Saatva vs. Avocado Mattress Comparison

Comparing Saatva & Avocado Mattresses

The Saatva Classic is widely known as one of the best hybrid mattresses with a premium, high-quality design that’s available in three firmness levels (Plush, Luxury Firm, and Firm). The Avocado Green is a hybrid latex mattress that features natural materials like organic cotton, organic latex foam and recycled steel, and is one of our picks for best organic mattresses. The Avocado Green is available with or without a pillow top. 

The Saatva is best for people who like a traditional innerspring feel, want to choose their bed’s firmness level and height, or require a very supportive mattress. The Avocado Green is the better pick for eco-conscious shoppers who place a high value on organic materials, tend to sleep hot, and love the responsive feel of latex. Saatva also offers a better price point of the two mattresses (around $1,100 for a Queen size), making it our choice for value shoppers.

In this mattress comparison, we’ll cover more pros and cons, similarities and differences and key features to help you decide which is the best mattress for you.

Differences

• Height Options—The Saatva comes in two heights (11.5” and 14.5”), while the Avocado is only available in one height: 11”. The optional addition of a pillow-top to the Avocado mattress adds about 2” of height. 
• Firmness Options—The Saatva is available in three distinct firmness levels. The Avocado comes in one firmness level, which can be softened a bit with the addition of a pillow top.
• Style—The Saatva is a luxury innerspring mattress and the Avocado is a latex hybrid mattress.
• Delivery—The Saatva comes with free White Glove delivery in the contiguous United States. The Avocado comes with free shipping to all 50 states, but installation and the removal of an old mattress aren’t included.
• Price—The Saatva costs as little as $1,100 for a Queen size after discounts are applied, while the Avocado costs up to $1,799.

Similarities

• Temperature Control—Both mattresses sleep cooler than average, thanks to temperature regulating foams and increased airflow through the coil layers.
• Edge Support—Both mattresses offer above-average edge support, largely due to the coil layers, which keep the sleep surface consistent.
• Green/Organic Materials—Both mattresses feature one or more organic materials.
• Supportive—Both are supportive enough for all sleeping positions and body types, including heavyweight couples.

Who the Saatva Mattress is Best For 

Best For…

• All body types and sleeping positions with a mattress supportive enough to protect heavier sleepers and soft enough to cradle lighter sleepers
• Those who sleep hot can rest cooler through the ventilation in the coil system 
• Value seekers looking to invest in a high quality mattress

May Not be Best For…

• Some couples who need better motion isolation and a quieter mattress
• People who like a deep conforming, memory foam feel and prefer to sink into their mattress

Read our full Saatva mattress review to learn more! 

Who the Avocado Mattress is Best For 

Best For…

• People who prefer eco-friendly mattresses and want organic materials incorporated into the entirety of their mattress construction
• Hot sleepers looking to avoid memory foam and enjoy the natural cooling benefits of cotton, wool and latex
• Back and stomach sleepers looking for a firmer mattress that can protect their spine and prevent their hips from sinking

May Not be Best For…

• Side sleepers looking for more contouring around their pressure points
• People who like a deep conforming, memory foam feel

Read our full Avocado mattress review to learn more! 

Deciding Between Saatva & Avocado

Firmness / Feel

All mattresses are assigned a rating on a firmness scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being very soft and 10 being very firm. The Saatva comes in three firmness options that correspond with 4/10, 6/10, and 7.5/10 on the firmness scale. The Avocado Green comes in one firmness setting, a 7/10 on the scale and can be softened to a 6.5/10 with the addition of a pillow top.

The Saatva’s firmness versatility makes it an ideal choice for any sleeping position and body type. If you’re a stomach sleeper, a back sleeper or if you enjoy a firm mattress, check out the Saatva Firm. If you’re a lightweight sleeper or side sleeper who wants to nestle into the bed’s pillow top layer for more contouring, go with the Plush Soft option.

The Avocado’s medium-firm setting makes it best for back and stomach sleepers who need a firm surface for spinal alignment, but sleepers in these categories who prefer a slightly softer feel should consider the addition of the pillow top, which will bring the firmness level down by about a half point.

