Puffy claims to be “internet’s most comfortable mattress.” If deep sleep and comfort are what you’re after, the Puffy may just be the mattress for you.
Several years ago, a handful of companies started compressing mattresses, squeezing them into cardboard boxes, and shipping them straight to buyers’ homes. Buying a bed-in-a-box takes the mattress shopping experience entirely into the virtual realm, allowing shoppers to bypass mattress stores and their sometimes pushy salespeople.
If you’re considering purchasing a mattress from an online bed-in-a-box company, you may be faced with a challenge. What was once an industry with just a handful of competitors is now flooded with companies offering mattresses with every size, style, price point, and special feature imaginable. Between the sheer amount of options, compelling advertising campaigns, and mattress industry jargon, the choice can feel overwhelming.
We created this guide to help you, the overwhelmed bed-in-a-box shopper. Below, you’ll find our top 10 bed-in-a-box mattresses and why we recommend them as well as a buyer’s guide to purchasing the best mattress-in-a-box. Be sure to check out our top picks for the best mattresses of 2020 overall as well.
Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.
Puffy claims to be “internet’s most comfortable mattress.” If deep sleep and comfort are what you’re after, the Puffy may just be the mattress for you.
One of the most well-rounded mattresses
Puffy currently offers three mattress models, including the Puffy, the Puffy Lux, and the Puffy Royal. All three models are all-foam and feature different price points, types of foam, and thicknesses.
Puffy mattresses use softer foams, making them preferable for sleepers who like a conforming feel. Motion isolation is the key strength of these mattresses, which absorb and minimize almost all transfer. If you sleep with a partner or wake easily, we think you’ll love a Puffy. All three Puffy options are available in sizes Twin through California King, come with a 101-night sleep trial and a lifetime, non-prorated warranty, and ship free in the contiguous U.S. and Canada. White glove delivery isn’t available at this time.
Read our full Puffy mattress review to learn more!
The Nectar mattress is perfect for those on a budget. Get all the advantages of a bed in a box without a hefty price tag.
Best Bed-in-a-box on a budget
The Nectar balances comfort and support nicely in its memory foam mattress, which features a Tencel cotton cover that encases layers of quilted gel memory foam, adaptive core memory foam, and a breathable base layer. The bed is 11” thick overall and feels medium firm.
If you like the deep, melting hug of memory foam and are looking for the best value, the Nectar may be the best mattress-in-a-box for you. The medium-firm feel will accommodate all sleeping positions for sleepers at a variety of body weights and sizes. The soft quilted cover and top layers of foam offer the slow sinking feel lovers of memory foam look for, but the quick-responding, firmer base layers offer support to keep your spine in alignment. The Nectar is available in sizes Twin through California King and comes with a 365-night trial, free shipping, and a forever warranty. White glove delivery is available for an additional fee.
Read our full Nectar mattress review to learn more!
Helix makes buying a new mattress easy. With so many options, their online quiz will point you in the right direction.
Luxury zoned support made for side sleepers
Helix offers a wide variety of thickness and firmness options in their foam hybrid mattresses, ensuring that they have a mattress for your needs. We particularly love the Helix Midnight Luxe.
If you’re unsure what your mattress needs are or haven’t shopped for a new mattress in the past, Helix offers an online sleep quiz that will match you with a suitable option for your sleep style, height, weight, and preferences. You’ll have an informed decision along with control over the final firmness and support level. The Helix comes with free shipping, a 100-night sleep trial, two free pillows, and a 10-year warranty.
Read our full Helix Midnight Luxe review for more info!
This double-sided mattress offers two comfort levels in one product. The Layla makes deciding on firmness levels easy. Change your mind? Just flip it over.
One side sift, one side firm
This memory foam mattress features two sides (soft and firm), is copper-infused to improve airflow, and provides pressure points with relief. The cover design allows for flipping with ease. It is an excellent option for side sleepers and couples who are looking to get the most out of their bed in a box.
Layla updated its mattress in late 2018, and we’ve fallen in love with it. This memory foam bed is double-sided, has a fluffy, airy feel, and is below average in price. If you spend most of your night on your side and are petite, you’ll enjoy the soft side. If you’re an average weight or slightly heavier, you’ll enjoy the firm side. It’s available in sizes Twin through California King, comes with a 120-night sleep trial and a lifetime, non-prorated warranty, and ships free in the contiguous U.S. White glove delivery is currently not available.
Read our full Layla mattress review to learn more!
If pressure relief is what you’re after when you turn in for the night, The Casper mattress’s comforting layers can accommodate you.
Affordable mattress made for all sleepers
The Casper is a memory foam mattress that offers close conforming, a medium-firm feel, and pressure relief. It features triple-layer memory foam and polyfoam comfort system that sits atop a high-density foam support core.
