Brooklyn Bedding vs. Tuft & Needle Mattress Comparison

•

January 7, 2023

Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft and Needle are two of the top brands in the bedding industry. In this comparison, we’ll look at how Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft & Needle compare in terms of quality, performance, and value for money. You can also explore our other reviews by reading our testing methodology.

Brooklyn Bedding vs Tuft and Needle Overview

In this section, we are going to cover the differences between Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft and Needle and identify which bed is best for whom.

Brooklyn Bedding is best for…	Tuft and Needle is best for…
Sleepers who seek variety	Budget shoppers
Heavyweight sleepers	Couples
Hot sleepers	Sleepers who seek balanced feel
Budget shoppers	Lightweight and average-weight sleepers

Who Should Choose the Brooklyn Bedding Mattress?

Sleepers who seek variety: Brooklyn Bedding’s unique foam blend is the best choice for sleepers who want to experience a variety of firmness levels in their mattress.
Heavyweight sleepers: If you’re a heavy sleeper, Brooklyn Bedding is the way to go since it offers a higher thread count and a thicker mattress for more support and comfort.
Hot sleepers: Hot sleepers will find great cooling comfort in the airflow through the individually-wrapped coils of the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid.
Budget shoppers: Brooklyn Bedding is the best choice for budget shoppers because it offers great value and a high-quality product for a luxurious feel.

Who Should Choose the Tuft and Needle Mattress?

Budget shoppers: Tuft and Needle is the best mattress for budget shoppers because it’s affordable, made with high-quality materials, and has a great warranty.
Couples: The Tuft & Needle mattress is best for couples because it provides the perfect balance between comfort and support, no matter what kind of sleeper you are.
Sleepers who seek a balanced feel: Tuft & Needle is the mattress for you if you want a balanced feel that will help you sleep soundly through the night without waking up in pain.
Lightweight and average-weight sleepers: Tuft & Needle is the best mattress for lightweight and average-weight sleepers because it has a unique, supportive foam layer that cradles your body and provides the support you need for a restful night’s sleep.

Brooklyn Bedding vs Tuft and Needle: Top Similarities

Value: Both Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft and Needle are companies that offer high-quality bedding at a lower price point than what’s available in traditional retailers.
Thickness: Both Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft & Needle offer mattresses that are similar in terms of thickness, with the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid being 11.5” tall and the T&N Mattress being 10” tall.
Motion Isolation: Both beds isolate motion to a significant extent, considering one is an all-foam mattress and one is a hybrid.
Feel: Both Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft & Needle are made with high-quality materials that are designed to last a long time, and they both offer mattresses that are designed to be breathable and easy to move around on.

Brooklyn Bedding vs. Tuft and Needle: Top Differences

Firmness: The T&N mattress comes in just one firmness level: medium-firm. The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid, on the other hand, is available in soft, medium, and firm levels.
Type: The T&N mattress is an all-foam mattress, and the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid is a hybrid mattress, combining coils and foam.
Support for Body Types: The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid provides adequate support for sleepers in all bodyweight categories, but the T&N struggles to provide enough support for heavyweight sleepers (especially those that sleep on their sides).
Price: Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft & Needle are similar in that they both offer high-quality mattresses at affordable prices. However, Brooklyn Bedding’s mattresses are a bit more expensive.

Brooklyn Bedding vs. Tuft and Needle: Firmness & Feel Differences

Let’s explore the differences between the Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft and Needle mattresses in terms of their feel and firmness levels.

What’s the Firmness Of the Brooklyn Bedding & Tuft and Needle Mattresses?

The T&N mattress is a medium-firm, and its low-density polyfoam comfort layer will provide some contouring and relief for pressure points without letting the body sink deeply into the mattress. On the other hand, the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid’s feel varies depending on the firmness setting you choose. The soft option provides deep contouring and a plush feel that alleviates pressure for the entire body, while the medium setting provides a balance of support and contouring. The firmer option is supportive, but sleepers will experience very little contouring if they choose this firmness setting.

What Do the Brooklyn Bedding & Tuft and Needle Mattresses Feel Like?

