winkbeds vs casper

Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

WinkBed vs. Casper Mattress Comparison

In our WinkBeds vs. Casper comparison, we provide the information you need to discover which bed is designed with your needs in mind. 

Comparing WinkBeds & Casper Mattresses

The original WinkBeds mattress is a luxury hybrid that marries the responsiveness and support of innerspring coils with the opulent pressure relief of a Euro pillow top. The flagship Casper is an affordable memory foam mattress that does an exceptional job supporting the spine. The WinkBed is better for hot sleepers, heavy people, and people who like a soft mattress. The Casper offers superior motion isolation, which makes it better for couples. 

In this WinkBeds vs. Casper mattress comparison, we’re going to explore what differentiates the flagship mattresses from these two popular online mattress companies. Read on to learn their similarities and differences, which is a good fit for you, and how the policies compare for these two brands. 

Differences

  • Construction: While Casper is an all-foam bed made from polyfoam and memory foam layers, the WinkBed is a luxury hybrid mattress. It has a pocketed coil support system with layers of foam and a Euro pillow top.
  • Cooling: The WinkBed’s hybrid design facilitates more airflow than Casper’s all-foam build, which makes it sleep cooler than the Casper mattress.
  • Responsiveness: The WinkBed is easier to move around upon than the Casper. This ease of movement is due to the springiness of the steel coils in the WinkBed’s base layer
  • Firmness Options: While the Casper comes in one firmness—medium-firmthe WinkBed comes in four firmness levels that range in firmness from medium-soft to firm.
  • Body Types Supported: The original Casper is best for people who weigh under 230 pounds. The WinkBed works for all body sizes, with the WinkBed Plus model engineered for people who weigh more than 230 pounds. The softer WinkBed option is better than the Casper for lightweight people who like a soft feel.

Similarities

  • Suits Every Sleeping Position: Thanks to Casper’s zoned support foam and WinkBed’s multiple firmness levels, both beds work well for side, stomach, and back sleepers.
  • Great for Couples: Both the Casper and WinkBed work well for people who share the bed. They each do a good job limiting motion transfer and have edges comfortable enough to lie along, so you can spread out.
  • Exceptional Spinal Support: Both of these beds have zoned support, which means that pressure points receive extra cushion while the back is properly supported. The results are beds that support healthy spinal alignment and are good for people with back pain.

WinkBed

Who Should Buy this Mattress? 

  • Heavyweight people
  • Hot sleepers
  • Elderly people
WinkBed
Firmness

Varies

Trial period

120 nights

Warranty

Limited lifetime warranty

Price

$$$

Who the WinkBeds Mattress is Best For 

Best For…

  • Plus-size people: The WinkBed comes in a plus model that’s made from durable and supportive materials for bigger bodies. With high-density foams and sag-resistant latex, the WinkBed Plus is an outstanding mattress for people who weigh more than 230 pounds 
  • Hot sleepers: The WinkBed has a breathable TENCEL cover and innerspring coil layer that boosts air circulation, diminishing excess heat retention. 
  • Elderly people: With zoned pocketed coils and an added layer of durable foam along the lumbar spine, the WinkBed brings cushioning for joints and reliable spinal support. Combined, these features make a bed that’s excellent for elderly folks with body pain. 

May Not be Best For…

  • Ultra-light sleepers: The WinkBed is a hybrid mattress, which means it has a support system made up of bouncy innerspring coils. While the thick foam layers on top do a good job dampening motion, you can feel when someone moves on the other side of the bed. 
  • Shoppers on a budget: The WinkBed is a luxury bed, so it has a higher price point when compared to some other mattresses.
  • Memory foam mattress fans: The WinkBed doesn’t have any memory foam, so it doesn’t have the contouring body hug that memory foam lovers desire.

Read our full WinkBeds Mattress Review to learn more! 

Casper Original

Who Should Buy this Mattress?

