Brooklyn Bedding vs. Saatva Mattress Comparison

Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

Brooklyn Bedding and Saatva are two of the most well-known bed-in-a-box mattress brands around. In this review, we take a look at the two brand’s flagship hybrid mattresses and break down their features, pros, and cons so you can decide which one is right for your sleeping position and preferences.

Product
Firmness
Score
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress
Multiple firmness options
4.8/5
Saatva Mattress
Multiple firmness options
4.3/5
Product
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress
Firmness
Multiple firmness options
Score
4.8/5
Product
Saatva Mattress
Firmness
Multiple firmness options
Score
4.3/5

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid vs. Saatva Overview

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid is best for…Saatva is best for…
Budget shoppersLuxury shoppers
Sleepers that prefer a balanced feelHot sleepers
Side sleepers and those with joint painSleepers who suffer from back pain

Who Should Choose the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid Mattress?

  • Budget shoppers: The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid is a few hundred dollars cheaper than the Saatva mattress.
  • Sleepers that prefer a balanced feel: The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid bed isn’t too plush or too firm. It keeps you gently lifted on top of the mattress while still providing you with pressure relief. 
  • Side sleepers and those with joint pain: This mattress allows your shoulders, hips, and knees to sink deeper into the mattress to help redistribute your body weight and relieve stress from these tender areas.

Who Should Choose the Saatva Mattress?

  • Luxury shoppers: The Saatva mattress is made with top of the line, eco-friendly materials, like organic cotton, and features a plush, quilted pillow top. 
  • Hot sleepers: Two breathable rows of innerspring coils and moisture-wicking cotton will help keep you cool throughout the night. 
  • Sleepers who suffer from back pain: The Saatva is built with two layers of responsive and sturdy innerspring coils that provide ergonomic support to your neck and spine.

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid vs. Saatva: Top Similarities 

  • The Saatva and Brooklyn Signature are both great options for back sleepers and combination sleepers.
  • Both of these mattresses are built with innerspring coils, which improves mobility and responsiveness on the mattress surface.
  • These mattresses are both made of durable mattress materials and should last about 6-7 years before they start to show signs of wear.

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid vs. Saatva: Top Differences 

  • We felt more pressure relief around our shoulders and hips on the Brooklyn Signature mattress.
  • The Saatva mattress has more of a pillow top feel, with a soft comfort layer and firm support layers underneath. The Brooklyn Signature has more of a hybrid feel with lots of cushion on top and a bit of bounce at the base. 
  • There is more soft foam on top of the Brooklyn Signature than the Saatva. That helps it do a better job of limiting motion transfer if you sleep with a partner or pet.
  • The Saatva mattress has a firmer level of support that is more suitable for stomach sleepers than the Signature.

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid vs. Saatva: Firmness & Feel Differences

Each of these hybrid mattresses has a unique feel that makes it better suited to different types of sleepers.

What’s the Firmness Of the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid & Saatva Mattresses?

Both of these mattresses are offered in three similar firmness level options. The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid comes in soft, medium, and firm, and the Saatva is available in plush soft, luxury firm, and firm. Although mattress firmness is subjective to each individual, if you have a lighter body weight, beds will typically feel more firm and a bed will feel softer to those with a heavier body weight.

What Do the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid & Saatva Mattresses Feel Like?

When you first lay down on the Brooklyn Signature mattress, you’ll first feel the cushioning comfort of the memory foam balanced by the firm support underneath. The Saatva, however, feels less plush and more firmly supportive, keeping you lifted so you feel as if you are floating on top of the bed.

What’s It Like to Sleep On the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid & Saatva Mattresses?

Both mattresses are responsive yet quiet and would work well for back or combination sleepers. Side sleepers, however, will appreciate the Brooklyn Signature mattress while stomach sleepers will likely get a better night’s rest on the Saatva.

The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid vs. Saatva Mattresses By Body Type

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid Performance By Body Type & Sleeping Position:

Body Type:BACK SLEEPERSSTOMACH SLEEPERSSIDE SLEEPERS
Lightweight (< 130 lbs): 43
Average-weight (130–230 lbs):533
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs): 424
We tested the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid in medium.