The Brooklyn Bedding mattress is bouncy and supportive, with a bit of give. It’s not very heavy, so you’ll be able to move it around on your own. Meanwhile, the Tuft & Needle Mattress is soft and cozy. It feels like a hug from your favorite blanket. The top layer of memory foam keeps you cool throughout the night.

What’s It Like to Sleep On the Brooklyn Bedding & Tuft and Needle Mattresses?

The Brooklyn Bedding & Tuft and Needle Mattresses are both made from high-quality materials and have a similar feel to them. Still, they differ in that the Brooklyn Bedding mattress is slightly thicker and has a more traditional feel, while the Tuft and Needle Mattress is thinner and has an edge support system that can be adjusted to suit your needs. Those who sleep on their sides will find that these mattresses offer good support for their hips, shoulders, and neck. However, those who sleep on their stomachs should look elsewhere—the Tuft and Needle mattress does not offer enough support for this position.

The Brooklyn Bedding vs. Tuft and Neele Mattresses By Body Type

Brooklyn Bedding Performance By Body Type & Sleeping Position:

Body Type:	BACK SLEEPERS	STOMACH SLEEPERS	SIDE SLEEPERS
Lightweight (< 130 lbs):	5	4	4
Average-weight (130–230 lbs):	5	3	3
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs):	5	2	2

Tuft and Needle Performance By Body Type & Sleeping Position:

Body Type:	BACK SLEEPERS	STOMACH SLEEPERS	SIDE SLEEPERS
Lightweight (< 130 lbs):	5	3	5
Average-weight (130–230 lbs):	5	4	3
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs):	2	2	2

1 = Very poor, 2 = Not good, 3 = Fair, 4 = Good, 5 = Excellent

Average-Weight Sleepers (130–230 lbs)

Average-weight back sleepers will find the Brooklyn Bedding mattress to be totally supportive and comfortable. Under-200 lbs side sleepers should have the pressure relief they require, while those closer to 230 lbs might wish to choose the soft variant. Although this mattress should be moderately supportive for stomach sleepers, the firm option might be a better choice.

The Tuft and Needle mattress, on the other hand, should provide an excellent blend of comfort and support for back sleepers. Side sleepers should get adequate pressure alleviation, while bigger people may experience severe pressure on their shoulders and hips. A more supportive, firmer mattress will be preferred by stomach sleepers.

Heavyweight Sleepers (> 230 lbs)

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid should be a comfortable, supportive fit for most back sleepers that fall into the heavyweight category. However, those who weigh more than 300 lbs might want to think about a mattress with more coil layers or a mattress designed for heavy folks. Side sleepers may find the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid to be overly firm. We advise choosing something with a thicker comfort layer that is softer. Heavy people who are stomach sleepers should perhaps look for something a little more supportive. Most likely, they won’t feel like their hips are receiving adequate support.

The Tuft & Needle may not be the ideal mattress for heavy persons, though. When you’re a stomach sleeper or back sleeper, you probably won’t get enough support. They’ll likely experience too much strain on their shoulders and hips if they are side sleepers.

Lightweight Sleepers (< 130 lbs)

The Brooklyn Bedding mattress is the perfect fit for lightweight back sleepers. Side sleepers will experience the pressure reduction required for a peaceful night’s sleep. The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid provides more than enough support for lightweight stomach sleepers.

Lightweight stomach sleepers may find the Tuft & Needle to be supportive enough. Meanwhile, light back and side sleepers should find the Tuft & Needle to be an excellent match. In fact, we discovered it to be among the top mattresses for children and teenagers.

Differences In Mattress Construction

In this section of the review, we are going to address the differences between Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft and Needle mattresses in terms of construction and materials.

Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Materials	Tuft and Needle Mattress Materials
Quilted cotton .5” polyfoam	Knit polyester-blend
2” gel-infused TitanFlex polyfoam	3” 2.8 PCF polyfoam
2” of gel-infused Energex polyfoam	N/A
6” pocketed coils1” high-density polyfoam base layer	7” 1.8 PCF high-density polyfoam
11.5”	10”

Cover

The Brooklyn Bedding mattress is designed to be more comfortable, with a .5” layer of polyfoam on top of the base foam. The Tuft & Needle mattress is designed to be more supportive and durable, with a 2” layer of latex foam on top of its base foam.

