Brooklyn Bedding vs Casper Mattress Comparison

The Casper is an all-foam mattress with breathable foam and a Zoned Support layer that gives you more pressure relief near your shoulders and knees. The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid is a hybrid bed made by mattress company Brooklyn Bedding. It pairs multiple cushioning foam layers with a supportive coil system. 

In this mattress comparison, we’re putting these distinctly different mattresses side-by-side. You’ll like the Casper if you favor the contouring feel of an all-foam bed. The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is a better fit for hot sleepers who need the breathability of a coil base. We think the Casper is the best mattress for couples and combination sleepers. The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid is better for sleepers who want multiple firmness options, since the Signature Hybrid is offered in soft, medium, and firm firmness settings.

Comparing Brooklyn Bedding & Casper Mattresses

Differences

• The all-foam construction of the Casper does a better job of keeping motion transfer to a minimum.
• The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid stays cooler, in part, because of better airflow through the coil base layer (as opposed to the high-density polyfoam base on the Casper).
• The Casper could technically be considered a memory foam mattress, though it incorporates polyfoam layers. As such, it has a close, conforming feel, while the hybrid construction of the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid is bouncier.

Similarities

• The Casper and Brooklyn Signature Hybrid each keep your spine in a healthy neutral alignment.
• Both beds keep you well supported along the perimeter.
• The pricing is similar for these two models. As mid-range mattress brands, you can get a Queen size for around $1,100.

Who is the Casper Mattress Best For… 

• Side sleepers with lightweight or average-weight body types will notice a comfy level of pressure point relief on the Casper.
• Combination sleepers don’t need to worry about feeling stuck in the responsive top layer.
• Back sleepers are the ideal candidate for the firmness level of the Casper.

Not Best For…

• Hot sleepers may not get as much airflow as they need to stay cool.
• Stomach sleepers—especially those with average or heavyweight body types—won’t get the best lumbar support on the Casper.
• Those who are sensitive to off-gassing may not like the temporary “new mattress” scent that comes with bed-in-a-box foam mattresses. Rest assured, Casper uses CertiPUR-US certified foams that have low emissions.

Read our full Casper mattress review to learn more! 

Who is the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid Mattress Best For… 

• Every sleeping position can be accommodated on one of the Brooklyn Signature’ Hybrid’s three firmness options.
• Hot sleepers will appreciate the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid’s pleasant, temperature-neutral construction. 
• We’re singling out stomach sleepers because they need a firm mattress, and the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid firm model provides the right level of support to keep lightweight and average-weight stomach sleepers’ hips and shoulders aligned. 

Not Best For…

• Those who prefer an all-foam mattress won’t experience the feel they’re looking for on a hybrid mattress.
• Couples won’t get the best motion isolation on the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid .

Read our full Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid mattress review to learn more!  

Deciding Between Brooklyn Bedding & Casper

Firmness / Feel

You can get a good idea of how a mattress feels by referencing where it falls on the firmness scale, which ranges from 1–10. Softer mattresses are lower on the scale, and firmer mattresses are—you guessed—higher up on the scale. If you have a lightweight body type, you’ll probably experience mattresses as slightly firmer, while heavyweight sleepers tend to find mattresses softer than advertised. 

At Mattress Nerd, we had the chance to personally test the Casper and Brooklyn Signature Hybrid mattresses. We think the Casper is right around medium-firm level, or 6/10. The firmness level of the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid depends on the version you choose. In our opinion, the medium version feels closer to medium-firm, while the soft and firm versions are true to form.

Motion Isolation

Solo sleepers don’t need to pay as much attention to motion transfer, but it’s an important performance factor for those who sleep with a partner, pet, or child. The better a mattress isolates motion, the less likely you are to be disrupted mid-REM cycle. In this comparison, the Casper does a better job of reducing motion transfer, probably because foam is better than coils at absorbing the impact of movement. Check out our other suggestions on the best mattress for couples.

Edge Support

Ever had a dream that you were falling and got jolted awake? You don’t have to worry about your dream becoming a reality if you sleep on a mattress with good edge support. Neither Casper nor Brooklyn Bedding reinforce the edges of the flagship mattresses, but they both provide decent edge support. We think the Casper does a slightly better job in this category. 

Pressure Relief 

Firmness level is often related to how well a mattress cushions pressure points. Accordingly, the soft Brooklyn Signature Hybrid provides the best pressure relief, the Casper and medium Brooklyn Signature Hybrid provide moderate pressure relief, and the firm Brooklyn Signature Hybrid offers the least pressure relief. If your mattress doesn’t provide proper pressure relief or support, you can expect to wake up with aches and pains.

Related: Best Mattress for Back Pain

Spine Alignment 

To avoid back pain, your mattress should keep your body in a neutral position that maintains the natural curves of your spine. Side sleepers should also have a straight line from neck to tailbone. Any variation can push the spine out of alignment and cause muscle soreness and other issues. 

The Casper and Brooklyn Signature Hybrid both keep your body weight evenly distributed, so your spine stays in a healthy alignment, regardless of sleeping position. See our list on the best mattress for heavy stomach sleepers, for proper spinal and pressure point protection. 

Durability 

Memory foam and hybrid mattresses both last between seven to 10 years on average, depending on how often they’re used. We estimate that the Casper and Brooklyn Signature Hybrid will last about that long, plus they are protected against defects by 10-year warranties.

Temperature 

The best cooling mattresses are built with cooling and temperature regulation technology to keep sleepers cool throughout the night. Mattress temperature can make or break your sleep experience, with hot mattresses usually causing more sleep disruptions than cold mattresses. In this case, the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid sleeps cooler, thanks to the breathable coil system at its base. Casper takes a swing at cooling with the bed’s perforated top layer, but it still retains more heat than the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid .

