Is a luxury memory foam mattress better than a bed-in-a-box online mattress brand? We’ll answer that question and more in this Casper vs. Loom & Leaf mattress comparison.
Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.
Casper vs. Loom & Leaf Mattress Comparison
Comparing Casper & Loom and Leaf Mattresses
The Casper is an all-foam mattress that features an extra-responsive foam top layer and zoned memory foam transition layer. The Loom and Leaf is a luxury memory foam mattress that’s available in two firmness options: relaxed firm and firm.
In general, the Casper is the better mattress for couples who are concerned about motion transfer, as well as combination sleepers who need a mattress that quickly responds to changes in sleeping position. You’ll like the Loom & Leaf mattress if you appreciate luxury touches like organic cotton. It’s also a little more versatile: Side sleepers will like the relaxed firm version, and back and stomach sleepers will like the firm version.
Differences
- The Casper mattress does a better job of isolating motion from one side of the bed to the other.
- The Loom & Leaf has a more traditional memory foam feel, with slow sinkage and whole body contouring. The Casper is conforming, but it’s generally more buoyant.
- As a luxury mattress brand, the Loom & Leaf is priced a little higher than the Casper, which is considered a mid-range mattress brand.
Similarities
- Both of these mattresses promote good sleeping posture (also called spinal alignment), so we consider them some of the best mattresses for back pain.
- The Casper and Loom & Leaf both have an all-foam construction that’s more prone to heat retention.
Casper Original
Who Should Buy This Mattress?
- Back sleepers
- Couples
- Budget shoppers
Firmness
6
Trial period
100 nights
Warranty
10 year warranty
Price
$$$
Who the Casper Mattress is Best For
Best For…
- Back sleepers will stay supported while sinking comfortably into the top layers of foam on the Casper.
- Couples won’t notice very much—if any—motion transfer when they share this bed.
- Budget shoppers will pay significantly less for a Casper than for the Loom & Leaf.
May Not be Best For…
- The Casper may sleep too hot for the comfort level of some sleepers.
- Stomach sleepers need a little more firmness than the Casper can offer.
- Some side sleepers may not get enough sinkage to cushion their shoulders
Read our full Casper mattress review to learn more!
Loom & Leaf
Who Should Buy This Mattress?
- Back sleepers
- Stomach sleepers (firm option)
- Side sleepers (relaxed firm option)
Firmness
Varies
Trial period
120 nights
Warranty
15 year limited warranty
Price
$$$
Who the Loom and Leaf Mattress is Best For
Best For…
- Back sleepers of all body types will get just the right amount of support and cushioning on either version of the Loom & Leaf.
- Stomach sleepers will get plenty of support for their hips and lower back on the firm version of the Loom & Leaf.
- The relaxed firm Loom & Leaf provides plenty of cushioning: enough for side sleepers.
May Not be Best For…
- Hot sleepers may get too warm on the dense memory foam layers that top the Loom & Leaf mattress.
- Those who like a bouncy mattress won’t get the feel they’re looking for from memory foam.
- Those sensitive to off-gassing (the “new mattress” smell) may want to stick with latex or innerspring mattresses.
Read our full Loom and Leaf mattress review to learn more!
Deciding Between Casper & Loom and Leaf
Firmness / Feel
The firmness level of a mattress is a measurement of how soft or hard the mattress will feel to sleep on. At Mattress Nerd, we use a firmness scale that ranges from 1–10. Softer mattresses are closer to 1/10, and firmer mattresses are closer to 10/10. If you have a heavier body type, you’re more likely to perceive a mattress as softer, while petite sleepers tend to experience mattresses as firmer than advertised.
Both the Casper and relaxed firm Loom & Leaf mattresses are considered medium-firm, or 6/10 on the firmness scale. The firm Loom & Leaf is 8/10. Predictably, you’ll sink deeper into the comfort layers on the Casper and relaxed firm Loom & Leaf mattresses. The Loom & Leaf has a slow-sinking feel like the best memory foam mattresses that will wrap around your body and take a little while to rebound when you get up.
Motion Isolation
Solo sleepers don’t need to pay as much attention to motion isolation, but couples should take note. All-foam mattresses typically reduce motion transfer better than hybrid and innerspring mattresses, so it’s no surprise that the Casper and Loom & Leaf mattresses both keep motion transfer to a minimum. Even so, we think the Casper does a slightly better job in this category. Both mattresses will keep couples undisturbed and lack of motion makes them some of the best mattresses for sex.
Edge Support
Edge support matters mainly for anyone who likes to feel well supported while sitting or sleeping near the edges of their bed. Some mattress companies frame their mattresses with foam or coil reinforcements, but neither Casper nor Loom & Leaf have any edge support features. Still, we felt supported on the edges of both mattresses, though we sunk a little lower into the Loom & Leaf.
Pressure Relief
Side sleepers should pay extra attention to how well a mattress relieves tension on pressure points like shoulders and hips. Generally, softer mattresses provide the best pressure relief, but medium-firm mattresses also do a good job.
The Casper and relaxed firm Loom & Leaf provide a similar amount of pressure relief. We think that the Loom & Leaf is a little more effective at cushioning your shoulders and hips, but it’s pretty close. The firm Loom & Leaf has enough pressure relief for stomach sleepers and lightweight or average-weight back sleepers, but not side sleepers.
