Puffy vs. Nectar Mattress Comparison

Comparing the Puffy & Nectar Mattresses

The Nectar and the Puffy are both memory foam mattresses that share many similar qualities, but with some slight differences that you should consider before buying. The Puffy mattress is suited for couples, as well as back, side, stomach and combination sleepers—pretty much all sleeping positions. The Nectar is also great for couples, but it’s more suited for back and side sleepers. In addition, the Nectar comes with a year-long sleep trial period to give you more time to see if the mattress is right for you. Both mattresses feature gel-infused foam that sleeps cooler than traditional memory foam mattresses.

Differences

• The Puffy accommodates all sleep positions, while the Nectar is better suited for back and side sleepers
• The Puffy is slightly firmer than the Nectar, with sturdier layers that make it the better mattress for combination sleepers to change positions without feeling “stuck” in the mattress

Similarities

• Both memory foam mattresses are a medium firmness and both come with a Lifetime warranty
• Couples will be satisfied with either the Puffy or the Nectar, both preventing motion transfer between couples or co-sleepers (think pets or children)
• Both the Puffy and the Nectar are best for lightweight ( < 130 lbs.) to average-weight (130–230 lbs.) sleepers. Those who are heavyweight (>230 lbs.) may find better support on hybrid or innerspring mattresses. For suggestions, check out our list on the best mattress for heavy people.

Who the Puffy Mattress is Best For 

Best For…

• Couples who need great motion isolation capabilities to remain undisturbed
• Back, stomach and side sleepers who need a mixture of softness and support
• Those who tend to sleep hot

May Not Be Best For…

• People who prefer extra firm innerspring mattresses
• Heavier stomach sleepers who need more support to keep their hips elevated and in spinal alignment

Read our full Puffy mattress review to learn more! 

Who the Nectar Mattress is Best For 

Best For…

• Back sleepers, who need proper distribution of their body weight when lying down on the mattress
• Side sleepers looking for support, yet softness on joints
• People who sleep hot but still want the feel of a memory foam mattress
• Couples who don’t want to be disturbed by a partner’s tossing and turning

May Not be Best For…

• People who are heavyset and need extra support
• Those who prefer to sleep on super-firm mattresses
• Stomach sleepers who need proper hip elevation to ensure spinal alignment

Read our full Nectar mattress review to learn more! 

Deciding Between Puffy & Nectar

Firmness / Feel

The best mattresses for side sleepers usually softer mattresses because they support their hips and shoulders, while back and stomach sleepers need firmer mattresses to keep their necks, back, shoulders, hips and legs adequately supported. The Puffy Mattress is slightly firmer than the Nectar, which allows it to accommodate all sleep positions. The Nectar is medium-firm, making it ideal for back and side sleepers.

Motion Isolation

Motion isolation is an important factor for couples who share a bed. If you sleep with a partner, you’ll require a bed that isolates motion as well as possible. Motion isolation allows you to change positions, or get in and out of bed, without disturbing your partner. A mattress with high motion isolation reduces the amount of motion transferred across the area of the mattress, allowing couples to sleep peacefully all night long, even if a child or a dog climbs into bed. Both the Puffy and Nectar mattresses score high marks in the motion isolation department, making them both solid options for couples.

Edge Support

If you have trouble getting in and out of bed every morning because you feel as if you’re sinking down on the edge of the mattress, it might be time to invest in a bed with solid edge support. That way, you can sit or lie on the very edge of the mattress without feeling like you’ll slide right off the edge. Even though all-foam beds tend to provide less edge support than innerspring and hybrid beds with metal coils, Puffy and Nectar mattresses provide exceptional edge support for their construction type. You shouldn’t have to worry about slipping off either bed, no matter how close to the edge you decide to sleep.

Pressure Relief 

If you’ve ever gotten up with sore or painful joints, your mattress may not be delivering the right amount of pressure relief for your body and sleep type. Certain mattresses are designed to address pressure points and to reduce pressure on key points of your body, depending on your sleep position. Because both mattresses have a medium-firm memory foam construction, they each provide great pressure relief. Each mattress is better than, for instance, an ultra-firm bed that fails to cradle your shoulders, elbows, knees and other pressure points.

Spine Alignment 

Another cause for pain and soreness in the morning is poor spinal alignment. If your spine is misaligned for several hours while you rest, you’re going to have a very uncomfortable sleep experience. That is why you want to carefully choose your new mattress to ensure it will keep your spine properly aligned. If you’re a side sleeper, we recommend the Nectar because the soft surface will allow your shoulders and hips to sink into the material, placing your spine in correct lateral alignment. The Nectar is always a great mattress for back sleepers because it distributes your weight evenly across your back, not putting pressure on any one area. The Puffy mattress is the best mattress for stomach sleepers because it should keep your hips from sinking too deeply into the mattress and negatively impacting spinal alignment.

