Brooklyn Bedding vs. Puffy Mattress Comparison

Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

In this mattress comparison, we help you decide between a hybrid mattress and an all-foam mattress—the Brooklyn Bedding and the Puffy! Read to find out which works better for you. Make sure to check out what others are saying in our testing methodology

Brooklyn Bedding vs. Puffy Overview

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid mattress is topped with two layers of cooling foam and supported by bouncy coils. The Puffy mattress has an all-foam construction that includes soft memory foam, buoyant transition foam, and supportive base foam.

Brooklyn Bedding is best for…Puffy is best for…
Combination sleepersSide sleepers
Back sleepershose with joint pain
CouplesLightweight and average-weight sleepers

Who Should Choose the Brooklyn Bedding Mattress?

  • Combination sleepers: Those who need a mattress that quickly responds to changes in position, the Brooklyn Signature is designed to be extra responsive.
  • Back sleepers: The Brooklyn Signature’s medium firmness provides a balance of cushioning and support.
  • Couples: Those who sleep with a partner and require both coil support and foam comfort will find the Brooklyn Signature a great compromise.

Who Should Choose the Puffy Mattress?

  • Side sleepers: On the Puffy, you should get adequate pressure relief around their shoulders and hips.
  • Those with joint pain: If you’re struggling with this, you can benefit from the softness and conforming nature of the Cooling Cloud comfort layers.
  • Lightweight and average-weight sleepers: The Puffy provides a sink just deep enough into the mattress to experience full-body cushioning without compromising on support.

Brooklyn Bedding vs. Puffy: Top Similarities 

  • Firmness: The Puffy and the medium version of the Brooklyn Signature both have a mid-range firmness level that we rated at 6/10. This medium-firmness is soft enough to sink into and supportive enough to keep you from feeling stuck “in” the mattress.
  • Temperature: Both of these beds feature cooling gel infusions in their proprietary foam layers.

Brooklyn Bedding vs. Puffy: Top Differences 

  • Motion transfer: The Puffy provides better motion isolation for those with sleeping partners. The springiness of the Brooklyn Signature causes bounce-back that may be disruptive when someone gets in or out of bed.
  • Responsiveness: The TitanFlex foam on top of the Brooklyn Signature rates higher for responsiveness than the Puffy, meaning it responds more quickly to your changes in position. The Cooling Cloud foam on top of the Puffy has more of the slow response typical of memory foam. 
  • Cooling level: The Brooklyn Signature mattress sleeps cooler than the Puffy thanks to airflow through the coil layer at the base of the mattress.

Brooklyn Bedding vs. Puffy: Firmness & Feel Differences

Read on to know the difference between the Brooklyn Bedding’s and Puffy’s firmness and feel. 

What’s the Firmness Of the Brooklyn Bedding & Puffy Mattresses? 

The Brooklyn Signature is available in three firmness options: soft, medium, and firm. The Puffy is available only in medium-firm. We actually think the Puffy and medium firmness Brooklyn Signature have the same firmness level: medium-firm. This provides a crowd-pleasing blend of comfort and support. 

What Do the Brooklyn Bedding & Puffy Mattresses Feel Like?

The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid has a balanced feel; in other words, it’s cushioning at first contact, but transitions into a more supportive “on the mattress” feel. The Puffy has a soft and supportive feel rather than feeling “stuck” in the mattress, it also has a balanced yet responsive foam feel, meaning it’s a good choice for combination sleepers who move around at night. 

What’s It Like to Sleep On the Brooklyn Bedding & Puffy Mattresses?

The Brooklyn Bedding has great motion isolation so you will not feel your partner tossing and turning at night, it is ideal for average weight back sleepers. The Puffy is a relatively simple all-foam mattress with gel-infused comfort layers. It’s a better choice for side sleepers and couples concerned with motion transfer.