The thick foam comfort layers in the Casper make it ideal for sleepers who struggle with back, neck, or shoulder pain when they sleep. Its medium firmness makes it suitable for sleepers who are average weight, and it isolates motion well for couples. Most sleepers will experience excellent comfort and close conforming from the three top layers, and the mattress is lightweight, making it easy to move and rotate throughout the year. The Casper comes with a 100-night sleep trial, free shipping in the U.S. and Canada, and a 10-year non-prorated warranty. It’s available in sizes Twin through California King.
Read our full Casper mattress review to learn more!
Looking for Luxury? Look no further than The DreamCloud. This mattress is sure to give sleepers a dreamlike sleeping experience.
A luxury mattress with a great return policy
The DreamCloud is a luxury hybrid bed-in-a-box with six layers. The breathable fabric cover encases a plush euro top (pillowtop), layers of medium- and high-density foam, a pocketed innerspring coil system, and a stabilizing foam base layer.
The DreamCloud features a luxurious construction for a relatively low price (a queen is just $999). This thoughtfully designed bed offers many advantages, including temperature neutrality, a plush feel, and a supportive, durable core. With six layers, the DreamCloud uses more material than other luxury hybrids, meaning it may work well if you’re heavyweight or tall. If you’re looking to sink into your mattress, the DreamCloud won’t be your bed-in-a-box; it’s best for average to heavyweight sleepers who need support, enjoy floating “on” the mattress rather than sinking into it, and want luxury at a reasonable price. The DreamCloud is available in sizes Twin through California King and comes with a longer-than-average 365-night trial, free shipping in the contiguous U.S., and a lifetime warranty. Check out our other luxury mattress picks.
Read our full DreamCloud mattress review to learn more!
Exceptional pressure relief with unrivaled soft comfort
The Nolah Signature mattress combines support, cooling, and options. The mattress is flippable, giving you a soft and a firm option in one mattress.
If your sleep needs change over time, or if you discover you need a firmer mattress than you expected, you can easily flip the bed over. The soft side includes a layer of AirFoam which is less trapping than traditional memory foam. Under that is a high-resilience foam layer that acts as a buffer between the dense support layer. The firm layer just has one layer of AirFoam between you and the support core.
Read our full Nolah Signature mattress review to learn more!
One of the softest beds in a box, Leesa makes high-quality mattresses for an affordable price point.
Great for most everyone! Excellent all-around mattress.
The Leesa is an affordable, mixed-foam mattress that features two comfort layers, a support core, and a cover woven from polyester and Lycra spandex. It’s considered medium-firm and measures 10” thick.
The Leesa is a great foam option for all types of sleepers. In 2018, the company added a new top layer of foam (LSA200) to make it even more soft and comfortable. The comfort layers cushion sleepers’ bodies without sagging, and the Leesa also does well isolating motion. It has a below-average price point when compared to other soft, all-foam beds, making it an excellent choice for sleepers who want a soft mattress but are on a budget. The Leesa is available in sizes Twin through California King and comes with a 100-night sleep trial, free shipping in all 50 states, and a 10-year non-prorated warranty. White glove delivery is currently not available for the original Leesa mattress. See: Best Affordable Mattresses
Read our full Leesa mattress review to learn more!
The Birch is made for eco- and budget-conscious shoppers alike. The Talalay latex for superior cooling and support coils ensure a restful night’s sleep.
Affordable, all natural hybrid
Made by Helix, the Birch is custom-made for sleepers who want a superior sleep experience made from organic materials. Organic wool, all-natural Talalay latex, and wrapped support coils combine to give you a healthy sleep experience without sacrificing comfort.
Wool and latex are known for being better than memory foam for a cool night’s sleep. Wool naturally pulls moisture away from you and dissipates it, while latex inherently doesn’t retain as much heat. The hybrid of wrapped coils with the softer upper layers means you’ll have a supportive sleep surface (along with good edge support), without experiencing too much pressure in the hips, shoulders, and spine.
Read our full Birch mattress review to learn more!
The Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress is one of the best hybrid mattresses sleepers can buy. Customizable firmness and multiple layers make for a great night’s sleep.
Soft, medium, and firm
The Brooklyn Signature is a hybrid mattress available in three firmness levels (soft, medium, and firm). It features gel-infused polyfoam, standard polyfoam, a quilted cover, pocketed coils, and a high-density, supportive base layer, and it measures 11.5” thick.
If you’re set on a hybrid with pocketed coils and want to choose your firmness level, the Brooklyn Bedding Signature is a nice option. The multiple firmness options make the Signature hybrid bed suitable for a wide variety of sleeper sizes, sleeping positions, and preferences. The mattress will feel conforming but responsive, is temperature neutral, and has very good motion isolation. It comes with a 120-night sleep trial, a 10-year warranty, and free shipping in the U.S. and Canada. White glove delivery is currently not available.
