Best Mattress Guides

Best Innerspring Mattresses of 2020

By Natalie Yerger

The innerspring mattress was invented in 1871, and the style is still widely manufactured and sold today. Pop culture often portrays innerspring mattresses as old, squeaky, and uncomfortable, but this is far from the truth. Sleepers who love innerspring mattresses brag of the style’s unparalleled high levels of support, ability to maintain an even surface, and responsiveness. 

In addition to these trademark qualities, innerspring designs have been improved with innovative construction techniques and materials, both of which have helped keep the style popular in spite of rising competition from alternative models.

Many shoppers who are first-time innerspring mattress buyers are initially drawn to the style for its price point, which tends to be relatively low. It can be challenging to know where to start in your search for the best innerspring mattress, thanks to the sea of options available today.

With this guide, we’re here to help. Keep reading to learn about our top picks for best innerspring mattresses. We also share a Buyer’s Guide to shopping for an innerspring mattress. There, you’ll learn everything you need to confidently make your purchase, including what an innerspring mattress is, the pros and cons of innerspring styles, important considerations for your purchase, and more.


The Best Innerspring Mattresses

Saatva

Best Affordable Luxury

The Saatva marries the look and the feel of a traditional innerspring mattress with new technology for a final product that’s both supportive and comfortable.

Nerd Score
4.7 / 5
Firmness

Varies

Trial

120 nights

Price

$$-$$$

The Saatva mattress contains a low-gauge Bonnell coil support core that’s topped with a plush comfort system and a euro-top cushioning layer, which together provide more added comfort than you’ll find in most innerspring options. Bonnell coils help keep the mattress relatively affordable, and they also keep it supportive. These coils can withstand high levels of compression without shifting. As such, the Saatva takes from the best of both worlds: it has the support, response, and durability of an innerspring mattress and the conforming and pressure relief of an all-foam or hybrid model. 

The Saatva is customizable (both firmness and height), meaning that it can work well for almost any sleeper, regardless of body weight or sleeping style. Firmness options include Plush Soft (4), Luxury Firm (6), and Firm (7.5), and you can choose from 11.5- and 14.5-inch profiles. Keep in mind that the Saatva’s responsiveness may make it unpleasant if you wake easily at the movements of a partner, as it doesn’t shine in the motion isolation department.

Read our full Saatva Mattress Review to learn more! 


 

Casper Wave Hybrid

Editor’s Pick

The Casper Wave strikes a balance with a middle-of-the-road firmness level and features that make it appropriate for sleepers of all shapes and sizes. It’s an excellent choice for sleepers who enjoy the Original Casper’s balance of conforming and support but want more bounce.

Nerd Score
4.8 / 5
Firmness

Medium: 5/10

Trial

120 nights

Price

$$$-$$$$

The Casper Wave Hybrid has an innerspring coil layer and additional memory foam to improve its ability to isolate motion, regulate temperature, and relieve pressure. This three-pronged hybrid combines the features of Casper’s memory foam Wave Model with gel pods for targeted structural support and an innerspring coil base for bounce and durability.

Casper took support one step further by corresponding the types of materials used throughout the mattress with the needs of various body parts. For example, the firm gel pods contour to the hips, which are heavier than the shoulders. Alternatively, the memory and latex foams throughout the mattress are placed where lighter areas of the body come into contact with the sleeping surface. 

The thoughtful design of and dedicated materials used in the Casper Wave make it the most expensive mattress in Casper’s lineup, but buyers receive a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year limited warranty with purchase. 

Read our full Casper Wave Hybrid Review to learn more! 


 

WinkBeds

Best for Heavyweight Sleepers

The WinkBed is constructed with a specialized support layer and pocketed coils for a breathable mattress with excellent support. Plus-sized sleepers should consider the WinkBed Plus, which is designed for sleepers in the heavyweight group and has specialized features to support individuals and couples in this category.

Nerd Score
4.5 / 5
Firmness

Varies

Trial Period

120 nights

Reason to Buy

$$-$$$

The WinkBed is an innerspring mattress that comes in three firmness options, making it an option for most sleepers, regardless of their sleeping position, body type, or weight. It features a support core of pocketed coils that are encased in foam, helping the mattress have airflow and strong edge support. On top of this core is a comfort system with polyfoam, gel polyfoam, and micro coil layers. The WinkBed also has a lumbar pad for added pressure relief in the low back.

Heavyweight sleepers have the option of purchasing the WinkBed Plus, which is a specialized firm hybrid designed to accommodate larger and taller sleepers. The comfort layer in this model includes zoned latex for targeted support where heavyweight sleepers need it most. In general, WinkBed’s models are responsive yet body-conforming, meaning they can alleviate aches and pains while providing the bounce that some sleepers prefer. It’s also an excellent choice for couples, as it isolates motion relatively well for an innerspring. 

Read our in-depth WinkBeds Mattress Reviews to learn more! 


 

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid

Best Value

Brooklyn Bedding carries out its design and production in-house and passes the cost savings to customers, meaning you can get this high-quality innerspring at an affordable price.