The Brooklyn Bedding vs. Puffy Mattresses By Body Type

Brooklyn Bedding Performance By Body Type & Sleeping Position:

Body Type:BACK SLEEPERSSTOMACH SLEEPERSSIDE SLEEPERS
Lightweight (< 130 lbs): 31
Average-weight (130–230 lbs):533
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs): 424

Puffy Performance By Body Type & Sleeping Position:

Body Type:BACK SLEEPERSSTOMACH SLEEPERSSIDE SLEEPERS
Lightweight (< 130 lbs): 3
Average-weight (130–230 lbs):334
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs): 223

1 = Very poor, 2 = Not good, 3 = Fair, 4 = Good, 5 = Excellent

Average-Weight Sleepers (130–230 lbs)

Average-weight back sleepers will likely get the support they need on the “medium” version of the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid. The medium option is a comfortable blend of soft, yet supportive, while the firm provides more sturdy support, making it a great mattress for back sleepers. Average-weight side sleepers will find the medium-firm Puffy to provide pressure relief and a gentle hug around the hips and shoulders. The upper layers of the Puffy will cradle pressure points and conform around the natural curves of the body. 

Heavyweight Sleepers (> 230 lbs)

Heavyweight stomach sleepers probably won’t find the support they need in the medium Brooklyn Signature Hybrid mattress, but they might find proper support in the firm version of the bed. Additionally, heavyweight combination sleepers will likely be able to change positions easily on the medium version of the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid mattress. If you’re a heavyweight stomach sleeper, back sleeper, or combination sleeper, the Puffy mattress will likely not be firm enough and cannot provide enough support. 

Lightweight Sleepers (< 130 lbs)

Lightweight stomach sleepers may find proper support in the medium version of the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid, but the firm would likely be better. If you’re a lightweight side sleeper, the Puffy should be a good fit for you thanks to the foam layers that provide pressure relief and a gentle hug around their hips and shoulders. 

Differences In Mattress Construction 

The Brooklyn Signature mattress cover is quilted with a thin layer of memory foam that adds extra plushness when you first lie down, it measures 11”. While the Puffy is an all-foam mattress with three layers dedicated to providing superior pressure relief and a “cloud-like” sleeping experience with a thickness of 10”.

Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Materials Puffy Mattress Materials
Premium Quilted CoverCooling Cloud foam
TitanFlex Comfort FoamClimate Comfort foam
VariFlex Transition FoamClimate Comfort foam
Ascension Coils & Flex Base
11”10”

Cover

The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid’s quilted, memory foam cover adds an element of cushion as soon as you lie down on the mattress. The Puffy’s cover consists of standard polyester that has some stretch across the surface, a thinner cover that feels cool to the touch. 

Comfort Layers

The top layer of the mattress is Brooklyn Bedding’s proprietary TitanFlex Comfort foam, which helps the mattress contour to your body while keeping your spine aligned. The top layer of the Puffy is made of two inches of Cooling Cloud foam with gel infusions that are meant to pull heat away from your body and promote airflow, so you don’t get too hot.

Support Layers

In the Brooklyn Bedding, another layer of TitanFlex foam acts as a transition layer between your body and the support coils to cushion your body weight and adapts to your position every time you shift in bed. The Puffy is designed with six inches of Firm Core foam support layer, which adds structure and durability to the mattress.

Brooklyn Bedding vs. Puffy Pricing

SizeBrooklyn Bedding PricesPuffy Prices
Twin$$
Twin XL$$
Full$$
Queen$$
King$$
California King$$

For exclusive discounts on both beds, see our Brooklyn Bedding mattress coupons and Puffy mattress coupons.

Brooklyn Bedding vs. Puffy Mattress Performance Ratings & Differences

The Brooklyn Bedding 4.8/5

The Signature Hybrid mattress comes in three firmness options and is made with a slew of proprietary materials. Brooklyn Bedding knows their mattresses.

The Puffy 3.4/5

The Original Puffy is a three-layer foam mattress made with cooling gel-infused memory foam and motion-isolating base foams. It has a medium-firm feel that blends contouring support with cushioning comfort.

Temperature

We think the Brooklyn Signature stays cooler than the Puffy, but the Puffy is still pretty temperature-neutral for a memory foam mattress.

Motion Transfer

It’s no surprise that the Puffy isolates motion better than the Brooklyn Signature. The all-foam construction of the Puffy dampens movement before it has the chance to spread, whereas the springiness of the coils in the Brooklyn Signature creates a bit more bounce-back.

