Casper Mattress Comparison

 Casper is one of the leaders in the bed-in-a-box mattress space and they offer five fan-favorite foam and foam hybrid mattresses. We’re going to compare these models so you can find the best fit for you. Then, we’ll outline what to expect when buying a new bed from Casper.

Casper Mattress Models 

The Casper Original is the brand’s flagship model and is their only memory foam mattress that boasts ergonomic zoned support. With a medium-firm feel and even weight distribution, this is one of the best Casper mattresses at supporting every sleeping position. Combine that with its superior motion isolation and the Casper Original might just be their best bed for couples and people who sleep with pets or children.

Read our full Casper Original Mattress Review

The Casper Hybrid is simply a hybrid version of the Original Casper mattress. By replacing the foam base layer with pocketed innerspring coils, the Casper Hybrid brings the same balanced sleeping experience with added cooling and responsiveness. While this bed is a touch softer than the Original, it too works well for all sleeping positions. But with the addition of breathable and springy coils, the Hybrid is superior for hot sleepers and people who switch positions a lot.   

Read our full Casper Hybrid Mattress Review

The Nova Hybrid is Casper’s softest mattress. With an ultra-plush surface paired with zoned support foam, the Nova generously cushions pressure points and hugs the body’s curves. The Nova’s softness makes it one of Casper’s best mattresses for side sleepers and lightweight people of every sleeping position. And thanks to contouring that both supports the spine and cushions the joints, the Nova is an excellent bed for people with joint or lower back pain.  

Read our full Casper Nova Hybrid Mattress Review.

The Casper Wave Hybrid is Casper’s most luxurious mattress. It’s designed to offer the greatest ergonomic support, making it a wonderful choice for people with back pain. With thick and deeply conforming comfort foam layers, the Wave Hybrid is designed for people who love cloud-like comfort. The Wave Hybrid boasts cutting-edge cooling technology, with cooling gel, breathable foam, and airy innerspring coils that make it one of the best cooling mattresses for people who like softer beds.  

Read our full Casper Wave Hybrid Mattress Review

The Casper Element is the most affordable Casper bed. This all-foam mattress has only two layers of foam and a medium-firm feel. The top layeris perforated Airscape foam with greater breathability than other budget foam beds. This layer lightly contours, while the support foam brings a balanced feel that falls between sleeping “on” and “in” the surface. The Element’s all-foam construction is good at minimizing motion transfer, helping couples sleep without disruptions. It’s an excellent mattress for growing children, dorm rooms, and guest bedrooms.

Read our full Casper Element Mattress Review.

Casper Mattress Brand by Sleep Style 

Here at Mattress Nerd, we classify lightweight sleepers as weighing < 130 lbs., while average-weight sleepers are between 130-230 lbs. and heavyweight sleepers weigh over 230 lbs.

Every Casper mattress, with exception of the Element, has ergonomic zoned support, with firmer foam at the middle of the bed and softer foam at the shoulders. The balanced support delivers the right feel for every sleeping position. However, no Casper mattress is designed specifically for heavier people, so none of their beds have the level of core support that heavyweight stomach sleepers need. Additionally, the Original Casper doesn’t have thick enough comfort layers to provide sufficient pressure relief for side sleepers with bigger bodies. 

The Element mattress is a minimal mattress with thin comfort layers and average support from the high-density foam base. Heavyweight people, no matter their sleeping positions, are unlikely to receive either the level of support or pressure relief that they need on the Element. It’s also not soft enough at the shoulders for lightweight side sleepers, and it may dip at the hips of stomach sleepers who weigh more than 230 pounds. The Element is best for back sleepers who weigh less than 230 pounds.

Other Considerations: Cooling, Back Pain, and Couples

When it comes to how cool Casper mattresses sleep, they range from somewhat warm to impressively cool. The Casper Original and Element mattresses sleep the warmest because neither has breathable innerspring coils or advanced cooling technology. Next, the Nova Hybrid is one of the best plush beds for hot sleepers, but it can sleep warm for heavier folks who sink into the top layers. Finally, the Casper Hybrid and Casper Wave Hybrid mattresses are cool enough for most hot sleepers thanks to excellent airflow and other cooling innovations. 

We love the Casper brand when it comes to back pain relief. Every Casper mattress, except for the budget-friendly Element, has one or more layers of ergonomically-zoned foam designed to keep the spine properly aligned in every sleeping position. Because side sleepers and lightweight people tend to find better pressure relief and alignment on softer beds, we recommend the Nova and Wave for side sleepers with back pain. The Casper Hybrid, Original, and Wave are excellent for stomach and back sleepers. All of the beds are best for people who weigh less than 230 pounds when it comes to optimal spine alignment and back pain relief. See the best mattresses for heavy people for more options. 

Couples are another group of people who typically love Casper mattresses. Each model does a better job than the average mattress at absorbing motion, which means that people who share the bed are less likely to wake up throughout the night when their partner repositions. Additionally, every model, excluding the Element, delivers exceptional support to lightweight and average-weight folks of every sleeping position. So couples with different habits both find Casper mattresses comfortable.

Casper Mattress Construction

How Construction Impacts The Feel of the Mattress

Casper mattresses fall into two categories. There are the all-foam beds—the Original and Element—and hybrid mattresses—the Hybrid, Wave, and Nova. The all-foam mattresses are going to have slightly better motion isolation, but they sleep warmer than the hybrids. The hybrid mattresses have a bouncier feel, sleep cooler, are more supportive, and boast enhanced durability. 

