Best Mattress Guides

Best Mattress for the Money

Finding the best mattress for the money is about more than comfort and needs. It's also about getting a mattress that is a good value for every penny you pay for it.

By Natalie Yerger

One of the most important factors shoppers in the market for a new mattress have in mind is price. Unless you’re ready to invest heavily in an expensive mattress, most people appreciate saving a few hundred dollars on their purchase. With that said, there’s a fine line between a high-value mattress, which balances quality materials and a reasonable price point, and a budget mattress that simply doesn’t perform well. 

In this article, we’ve rounded up the best mattresses for the money. By our standards, this means the mattresses in this list will give you excellent value for their respective costs and strike a nice balance, providing high-quality materials, performance, and comfort for the body types and sleeping positions they’re targeted for at a great price. Keeping reading this mattress review for our top online mattress picks for the money.

Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

The Best Mattress for the Money 2020

Nectar

Editor's Pick

The Nectar checks the boxes for everything we look at when considering whether a bed is a value pick, including generous trial and warranty policies, a low price tag, an accommodating feel, and more.

Score
4.7 / 5.0
Firmness

6

Price

$$

Warranty

Lifetime

The Nectar has a simple all-foam construction, which includes a base layer of polyfoam, a transitional layer, a comfort layer of memory foam, and a cover that incorporates quilted gel memory foam, putting this at the top of our list of best mattresses for side sleepers.

While the construction isn’t something to write home about, these materials deliver above and beyond considering the bed’s price point. In terms of feel, the Nectar offers the deep, sinking feel of memory foam. It has a medium-firm firmness level that can accommodate a wide variety of sleeping styles and body types. 

Nectar frequently has discounts and promotions, which can cut a few hundred dollars off of the final cost, and they often throw in two free memory foam pillows with purchase. The Nectar comes with a 365-night trial period, so you’ll have a full year to try out the bed, and it’s backed by a Forever warranty if you decide to keep it.

Read our full Nectar mattress review to learn more.

Casper Element

Runner Up

For value seekers shopping for a temporary sleeping space, a dorm room, or a guest bedroom, the Casper Element is a comfortable, breathable, and affordable pick that suits most lightweight and average weight sleepers.

Score
4.7 / 5.0
Firmness

6.5

Price

$

Warranty

10 year limited warranty

Many shoppers seeking the best mattress for the money are looking to outfit a temporary living space, dorm room, guest bedroom, or another sleeping surface that won’t be used forever. For these shoppers, the Casper Element is a near-perfect choice.

It’s a mixed-foam mattress that measures 10” tall, has a Medium firmness level, and is constructed with comfort layers of memory foam and polyfoam, a polyfoam transitional layer, and a polyfoam support core. It also features a removable and washable polyester cover.

If used as intended, the Casper Element is one of the best affordable mattresses for small and average weight sleepers, especially if you’re looking for a mattress that doesn’t need to have the bells and whistles of a luxury construction but will sleep comfortably for a few years.

Keep in mind that if you’re a larger person, we don’t recommend the Casper Element as you won’t find it supportive enough in any sleeping position. The Casper Element comes with a 100-day trial, a 10-year warranty, and free shipping in the contiguous U.S.

Read our full Casper Element mattress review to learn more.

Saatva Classic

Best Innerspring Mattress for the Money

Saatva is a trustworthy brand known for making high-quality, affordable luxury beds with reasonable price tags, making the Saatva Classic our value innerspring mattress pick.

Score
4.7 / 5.0
Firmness

Varies

Price

$$$

Warranty

15 year

The Saatva Classic mattress comes in two heights (11.5” and 14”) and three firmness options (Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm). The construction includes a layer of traditional innersprings, a layer of transitional foam, a layer of shorter pocketed coils, a layer of memory foam, and a Euro pillow top, making this one of the best hybrid mattresses in our book.