Saatva Performance By Body Type & Sleeping Position:

Body Type:BACK SLEEPERSSTOMACH SLEEPERSSIDE SLEEPERS
Lightweight (< 130 lbs): 553
Average-weight (130–230 lbs):554
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs): 34
We tested the Saatva mattress in luxury firm.

1 = Very poor, 2 = Not good, 3 = Fair, 4 = Good, 5 = Excellent

Average-Weight Sleepers (130–230 lbs)

Average-weight back and stomach sleepers could get the support they need on the firm Brooklyn Signature Hybrid or the firm Saatva mattress, while side sleepers could opt for the soft or medium/luxury-firm options of either bed. Both beds are well suited for average-weight sleepers in all sleeping positions, so combination sleepers will also be comfortable on either option. 

Heavyweight Sleepers (> 230 lbs)

If you’re a heavyweight back or stomach sleeper, the “firm” version of the Signature Hybrid or the Saatva could work for you. The Saatva is probably a better bet if you’re a stomach sleeper, however, because the second row of innerspring coils will help keep your spine in a neutral position throughout the night.

Heavyweight side sleepers will likely be comfortable on the medium version of the Signature Hybrid or the Saatva mattress. Combination sleepers will be also comfortable on either the medium or firm version, depending on their primary sleeping position. 

Lightweight Sleepers (< 130 lbs)

Lightweight back sleepers will likely get the support they need on the medium version of the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid or the luxury-firm Saatva mattress. Lightweight side sleepers will be more comfortable on the Brooklyn Signature since it offers deeper pressure relief, and they should also opt for the medium model.

Lightweight stomach sleepers, however, should choose the more supportive Saatva to avoid sinkage that can cause lower back pain. Since both beds are bouncy and responsive, combination sleepers will be happy on either mattress. 

Differences In Mattress Construction 

These hybrid beds have similar constructions, but the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid is 11” tall while the Saatva can be 11.5” or 14.5” tall, depending on which option you choose. 

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid Mattress Materials Saatva Mattress Materials
Quilted comfort foamOrganic cotton cover
Two layers of memory foamEuro-style pillow topper
Ascension Coils14.5-Gauge Recycled Steel Coils
Flex Base13-Gauge Coil Base Layer

Cover

The Brooklyn Signature mattress cover is quilted with a thin layer of comfort foam to provide a little extra cushioning. The Saatva mattress cover is made of organic cotton that’s designed to stay cool throughout the night. 

Comfort Layers

The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid has two foam comfort layers. The first layer is called TitanFlex foam which has a soft feel and the responsiveness of latex. The second layer of foam is called VariFlex foam (formerly Energex foam), which acts as a transition into the coil support system below. 

The Saatva features a 3” euro pillow top that feels plush and decadent when you first lie down on the mattress. The pillow topper is supported by an active wire frame and an extra layer of memory foam under the center third of the mattress to improve lumbar support and prevent you from sinking uncomfortably far into the bed. 

Support Layers

A base layer of support polyfoam adds stability and reduces sagging to the bottom of the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid mattress. 

The Saatva features three support layers, including a dual layer coil system. The top layer is micro-coils that provide nuanced motion isolation and make moving around on the mattress a lot easier. The second layer of coils is much firmer. It’s the support system for the whole mattress. Finally, high-density foam frames the entire mattress and improves edge support.

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid vs. Saatva Pricing

SizeBrooklyn Signature Hybrid PricesSaatva Prices
Twin$699.00$935.00
Twin XL$799.00$1225.00
Full$899.00$1695.00
Queen$1249.00$1795.00
King$1499.00$2195.00
California King$1499.00$2195.00

For exclusive discounts on both beds see our Brooklyn Signature Hybrid mattress coupons and Saatva mattress coupons.

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid vs. Saatva Mattress Performance Ratings & Differences

Temperature

Temperature regulation is really important for a comfortable night’s sleep. The Saatva and Brooklyn Signature naturally sleep fairly cool because the coil base layers create lots of space for airflow. Brooklyn Bedding‘s TitanFlex foam is even infused with cooling gel. 

We don’t think you’ll overheat on either of these beds, making them both great mattresses for hot sleepers.

