Puffy vs. Saatva Mattress Comparison

The Puffy mattress has three foam layers and a conforming memory foam feel, while the Saatva is a luxury hybrid bed that comes in multiple firmness options. 

The Puffy’s superior motion isolation makes it better for couples, and its cradling memory foam provides better pressure relief for most side sleepers. If you toss and turn, sleep hot, weigh more than 230 lbs, or spend much time stomach sleeping, the Saatva is likely the better option. 

Learn more about these beds and which one is best for you in our Saatva vs. Puffy mattress comparison.

Comparing the Saatva Mattress & Puffy Mattress

Differences

• Design: The Puffy is a memory foam mattress, and the Saatva is a hybrid mattress with both foam and coils. Additionally, the Saatva comes in three firmness options while the Puffy is only available in one firmness. 
• Temperature Regulation: The Saatva’s two coil layers are ultra-breathable, with air circulation cycling out excess warmth before you overheat. While the Puffy is sufficiently cool for most people, its all-foam design is not as good as the Saatva for hot sleepers. 
• Motion Transfer: Many couples prefer the Puffy because they barely feel their partner’s movements. The Saatva’s two coil layers and bouncy surface will probably cause you to feel some motion transfer.
• Plus-Size Support: The Saatva is much better for heavyweight folks thanks to its reinforced lumbar support and a durable coil-on-coil support system. On the flip side, people with bigger body types can sink down and feel stuck on the Puffy.

Similarities

• Excellent Pressure Relief: Both the Puffy and the softer Saatva models have soft, pressure-relieving surfaces that are great for those with joint pain. 
• Good Back and Side Sleeper Support: These beds offer a balance of plush cushion and reliable support that works well for side and back sleepers. 
• Sold Directly to Consumers: You can’t buy any Saatva or Puffy mattress at a physical retail store. Instead, both companies skip middlemen and sell directly to you, allowing each to offer competitive pricing considering the high-quality materials.

Related: Best Mattresses for Back Sleepers

Who the Puffy Mattress is Best For 

Best For…

• People with Joint Pain: The Puffy boasts 4” of comfort foam, with conforming memory foam providing outstanding pressure relief. The soft memory foam cradle is gentle on joints and may help people with arthritis to sleep better. 
• Memory Foam Lovers: Do you love the doughy, hugging feel of memory foam mattresses? If you do, the Puffy won’t disappoint. 
• Couples and Those Who Co-Sleep: Thanks to its all-foam design, you and your partner, children, or pets can sleep together without feeling every movement.

May Not be Best For…

• Combination Sleepers: You’ll gently sink into Puffy’s contouring memory foam layers, and there aren’t any springy coils to counteract the effect. While it’s not incredibly difficult to reposition, people who toss and turn may prefer something more responsive. 
• People Living in a Warm Climate: The Puffy will feel hot if you live in a hot climate and don’t have air conditioning. The foams are somewhat slow at releasing stored body heat.
• Soft or Firm Mattress Fans: The Puffy has a balanced medium-firm firmness level. If you want cloudlike plushness or sturdy support, this isn’t the right mattress for your needs. 

Read our full Puffy Mattress Review to learn more! 

Who the Saatva Mattress is Best For 

Best For…

• All Comfort Preferences: Saatva’s three firmness options (Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm) range from very firm to exceptionally soft, with a middle medium-firm model for the average person. 
• People with Back Pain: Saatva incorporates an active wire structure and memory foam support layer along the spine, encouraging healthy spinal alignment—particularly for back and stomach sleepers. If you’re prone to aches and pains, check out our roundup of best mattresses for back pain. 
• Innerspring Mattress Lovers. With two coil layers and just 3” of foam up top, the Saatva feels like a bouncy innerspring mattress.

