Check out our mattress comparison between the Brooklyn Aurora Hybrid and the Casper Original to see which one is best for you.
Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.
Casper Mattress vs. Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Comparison
Comparing Brooklyn Bedding & Casper Mattresses
The Brooklyn Aurora Hybrid Cooling Mattress is a hybrid sleep option that combines memory foam and innerspring coils, while the Casper Original is an all-foam mattress. The Brooklyn Aurora is suited for sleepers of all positions who have trouble staying cool at night and who prefer the feel of traditional innerspring mattresses. The Casper Original Mattress is for pure foam lovers who sleep on their back or side, and who are looking for a more budget-friendly sleep option.
Differences
- The Brooklyn Aurora is built with a combination of foam and innerspring coils, while the Casper Original Mattress is pure foam.
- The Casper Original Mattress is about half the price of the Brooklyn Aurora, making it one of our picks for the best affordable mattress.
- The Brooklyn Aurora accommodates all sleep positions, while the Casper Original is better suited as a mattress for back sleepers and side sleepers.
- The Brooklyn Aurora is specially targeted to dissipate heat, while the Casper has average cooling properties
Similarities
- Both mattresses are backed by a 10-year warranty.
- Both mattresses offer great motion isolation.
- Both mattresses, despite different constructions, can be the best side sleeper mattress, by contouring around the body and providing pressure relief at the shoulders and hips.
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora
The Aurora hybrid is Brooklyn Bedding's most popular mattress. It comes in three firmness levels and features both innerspring coils and cooling copper-infused gel foam, meaning it suits those who sleep hot, as well as a wide range of sleep preferences.
Score
4.8
/
5.0
Firmness
5
Trial period
120 days
Warranty
10-year limited warranty
Who the Brooklyn Bedding Mattress is Best For
Best For…
- All sleep positions
- Hot sleepers
- Couples that share a bed
May Not be Best For…
- Budget shoppers
- Pure memory foam lovers
Read our full Brooklyn Bedding Aurora mattress review to learn more!
Casper Original
The original mattress that made the brand famous, the Casper is known for its design that suits all sleep positions. Casper's Zoned Support feature is engineered to support the hips, shoulders and back to keep the spine aligned. At an affordable price point, too, this mattress is hard to beat.
Score
4.8
/
5.0
Firmness
6
Trial period
100 nights
Warranty
10 year warranty
Who the Casper Mattress is Best For
Best For…
- Side and back sleepers
- Sleepers with back and hip pain
- Sleepers with a lower budget
May Not be Best For…
- Stomach sleepers
- Sleepers who prefer the feel of innerspring mattresses
- Extra hot sleepers
Read our full Casper mattress review to learn more!
Deciding Between Brooklyn Bedding & Casper
Firmness / Feel
Your mattress’s firmness is measured on a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being the softest and 10 being the most firm. Side sleepers will want a mattress that is on the softer side to cushion their hips and shoulders, but back and stomach sleepers will want a firmer mattress that supports their hips, back, neck and shoulders.. The Brooklyn Aurora comes in three firmness levels (4/10, 5/10, 7/10), so it can accommodate all types of sleepers, but the Casper Original is a 6/10 on the firmness scale, making it a top mattress for back sleepers and side sleepers.
Motion Isolation
If you share a bed with someone else, you’ll find motion transfer to be one of your biggest issues. As you change positions or get in and out of bed, the motion can travel across the bed and disturb your partner. However, mattresses with adequate motion isolation can prevent this. The encased coils of the Brooklyn Aurora absorb movement and minimize disturbance, and the Casper’s polyfoam layer will prevent motion transfer across the bed. Check out our other suggestions on the best mattress for couples.
Edge Support
Getting in and out of bed can become more difficult over time as the edges of your mattress start to sink. That is why you want a mattress with reinforced edges to maintain their structure for a long time. Both mattresses excel in edge support.The Casper’s base layer provides quality edge support for an all-foam mattress and the Brooklyn Aurora’s base layer reinforces the encased coils above it.
Pressure Relief
If your mattress doesn’t provide proper pressure relief or support, you can expect to wake up with aches and pains, requiring a mattress for back pain. To protect back sleepers’ pressure points in the neck and back or the shoulders and hips for side sleepers, you need a mattress that cradles those areas. Stomach sleepers need extra support to keep the hips supported, so the Aurora firm option will better suit their needs. The balanced firmness in the Casper should contour around the shoulders and hips.
Spine Alignment
Keeping your spine aligned while you sleep is incredibly important, not just for comfort, but also for your health. Depending on your sleep position, you’ll want to find a mattress made of the right materials and with the proper firmness level to ensure quality spinal alignment. Side and back sleepers will like the Casper Original Mattress and Brooklyn Aurora soft and medium options, but stomach sleepers will want the firm Brooklyn Aurora to keep their spines aligned at night. See our list on the best mattress for heavy stomach sleepers, for proper spinal and pressure point protection.