Both mattresses will offer a very supportive feel, but the Avocado will generally have a little more bounce and will conform less to the body than the Saatva. Neither bed has a deep sinking, viscous memory foam feel. If that’s what you’re after, we recommend considering a memory foam mattress.

Motion Isolation

The best mattresses for couples tend to reduce motion transfer. Couples who wake one another up throughout the night as they toss and turn or get in and out of bed need a bed that absorbs these disruptions. Foam beds with materials like memory foam tend to offer the best motion isolation, so if that’s a sticking point for you we might recommend a memory foam mattress.

Still Avocado and Saatva both take measures to reduce motion transfer. The Avocado’s coil core and responsive latex contribute to this quality, and the Saatva’s coil-on-coil core gives it more bounce. The individual coils work to neutralize motion across the bed.

Edge Support

Hybrid and innerspring mattresses offer much better edge support than foam beds, which tend to experience sagging around the perimeter over time. The coil-on-coil support system in the Saatva helps give it optimal edge support for customers who need a consistent sleeping surface or want to spread out on a smaller mattress. The Avocado’s firmer feel, thick pocketed coil layer, and high-density latex layers in the support core give it above-average edge support. For additional plush, both brands offer the additional of a Saatva mattress topper or Avocado mattress topper.

Pressure Relief 

Pressure relief refers to how well a bed alleviates pain from pressure points in any sleeping position. All sleeping positions have pressure points, but too much pressure buildup can cause issues such as back pain. All-foam beds tend to win in the areas of pressure relief, but mattresses with coil cores can offer this characteristic if they have thick foam layers. The Saatva’s softer foam layers will contour around the shoulders and hips, similar to the organic cotton of the Avocado.

Still, the Saatva has better pressure relief than the Avocado in all three firmness options thanks to the plush foams in its euro top. If you’re set on the Avocado but know you need a little more pressure relief, consider investing in the pillow top add-on at checkout.

Related: Best Mattresses for Side Sleepers

Spine Alignment 

Spinal alignment refers to how well a bed aligns the spine in its natural ‘S’ curve in any sleeping position. It’s hard to confidently rate how well any mattress will offer spinal alignment for you without knowing your bodyweight and preferred sleeping position. For example, side sleepers require a bed that closely conforms to their body in order to achieve spinal alignment, while back and stomach sleepers require firmer, flatter surfaces to promote a nicely aligned spine.

Both mattresses can offer spinal alignment for certain sleeper types, but the Saatva’s range of firmness levels makes it more likely to do so regardless of your weight or sleeping position. The Avocado will be most successful at aligning the spines of average weight and heavyweight back and stomach sleepers

Durability 

The average lifespan of a mattress is about seven to ten years. Durability is achieved through high-quality materials, but is also a product of the bed’s style: foam beds tend to have shorter lifespans than beds made with coil cores. Both the Saatva and the Avocado are made with coil cores, and both offer impressive warranties.

Temperature 

Temperature neutrality is a key strength of both mattresses. The best cooling mattresses do this through coil cores and low-density foams, which promote breathability and strong airflow. The Saatva’s coil-on-coil design helps the bed offer better circulation than even the average innerspring or hybrid bed.

The Avocado’s layer of latex, which is great for temperature regulation, and coil core, also make it an excellent choice for people who sleep hot. We think the Avocado has a slight edge on the Saatva in this category because it has a firmer setting and therefore less comfort layers on top that can trap body heat.

Saatva Mattress Construction 

The Saatva is a luxury innerspring mattress that features a Euro pillow top with thick comfort layers and a coil system in its support layers. It’s available in three firmness levels and two heights, ensuring most shoppers can find an option that works for them.

All three versions of the Saatva (Plush Soft, Medium Firm and Firm) have a Euro top cover that contains between 1.25” and 1.5” of soft or firm polyfoam and is made from organic cotton. All three also have .75” of dacron fibers beneath the polyfoam. This top gives the bed a soft feel for an innerspring mattress, and side sleepers may benefit from the extra contouring it provides around the hips and shoulders.