Read our full Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress review to learn more!
A “mattress in a box”, also called “bed in a box”, is exactly what it sounds like. It is literally a mattress that has been vacuum-sealed, rolled up and put into a box that ships directly to your home. These mattresses range from memory foam to a more traditional feeling, hybrid mattresses, and perform just as good as mattresses sold at large retailers. You typically won’t find a strict innerspring mattress in a box, but you can find some innersprings with added comfort layers, making them a hybrid. Bed in a box mattresses allow customers to save money, cutting out overhead costs and additional fees.
While shopping for mattresses online is becoming more and more popular, there is still the question that looms in the minds of many consumers; “Does rolling up my mattress cause damage?” The short answer is no. The process allows the integrity of the bed to be maintained during its travel. Most brands do recommend not leaving your bed in a box in the nbox too long after receiving because the longer it remains rolled up, it obviously becomes more compressed. When your mattress arrives, simply pull the rolled up mattress out of the box, and watch it expand.
Thousands of people wind up happy with their bed-in-a-box purchase, but that isn’t to say it’s for everyone. If you enjoy in-store browsing and the experience of seeing and lying on mattresses, you’ll probably gravitate toward the traditional mattress shopping experience of finding a brick-and-mortar retailer. However, if you’re up for the challenge of finding the best bed-in-a-box mattress without ever seeing it in person, shopping online could be enjoyable for you. Here’s a shortlist of who we think a bed in a box is ideal for:
Individuals who already know the brand and style they want to purchase
Millennials and Internet-savvy shoppers who aren’t intimidated by the idea of making a major investment by shopping online
Shoppers who prefer to do their own research and reading about comfort, warranties, sleep trials, shipping and return information rather than be guided by a mattress salesperson
When deciding whether to buy online or in-store, it can be helpful to consider the benefits of purchasing a bed-in-a-box.
Quick shipping—A mattress sold in a box or bag will typically arrive within one week after your order has been placed.
Extensive sleep trial periods<—To lessen the blow of the fact that shoppers can’t try the mattress prior to purchase, the majority of bed-in-a-box companies offer generous sleep trials with free returns.
Cost savings—You’ll find everything from affordable, basic mattresses to luxury, multi-thousand dollar beds that come in a box. The variety is nice, but the cost savings are even nicer. The majority of these companies pass the cost savings they receive from eliminating a middle man onto their customers.
No pushy salespeople – Instead of being swarmed by salespeople as you step into a traditional mattress showroom, you can calmly scroll through your computer and buy on your own terms.
When your new mattress arrives at your doorstep, you will likely be shocked that your brand new bed is in such a small box! There are few steps to keep in mind to ensure that you and your mattress make it to your room safely and efficiently!
Wait to unbox – We know it is exciting to get your new mattress in the mail, but it will be much easier to move to the desired room if it is still in the box! Once you and your helper have moved the box into the room, cut the top of the box open, then lay the box on its side on top of the foundation.
Unfold, then cut open! – Have one person pull the mattress out of the box, while the other pulls the box in the other direction. Putting the box on the floor, unroll the mattress, ensure the bottom of the mattress is in the correct direction, and then unfold. After the mattress is laying flat, grab a pair of scissors and cut the plastic from the side and bottom of the bed, being careful not to cut the fabric.
Watch it expand! – After the plastic is removed from the mattress it will immediately begin to expand. Most beds in a box brands recommend waiting a few hours to a day before sleeping on it.
When you cut the plastic off of the mattress, you will likely experience a smell that some described as “chemically.” This is the mattress releasing VOCs (volatile organic compounds), these are harmless, but the odor can range from very faint to very powerful. The smell should go away within a few hours. If your mattress has a very strong off-gassing smell, you can crack a window and turn on the fan to increase airflow.
These smells come most often from the polyfoam (polyurethane foam) used in memory foam mattresses. Since foam of some type is used in almost every bed in a box mattress, most will have some odor. If you are very concerned about off-gassing, going with a latex mattress is your best bet. Since they are made with organic, all-natural materials, they do not produce any VOCs.
While some mattress companies make models that require the use of a specific bed frame (often their own), most mattresses in a box are compatible with any foundation, be it a box spring, wooden slats, adjustable bed, or even the floor in some cases.
Originally pioneered by Casper, the first well known bed-in-a-box company, the boxed mattress market has evolved into a heavily populated industry in the last decade. Hundreds of online mattress retailers now compress and roll their mattresses into tall cardboard boxes or bags in order to ship them quickly to customers in the United States and beyond. In order to help you narrow down the best mattress-in-a-box for your bedroom, here’s a list of what to look for.
