Brooklyn Bedding vs. Layla Mattress Comparison

Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid mattress pairs soft foam layers with a supportive coil base layer. The Layla mattress is an all-foam mattress with a flippable construction that includes a soft side and a firm side.

Brooklyn Bedding vs Layla Overview

Know which mattress is best for you. Whether you’re a budget shopper or looking for mattresses for couples, there’s one here for you. Read more below:

Brooklyn Bedding is best for…Layla is best for…
Hot sleepersSide sleepers 
People who like a neutral foam feelCouples
All sleeping positions and body typesIndecisive shoppers

Who Should Choose the Brooklyn Mattress?

  • Hot sleepers: If you tend to wake up sweaty and hot during the night, this bed is a good option. The coil layer keeps air flowing through the mattress and the top layer of foam is infused with cooling gel.
  • People who like a neutral foam feel: If you like a universally comfortable, soft foam feel that doesn’t sink like memory foam, you’ll like the Signature Hybrid.
  • All sleeping positions and body types: The Signature Hybrid’s three firmness options offer something for just about every sleeper type.

Who Should Choose the Layla Mattress?

  • Side sleepers: Experience plenty of pressure relief on the soft side of the Layla.
  • Couples: Appreciate excellent motion isolation and minimal disruptions from their sleeping partner.
  • Indecisive shoppers: Benefit from two firmness options in one mattress.

Brooklyn Bedding vs Layla: Top Similarities 

  • Spine Support: Both of these mattresses support healthy spinal alignment for back and side sleepers.
  • May not be for stomach sleepers: Neither bed is the best fit for heavyweight stomach sleepers, since they need a mattress that’s firm enough to keep their hips lifted in alignment with their shoulders.

Brooklyn Bedding vs Layla: Top Differences 

  • Responsiveness: The Brooklyn Signature is higher in responsiveness than the Layla, meaning it responds more quickly to your changes in sleeping position. 
  • Pressure Relief: The soft side of the Layla provides more pressure relief than the Brooklyn Signature.
  • Temperature: The Brooklyn Signature mattress sleeps cooler than the Layla, thanks to a more breathable construction that includes coils.
  • Motion Isolation: We think the Layla offers better motion isolation, which is typical of all-foam beds.

Brooklyn Bedding vs Layla: Firmness & Feel Differences

Firmness levels have a direct correlation with a good night’s sleep. Figure out the feel, firmness, and functionality of each mattress below:

What’s the Firmness of the Brooklyn Bedding vs Layla Mattresses? 

Both beds in this mattress comparison come with multiple firmness options: the Brooklyn Signature is available in soft, medium, and firm. We’ve personally tested the medium Brooklyn Signature, and give it a 6/10 firmness level rating. The flippable Layla mattress has a medium-soft side and a medium-firm side. The softer side falls around 4/10, and the firmer side is close to 7/10.

What Do the Brooklyn Bedding & Layla Mattresses Feel Like?

Both of these beds have motion-isolating foam comfort layers, but the support foam at the core of the Layla absorbs motion a little better than the coils at the base of the Brooklyn Signature.

What’s It Like to Sleep on the Brooklyn Bedding vs Layla Mattresses?

If you’re a back sleeper or combination sleeper, we recommend the Brooklyn Signature, since it combines responsiveness, support, and comfort. It’s also a slightly cooler choice for hot sleepers. The Layla is a better choice for those who want the deep compression and pressure relief of memory foam. It’s also a great option for couples who want to minimize motion disruptions.

Brooklyn Bedding vs Layla Mattresses By Body Type

Brooklyn Bedding Performance By Body Type & Sleeping Position:

Body Type:BACK SLEEPERSSTOMACH SLEEPERSSIDE SLEEPERS
Lightweight (< 130 lbs): 43 2
Average-weight (130–230 lbs):533
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs): 424

Layla Performance By Body Type & Sleeping Position:

Body Type:BACK SLEEPERSSTOMACH SLEEPERSSIDE SLEEPERS
Lightweight (< 130 lbs): 545
Average-weight (130–230 lbs):434
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs): 223

1 = Very poor, 2 = Not good, 3 = Fair, 4 = Good, 5 = Excellent

Average-Weight Sleepers (130–230 lbs)

Average-weight back sleepers will likely get the support they need on the “medium” version of the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid, and side sleepers will likely find adequate pressure relief and spinal alignment in the medium version of the Signature Hybrid. Average-weight stomach sleepers probably won’t find the support they need in the medium Brooklyn Signature Hybrid mattress, but they might find proper support in the firm version of the bed while combination sleepers will likely be able to change positions easily on the medium version of the mattress. 

For average-weight back sleepers, Layla ensures proper spinal alignment and helps ease back pain. Similar combination sleepers will find this relatively responsive for motion transfer. Side and stomach sleepers might experience sinking in the hips on this bed, therefore, should opt for a firmer mattress. 