Comfort Layers

The Brooklyn Bedding mattress differs from the Tuft and Needle mattress in that it has a 2” gel-infused TitanFlex polyfoam, while Tuft & Needle has a 3” 2.8 PCF polyfoam. This means that the bed is firmer, with more of a bounce to it, as well as having more of an edge support.

Support Layers

The Brooklyn Bedding mattress differs from Tuft and Needle in terms of its support layers. The Brooklyn Bedding mattress has 6” pocketed coils and 1” high-density polyfoam base layer, while the Tuft and Needle mattress has 7” 1.8 PCF high-density polyfoam. This means that the Brooklyn Bedding mattress offers better support for sleepers looking for a firmer feel.

Brooklyn Bedding vs. Tuft and Needle Pricing

Size	Brooklyn Bedding Prices	Tuft and Needle Prices
Twin	$	$
Twin XL	$	$
Full	$	$
Queen	$	$
King	$	$
California King	$	$

For exclusive discounts on both beds, see our Brooklyn Bedding mattress coupons and Tuft and Needle mattress coupons.

Brooklyn Bedding vs. Tuft and Needle Mattress Performance Ratings & Differences

Let’s differentiate the Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft and Needle mattresses in terms of their performance by temperature, durability, pressure relief, and more.

Temperature

Both Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft and Needle mattresses are made from high-quality materials, meaning they’re both breathable and comfortable to sleep on. Both mattresses have similar ratings in temperature performance, so if you’re looking for something that will keep you cool, either of these mattresses could be a good option.

Motion Transfer

In general, softer mattresses, such as all-foam beds, minimize motion transfer better than more responsive styles, including latex and hybrid beds. The Tuft and Needle and Brooklyn Signature Hybrid absorb motion very well relative to their mattress style categories, making them good mattresses for couples.

Edge Support

The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid Mattress has far better edge support than the Tuft & Needle Mattress, but that advantage comes from Brooklyn’s layer of metal coils. Most all-foam mattresses, like the Tuft & Needle, fall short in this category.

Pressure Relief

Both the Tuft and Needle and Brooklyn Signature Hybrid offer excellent pressure relief, even though the way the relief feels differs slightly. Overall, the coils of the Brooklyn Bedding should support heavier sleepers better without unwanted pressure building up in their shoulders and hips. Both options are great mattresses for back sleepers, firm enough to support the entire body without the hips sinking too deep into the mattress.

Pain Relief

If you’re a back sleeper focused on spinal alignment, take a look at the firmer Tuft & Needle or the firm setting of the Brooklyn Bedding mattress. Though these won’t feel as “plush” or “cloud-like” when you lay down on them at night, it’s far more important to have an all-night alignment that doesn’t leave you with aches and pains in the morning.

Durability

All-foam beds tend to be less durable than hybrid mattresses, for example, due to the fact that foams compress and lose their shape much faster than coils. That said, the Tuft & Needle and Brooklyn Bedding models have competitive warranties that show the brands’ confidence in their products.

Shipping, Returns, & Warranties

Brooklyn Bedding

Brooklyn Bedding offers free shipping anywhere in the United States, including Alaska and Hawaii. It also comes with a 120-night trial period which means you can test the mattress for feel before committing fully to it, and you’ll receive a free refund if it’s not for you. The mattress also has a 10-year Brooklyn Bedding warranty that covers some manufacturing and material defects.

Tuft and Needle

Tuft & Needle offers free shipping only around the contiguous U.S.; however, if you reside in Alaska and Hawaii, you will need to pay an extra shipping fee. Tuft & Needle offers White Glove delivery in the contiguous U.S. for a flat fee. You’ll have a 100 nights trial period to test out your new T&N mattress, and it has a limited 10-year warranty, covering body impressions or indentions, damaged construction, or dimensional specification failures.