Nerd Score
4.8 / 5
Firmness

Varies

Trial

120 nights

Price

$$-$$$

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid contains a 2-inch top layer of gel-infused TitanFlex polyfoam and a 2-inch layer of gel-infused Energex polyfoam at the top. Six-inch pocketed coils and a 1-inch layer of high-density base polyfoam make up the remainder of the bed, creating a profile that’s altogether 11.5 inches thick.

The Signature comes in three firmness options (soft, medium, and firm), each of which offer a distinct feel. In all models, the Signature offers excellent airflow and temperature neutrality thanks to the pocketed coil layer. Keep in mind that the Signature lacks the traditional responsive feel of an innerspring mattress, which will be a drawback or a plus, depending on your preferences.

The 4” all-foam comfort system also helps the Signature isolate motion better than other innerspring and hybrids, making it a great choice for couples. With high-quality construction, a 120-night sleep trial, and a 10-year warranty, this is our pick for best value innerspring mattress.

Read our full Brooklyn Signature Mattress Review to learn more!


 

Helix

Most Customizable

If you’ve ever entertained the idea of having a mattress made especially for you, you’ll love the Helix. The brand’s sheer number of options (six in total) will make you feel like you’ve hired a craftsman to create your bed.

Nerd Score
4.7 / 5
Firmness

Varies

Trial

100 nights

Price

$$-$$$

The Helix, made by Helix Sleep, represents six hybrid mattresses made with comfort foams and pocketed coils. The beauty of purchasing a Helix is that there’s bound to be an option that’s nearly perfect for you. The company even offers an online sleep quiz to help you determine which model is best for your size, weight, sleep position, and body type.

Each of Helix Sleep’s six hybrid models, the Sunset, Midnight, Twilight, Moonlight, Dusk, and Dawn, are made to suit the preferences of sleepers with varying firmness preferences, body types, and sleep positions. Every Helix mattress features a cover made from polyester that has a soft and stretchy feel, but the comfort layers vary by model. For example, the Sunset, Midnight, and Twilight mattresses have 2-inch comfort layers and gel-infused memory foam. The Moonlight, Dusk, and Dawn mattresses feature 1-inch comfort layers of Helix’s proprietary polyfoam, which doesn’t conform as closely. 

All the mattresses have a transitional layer of dynamic foam and support layers at their cores of 8-inch pocketed coils over a 1-inch layer of high-density base foam. These high-profile, highly customizable beds are an excellent choice for customers who want a reasonably priced mattress but aren’t sure which firmness is best for them.

Read our full Helix Sleep Mattress Review to learn more! 


 

DreamCloud

Best for Pain Relief

A medium-firm hybrid, the DreamCloud provides a firmer feel, excellent spinal alignment, and enough support for heavyweight sleepers.

Nerd Score
4.8 / 5
Firmness

Medium-Firm 6.5/10

Trial

365 nights

Reason to Buy

$$

The DreamCloud features six layers in is construction: three comfort layers, a transitional layer, a support core, and a polyfoam base. These layers contain 1-inch of polyfill, a half-inch of polyfoam, 1.5 inches of gel-infused memory foam, 2.5 inches of soft conventional foam, 8 inches of pocketed coils, and 1.5 inches of dense base polyfoam, respectively.

We recommend the DreamCloud for heavyweight sleepers or individuals with back pain or chronic pain for several reasons. Although the mattress contains several memory foam layers, sleepers will experience the feeling of sleeping on the bed rather than sinking into it. This is excellent quality for heavyweight sleepers, who require additional support. It also works well for back sleepers, who need a firm surface for ideal spinal alignment, and those with chronic pain, for whom firm edges ease the task of getting in and out of bed. 

Read our full DreamCloud Mattress Review to learn more!


 

What is an Innerspring Mattress? 

Innerspring mattresses, sometimes referred to as coil mattresses, contain a supportive core of metal coils that sits beneath a comfort layer. The comfort layer is typically constructed from soft, responsive material such as memory foam, latex, or polyfoam. Technically, the thickness of the comfort layer distinguishes an innerspring mattress from a hybrid mattress, which both have comfort layers. Mattresses with comfort layers 2” thick or less are considered innerspring, whereas mattress with thicker comfort layers are considered hybrids.

Innerspring mattresses almost always contain a high-density polyfoam base layer, which both keeps the bed stable and provides reinforcement for the coils. There are four main types of coils, including Bonnell, offset continuous coil wire, and pocket coils, which we’ll discuss in detail in the innerspring mattress buying guide below.

Innerspring Mattress Buying Guide

In this buyer’s guide, we cover everything you need to know when shopping for an innerspring mattress. You’ll learn the types of innerspring mattresses available, the key shopping considerations, and tips for picking the best innerspring mattress for your bedroom.

Types of Innerspring Mattresses

Innerspring mattresses are distinguished by the type of coils they contain, which fall into several categories.