The feel of the bed will depend on the firmness option you get, but it’s generally reminiscent of a traditional innerspring mattress. You’ll feel supported by the coils and their responsiveness will make changing positions throughout the night easy if you’re a combination sleeper. 

All in all, the Saatva is a phenomenal value pick because it retails for much less than other high-quality hybrid and innerspring mattresses; a Queen size is just $1,100. The Saatva comes with a 120-night trial, a 15-year warranty, and free White Glove delivery, which includes old mattress removal.

Read our full Saatva mattress review to learn more.

Puffy

Best for Lightweight Sleepers

The Puffy’s medium firmness level and extra-soft memory foam top layer make this our value pick for lightweight sleepers, who will find a balance of support and pressure relief in any sleeping position.

Score
4.8 / 5.0
Firmness

7

Trial period

101 days

Reason to buy

One of the most well-rounded mattresses

The Puffy is a 3-layer all-foam mattress that’s constructed with a base layer of polyfoam, a transition layer of climate foam, and a thin layer of memory foam in the comfort layer. The bed has a neutral feel and a Medium firmness that will work for back sleepers, side sleepers, stomach sleepers, and combination sleepers. 

This is our value pick for petite and lightweight individuals. This body type, which will compress the Puffy’s layers of foam less, will still find the mattress surface soft enough to achieve a nice combination of pressure relief and support. The Puffy comes with a 101-night sleep trial, a Lifetime warranty, and free shipping to all 50 states, adding to its appeal.

Read our full Puffy mattress review to learn more.

Awara

Best for Eco-Conscious Shoppers

The Awara holds several environmental certifications that eco-conscious shoppers on a budget will appreciate.

Score
4.7 / 5.0
Firmness

6.5

Price

$$$

Warranty

Lifetime

The Awara is a natural latex hybrid mattress that’s made with a plush Euro top cover, a 4-inch Dunlop latex foam layer, and 9-inch pocketed coils. For eco-conscious shoppers on a budget, the bed’s long list of certifications and incorporation of natural materials are very appealing.

It features all-natural Dunlop latex, is Rainforest Alliance-certified, is Global Organic Latex Standard-certified, and the Euro top features organic cotton and New Zealand wool, which is known for its moisture-wicking and cooling properties.

The Awara performs especially well for average and heavyweight sleepers, as its firmness level and combination of sturdy latex and pocketed coils prevent sinking while allowing for moderate contouring. The Awara comes with a 365-night trial, free shipping in the contiguous U.S., and a lifetime warranty, and it costs less than $1,700 for the largest size.

Read our full Awara mattress review to learn more.

DreamCloud Mattress

Best for Heavyweight Sleepers

The DreamCloud excels in supporting heavyweight sleepers in all positions, a rare quality to find among affordable hybrid mattresses.

Score
4.8 / 5.0
Firmness

6.5

Price

$$$$

Warranty

Lifetime

The DreamCloud is a medium-firm hybrid that features two comfort layers (one of which is gel-infused), a transitional layer of polyfoam, a support core of 8-inch pocketed coils, and a 1.5-inch polyfoam base. The DreamCloud is a Medium-Firm on the firmness scale and is a great affordable luxury option.

High-value mattresses can be difficult to find for heavier sleepers, for whom appropriately suited mattresses typically incorporate more materials to achieve a proper support level and therefore have higher price points.

The DreamCloud is an exception to this rule, with 5.5 inches of comfort and transitional layers that provide the support heavy sleepers need to prevent sinking, enhance edge support, and more. The DreamCloud costs less than $1,000 in all sizes and comes with a 365-night trial, free shipping, and a limited lifetime warranty.

Read our full DreamCloud mattress review to learn more. 

Brooklyn Bedding Signature

Best Hybrid Mattress for the Money

The cost-to-value ratio for this American-made hybrid is excellent, and it comes in three different firmness levels, making it suitable for practically any sleeper.