Every mattress other than the Element has at least one ergonomically-zoned foam layer. What this means is that every Casper mattress, besides the Element, does a good job supporting spinal alignment in every sleeping position. However, differences in firmness and feel make each better for different people. 

The Casper, Casper Hybrid, and Element are the firmest Casper mattress. Their balanced feel makes them a good fit for the average sleeper, especially back sleepers who will like the medium-firm firmness of these beds. 

The Wave Hybrid and Nova Hybrid both have the most layers, with added softness and zoned support that makes each better for people with body aches and pains. The cushion at the shoulders and support along the middle of the body minimize pressure while keeping the spine properly aligned. These beds are more luxurious and have a higher price point when compared to the other Casper mattresses.

Casper Mattress Pricing 

Disclaimer: These are standard prices without promotions or Mattress Nerd exclusive offers with a CTA to check for the best price

Want to lower these prices? Check out our Casper mattress coupons.

Dimensions & Specs 

Casper Mattress Warranty, Shipping & Sleep Trial

Every Casper mattress is compressed into a box before it’s shipped to you. Casper offers free shipping to customers in the continental United States and parts of Canada, with shipping for a fee to people in Hawaii and Alaska. Thanks to their beds being made in the U.S. and Canada, they typically arrive in two to five business days. 

Only the Casper Wave King and California-King mattresses come with free white glove delivery, during which a team sets up your new mattress and gets rid of your old mattress. Presently, Casper doesn’t offer a white glove delivery upsell for their other beds. 

When you buy a Casper mattress, it comes with a 100-night trial. Unlike most online mattress brands that make you wait 30 days before qualifying for a return, you may return your Casper bed at any time during the sleep trial. Casper will work with you to pick a date and time that you’ll be home to have a team come and pick up the bed. Returned mattresses are either donated or recycled. You can expect a full refund within two weeks from the pickup date. 

Learn More: Casper Mattress Return Policy Breakdown

For the majority of customers who decide to keep their new Casper bed, it’s backed by a 10-year limited warranty. The Casper warranty covers defects that wouldn’t be expected from normal wear-and-tear. Examples of defects include body impressions that are deeper than 1” and cracks or splits in the foam. Check out what mattress warranties cover more generally with this post.

If you love the Casper brand, see our best online mattress reviews to compare brands and models. 

Compare Casper Mattresses to More Brands 

• Casper vs. Amerisleep
• Casper vs. Bear
• Casper vs. Brooklyn Bedding
• Casper vs. GhostBed
• Casper vs. Helix
• Casper vs. Layla
• Casper vs. Leesa
• Casper vs. Loom & Leaf
• Casper vs. Lull
• Casper vs. Nectar
• Casper vs. Puffy
• Casper vs. Purple
• Casper vs. Saatva
• Casper vs. Tempur-Pedic
• Casper vs. Tuft & Needle
• Casper vs. WinkBeds
• Casper Nova Hybrid vs. Layla Hybrid
• Casper Mattress Alternatives

Casper FAQs

How long do Casper mattresses last?

When regularly rotated and used atop a supportive base, most Casper mattresses last between seven and 10 years. The Element is a more minimal mattress without the zoned support, and therefore may not last as long as other Casper beds, although it’s still likely to last at least five-to-seven years.   

Should you use a box spring with a Casper mattress? 

Casper recommends that you do not place any of their mattresses on box springs as they don’t provide the correct level of support. Instead, they recommend that you use an adjustable base, foundation, platform bed frame or slatted bed frame with slats spaced less than 4” apart. 

Are Casper mattresses a good deal? 

Casper sells most of its mattresses directly to the consumer. By reducing showroom and salesperson costs, Casper can sell high-quality all-foam and hybrid mattresses at competitive price points. Most beds of similar quality, especially those found at brick-and-mortar retailers, are more expensive than Casper mattresses. 

Where can I buy Casper mattresses? 

Most people buy directly from casper.com or at one of their retail locations. Some of Casper’s beds are available at retail stores like Target and Macy’s or online from Amazon. The return policy and trial period vary based on where you buy your Casper mattress.

Addressing Casper Mattress Complaints

• Expensive: Complaints about Casper’s cost are surprising given that the Casper Original retails for just over $1,000 in the Queen size. That being said, it’s important to understand that people evaluate the cost based on how well a product performs against their expectations. Overall, we think the Casper is fairly priced for customers who understand that it’s designed to be a comfortable, accommodating mattress: not the best mattress they’ve ever slept on.
• Customer service issues: Thumbing through the reviews carefully reveals that some Casper customers take issue because they misunderstand the company’s policies or have expectations about promises that Casper did not clearly set forth in the first place. For example, while Casper promises that its mattresses ship free, it does not classify a specific shipping window.
• Not durable enough: Foam mattresses are not known for their durability, but the Casper has a relatively strong support system for a foam bed. While it technically lasts about seven years, sleepers may find that body impressions formed night after night of sleep make the bed more uncomfortable.
• Back pain: Different mattresses are suited for different sleeper types, and how well a bed alleviates or prevents back pain is very dependent on your weight, body type, and sleeping position. The three foam layers of the Casper mattress may soften and sag slightly over time, meaning it may be most appropriate for lightweight and side sleepers.

Key Details About Casper Brand

Casper is one of the most well-known direct-to-consumer mattress brands. When you think of bed-in-a-box brands, Casper is bound to come to mind. They’re known for their competitively priced high-quality mattresses, offering five all-foam and hybrid beds that work well for lightweight and average-weight people. Since Casper launched in 2014, this US-based mattress brand has received primarily positive reviews, both from customers and mattress review sites.