Pocket Spring Coils (Wrapped/Encased Coils)—Often referred to as pocketed coils, pocket spring coils enhance the contouring properties of a mattress and reduce its motion transfer. The coils are encased in a cloth and connected to one another by thin strands of fabric. They are typically the most expensive models available.

Open Coils—Innerspring mattresses with open coils are considered traditional innerspring mattresses and contain interconnected coils in a metal mesh. The mesh provides even support throughout the mattress.

Offset Coils—Offset coils have an hourglass shape and a hinge-like, flat bottom. They’re joined together with helical (spiral-shaped wires), and their bottoms are straightened to create the hinging effect when the mattress is compressed. Offset coils can be found in double offset or free arm offset styles. They’re considered to be the most durable type of innerspring coil. 

Continuous Wire Coils—Continuous wire coils are designed to withstand heavy compression. These mattresses contain several rows of singular wires that are molded into circular shapes and joined by helical on either side. Similar to offset coils, this design creates a hinging effect, and continuous wire coils are known for their stability and resilience. However, continuous wire coils can’t contour to your body as well, which results in a shorter lifespan for the mattress overall.

HybridsHybrid mattresses combine two or more support systems. Typically, hybrid mattresses contain an innerspring system with layers of memory foam or latex on top. As mentioned above, there are two main types of innerspring mattresses: hybrid and innerspring. Traditional innerspring models are made with an interconnected “grid” of coils covered by a thin comfort layer. Hybrid mattresses are often made with individually pocketed coils and thicker comfort layers.

Considerations When Buying

When shopping for an innerspring mattress, these are the most important features and considerations to keep in mind. 

Coil Type—As discussed above, the coil type can impact the durability, quality, and price of the mattress.

Coil Count—Coil count refers to the number of coils used in the coil layer of the mattress. Most innerspring mattresses contain anywhere from 500 to 1,000 coils, though some contain less than 300 and others contain several thousand. Coil count can be an indicator of lifespan and the mattress’ contouring capabilities. In general, high coil count innerspring mattresses tend to be the most expensive and the most contouring.

Feel—Prior to shopping for an innerspring mattress, it’s essential to be sure than an innerspring mattress is, in fact, the type of mattress you want to purchase. Just like hybrid and all-foam styles, innerspring mattresses have a signature feel that sleepers either do or don’t enjoy. In general, people find innerspring mattresses to be less contouring to the body than foam models. However, they also find that innerspring mattresses have stronger edge support, are cooler, and have better responsiveness than other styles.

Price—Innersprings are often priced lower than other mattress types, but luxury styles can still cost several thousand dollars. 

Lifespan—One of the leading criticisms of innerspring mattresses is their durability. Over the years, innerspring mattresses have become known for short lifespans relative to other beds on the market. Premature sagging, lack of motion isolation, and other durability-related issues are still an issue in some innerspring models, but manufacturers have improved innerspring coil technology in recent years to help combat these issues.

How to Pick the Right Mattress For You

Once you understand how innerspring mattresses are made and the differences between types, we recommend setting your shopping budget and going from there. This will eliminate some options, most likely, and narrow your search. From there, it’s up to you! Fortunately, most bedding manufacturers with an online presence offer generous night trials and return policies, so even if you end up selecting an innerspring model that doesn’t work for you, you won’t be stuck with it.

Pros & Cons of Innerspring Mattresses 

PROS

  • Innersprings provide a relatively flat, firm sleeping surface that’s especially supportive for back and stomach sleepers
  • Due to the airflow allowed between the coils, innerspring mattresses tend to sleep cooler than all-foam models
  • Off-gassing is less common with innerspring mattresses than it is in hybrid and memory foam mattresses
  • Innerspring mattresses are among the most affordable options on the market

CONS

  • Sleepers complain of sagging and durability issues
  • Innersprings don’t offer as much contouring or pressure relief as foam
  • Cheap innerspring mattresses can be squeaky and don’t isolate motion well, which can lead to poor sleep for couples
  • The average lifespan of innerspring mattresses is relatively short when compared to other styles on the market

Conclusion 

The best innerspring mattress for you will depend on your sleeping style, height, weight, budget, and several other factors. We recommend using the buyer’s guide above to narrow down to the type of innerspring mattress you’re interested in. From there, reference our list of the top innerspring mattresses to see if there’s an option that could be a good fit for you! Don’t think innerspring is the right fit for you? Check out our other recommendations for the best mattresses of 2020.


Still need guidance in your mattress buying journey? Check out our ultimate mattress buying guide!

Recap of the Best Innerspring Mattresses

Mattress Best… Firmness Level 
Saatva Affordable Luxury Plush-Soft, Luxury-Firm & Firm
Casper Wave Hybrid Editor’s Pick Medium
WinkBeds For Heavyweight Sleepers Soft, Luxury-Firm & Firm
Brooklyn Signature Hybrid Value Soft, Medium & Firm
Helix Sleep Customizable Mattress Plush, Medium & Firm
DreamCloud For Pain Relief Medium-Firm

Comments (0)


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

By continuing to browse or by clicking “OK” you agree to the storing of first- and third-party cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Privacy Policy.

OK