Score
4.7 / 5.0
Firmness

5

Price

$$

Warranty

10-year limited warranty

The Brooklyn Signature is a hybrid mattress that features a couple layers of gel-infused polyfoam, a 6-inch core of pocketed coils, and a 1-inch layer of base polyfoam, all of which are encased in a quilted cotton cover. Overall, the bed is 11.5” thick and provides a nice balance of support and pressure relief for practically any body type and sleeping position.

That’s what we love most about the Brooklyn Signature: It’s highly versatile for such a low-cost mattress.  The Signature comes in three firmness levels, which include a Soft model for pure side sleepers, a Medium version that can accommodate any sleeping position, and a Firm model that’s targeted toward back and stomach sleepers.

Additionally, because it has more of a neutral, soft foam feel, it isn’t as polarizing as a deep-cradling memory foam mattress, so most sleepers find it comfortable, accommodating, and supportive. Best of all, the Brooklyn Signature retails for less than $1,000 in the Queen size.

Read our full Brooklyn Signature mattress review to learn more.

Tuft and Needle Mint

Best for Couples

The Tuft & Needle Mint is an all-polyfoam bed that’s constructed with a graphite- and gel-infused cooling comfort layer, a gel-infused layer of transitional foam, and a high-density polyfoam support core, all of which are encased in a polyester blend cover.

Score
4.9 / 5.0
Firmness

5

Price

$$

Warranty

10 year warranty

The Mint is a Medium-Firm mattress and is 12” tall.  It’s one of the best mattresses for couples due to its excellent performance in motion isolation and noise reduction. If you sleep with a partner or co-sleep with a child or pet, you shouldn’t be able to feel their motions throughout the night at all.

The Tuft and Needle also makes no noise when bearing weight, which, while a defining trait of most all-foam beds, is especially attractive for couples seeking a budget mattress that will guarantee they don’t wake one another throughout the night. The Tuft and Needle Mint comes with a 100-night trial, free shipping in the contiguous U.S., and a 10-year warranty.

Read our full Tuft and Needle Mint mattress review to learn more.

Best Mattress for the Money Buying Guide

Finding a good mattress at a reasonable price point can be a challenge in today’s mattress industry, which is crowded and becoming increasingly complex due to the variety of mattress types, mattress materials, and mattress brands available.

In this buyer’s guide, we hope to quell some of the confusion by educating you about important considerations when shopping for the best mattress for the money. Read on for an overview of the types of mattresses available and key shopping considerations to keep in mind when looking for a high-quality mattress that’s reasonably priced.

Types

The type of mattress you choose will greatly impact how the mattress performs in various categories, so we’ll cover mattress types first.

  • Foam—All-foam mattresses combine memory foam, polyfoam, and proprietary foams, or exclusively use one type of foam in their construction. They’re known for their close conforming and pain relief, and they’re widely available and have below-average price points.
  • Innerspring—Innerspring mattresses combine steel coils with a thin layer of polyfoam. Considered the most traditional mattress type, innerspring beds excel in breathability and are affordable, but they can be too firm and noisy for some.
  • Hybrid—Hybrid mattresses combine memory foam or latex comfort layers with pocketed support coils, taking from the best of both worlds of all-foam and innerspring mattresses. These styles come in a wide variety of firmness levels and often have specialized features, but they tend to be expensive.
  • Latex—Latex mattresses combine a latex or high-density polyfoam support core with a natural or synthetic latex comfort layer. While similar to foam beds in general, latex mattresses are more cooling and responsive.
  • Airbed—Airbeds have one or two air chambers as the support core that can be adjusted to reach the sleeper’s desired firmness, but these styles tend to be expensive due to the materials and technology used in their construction.

Considerations

Sleep Trial and Return Policy

Most online mattress companies now offer customers a sleep trial period, which allows sleepers to test out the bed for a limited number of nights. During the trial period, shoppers can return the mattress for a full refund if it doesn’t suit their needs.