Most mattresses in a box ship to customers in the U.S. for free. Some brands do charge to ship to Hawaii and Alaska for a flat fee. If you are looking for expedited shipping or overnight that will cost you extra. Some brands offer white glove delivery, most is at an extra cost (around $100). White glove delivery means the mattress will not be left at your door, but will be carried in your home, unboxed and unwrapped. They will also take your old mattress and dispose of it if you want. Most mattresses are delivered within two weeks of the time you order.
The ability to try out a mattress and return it is one of the many benefits of buying a mattress online. These are often referred to as “sleep trials” by a bed in a box brand, they are usually very easy to find on the brand’s website. Most returns are free and do not worry, you aren’t expected to shove the mattress back into the box. Typically, someone will come to your home and remove the mattress and handle the return for you within your trial period. Occasionally, the brand will ask you to simply donate the mattress and issue you a refund upon proof of donation. After your sleep trial ends, returns will likely not result in a full refund or even a partial one at that. Unless the mattress is defective, you are likely stuck with your bed until you are ready to buy a new one.
In short, warranties protect against defects in a mattress. Most mattresses sold online have generous warranties ranging from 10 years to lifetime. This means that within the warranty period if a mattress stops performing or becomes defective, the company will replace it. The most common coverage includes; sinking/sagging, lasting impressions, materials becoming broken or damaged, or flaws that existed when you purchased the mattress. There is an equally long, if not longer, list of things not covered by your warranty. These lists are usually easy to find on the brand’s website. Some warranties are prorated, meaning you are fully covered for a certain amount of time, and as the years increase, the amount of things covered, or the cost which they are willing to replace decreases. Other warranties simply end after x amount of years. One last thing you should know about a mattress warranty is that they are only applicable to the original owner. This means if you buy a mattress from a non-reputable place, you have voided any warranty that once was attached to that product.
Foam – A foam mattress is one of the most common types that you will find as a bed in a box. They are easy to compress and have become a popular option for athletes, side sleepers, and those who like contouring feel when they sleep. Memory foam will not get as firm as some other mattress types, so that is something to keep in mind if you have concerns about a very straight spine. Foam is also great for couples, as long as it is not too soft. It usually minimizes motion transfer, but if you sink too much it can be hard to move around on.
Hybrid – Hybrid mattresses are popular due to their combination of coils and comfort layers of different materials, typically foam. Hybrids are good for every type of sleeper. If you are a heavier stomach sleeper, you still may experience some sinking in your hips. However, if you are average weight side, stomach or back sleeper, you can find a hybrid that is perfect for you.
Innerspring – Traditional innerspring mattresses are the least common to be rolled in a box. These are what usually come to mind when you think of an “old-school” mattress. Constructed with coils, these mattresses are more bouncy than hybrid and foam mattresses, making them great for heavy sleepers and those who need a lot of support.
Latex – Latex mattresses are made of all-natural materials, meaning they have no off-gassing and are the safest option for sleepers with allergies or eco-friendly shopping habits. They vary in their firmness from very soft to very firm and are more supportive than foam mattresses. Latex mattresses are typically more expensive than other mattress types, but sleepers agree they are worth the splurge. These mattresses perform especially well for back and stomach sleepers, as well as those who do not want their body heat to be trapped since they combine comfort, support, and airflow. Latex mattresses are extremely durable and will last you longer than just about any other mattress.
Shopping for the best bed-in-a-box can feel overwhelming, especially if it’s your first time. We hope this guide was helpful for narrowing down your choices from a couple hundred to ten or so. Use the buyer’s guide as you get started on your shopping journey for a mattress-in-a-box, and we hope you find the bed that’s perfect for you!
If you still need guidance in your mattress buying journey, check out our ultimate mattress buying guide
|Nectar||Best Budget Mattress in a Box||4.7/5|
|Helix Midnight Luxe||Best Bed in a Box for Side Sleepers||4.8/5|
|Layla||Best Cooling Bed in a Box||4.7/5|
|Casper||Best Memory Foam Bed in a Box||4.7/5|
|DreamCloud||Best Luxury Bed in a Box||4.8/5|
|Nolah Signature 12||Best Firm Mattress in a Box||4.8/5|
|Leesa||Best Bed in a Box for Couples||4.9/5|
|Birch||Best Organic Bed in a Box||4.9/5|
|Brooklyn Bedding Signature||Best Hybrid Mattress in a Box||4.7/5|
Are memory foam or hybrid mattresses better? In this guide, we review both mattress types and explain the materials, how they feel, and the pros and cons of each.
Check out the best memory foam mattresses online and learn the benefits of sleeping on memory foam.