Edge Support 

The Brooklyn Signature has reinforced edges, but we weren’t too impressed with the support level. We didn’t feel like we’d slide off the mattress, but there was quite a bit of sinkage when we sat on the sides of the bed. 

That was also the case with the Puffy, though we noticed even more compression. Overall, if edge support is your deciding factor, go with the Brooklyn Signature, but don’t expect excellent edge support on either mattress.

Pressure Relief 

The Brooklyn Signature and Puffy both provide pressure relief, but the Puffy outperforms the Brooklyn Signature in this category, at least with regard to the medium and firm Brooklyn Signature options. The Puffy is our pick for side sleepers, though the soft version of the Brooklyn Signature is a worthwhile option, too.

Pain Relief 

If you struggle with back pain and sleep on your back—as opposed to your side or stomach—the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid should help you remain in proper spinal alignment (and thus reduce pain). The Puffy mattress is a lot like sleeping on a cloud; however, some sleepers may want more firmness and less fluffiness. For better options, see the best mattresses for back pain.

Durability 

Both of these beds are high-quality and backed by industry-standard warranties, so they should last between six to ten years with normal use.

Shipping, Returns, & Warranties 

Brooklyn Bedding 

Brooklyn Bedding mattresses provide free shipping for orders in the contiguous USA (deliveries to Alaska and Hawaii cost $125, and shipments to Canada cost $250). The 120-night sleep trial starts on the day your mattress is delivered, so you can test out your new mattress in the comfort of your home. Returns are free; but if you keep your mattress, it’s protected by a 10-year warranty.

Puffy

Puffy mattresses are made in the USA and shipped for free within one to three business days (extra fees apply to Alaska and Hawaii deliveries). You get a 101-night in-home trial period, free returns, and a Lifetime warranty. The warranty entitles you to a free replacement mattress if yours develops indentations over 1.5” and manufacturing defects of the cover (i.e. a broken zipper or unraveled seams).

More Brooklyn Bedding Mattresses

This mattress is no longer available for purchase. To help you find your next mattress, check out our list of the best mattresses available on the market now.

See our full Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe Hybrid Mattress Review to learn more.

This mattress is no longer available for purchase. To help you find your next mattress, check out our list of the best mattresses available on the market now.

See our Brooklyn Sedona Elite mattress review to learn more.

More Puffy Mattresses

This mattress is no longer available for purchase. To help you find your next mattress, check out our list of the best mattresses available on the market now.

See our full Puffy Lux Hybrid mattress review to learn more.

This mattress is no longer available for purchase. To help you find your next mattress, check out our list of the best mattresses available on the market now.

See our full Puffy Royal Hybrid mattress review to learn more.

Our Final Take

We don’t think one of these mattresses is better than the other, but we can tell you which is the best mattress for your specific sleep needs. The Brooklyn Signature is our pick for combination sleepers, hot sleepers, and those who want multiple firmness options. The Puffy is better for those with joint pain, memory foam lovers, and those who prioritize pressure relief.

If you’re still undecided, keep in mind that the pricing for these beds is really similar, and both come with generous trial periods typical of the bed-in-a-box market. Choose the one that aligns with your top sleep needs, and give it a try!

Brooklyn Bedding & Puffy FAQs

Does the Puffy mattress need to be flipped?

The Puffy is a single-sided mattress, so it doesn’t need to be flipped top-to-bottom. However, to ensure your mattress wears evenly, rotate it head-to-foot once a month for the first few months and then once every season (every three or four months) for the rest of the mattress’s lifespan.

How long can I keep my Brooklyn Signature in the box?

Brooklyn Bedding suggests you unbox your mattress no later than three weeks after the date of delivery. As a general rule, it’s best to unbox your new mattress quickly after it arrives at your doorstep to minimize the risk of off-gassing smells and mattress impressions.

How much weight can the Brooklyn Signature hold?

This bed-in-a-box mattress can support up to 900 lbs. of body weight for the Queen, King, and Cal king sizes. A full-size Brooklyn Signature mattress can hold 700 lbs., and a Twin and Twin XL can support up to 600 lbs. of body weight.