Heavyweight Sleepers (> 230 lbs)

If you’re a heavyweight back sleeper or someone who prefers an ultra-firm mattress, the “firm” version of the Signature Hybrid could work for you. Side sleepers and combination sleepers will likely find adequate pressure relief and spinal alignment but stomach sleepers probably won’t find the support they need in the medium Brooklyn Signature Hybrid mattress, but they might find proper support in the firm version of the bed.

Layla is not ideal for heavyweight back sleepers because of the mattress’s all-foam construction. Side, stomach, and combination sleepers reported to feel sinking on the hips and may need a firmer mattress. 

Lightweight Sleepers (< 130 lbs)

Lightweight back sleepers will likely get the support they need on the “medium” version of the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid. The “soft” version of the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid should be good for side sleepers but stomach sleepers may find proper support in the medium version of the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid. Combination sleepers will likely be able to change positions easily on the medium version.

Layla’s firm mattress may give enough support for lightweight back sleepers, as well as for stomach and side sleepers who should find enough support on the Layla. Combination sleepers should feel easy to move around on and relatively responsive, especially on the firmer side of the bed. 

Differences in Mattress Construction 

The Layla mattress is flippable and comes with a color-coded cover that provides visual cues for which side is which. The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid mattress is a great example of an affordable hybrid bed with three foam layers used in the mattress.

Brooklyn Bedding Signature HybridLayla Mattress Materials
Quilted Memory Foam TopThermoGel Cooling Cover
TitanFlex Comfort Foam (2″)3” Copper Gel Memory Foam
TitanFlex Support Foam (2″)Max Airflow Support Foam
Ascension Pocketed Coils (6″)Support Core Foam

Cover

The Brooklyn Signature is wrapped in a soft, breathable polyester mattress cover. Layla’s four layers of foam are encased in a cooling mattress cover that’s infused with heat-absorbing ThermoGel.

Comfort Layers

The top layer is Brooklyn Bedding’s proprietary TitanFlex foam that easily compresses under pressure and rapidly springs back to shape when you change positions (a great feature for combination sleepers). The soft side is topped with 3” of gel and copper-infused memory foam.

Support Layers

The coil system rests on a thin layer of support foam and improves the overall support and airflow of the mattress. The core of the mattress is a dense layer of support foam that gives the mattress structure and durability. 

Brooklyn Bedding vs Layla Pricing

SizeBrooklyn Bedding PricesLayla Prices
Twin$$
Twin XL$$
Full$$
Queen$$
King$$
California King$$

For exclusive discounts on both beds see our Brooklyn mattress coupons and Layla mattress coupons.

Brooklyn Bedding vs Layla Mattress Performance Ratings & Differences

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress

Best for: back sleepers, hot sleepers, and combination sleepers. The Signature Hybrid mattress comes in three firmness options and is made with a slew of proprietary materials. Brooklyn Bedding knows their mattresses.

Nerd Score

4.8/5 

Layla Mattress

Best for: side sleepers, couples, and indecisive shoppers. The Layla and Layla Hybrid mattresses both feature cooling features in their construction such as copper gel-infused memory foam and a breathable top layer. Between these two beds, the Hybrid has a more cooling construction because of its gel-infused top layers and breathable coil base.

Nerd Score

3.6/5 

Temperature

If you run hot or cold at night, you need a mattress that keeps a neutral temperature profile. Both the Brooklyn Signature and Layla incorporate temperature-regulating gel memory foam and breathable base layers. Even so, the breathability of the coils at the base of the Brooklyn Signature gives it a cooling edge over the Layla. If you love memory foam, the Layla is still a relatively cool option, but it’s noticeably warmer than the Brooklyn Signature.

Motion Transfer

Motion transfer can cause sleep disruptions if you share your bed, so it’s especially important for couples. In general, memory foam isolates motion better than coils because coils have a natural bounce-back. Both of these beds have motion-isolating foam comfort layers, but the support foam at the core of the Layla absorbs motion a little better than the coils at the base of the Brooklyn Signature. We don’t think couples will notice major motion disruptions on either bed, but if you’re an especially light sleeper, the Layla is the better choice.

Edge Support 

Edge support is an important category for sleepers who share their bed or for anyone planning to use the edges of their bed for daily tasks (ex: putting your shoes on in the morning). Mattresses with reinforced edges—like extra firm springs or high-density foam—provide the best edge support. 

The Brooklyn Signature has firmer coils around its perimeter, but the Layla doesn’t have any extra edge support elements. Predictably, we felt better supported around the sides of the Brooklyn Signature mattress. On the Layla, we felt more supported on the firm side than on the soft side.