Casper Mattress Construction

The Casper mattress is topped with a proprietary polyfoam called AirScape foam. It’s a soft foam that’s remarkably responsive. It’s also aerated with hundreds of small holes that create a path of escape for body heat that would otherwise get trapped in the foam. 

The transition layer is made with Zoned Support foam. This memory foam layer is firmer near your hips to give your lower back extra support. The whole mattress is supported by dense base foam and wrapped in a recycled polyester cover.

Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Comparison

The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid mattress features a quilted memory foam top layer that gives the mattress an extra cushioning feel when you first lie down. The star of the show is Brooklyn Signature Hybrid‘s patented TitanFlex foam. This foam layer is both conforming and responsive.

Next, Energex transition foam adds an extra measure of cushioning in the soft and medium versions. At the base, bouncy coils and high-density foam support the whole mattress and prevent sagging.

Sizing & Price Comparisons

Mattress Size	Casper Mattress	Brooklyn Bedding Mattress
Twin	$595	$599
Twin XL	$695	$749
Full	$995	$899
Queen	$1,095	$1,124
King	$1,295	$1,374
California King	$1,295	$1,374

Check out our Brooklyn Bedding Coupons & Casper Mattress Coupons for the best price on a new mattress.

Shipping and Returns for Brooklyn Bedding & Casper

Casper

The original Casper mattress is shipped for free in the U.S. and Canada, though extra shipping fees apply to residents of Alaska and Hawaii. Mattresses ship from warehouse partners within one to two business days, and Casper will send you a tracking number with an estimated delivery date. 

The 100-night sleep trial starts right when your mattress is delivered and comes with free returns. If you opt to return your mattress, Casper will arrange for it to be picked up and, in most cases, recycled or donated. You’ll get a full refund back to your original payment form. 

Casper’s 10-year mattress warranty protects against defects like cracks or indentations in the foam and broken zippers on the mattress cover. If your mattress develops any of these defects from normal use, you may be eligible for free repairs or a replacement mattress.

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid

Brooklyn Bedding offers free FedEx ground shipping for all mattress deliveries within the contiguous U.S. Shipping to Alaska and Hawaii costs around $125, and it costs $250 to ship to Canada. Delivery takes between three to five business days.

Your 120-night trial period comes with free returns and full refunds (minus shipping costs). You will need to sleep on the mattress for a minimum of 30 days before initiating a return. Brooklyn Bedding gives customers one return or exchange per year. If you bought your mattress at a Brooklyn Bedding retail location, reach out to them for return instructions; otherwise, contact the customer care team for purchases made online.

The 10-year Brooklyn Bedding mattress warranty covers indentations deeper than 1″, splits or cracks in the foam, deterioration in the cell structure of the foam, and excessive sagging (when the mattress is adequately supported). Defective mattresses are eligible for repairs or replacement.

Note: The return policies for both mattress brands may be different if they were purchased from Amazon or another retailer. 

More Brooklyn Bedding Mattresses

See our full Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe Mattress Review to learn more.

See our Brooklyn Sedona Elite mattress review to learn more.

More Casper Mattresses

See our full Casper Hybrid Mattress Review to learn more.

Read our full Casper Wave Hybrid mattress review to learn more. 

Read our Casper Nova Hybrid mattress review for more.

Read our Casper Element mattress review for more.

Still Can’t Decide? Check out some of our most popular mattress comparisons:

• Casper vs. Amerisleep
• Casper vs. Bear
• Casper vs. Brooklyn Bedding
• Casper vs. GhostBed
• Casper vs. Helix
• Casper vs. Layla
• Casper vs. Leesa
• Casper vs. Loom & Leaf
• Casper vs. Lull
• Casper vs. Nectar
• Casper vs. Puffy
• Casper vs. Purple
• Casper vs. Saatva
• Casper vs. Tempur-Pedic
• Casper vs. Tuft & Needle
• Casper vs. WinkBeds
• Casper Nova Hybrid vs. Layla Hybrid
• Casper Mattress Alternatives
• Brooklyn Bedding vs. Avocado
• Brooklyn Bedding vs. Casper
• Brooklyn Bedding vs. GhostBed
• Brooklyn Bedding vs. Helix
• Brooklyn Bedding vs. Layla
• Brooklyn Bedding vs. Leesa
• Brooklyn Bedding vs. Lull
• Brooklyn Bedding vs. Nectar
• Brooklyn Bedding vs. Nolah
• Brooklyn Bedding vs. Puffy
• Brooklyn Bedding vs. Purple
• Brooklyn Bedding vs. Saatva
• Brooklyn Bedding vs. Tuft & Needle
• Compare Brooklyn Bedding Mattresses
• Titan Mattress Review
• Brooklyn Bedding Spartan Mattress Review
• Brooklyn Bedding Bloom Mattress Review
• Brooklyn Bedding Sedona Elite Mattress Review
• Brooklyn Bedding Bowery Hybrid Mattress Review
• Brooklyn Bedding Plank Mattress Review 

Our Final Take

The Casper and Brooklyn Signature Hybrid mattresses both boast rave customer reviews, and we’ve just highlighted the pros and cons, but which is the best mattress for you? If you need a mattress that stays cool, the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid is your best bet, but if you like the contouring feel of memory foam, go with the Casper. Side sleepers will sleep easy on the Casper or the soft Signature Hybrid . We favor the Casper for your average back sleeper, and the firm Signature Hybrid for stomach sleepers.