  • Budget shoppers
  • Couples
  • People with lower back pain
Casper Original Mattress
Firmness

6

Trial period

100 nights

Warranty

10 year warranty

Price

$$$

Who the Casper Mattress is Best For 

Best For…

  • Budget shoppers: The Casper is an affordable bed, with a price point that’s less than your average new mattress
  • Couples: Casper’s all-foam construction dampens movement so you won’t feel much wiggling from one side of the bed to the other. Good motion isolation is important for light sleepers who sleep with a partner, pet, or child.  
  • People with lower back pain: The Casper bed has three comfort zones, with firmer foam along the middle of the mattress. Extra support along the entire spine means superb spinal alignment, an excellent perk for people who struggle with lower back pain.

May Not be Best For…

  • People who sleep hot: Casper is an all-foam bed. In spite of open-cell foam that encourages airflow, it stores more body heat than most hybrid or innerspring mattresses
  • People who like a bouncy feel: The Casper mattress does not have any steel coils, the material that creates the springy traditional mattress feel. While you won’t feel stuck like on some memory foam beds, there isn’t much bounce.
  • Heavyweight folks: The Casper’s support system and comfort layers best support people who weigh less than 230 pounds.

Read our full Casper Mattress Review to learn more! 

Deciding Between WinkBeds & Casper

Firmness / Feel

One of the biggest distinctions between the Casper and WinkBed is firmness. The Casper is a medium-firm mattress, falling at a 6/10 on a 1–10 firmness scale, with 10 being the firmest. An average-weight person is going to sink slightly into the comfort layers without feeling completely enveloped by foam. 

The WinkBed comes in four different firmnesses—softer, luxury-firm, firmer, and plus. Here’s where each falls on the 1–10 firmness scale, along with how each feels. 

  • Softer (4.5): A medium-soft bed that hugs the body in a cloud-like embrace.
  • Luxury-Firm (6.5): A medium-firm mattress with a similar balanced feel as the Casper
  • Firmer (7.5): A firm bed that feels like you’re floating on the surface. 
  • Plus (8): A firm mattress designed for heavier folks. People who weigh more than 230 pounds are likely to notice a similar balanced feel as average-weight people on the luxury-firm model. What this means is that you won’t feel either fully “in” or “on” the surface. 

Medium-firm beds like the Casper and luxury-firm WinkBed are the most popular mattresses. This level of firmness is known as the universal firmness because it’s what most people prefer, especially back and stomach sleepers. Side sleepers typically desire a softer top layer with greater pressure relief, such as the softer WinkBeds mattress

The more you weigh, the softer a mattress feels. For this reason, most plus-size people are likely to prefer the feel of the WinkBed Plus over the Casper or other WinkBed models. Lightweight folks, on the other hand, may lean towards the softer WinkBed or the Casper mattress. To learn about other WinkBeds models, see our WinkBeds mattress reviews.

WinkBeds Performance By Sleeping Position:
Body Type: BACK SLEEPERS STOMACH SLEEPERS SIDE SLEEPERS
Lightweight (< 130 lbs):  4 5 3
Average weight (130 – 230 lbs): 4 4 4
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs):  4 4 4
Casper Performance By Sleeping Position:
Body Type: BACK SLEEPERS STOMACH SLEEPERS SIDE SLEEPERS
Lightweight (< 130 lbs):  5 3 4
Average weight (130 – 230 lbs): 5 3 5
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs):  4 2 4

1 = Very poor, 2 = Not good, 3 = Fair, 4 = Good, 5 = Excellent

Motion Isolation

Do you share your bed with another person or pet? If you do and either of you is easily woken up at night, you should look for a mattress with excellent motion isolation. These beds absorb movement so that it doesn’t spread to the other side of the bed. 

Both the WinkBed and Casper do a good job at limiting motion transfer, but Casper is the winner here. The WinkBed’s coils share a bit more motion than the Casper’s foam layers. However, most sleepers find that the thick comfort layers of the WinkBed do a good enough job to help them sleep soundly. 