Pressure Relief 

Pressure relief is a performance category that demonstrates how well a mattress cushions your bumpier bits. Mattresses with lots of pressure relief have a cloud-like feel, thanks to deep contouring around pressure points. Depending on your sleeping position, you’ll need more or less pressure relief. For example, side sleepers need ample sinkage around their shoulders and hips, while stomach sleepers need a firmer mattress to keep their lower back supported.

Pain Relief 

Good posture is important to avoid neck and back pain, but did you know that you can have bad posture while sleeping? Your spine naturally has gentle curves, and when it’s repeatedly pulled out of that shape, that puts strain on your muscles. You’ve experienced the effects of poor sleeping posture if you’ve ever woken up with a sore neck or lower back.

Mattresses that support spinal alignment evenly distribute your body weight, so your spine stays in a neutral position. We found that both of these mattresses sustained good spinal alignment, but the Brooklyn Signature did a slightly better job for side and back sleepers, while the firm side of the Layla was better for lightweight stomach sleepers. For options that work with more body types: best mattresses for stomach sleepers.

Durability 

When you spend hundreds of dollars on a mattress, you want it to last for as long as possible. Generally, hybrid and memory foam mattresses last longer than innerspring mattresses. We think you can expect at least six to seven years from the Brooklyn Signature and Layla, though they may last up to a decade. Plus, Brooklyn Bedding and Layla both protect their mattresses with generous warranties that cover defects.

Shipping, Returns, & Warranties 

Brooklyn Bedding 

Free shipping to all 48 contiguous states in the U.S. via FedEx Ground with additional charges for Alaska, Canada, and Hawaii. Offering a 120-night trial period, allowing for a break-in period for your body to adjust before deciding on the mattress. If you decide you don’t like the bed, you can initiate a return for a full refund after 30 nights.

The Signature Hybrid is covered by a 10-year warranty from the date of purchase including deterioration in the cell structure of the foam, splitting and cracking of the material, impressions greater than 1”, and sagging if the mattress is continuously supported by a foundation.

Layla

Free shipping to all 48 contiguous states in the U.S. with additional charges for Alaska, Canada, and Hawaii. Offering a 120-night trial period, allowing for a break-in period for your body to adjust before deciding on the mattress. 
Layla also provides an industry-leading Lifetime warranty. You can claim free repairs or a replacement if your mattress develops body impressions over 1”, cracks in the foam, or unraveled seams in the mattress cover.

More Brooklyn Bedding Mattresses

This mattress is no longer available for purchase. To help you find your next mattress, check out our list of the best mattresses available on the market now.

See our full Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe Mattress Review to learn more.

This mattress is no longer available for purchase. To help you find your next mattress, check out our list of the best mattresses available on the market now.

See our Brooklyn Sedona Elite mattress review to learn more.

More Layla Mattresses

This mattress is no longer available for purchase. To help you find your next mattress, check out our list of the best mattresses available on the market now.

See our full Layla Hybrid mattress review to learn more.

Our Final Take

The Brooklyn Signature and Layla are both high-quality, bed-in-a-box mattresses, but they’re best suited to different kinds of sleepers. We favor the Brooklyn Signature mattress for back sleepers, combination sleepers, and those who need a mattress that stays cool. The Layla is a better option for memory foam devotees and couples who want motion isolation and firmness options.

If pricing is your main concern, keep in mind that the price point for a queen size only differs by $25 (the Brooklyn Signature is more expensive). Plus, both mattresses come with 120-night trial periods, free returns, and generous warranties.

Brooklyn Bedding vs Layla FAQs

Is the Layla mattress toxic?

No, it is not toxic. You’re probably wondering about the off-gassing smell Layla emits when you unbox the bed. This is completely normal when the foam is vacuum-packed. Let your bed air out for a few hours to days, and you should be just fine.

How long does the Layla mattress last?

Like most all-foam mattresses, Layla should last you anywhere from five to seven years. But remember: Layla is a flippable mattress, so you may be able to get more life out of your bed by flipping it once one side wears down. Be sure to rotate it regularly.

Does Brooklyn Bedding need a box spring?

No, the Brooklyn Signature mattress does not require a box spring. The mattress can work with any support system that provides minimal to no flex.

RELATED ARTICLES

_wp_attachment_image_alt
Best Mattress

Best Bed-in-a-Box

We tell you everything you need to know about the best bed-in-a-box and how to pick the one that will match your needs, from cooling to firmness.
_wp_attachment_image_alt
Best Mattress

Best Mattresses for Back Sleepers

A guide for back sleepers to find the best mattress for their sleep position and the benefits of sleeping on your back.
_wp_attachment_image_alt
Best Mattress

Best Mattresses for Side Sleepers

Mattress Nerd consulted Dr. Tom Ingegno to ensure that this article met our editorial standards. Did you know that about 74 percent of adults sleep on their sides for at least a portion of the night? For many, there’s no cozier position than side sleeping. Whether you like to extend your legs fully, keep one straight, or pulling […]