Motion Transfer

Motion transfer measures how well a mattress muffles movements on the mattress surface before they have the chance to spread. A mattress that doesn’t limit motion transfer will cause you to feel more of your sleeping partner‘s movements. Generally, memory foam reduces motion transfer the best, while coils have a natural springiness that can amplify motion transfer. 

When we reviewed the Brooklyn Signature and Saatva mattresses, we noted that the Signature did a better job of minimizing motion transfer. With that said, unless you have a restless sleeping partner, we don’t think you’ll experience too many disruptions on either bed. For more options, check out the best mattresses for couples.

Edge Support 

Saatva and Brooklyn Bedding both reinforce the edges of their flagship mattresses, which means they frame the sides of the bed with extra supportive materials to add extra stability. This is helpful if you like to sit on the edge of your bed when getting ready in the morning, or if you need a sturdy surface to get in and out of bed. 

To our surprise, the Signature did not provide much edge support. We felt as though we might slide off the side of the bed if we sat too close. On the other hand, the Saatva provided excellent edge support. It’s a better choice for those who want to use their entire mattress surface.

Pressure Relief 

If you are a side sleeper, then pressure relief is extra important for you. Side sleepers put a lot of stress on their shoulders and hips, so they need a mattress that contours around their pressure points. Hybrid and innerspring mattresses generally provide less pressure relief because coils are not as easily compressed as foam. Mattresses with a coil layer are best for stomach and back sleepers, though both mattresses offer a soft firmness option that may provide enough pressure relief for side sleepers.

Pain Relief 

A bed that helps keep your back in a healthy posture throughout the night may help relieve pain. When your spine is pushed out of alignment by your mattress or pillow, you might notice neck or back pain in the morning. 

Both of these mattresses do a great job of supporting a healthy, neutral spine alignment, but we think the extra lumbar support in the Saatva gives it a slight edge over the Brooklyn Signature. 

Durability 

The Brooklyn Signature and Saatva are both high-quality mattresses that should last you upwards of 6 or 7 years before beginning to show signs of wear. Plus, both mattress companies provide generous warranties that protect you against manufacturing defects and premature deterioration.

Shipping, Returns, & Warranties

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid 

Brooklyn Bedding provides free shipping on your mattress purchase within the contiguous United States. Deliveries to Alaska and Hawaii are $125, and $250 to Canada. 

You get a 120-night sleep trial period to test out your new mattress, plus free returns. Your mattress is also covered by a 10-year warranty that protects against sagging over 1” and cracks in the foam. 

Note: The sleep trial and return policy may be different if you purchase your mattress from Amazon.

Saatva

Saatva’s free shipping includes white glove delivery and old mattress removal. Customers receive a 365-night sleep trial period and free returns, minus a $99 transportation fee. Used mattresses are picked up and donated.

Saatva protects their mattresses against defects with a Lifetime warranty for the original owner. During the first two years of Saatva’s warranty, they’ll replace your defective mattress for free. After that—they’ll repair and recover your mattress for a $99 transportation fee both ways.

Other Models Available

EcoSleep Luxe

The EcoSleep Luxe by Brooklyn Bedding is a luxury mattress made with natural latex, organic cotton and wool, and pocketed coils. The adjustable pillow top accommodates all sleeping positions, and the construction keeps hot sleepers from overheating.

Nerd Score 4.2/5
Read Full Review

Material

Hybrid

Trial Period

120 nights

Shipping Method

Free shipping

Firmness

Medium-firm: 6/10

Warranty

10-year warranty

Price Range

$$$$$

We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types:

Hot Sleepers
If you often overheat while you sleep, this mattress should help you stay cool.
Side Sleeping
Ideal for lightweight and average weight side sleepers.

Financing Options

Financing options are available for this mattress.

Average Customer Rating
5.0/5

EcoSleep Luxe

The EcoSleep Luxe by Brooklyn Bedding is a luxury mattress made with natural latex, organic cotton and wool, and pocketed coils. The adjustable pillow top accommodates all sleeping positions, and the construction keeps hot sleepers from overheating.