Edge Support

Edge support matters if you’re someone who uses the perimeter of the mattress for support when getting into or out of bed, if you sit along the edges, or if you sleep along the edges in an effort to carve out some personal space. 

Both of these mattresses have edges that are quite comfy to sleep along. When it comes to sitting on the edge or using it for support, the WinkBed is slightly sturdier than the Casper. The durable innerspring coil construction brings a bit more stability when putting lots of weight on the edges.

Pressure Relief 

Side sleepers and people with joint pain are the two main groups that look for a mattress with extra cushion. Soft foam at the hips and shoulders minimize pressure and pain at these sensitive areas. 

The WinkBed wins in this category. Not only does this mattress come in four firmness options, with the softer version great for most side sleepers, but it also has softer foam at the hips and shoulders. In comparison, the Casper has a more plush feel at the shoulders, but firmer support at the hips. For people with hip pain or who experience pressure at the hips when side sleeping, the WinkBed offers superior relief.

Spine Alignment 

A mattress’s ability to support healthy spinal alignment is one of the most important factors to consider when shopping for a new bed. And if you’re someone who has ever had back or neck pain, proper alignment is essential. The right mattress for good alignment depends upon your sleeping position and body size. 

Plus-size people are best suited by the WinkBed Plus version thanks to extra support that minimizes sinkage for heavier folks. The Casper has a slight edge over the WinkBed for lightweight and average-weight stomach sleepers thanks to firmer foam at the hips. In comparison, the WinkBed’s softer foam at this area is better for side sleepers

Both the WinkBed and Casper do a good job at supporting the spines of back sleepers who weigh less than 230 pounds.

Durability 

Thanks to the added support of innerspring coils, the WinkBed mattress is more durable than the Casper. Additionally, heavyweight people need denser foams to reduce sagging over time, and the WinkBed Plus offers this perk. 

Temperature 

The WinkBed is more breathable than the Casper mattress. The increased airflow sweeps away stored body heat, which helps support temperature regulation over the night. If you’re someone who often wakes up hot and sweaty, we recommend the WinkBed

WinkBeds Mattress Construction

Cover TENCEL Cover
Comfort Layer  Euro Pillow Top with 2–3 layers of Gel Foam

Or

Euro Pillow Top with High-Density Anti-Sag Foam (Plus)

Transitional Layer SupportCell Foam +

LumbarLayer Support Foam

Or

Seven-Zoned Latex Layer (Plus)

Support Layer Zoned Pocketed Coils with extraEDGE Support System + Base Foam
Mattress Thickness  13.5”

The WinkBed is a thick hybrid bed with layers of foam atop individually encased coils. The top layers vary based on which firmness you choose—softer, luxury-firm, firmer, or plus. All models have a Euro pillow top with polyfoam layers designed to provide the desired level of cushion. The plus version swaps out transitional polyfoam with zoned latex for greater support. With zoned support, the WinkBed delivers support and cushioning at the right areas. 

Casper Mattress Construction

casper inside
Cover Breathable Cover
Comfort Layer  AirScape Perforated Foam (1.5”)
Transitional Layer Zoned Support Memory Foam (2”)
Support Layer High-Density Polyfoam (7”)
Mattress Thickness  11”

The Casper is a three-layer mattress that combines Casper’s proprietary soft and responsive AirScape polyfoam with contouring memory foam. The memory foam layer has softer zones along the top and bottom thirds of the bed with firmer support along the spine. These foams combine for a feeling that falls between sleeping “in” and “on” the mattress. A base layer of dense foam brings outstanding motion isolation

Sizing & Price Comparisons 

Mattress Size  WinkBed Price WinkBed Plus Price Casper Price
Twin $1,049 $1,249 $595
Twin XL $1,149 $1,349 $695
Full $1,299 $1,499 $995
Queen $1,599 $1,799 $1,095
King $1,799 $1,999 $1,295
Cal King $1,849 $1,999 $1,295

To see deals and offers on these beds, check out our WinkBeds mattress coupons and Casper mattress coupons.