Durability 

Puffy and Nectar each stand behind their mattress’ durability, which is why they both offer a Lifetime warranty (Nectar calls it a Forever warranty) for mattress purchases. Though every mattress goes through wear and tear over time, some actually tend to lose their shape or structure, which will compromise your level of comfort over the years. You want a mattress that has long-lasting durability and that won’t deteriorate quickly. The Lifetime guarantee from Nectar and Puffy has us feeling confident that these mattresses will last for quite a while, and if they don’t, a replacement can be at your door relatively easily.

Temperature 

Sleeping hot is unpleasant. That’s why you need a mattress that incorporates temperature-regulation technology to help you stay cool throughout the night. Though both mattresses are made of an all-foam construction, which is known for sleeping hot and limiting the breathability of the bed, the Puffy has a proprietary Climate-Adaptive Foam layer that is specially designed to cool the mattress. See our picks for the best mattress for hot sleepers for other mattresses that sleep cool.

Puffy Mattress Construction

The top layer of the Puffy Mattress is made of breathable Cooling Cloud, gel-infused memory foam, which pulls heat away from your body and encourages airflow. It also cradles the body so that there isn’t unwanted pressure on sensitive points. The next layer is made of a unique technology called Climate-Adaptive Foam that further regulates temperature and reduces heat and humidity. The base layer, also known as the Firm Core Support Foam Layer, provides the Puffy mattress with its trademark structure and durability, so you can expect your bed to remain durable and firm for a long time. Still, it’s important to keep in mind that most all-foam mattresses don’t tend to hold up as long as innerspring or hybrid mattresses. 

Nectar Mattress Construction

The top layer of the Nectar is made of quilted gel memory foam, which promotes airflow and heat reduction while also contouring to the body’s shape. The second layer features even more gel memory foam, and its purpose is to evenly distribute weight and deliver pressure relief to your shoulders, back, hips and legs. The following layer is crafted of Adaptive Hi-Core memory foam, which prevents you from sinking into the foam and cradles pressure points. The final layer is made of a dense, thick foam that allows the mattress to retain its structure for a long time without sagging.

Sizing & Price Comparisons 

Our Puffy Mattress Coupons and Nectar Mattress Coupons pages have great deals to explore!

Shipping and Returns for Puffy & Nectar

Puffy Mattress

Shipping the Puffy Mattress is free to any location within the contiguous United States, but there is a charge on orders shipped to Hawaii or Alaska. The new mattress will arrive compressed and rolled up into a box, so setup is incredibly simple.

The Puffy’s return policy includes a 101-night sleep trial. For 101 nights, you can test out your mattress and see if it’s to your liking. If you want to return it, you can do so without worrying about return charges or fees. All you need to do is call the customer support line with your order number and a Puffy representative will initiate the return process. Your mattress will be picked up and donated to a local charity or a recycling center, and once the return has been processed, your money will be refunded. Puffy’s Lifetime warranty adds extra protection as well.

Nectar Mattress

Nectar ships its mattresses for free across the continental United States, but for Hawaii or Alaska residents, there is a one-time fee. After placing your order, it may take up to two to five business days to arrive at your door compressed in a cylindrical case. For an additional $149, you can purchase White Glove Delivery, meaning a delivery specialist will bring the new mattress inside and set it up, while also removing and disposing of your old mattress.

You’ll also receive a 365-night trial period to test out your new Nectar mattress and to determine if it’s right for you. This trial period allows you to try it out for up to a year, and if you’re unhappy with it, you can return it for a full refund, no questions asked. The only stipulation is that Nectar asks that customers keep the mattress for a 30-day break-in period before returns can be initiated. If you’re unhappy with the mattress after 30 days, call the customer support line and they’ll be happy to help you initiate the return process. Moreover, Nectar has a Lifetime “Forever” warranty to help ensure satisfaction years down the road.

More Puffy Mattresses

See our Puffy Lux Mattress Review to learn more.

See our Puffy Royal Mattress Review to learn more.

More Nectar Mattresses

See our Nectar Lush Mattress Review to learn more.

Haven’t made a decision yet? Check out these other comparisons:

Nectar vs. Casper

Nectar vs. Lull

Nectar vs. Tuft & Needle

Nectar vs. Layla

Nectar vs. Loom & Leaf

Puffy vs. Casper

Puffy vs. Leesa

Our Final Take

Nectar and Puffy mattresses are both great choices for all-foam mattresses that won’t break the bank. If you’re a back or side sleeper, a hot sleeper or if you share your bed with someone, the Nectar mattress is worth considering. If you sleep on your stomach and you prefer a firmer sleep surface, we recommend the Puffy.