Our Top Picks – The Best Mattresses of 2019

There are a lot of mattress options these days and it can be overwhelming when trying to make a decision.  But not to worry, we did the heavy lifting for you and tested countless options.  Here is a list of some of our favorites!

Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.


Best Overall Mattress

“There are few ‘sure things’ in the world, but the Leesa comes very close to being a sure-fire hit for average sleepers who need a new mattress.” 

  • Core strength, pressure relief, cooling, bounce thanks to Leesa’s three-layer foam construction
  • Adapts to all sleep positions and most body types
  • Risk-free experience – Free shipping and 100 days trial and 10-year warranty


“Nectar has great commercials, a great trial period, a great warranty and a great price point.”

  • High customer satisfaction: Company says less than 3 percent return the mattress
  • Tencel cover to help with temperature regulation
  • 365 day trial and lifetime warranty


Best Sleep Quality

“Sapira gives you so much for the money. In quality, materials, and performance, you could easily pay $3000+ for something comparable.”

  • Excels at responding quickly to changes in sleep position
  • The innerspring coils and perforated Avena foam top layer will also help you stay cooler
  • 100 night trial makes the Sapira a low-risk purchase


“The Puffy name refers to the idea of sleeping on a cloud, and they might be onto something.”

  • Designed to adapt to body movements and keep you cool
  • Zip off the cover for easy cleaning
  • 101 night risk-free trial and lifetime warranty


“It is a big mattress and is often considered the most affordable luxury mattress.”

  • 8 layer pack a lot of technology into providing a versatile sleep surface
  • A top of the line hybrid construction complimented by a patented plush top
  • 365 day trial and forever warranty.  Tough to beat


“Double sided, copper infusion, removable cover..this mattress is packed with cool features.

  • Change firmness by flipping the mattress to the other side
  • Copper is reported to promote healing and also helps the Layla mattress sleep cooler
  • 120 night trial and lifetime warranty

Brooklyn Signature

“The people at Brooklyn Bedding have tons of experience deconstructing and constructing mattresses to get at the best mix of materials and engineering.”

  • Customizable by firmness—soft, medium or firm
  • 1,024 separately wrapped coils support body and reduce motion transfer
  • 120 night trial

Alexander Signature

“Highly customizable and highly rated”

  • Quilted tops on all mattresses. Not everyone does that.
  • Comes in both foam and hybrid options
  • 100 night trial and 20-year warranty


“Lull has A LOT of 5 star reviews…and we understand why.”

  • Three different foam layers construction to offer a balance of comfort and support
  • Provides a lot of quality at a price that was surprisingly competitive
  • 100 night trial and 10 year warranty

Tomorrow Sleep Hybrid

“It’s better value for your money than most mattresses you’ll find in a retail store. And it’s backed by a bigger company than other direct-to-consumer mattresses”

  • Five-layer hybrid in medium soft or medium hard(Tomorrow also has an all foam option)
  • Parent company has nearly 150 years of experience making mattresses
  • 365 night trial – among the best in the industry

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments (1)

  1. Hi. We are looking at a “Blackhawk” Stearns and foster. Can’t find it listed except at store. Appreciate any help .
    Just bought a saavta but too soft. Thanks

By continuing to browse or by clicking “OK” you agree to the storing of first- and third-party cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Privacy Policy.