Shipping and Returns for WinkBeds & Casper

WinkBeds Mattress

WinkBeds ships their bed-in-a-box mattresses to the 48 contiguous United States for free. Because WinkBeds mattresses are handmade to order, it can take up to two weeks to receive your new bed. 

Every WinkBed mattress comes with a 120-night sleep trial that begins the day your mattress arrives on your doorstep. WinkBeds requires that you give the mattress a try for 30 days after receipt, after which the brand offers full refunds during the trial period.

Read More: WinkBeds Return Policy Breakdown 

The WinkBedsLifetime warranty is hard to beat. The warranty isn’t prorated, which means that WinkBeds covers the entire cost to replace or repair the bed, even if it’s been 15 or 20 years. The only downside that we see with the WinkBeds warranty is that body impressions aren’t covered until they’ve exceeded 1.5” deep, while most mattress brands replace beds with indentations greater than 1”.

Additionally, WinkBeds mattresses come with a 50 percent replacement guarantee. If, at any time, you decide that you would prefer a different WinkBeds bed, simply contact them and pay 50 percent the price of the new mattress. It must be the same size as your original bed.

Casper Mattress

Casper offers free shipping to customers in the contiguous U.S. and parts of Canada. They do ship to Alaska and Hawaii, but there is a fee added at checkout. Casper is also a bed-in-a-box company, so expect your new bed to arrive compressed into a box. Unlike WinkBeds, Casper is known for their fast shipping, with most orders arriving within five business days. 

Casper customers also enjoy a sleep trial period, during which Casper offers free returns. Unlike WinkBeds, Casper accepts returns at any time during its 100-night trial, so you won’t need to wait if you’re sure you don’t like the bed right away.  

Casper mattresses come with the industry-standard 10-year warranty. While this policy is not as long as WinkBeds’, it covers body indentation greater than 1”, rather than 1.5” like WinkBeds. 

Learn More: Casper Mattress Warranty Breakdown

More WinkBeds Mattresses

WinkBeds GravityLux

The WinkBeds GravityLux is WinkBeds’ only all-foam mattress. With contouring memory foam and three firmness levels that include the softest WinkBeds mattress, it’s a top pick for side sleepers

WinkBeds EcoCloud

The EcoCloud is the all-natural and eco-friendly WinkBeds mattress, making it the brand’s best mattress for people looking for an environmentally friendly bed. It’s the coolest and most responsive WinkBeds model. 

Read our WinkBeds EcoCloud mattress review for more. 

More Casper Mattresses

Casper Element

The Casper Element is the least expensive Casper mattress. While its medium-firm feel is similar to that of the original Casper, it has more minimal comfort layers that make it best for back sleepers

Casper Element Mattress in a plain room

See our full Casper Element Mattress Review to learn more. 

Casper Nova Hybrid

The Casper Nova Hybrid is the best Casper bed for people who love ultra-soft, enveloping surfaces. It offers superior pressure relief while still supporting proper spinal alignment and sleeping cool.

nova hybrid plain room xl 1

See our full Casper Nova Hybrid Mattress Review to learn more. 

Casper Wave Hybrid

The Casper Wave Hybrid is the most opulent Casper bed designed for the luxury mattress shopper. With Casper’s most advanced ergonomic support and cooling innovations, we recommend it over the other Casper models for people with back pain and those who sleep hot. 

Casper Wave Hybrid Mattress

See our full Casper Wave Hybrid Mattress Review to learn more. 

Our Final Take

The original WinkBed’s four firmness options lead us to recommend it over the Casper for side sleeping and heavier folks. It’s also cooler and more responsive, which makes it easier to move around. The Casper’s reinforced midsection delivers better alignment for stomach sleepers, and its all-foam construction means even better motion isolation than the WinkBed.