Nerd Score 4.2/5
Read Full Review

Material

Hybrid

Warranty

10-year warranty

Firmness

Medium-firm: 6/10

Shipping Method

Free shipping

Trial Period

120 nights

Price Range

$$$$$

We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types:

Hot Sleepers
If you often overheat while you sleep, this mattress should help you stay cool.
Side Sleeping
Ideal for lightweight and average weight side sleepers.

Financing Options

Financing options are available for this mattress.

Average Customer Rating
5.0/5

EcoSleep Luxe

The EcoSleep Luxe by Brooklyn Bedding is a luxury mattress made with natural latex, organic cotton and wool, and pocketed coils. The adjustable pillow top accommodates all sleeping positions, and the construction keeps hot sleepers from overheating.

Nerd Score 4.2/5
Read Full Review

Material

Hybrid

Firmness

Medium-firm: 6/10

Trial Period

120 nights

Warranty

10-year warranty

Shipping Method

Free shipping

Price Range

$$$$$

We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types:

Hot Sleepers
If you often overheat while you sleep, this mattress should help you stay cool.
Side Sleeping
Ideal for lightweight and average weight side sleepers.

Financing Options

Financing options are available for this mattress.

Average Customer Rating
5.0/5

See our Brooklyn Bedding EcoSleep Luxe review to learn more.

Saatva HD Mattress

The Saatva HD ranks as a top mattress for heavyweight individuals over 230 lbs. The durable materials and construction provide comfort and support by keeping sleepers lifted and cushioned. The medium-firm feel works best for back and side sleeping.

Nerd Score 4.5/5
Read Full Review

Material

Hybrid

Trial Period

365 nights

Shipping Method

Free white glove delivery

Firmness

Medium-firm: 7/10

Warranty

Lifetime warranty

Price Range

$$$$$

We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types:

Hot Sleepers
If you often overheat while you sleep, this mattress should help you stay cool.
Back Pain
This bed is perfect for anyone suffering from back pain.
Back Sleeping
Ideal for average weight and heavyweight back sleepers.
Side Sleeping
Ideal for heavyweight side sleepers.
Stomach Sleeping
Ideal for average weight and heavyweight stomach sleepers.

Financing Options

Financing options are available for this mattress.

Average Customer Rating
4.9/5

Saatva HD Mattress

The Saatva HD ranks as a top mattress for heavyweight individuals over 230 lbs. The durable materials and construction provide comfort and support by keeping sleepers lifted and cushioned. The medium-firm feel works best for back and side sleeping.

Nerd Score 4.5/5
Read Full Review

Material

Hybrid

Warranty

Lifetime warranty

Firmness

Medium-firm: 7/10

Shipping Method

Free white glove delivery

Trial Period

365 nights

Price Range

$$$$$

We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types:

Hot Sleepers
If you often overheat while you sleep, this mattress should help you stay cool.
Back Pain
This bed is perfect for anyone suffering from back pain.
Back Sleeping
Ideal for average weight and heavyweight back sleepers.
Side Sleeping
Ideal for heavyweight side sleepers.
Stomach Sleeping
Ideal for average weight and heavyweight stomach sleepers.

Financing Options

Financing options are available for this mattress.

Average Customer Rating
4.9/5

Saatva HD Mattress

The Saatva HD ranks as a top mattress for heavyweight individuals over 230 lbs. The durable materials and construction provide comfort and support by keeping sleepers lifted and cushioned. The medium-firm feel works best for back and side sleeping.

Nerd Score 4.5/5
Read Full Review

Material

Hybrid

Firmness

Medium-firm: 7/10

Trial Period

365 nights

Warranty

Lifetime warranty

Shipping Method

Free white glove delivery

Price Range

$$$$$

We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types:

Hot Sleepers
If you often overheat while you sleep, this mattress should help you stay cool.
Back Pain
This bed is perfect for anyone suffering from back pain.
Back Sleeping
Ideal for average weight and heavyweight back sleepers.
Side Sleeping
Ideal for heavyweight side sleepers.
Stomach Sleeping
Ideal for average weight and heavyweight stomach sleepers.

Financing Options

Financing options are available for this mattress.

Average Customer Rating
4.9/5

See our Saatva HD review to learn more.