May Not be Best For…

• People Who Like Memory Foam: The Saatva doesn’t have much memory foam, so it’s not a good choice for sleepers who want a cradling memory foam sensation. 
• Sensitive Sleepers Who Co-Sleep: If you easily wake up when your partner gets out of bed or moves around, the Saatva may not be a good fit. With two coil layers and relatively thin foam layers, you’ll feel movement if you share the bed. 
• Shoppers On a Budget: The Saatva is a luxury mattress. Despite a reasonable price point for its high-quality construction, it’s too pricey for many shoppers.

Read our full Saatva Mattress Review to learn more! 

Puffy Mattress vs. Saatva Mattress Performance Differences

Firmness / Feel

Puffy Performance By Sleeping Position:

Body Type:	BACK SLEEPERS	STOMACH SLEEPERS	SIDE SLEEPERS
Lightweight (< 130 lbs):	4	3	5
Average-weight (130–230 lbs):	3	3	4
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs):	2	2	3

Saatva Performance By Sleeping Position:

Body Type:	BACK SLEEPERS	STOMACH SLEEPERS	SIDE SLEEPERS
Lightweight (< 130 lbs):	5	5	3
Average-weight (130–230 lbs):	5	5	4
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs):	4	3	4

1 = Very poor, 2 = Not good, 3 = Fair, 4 = Good, 5 = Excellent

Where a mattress falls on the firmness scale tells you a lot about who will like it. On the one to 10 firmness scale, with one being the softest, the Puffy falls at a 6/10 and the Saatva a 3/10 (Plush Soft), 6–6.5/10 (Luxury Firm), or 8/10 (Firm). 

At a 6/10, the Puffy is a medium-firm mattress—the firmness that most adults prefer. But thanks to a top layer that readily compresses at your pressure points, we recommend the Puffy primarily to side and back sleepers weighing less than 230 lbs. It’s okay for stomach sleepers, but the more you weigh, the more sinkage you may experience at your hips. 

The Saatva’s three firmness levels accommodate all sleeping positions, while the durable lumbar support creates a surface that’s sufficiently supportive for all body types. We recommend the Firm model for heavyweight people and firm mattress fans, the Luxury Firm for people who prefer an average mattress firmness, and the Plush Soft for lightweight side sleepers.

Motion Isolation

Couples who sleep on the Saatva notice when the other person moves around. But on the Puffy all-foam mattress, movements don’t easily spread to the other side. So if you share your mattress, you might prefer the Puffy—especially if one of you is a light sleeper or if you don’t share the same sleep schedule. For more motion isolating beds, check out our list of best mattresses for couples.

Edge Support

The Saatva’s edges are extraordinarily sturdy. It’s the dual coil layers and reinforced high-density foam encasement that create a perimeter that you can sit or sleep along comfortably. While the Puffy has decent edge support, there is some sagging when you sit on the edges.

Pressure Relief 

Overall, the Puffy is the better pick for most people looking for outstanding cushion and pressure relief. Its all-foam design and pressure-relieving memory foam layers mold to the body, evenly distributing weight and minimizing pain at the shoulders and hips. However, if you’re a lightweight side sleeper, you might enjoy the cloud-like softness of the Saatva Plush Soft model.

Related: Best Mattresses for Side-Sleepers

Spine Alignment 

One of the biggest selling points of the Saatva is the lumbar alignment technology. Because the human body weighs the most along the mid-section, Saatva incorporates added cushion and support here. This keeps the hips lifted in alignment with the shoulders, which is critical for stomach sleepers who want to avoid back pain.

Additionally, with three firmness options, the Saatva provides superb back support for people of every body size and sleep position. While the Puffy offers good spinal support for most people, the Saatva is usually better in this regard. 

Durability 

The Saatva is more durable than the Puffy. The biggest contributor to the Saatva’s longevity is the supportive base of steel coils. Steel coils are interconnected, with firmness and support that can easily last decades. 

The Puffy has thick foam layers and a foam base, so you’re more likely to have problems with excess foam softening on the Puffy than the Saatva.

Temperature 

Hot sleepers should go with the Saatva over the Puffy. The Puffy is a memory foam mattress, and despite a top layer of cooling gel memory foam, the Puffy can sleep a touch warm if you tend to overheat at night. 