Spine Alignment
Spinal alignment is another way of saying good sleeping posture. Just like good posture while sitting or standing can prevent neck and back pain, good posture while sleeping keeps you from waking up stiff and sore. Fortunately, both the Casper and Loom & Leaf mattresses support your spine really well, probably due to their Zoned Support layers.
Durability
Memory foam mattresses typically last seven to 10 years, though they can last longer or shorter depending on the frequency and intensity of use. The Casper is protected by a 10-year warranty, and the Loom & Leaf is protected by a 15-year warranty, so even if your mattress develops defects, you can make a claim and receive repairs or a replacement.
Temperature
The best cooling mattresses create temperature neutral or cool products through a number of methods. Foam beds tend to retain heat more than hybrid or innerspring beds, so the Casper and Loom & Leaf tend to sleep a little warm. Still, this will only be an issue for those who sleep really hot at night. If you’re choosing between the two, we think Loom & Leaf stays a little cooler, probably because of the cooling gel in the top layer.
The Casper mattress is wrapped in a breathable polyester mattress cover that allows you to sink deep into the AirScape foam on top of the mattress. This top layer is perforated, which improves airflow by pushing hot air away from the mattress. The second layer is Zoned Support foam. This memory foam layer is firmer in the center third, which cradles and lifts your hips. An extra thick layer of base foam keeps you from sinking too far into the mattress.
Loom & Leaf Mattress Construction
The Loom & Leaf mattress is covered in soft organic cotton that’s treated with an all-natural antimicrobial treatment. Instead of a chemical flame retardant, the Loom & Leaf includes a layer of natural thistle pulp.
The top layer of gel-infused visco-elastic memory foam is divided into ergonomic zones that provide targeted support for your lower back. The second layer is high-density memory foam that contours around pressure points, and the third layer and base layers are made of supportive polyfoam.
Sizing & Price Comparisons
| Mattress Size | Casper Mattress | Loom & Leaf Mattress |
| Twin | $595 | $899 |
| Twin XL | $695 | $1,199 |
| Full | $995 | $1,699 |
| Queen | $1,095 | $1,799 |
| King | $1,295 | $2,099 |
| California King | $1,295 | $2,099 |
For the best price on a new mattress, check out our Casper Mattress Coupons & Saatva Mattress Coupons.
Shipping and Returns for Casper & Loom and Leaf
Casper:
Casper customers in the U.S. and Canada get free shipping, while those in Alaska and Hawaii are required to pay an extra shipping fee. Mattresses leave the warehouse one to two business days after you place your order, and you’ll receive a tracking number via email with an estimated delivery date.
Once your mattress is delivered, the Casper 100-night sleep trial starts. You can return your mattress at any point during the trial period, and will receive a full refund once your mattress is picked up and donated or discarded.
Note: The return policy for Amazon purchases may be different.
After the trial period ends, Casper mattresses are covered by a 10-year warranty that protects against manufacturing defects like indentations, cracks, splits, and broken zippers. If your mattress develops one of these defects, you may be eligible for free repairs or a replacement mattress. You can also upgrade to a more expensive mattress model by paying the difference between the two beds.
Learn More: Casper Mattress Warranty
Loom & Leaf:
Loom & Leaf mattresses are shipped for free, and customers enjoy free white glove delivery and old mattress removal. Currently, Saatva doesn’t ship to Alaska or Hawaii, but they will work with you to arrange for freight forwarding.
The Loom & Leaf mattress comes with a 180-night sleep trial. At any time during the trial, you can initiate a return for only $99. Saatva will pick up your used mattress and either donate it to a veterans shelter or offer it to Saatva employees.
The 15-year mattress warranty protects against manufacturing defects. For the first two years of the warranty, you’ll receive a replacement mattress if yours becomes defective. During years three to 15, repairs or a replacement will cost $99 for transportation both ways. Saatva also offers a Fairness Replacement Option, which enables you to keep your defective mattress and buy a replacement at a prorated cost.
Casper Hybrid
The Casper Hybrid mattress also uses AirScape foam and Zoned Support memory foam, but swaps the foam base layer for bouncy, breathable coils.
See our full Casper Hybrid Mattress Review to learn more.
Casper Nova Hybrid
The Nova Hybrid is Casper’s softest mattress. It combines coils with two layers of perforated AirScape 2 foam and the Zoned Support Pro comfort layer, which is divided into seven zones instead of three.
Check out our full Casper Nova Hybrid Mattress Review to learn more.
Casper Wave Hybrid
The Wave Hybrid is a cooling mattress with two layers of gel-infused AirScape 3 foam and supportive gel pods in the center of the mattress.
See our full Casper Wave Hybrid mattress review for more.
More Saatva Mattresses
Saatva Classic
Saatva is one of the first direct-to-consumer online mattress companies. The Saatva mattress is not a “bed-in-a-box” company, because it doesn’t come in a box at all. It’s a regular innerspring mattress delivered to your door by delivery professionals.
Read out full Saatva Classic Mattress Review to learn more.
If you haven’t decided on your new mattress, check out some of our other comparisons:
Our Casper vs. Loom & Leaf Final Review
The Casper and Loom & Leaf both make use of contouring memory foam layers, but otherwise feel like pretty different mattresses. The Casper’s Zoned Support layer is ideal for back sleepers and those with back pain. The dense foam layers also keep motion transfer to a minimum, which is a great feature for couples. The Loom & Leaf comes with a luxury price tag, but the relaxed firm is our pick for side sleepers, and the firm version is well-suited to stomach sleepers.