Durability
Not all mattresses are made the same, and not all of them will retain their shape and structure for a long time. Both the Brooklyn Bedding and Casper mattress options are recognized for having outstanding durability that will ensure they last. The base support foam protects the coils as they compress on the Brooklyn Aurora and the Casper is a strong all-foam bed with a durable base.
Temperature
The best cooling mattresses are built with cooling and temperature regulation technology to keep sleepers cool throughout the night. As a hybrid mattress that is usually cooler than memory foam, the Brooklyn Aurora also has added TitanCool technology that actively draws heat away from the body. However, the perforated foam in the Casper will also prevent heat from being trapped against the sleeper. Both mattresses will keep you cool at night, but for extra hot sleepers, we recommend the Brooklyn Aurora.
Brooklyn Bedding vs. Casper: We compare the construction of the Brooklyn Bedding mattress (left), to the Casper (right).
Brooklyn Bedding vs. Casper Mattress Construction
| Brooklyn Aurora Hybrid Mattress | Casper Original Mattress | |
| Cover | Copper Gel Energex foam | Open-cell memory foam |
| Comfort Layer | TitanFlex foam | Responsive memory foam |
| Transitional Layer | Sturdy memory foam | Zoned Support Foam layer |
| Support Layer | Pocketed coils | Support foam |
| Base Layer | High-density foam | N/A |
| Mattress Thickness | 13 inches | 11 inches |
Brooklyn Bedding Construction
The Brooklyn Aurora Hybrid’s top layer is made of proprietary Copper Gel Energex foam, which provides extra bounce and airflow compared to traditional memory foam. The next layer consists of TitanFlex foam that adjusts and responds to your body shape.
Underneath the TitanFlex foam is more sturdy and responsive memory foam that further contours to your body. The fourth layer consists of individually wrapped pocket coils that help promote motion isolation while encouraging airflow. Finally, the base layer of the mattress is made of high-density foam to ensure your mattress retains its shape and structure for a long time. The coils should create a bouncier surface for sleepers to change positions, making the Aurora a better mattress for combination sleepers.
Casper Construction
The Casper Original Mattress is topped with a layer of open-cell memory foam to promote airflow and to keep you comfortable. The next layer is made of responsive memory foam that contours to your body and offers support. The following Zoned Support layer is slightly firmer near your hips and back, but softer around your shoulders, giving your body the support it needs. The final base layer of the mattress consists of several inches of support foam to keep the mattress from sagging, and allows it to keep its shape and structure.
Get Our Exclusive Deal
Sizing & Price Comparisons
| Mattress Size | Brooklyn Bedding Price | Casper Price |
| Twin | $999 | $595 |
| Twin XL | $1,249 | $695 |
| Full | $1,549 | $995 |
| Queen | $1,699 | $1,095 |
| King | $2,124 | $1,295 |
| Cal King | $2,124 | $1,295 |
Check out our Brooklyn Bedding Coupons & Casper Mattress Coupons for the best price on a new mattress.
Shipping and Returns for Brooklyn Bedding & Casper
Brooklyn Bedding
All Brooklyn Bedding mattresses ship to the 48 contiguous United States via FedEx Ground free of charge. Once you place your order, it will take approximately 3 to 4 business days to arrive at your door.
Your Brooklyn Bedding mattress comes with a 120-night sleep trial period. During that time, you can return or exchange your mattress risk-free for a full refund, but you must wait 30 days from your delivery date to initiate a return.
Casper
Casper ships its mattresses for free across the continental United States. For an additional fee, you can add White Glove Delivery, which will include setup of your new mattress, as well as takeaway and disposal of your old mattress.
Your Casper mattress order comes with a 100-night trial period, meaning that you can test it out for 100 days to see if it’s right for you. If you’re unhappy with your mattress during that time period, you can return it for a full refund.
See our Brooklyn Bedding mattress warranty and Casper mattress warranty to know what’s covered in your mattress purchase.
Brooklyn Bedding Signature
The Signature Hybrid mattress comes in three firmness options and is made with a slew of proprietary materials. Brooklyn Bedding know their mattresses.
See our full Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress Review to learn more.
More Casper Mattresses
Casper Hybrid
Striking the perfect balance between the contour of memory foam and the bounce of pocket-coils, the Casper Hybrid offers the best of both worlds when it comes to superior comfort and support.
See our full Casper Hybrid Mattress Review to learn more.
Casper Wave Hybrid
The Casper Wave Hybrid strikes a balance with a middle-of-the-road firmness level and features that make it appropriate for sleepers of all shapes and sizes. It’s an excellent choice for those who enjoy the Original Casper’s balance of conforming support but want more bounce.
Read our full Casper Wave Hybrid mattress review to learn more.
Still Can’t Decide? Check out some of our most popular mattress comparisons:
Our Brooklyn Bedding vs. Casper Final Review
With different constructions, both the Casper and the Brooklyn Aurora provide support and comfort for a variety of sleepers. If you are a back or side sleeper who desires a pure foam sleep surface with targeted pressure relief for your hips and back, we recommend the Casper Original Mattress. If you sleep in a variety of positions, tend to run hot at night, and you prefer the traditional innerspring feel to your mattress, you should go for the Brooklyn Aurora.