On the other hand, the Saatva is one of the best mattresses for hot sleepers, thanks to the breathability of a hybrid mattress design.

Puffy Mattress Construction

Along the Puffy’s surface is cooling gel memory foam, with a plush feel that hugs the hips, shoulders, and lower back. Next, Puffy utilizes another layer of conforming foam with cooling innovations for excellent pressure relief without excessive heat retention. The final 6” layer of firm, durable foam adds support while ensuring little to no motion transfer.

Saatva Mattress Construction

The Saatva is a hybrid mattress that comes in three firmness levels. Each of these models boasts a dual innerspring coil system for a feel that’s bouncy, cool, and supportive. Along the middle of the mattress are layers of memory foam and “active wire” for additional lumbar support, which means very little sinkage at the body’s core. Finally, a thick euro pillow top brings immediate softness and pressure relief. 

Sizing & Price Comparisons 

Mattress Size	Puffy Mattress	Saatva Mattress
Twin	$	$
Twin XL	$	$
Full	$	$
Queen	$	$
King	$	$
California King	$	$
Split King or California King	N/A	$

Get the lowest price by using a Puffy coupon or Saatva coupon!

Shipping and Returns for Puffy & Saatva

Puffy Mattress

Puffy is a bed-in-the-box mattress company, meaning the Puffy mattress arrives on your doorstep compressed into a relatively small cardboard box. If you live in the continental U.S., you won’t pay for shipping, but if you live in Hawaii or Alaska, there’s a non-refundable shipping fee. 

The Puffy has a 101-night sleep trial with a 14-day waiting period. After owning your new mattress for 14 days, you may contact Puffy before the end of the trial period to start the return process. After someone picks up the Puffy for donation, you’ll receive a full refund. 

If you end up loving your Puffy and decide to keep it, you’ll enjoy a Lifetime warranty. For the entire time you own the mattress, Puffy will replace or repair it if you experience a manufacturing defect. Some examples of defects include body impressions, faulty covers, or crumbling foam.

Saatva Mattress

Saatva customers receive luxury service with free white glove delivery. White glove service includes new mattress setup and old mattress removal. Plus, the Saatva ships at its full size, so there’s very little off-gassing odor, and you can sleep on the bed right away. 

If you discover that the Saatva isn’t the best mattress for you, you can return it at any time during the first year (365-nights) after delivery. Saatva charges a $99 return fee, which offsets the cost of the free delivery service. 

Saatva has a Lifetime warranty covering material defects of workmanship errors.

More Puffy Mattresses

See our full Puffy Royal Hybrid Mattress Review to learn more.

See our full Puffy Lux Hybrid Mattress Review to learn more.

More Saatva Mattresses

See our full ZenHaven Mattress Review to learn more.

See our full Loom & Leaf Mattress Review to learn more.

See our full Saatva Solaire Mattress Review to learn more.

Haven’t made a decision yet? Check out these other comparisons and reviews:

• Puffy vs. Lull
• Puffy vs. Nolah
• Puffy vs. WinkBed
• Puffy vs. Purple
• Puffy vs. Nectar
• Puffy vs. Leesa
• Puffy vs. Casper
• Comparing Puffy Mattresses
• Saatva vs. Layla
• Saatva vs. Leesa
• Saatva vs. Purple
• Saatva vs. WinkBed
• Saatva vs. Loom & Leaf
• Saatva vs.  Brooklyn Bedding
• Saatva vs. DreamCloud
• Saatva vs. Avocado
• Saatva vs. Casper
• Comparing Saatva Mattresses
• Saatva HD Mattress Review
• Saatva Youth Mattress Review

Our Final Take

Sensitive sleepers and people who love the hugging feel of memory foam should choose the Puffy. But if you’re someone who sleeps hot, weighs more than 230 lbs, or likes a responsive, bouncy feel, the Saatva Classic is the right choice. And with multiple firmness options, the Saatva has models that fit soft and firm mattress fans better than the medium-firm Puffy.