The comfort layers feature a top layer of polyfoam and a second layer of memory foam that together measure 1” thick. The softest version offers the most body conforming materials, while the Luxury Firm and Firm versions conform less and are better options for strict back sleepers and stomach sleepers.

The support core includes a layer of 4” pocketed coils that are moderately thick, giving the bed some responsiveness without making it overly bouncy. This top layer of coils also acts as a transitional layer for the taller layer of coils beneath it. The thicker bottom layer of coils measures either 4” or 7” tall, depending on the height of the mattress, and helps stabilize the bed while  reinforcing its perimeter to improve edge support. Altogether, the Saatva measures 11.5″ or 14.5” tall.

Avocado Construction

The Avocado Green mattress is a natural latex hybrid made with eco-friendly materials. It’s available with or without a pillow top add-on.

The cover features 100% GOTS-certified organic cotton and is hand-tufted. Although the cover is non-removable, it’s free from chemicals like glue and fire retardants. It has green handles on the sides for easy moving.

The top layer includes GOTS-certified organic wool from a small farmer’s collective. It helps wick moisture and provide temperature control for people who tend to sleep hot. If you choose to add the pillow top to the mattress, this layer will be followed by 2” of GOLS-certified Dunlop latex, which gives the mattress a softer feel overall.

Regardless of which model you choose, the bed will include a 2” foam layer of natural Dunlop latex that has slightly higher density than the pillow-top latex add-on. This latex comfort layer gives the bed a soft bounce and makes it very resilient, which results in a longer lasting mattress.

The support core of the Avocado is composed of 1” of very firm Dunlop latex and pocketed steel coils. The coils are zoned to enhance ergonomic support, which means they’ll feel firmer around the torso and softer at the shoulders and feet. This enhances spinal alignment and durability. Altogether, the bed measures between 11” tall without the pillow top and about 13” tall with the pillow top.

See: Memory Foam vs Hybrid

Sizing & Price Comparisons 

For the best price on a new Saatva mattress, check out our Saatva Mattress Coupons.

Shipping and Returns for Saatva & Avocado

The industry standard for shipping and returns is free shipping, free returns, and at least a 100-night sleep trial. Both the Avocado and the Saatva meet or exceed these norms.

The Saatva comes free White Glove delivery, which means they’ll bring the bed in, set it up for you, and include old mattress removal upon request. You’ll have 180 nights to test out the Saatva, but the one caveat about this bed is that it costs $99 to return. The Saatva’s warranty is 15 years of non-prorated protection and the company considers itself to be the friendliest warranty in the industry.

The Avocado Green mattress ships free to all 50 states compressed and rolled as bed-in-a-box. You’ll have a full year to determine whether the mattress is right for you, so you can opt to return the mattress in exchange for a product refund at any point during the trial.

More Saatva Mattresses

See our full Saatva Youth Mattress Review to learn more.

Read our full Saatva HD Mattress Review to learn more.

Haven’t Decided on Your Dream Mattress? Read some of our other mattress comparisons:

Saatva vs Loom & Leaf

Saatva vs Casper

Saatva vs DreamCloud

Casper vs Loom & Leaf

Avocado vs Awara 

Our Saatva vs. Avocado Final Review

The Saatva and Avocado are both high-quality beds, but they differ in a few categories. If you’re looking for a premium online mattress at a great value, we recommend the Saatva. The Saatva’s also our recommendation if you want to choose your bed’s firmness level or height, and it can work for pretty much any body type and sleeping position.

Lightweight and side sleepers should go with the Plush Saatva, and average weight and heavyweight back and stomach sleepers should consider the Luxury Firm and Firm versions. The Avocado will be your mattress if you’re an eco-conscious shopper and really like the bouncy, responsive feel of latex foam. As a firmer mattress, it’s also a more ideal choice for back and stomach sleepers, but it won’t be suitable for lightweight sleepers or side sleepers who need extra cushioning.