Sleep trials range from 30 to 365 nights, and some trials require a 30-night break-in period. We recommend thoroughly reviewing the sleep trial and return policies for the value mattress you choose, as some mattress companies have frustrating fine print written into their policies, like fees that cover the shipping cost of returns.

Durability

Discovering a mattress with high-end materials at a great price is exciting, but before you pull the trigger, we recommend learning about the bed’s durability. On average, most mattresses last about seven years. The bed’s support system and the quality of its materials will play into this. Typically, more durable beds will have high performance ratings for edge support, sagging, and motion transfer, so these characteristics can serve as clues.

Price Range

As we mentioned earlier in this review, a high-value mattress doesn’t necessarily mean it’s going to be the most affordable mattress on the market. Rather, the best mattresses for your money will deliver on quality, durability, comfort, and policies for a great price relative to these qualities. We recommend choosing a price range you feel comfortable with but that doesn’t overextend you financially. 

Shipping

Most mattresses now come with free shipping in the contiguous U.S., but if you live in Hawaii, Alaska, or another U.S. territory, you may incur shipping fees, which you’ll want to account for when considering your new mattress budget.

It’s common for online mattresses to ship as a bed-in-a-box, but some mattresses arrive as-is and will require more than one person to be transported into your designated sleeping area.

How to Pick the Right Mattress

Sleep Position

Most sleepers have a primary sleeping position that they gravitate to, whether it’s their back, side, or stomach. Sleepers who rotate between two or more of these primary positions throughout the night are called combination sleepers. Your sleeping position greatly impacts the level of firmness and support you need in a mattress. Before settling on a value mattress, consider the position you most often find yourself in when you wake up.

If you’re a side sleeper, mattresses with thicker comfort layers almost always provide the contouring you’ll need around your hips and shoulders to sleep soundly. If you sleep on your back or stomach, firmer mattresses will support the hips and shoulders to help keep your spine in alignment. If you’re a combination sleeper, look for Medium to Medium-Firm mattresses with some level of responsiveness, which will make it easier to change positions throughout the night.

Keep in mind that these recommendations are for average weight sleepers; if you’re lightweight, you’ll need a softer mattress to achieve these same things, and if you’re heavyweight, you’ll need a firmer mattress.

Pressure Points

All sleepers have pressure points, and they vary depending on your sleeping position. For example, side sleepers’ primary pressure points are the hips and shoulders, whereas back sleepers come into closer contact with the mattress along the full length of their spine.

While pressure points are normal, they can become troublesome if these areas become painful or ache during the day. If you experience back pain or have aches in certain areas of your body, we recommend looking for a value mattress that is pressure-relieving and conforming. These mattresses typically have thicker cushioning layers with materials like memory foam, which allow for greater sinking and body-cradling. 

Size of the Bed

Most mattresses are available in the standard sizes, which include Twin, Twin XL, Full (or Double), Queen, King, and California King. Some mattresses may be available in split sizes, which include Split Queen, Split King, and Split California King.

The mattress size you choose should fit nicely into your budget while suiting your body type, personal preferences, and lifestage. For example, a Queen size mattress is often the right pick for single adults who like to sprawl out and couples who don’t mind cuddling up at night, whereas a King size mattress is a good pick for couples investing in a new mattress who want additional space. 

Conclusion 

Mattress buying can be stressful, but it doesn’t have to be. We hope these top picks for the best mattress for the money serve as a good first step as you search for the right mattress for your space. 

Recap of The Best Mattresses for the Money

Mattress Award Firmness
Nectar Editor’s Pick 6/10
Casper Element Runner Up 6.5/10
Saatva Best Innerspring Mattress for the Money Varies
Puffy Best for Lightweight Sleepers 7/10
Awara Best for Eco-Conscious Shoppers 6.5/10
DreamCloud Best for Heavyweight Sleepers 6/10
Brooklyn Signature Best Hybrid Mattress for the Money 5/10
Tuft and Needle Mint Best for Couples 5/10

 


Comments (0)


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *