleepers may want more firmness and less fluffiness. 

Side sleepers under 230 lbs should experience enough pressure relief to avoid back pain, as well as shoulder or hip pain. The Puffy evenly distributes the weight of back sleepers, particularly those weighing under 130 lbs, so they shouldn’t develop new back pain on the mattress. 

Stomach sleepers need more support to prevent their hips from sinking too far into the top layers of the mattress. Sunken hips make your lower back arch out of alignment, which can cause new back pain or exacerbate pre-existing back pain. For better options, see the best mattresses for back pain.

Sex

The best mattresses for sex are usually quiet, cooling, and responsive. Although the Puffy mattress checks off all these boxes, some couples may feel too warm during sex on this mattress.

Off-Gassing

It’s not uncommon for bed-in-a-box mattresses like the Puffy to produce a temporary off-gassing odor after unboxing. This is totally normal and to be expected. That said, it can be off-putting to some. Know that Puffy uses CertiPUR-US certified foams, so you don’t have to worry about the odor being toxic. Just plan to let your new mattress air out (sans bedding!) for 24–72 hours, and the odor should dissipate.

Durability 

One downside of foam mattresses is that they can slowly deform over time, but they can still typically last six or seven years before showing signs of wear. The Puffy may be prone to developing permanent body impressions, but if those exceed 1.5”, you may qualify for warranty coverage.

Construction: What’s Inside the Puffy Mattress?

The Puffy is an all-foam mattress with three layers dedicated to providing superior pressure relief and a “cloud-like” sleeping experience. With softer upper layers that cradle around the body and a dense polyfoam base layer, sleepers should experience a soft cloud-like feel without getting “stuck” in the mattress. Let’s see how the Puffy’s layers stack up:

How Much Does A Puffy Mattress Cost?

Mattress Size	Price	Dimensions	Height	Weight
Twin	$899.00	39” x 75”	10”	29 lbs
Twin XL	$949.00	39” x 80”	10”	30 lbs
Full	$1099.00	54” x 75”	10”	40 lbs
Queen	$1299.00	60” x 80”	10”	48 lbs
King	$1449.00	76” x 80”	10”	61 lbs
California King	$1449.00	72” x 84”	10”	61 lbs

Check out our Puffy mattress coupons to see if the Puffy is in your budget! For other options, see the best mattress deals of 2023.

How Do the Policies Measure Up?

Shipping & Unboxing

The Puffy is made in the USA and ships for free via FedEx (there’s a shipping fee to Alaska and Hawaii). Expect your new mattress to arrive within two to five business days. 

The Puffy is delivered bed-in-a-box style—compressed and rolled in a box that’s 19″ x 19″ x 42”. For setup, take the rolled mattress out of the box and carefully cut away the vacuum-sealed covering. It will take about 10 minutes to fully expand. The Puffy bed can be placed on any bed frame or box spring in good condition.

Puffy Mattress Warranty Information

The Puffy mattress comes with a non-prorated Lifetime warranty for the original owner of the mattress, which means that Puffy covers the full cost for mattress repair or replacement as long as the original owner has the bed. The company guarantees your mattress will be free from material or workmanship defects for as long as you own it. 

What Is Covered By the Puffy Mattress Warranty?

• Permanent body impressions deeper than 1.5″
• Manufacturing flaws in the mattress cover fabric, stitching, or zipper
• Foam splitting, cracking, or crumbling that isn’t due to user damage or misuse
• Faulty springs that pop through the side of the mattress

What the Puffy Warranty Does Not Cover

• Gradual Softening: It’s normal for the top foam layer to lose some of its firmness over time. On the 1–10 firmness scale, you might notice your mattress dropping a point or two after five or 10 years. Unfortunately, firmness changes happen with every mattress. As such, the warranty doesn’t cover gradual softening.
• Subjective Issues: Puffy won’t replace or repair the mattress because it no longer fits your needs. If this happens, it may simply be time to shop for a new one.
• Off-Gassing: Bed-in-box mattresses come with one major downside: temporary off-gassing lasting 24–72 hours after unboxing. The scent can cause headaches, but you don’t need to worry about any dangerous health effects because the Puffy bed contains CertiPUR-US certified foams. Off-gassing isn’t covered by warranty, but it shouldn’t last longer than a few days max.
• Sagging Caused By Poor Support: Invest in a foundation that’s the right size and sufficiently supportive for your new Puffy mattress.
• Accidental Damage: We recommend using a mattress protector because Puffy won’t cover damage done by a dog, opening the box with too large of a knife, or accidentally spilling something on the surface.

What Could Void My Warranty?

• Using an unsupportive foundation or bed frame
• Burns, tears, spills, or other damage caused by you
• Mold, bed bugs, or other infestations
• Buying the Puffy mattress second hand
• Buying the Puffy from anyone other than Puffy or an authorized Puffy distributor
• Moving outside of the United States

Filing a Warranty Claim With Puffy

Puffy makes filing a warranty claim easier than many companies. Here’s how to get a claim started.

What you’ll need: 

• The first and last name of the person who ordered the Puffy
• A photo or video of the defect
• A description of the defect
• Your order number (optional)

Next, put all of the above information into an email and send it to support@puffy.com. Within a week, a Puffy representative should contact you and tell you the next steps. To learn more, check out our breakdown of the Puffy mattress warranty.

Trial Period & Returns

Puffy offers a 101-night trial period. If you decide it’s not the right mattress for you, simply return it for a full refund before your 101-night sleep trial expires. Puffy will arrange for a representative to come to your home to pick up your mattress and donate it to a local charity. Puffy does ask that you give it a good 30 nights before you make a decision.

Addressing Puffy Mattress Complaints

• Durability and Saaging: The Puffy definitely isn’t the most durable mattress we’ve tested. This is due primarily to its relatively thin three-layer all-foam construction. Some customers have reported sagging or indentations after sleeping on the mattress for just a few weeks and after years of use. The good news is, Puffy offers a lifetime warranty that covers indentations greater than 1.5”. Plus, the brand offering a 101-night sleep trial, so if you have any issues with your mattress during the trial period, you can return it for a full refund. 
• Temperature Regulation: Some buyers have reported that the Puffy doesn’t sleep cool enough. And that’s true, this all-foam mattress may cause some sleepers to overheat at night. If sleeping hot is an issue for you, check out our best cooling mattresses page where you’re sure to find a bed that fits your needs.

Comparing Different Puffy Brand Mattresses

See All: Puffy Mattress Comparison

Puffy vs. Puffy Lux Hybrid

Puffy Original Mattress is Best For:	Puffy Lux Hybrid Mattress is Best For:
Average-Weight Side Sleepers	Side Sleepers Of All Body Types
Budget-Conscious Shoppers	Hot Sleepers
Shoppers Looking For An All-Foam Mattress Feel	Back Sleepers Under 230 lbs

The Puffy Lux is thicker than the Puffy, with a softer feel and many of the same features as the Puffy. Both include the same temperature-regulating materials and pressure-relieving qualities. Both mattresses will support back sleepers, but the Puffy Lux will provide even better relief for side sleepers. 

The Puffy Lux also swaps a foam base layer for breathable coils, so we think it’s a better match for hot sleepers. The original Puffy has lower price points, so it’s the better choice for those on a tight budget.

See our full Puffy Lux Hybrid Mattress Review to learn more.

Puffy vs. Puffy Royal Hybrid

Puffy Original Mattress is Best For:	Puffy Royal Hybrid Mattress is Best For:
Side Sleepers Under 230 lbs	Those Who Like Soft Mattresses
Budget-Conscious Shoppers	Side Sleepers Of All Body Types
Couples	Those Who Need Extra Pressure Relief

The Puffy Royal Hybrid is taller and softer than the original Puffy. It has two more layers than the original, plus a coil system that improves breathability. You’ll pay quite a bit more for the Royal, since Puffy considers it a luxury mattress.

The feel of the Puffy Royal is right in line with Puffy’s “cloud-like” promise. It has a plush feel that makes it the least firm of the three different mattresses. We recommend the Puffy Royal for side sleepers and those who want to really sink into their mattress. 

See our full Puffy Royal Hybrid Mattress Review to learn more.

Comparing Puffy to the Competition

Puffy Mattress vs. Nectar Mattress

Puffy Original Mattress is Best For:	Nectar Mattress is Best For:
Lightweight & Average-Weight Side Sleepers	Average-Weight Side Sleepers
Lightweight Back Sleepers	Budget-Conscious Shoppers
Combination Sleepers	Lightweight & Average-Weight Back Sleepers

The Puffy and Nectar are both memory foam mattresses, but the Nectar has more of a true memory foam feel. It responds more slowly to your changes in sleeping position and more closely conforms to the shape of your body. 

We think the Nectar retains more heat than the Puffy, so it’s not a good mattress for hot sleepers. Also, the Puffy is a little more responsive. Otherwise, these beds scored well for motion isolation, pressure relief, and edge support. With discounts, you’ll save more on the Nectar. 

See our full Nectar vs. Puffy Mattress Comparison to learn more.

Puffy vs. Purple

Puffy Original Mattress is Best For:	Purple Mattress is Best For:
Those Who Like Contouring Memory Foam	Those Who Like A Floating Sensation
Couples	Hot Sleepers
Side & Back Sleepers Under 230 lbs	Back & Side Sleepers

Except for a foam base layer, the Puffy and Purple mattresses couldn’t be more different. The Purple has a Smart Grid top layer that’s made with a flexible, cooling, durable material called Hyper-Elastic Polymer. This Grid has a waffle-like shape that’s pressure-relieving, but not quite as cushioning as the foam on top of the Puffy. 

The Purple is more durable and sleeps cooler than the Puffy, but the Puffy does a better job of isolating motion and relieving pressure. Based on normal pricing, the Puffy costs a couple hundred dollars more than the Purple, but Puffy regularly offers significantly bigger discounts that drop the Puffy’s pricing below Purple’s.

See our full Purple vs. Puffy Mattress Comparison to learn more.

Puffy vs. Casper

Puffy Original Mattress is Best For:	Casper Mattress is Best For:
Side Sleepers Under 230 lbs	Side Sleepers Under 230 lbs
Back Sleepers Under 130 lbs	Back Sleepers Under 230 lbs
Hot Sleepers Who Love Memory Foam	Combination Sleepers

The Puffy and Casper are both memory foam mattresses with a medium-firm feel. Unlike the Puffy, the Casper has Zoned Support that provides a little more lumbar support and pressure relief. The Casper also narrowly outperformed the Puffy for ease of movement and edge support.

Back sleepers over 130 lbs and stomach sleepers under 130 lbs should go with the Casper. Lightweight and average-weight side sleepers could go either way. Neither mattress is particularly cooling, but we noticed less heat retention on the Puffy. Technically, the Puffy costs more, but is the lower cost mattress after seasonal discounts. 

See our full Casper vs. Puffy Mattress Comparison to learn more.

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s the Bottom Line?

With cooling gel memory foam and excellent motion isolation, the Puffy is a great option for many couples and body types. Side sleepers will enjoy the contouring foam layers, and average-weight back sleepers benefit from full-body support. We don’t recommend the Puffy to stomach sleepers or hot sleepers.

Nerd Scores for the Puffy Mattress

Performance Factor	Out of 5
Motion Isolation	3.75
Pressure Relief	5
Ease of Movement	4
Edge Support	3
Temperature Control	2
Durability	2.5

Haven’t made a decision yet? Check out these comparisons:

• Puffy vs. Casper
• Puffy vs. Leesa
• Puffy vs. Nectar
• Puffy vs. Purple
• Puffy vs. WinkBeds
• Puffy vs. Nolah
• Puffy vs. Lull
• Puffy vs. Saatva