Casper vs. Tempur-Pedic Mattress Comparison

Comparing Casper & Tempur-Pedic Mattresses

If you’ve been browsing the Internet for a new mattress, you’ve probably come across Casper and Tempur-Pedic. Casper is often called one of the best online mattresses and is a comfortable, soft foam mattress that appeals to the average sleeper for its balanced feel and zoned support. Tempur-Pedic, on the other hand, has carved out its spot in the mattress industry as a household name known for its signature, deep cradling and pressure relief and its detailed, premium constructions. Casper has great value while TempurPedic offers a luxurious sleep experience.

See: Best Luxury Mattresses

In this mattress comparison, we’re sharing everything you need to know when comparing the Casper mattress to Tempur-Pedic including price, feel and construction, firmness settings, shipping and warranty policies, and more. At the end of the article, you’ll have enough information to determine which brand might have the right new mattress for you.

Note: Please keep in mind that we’re comparing Casper’s most popular model, the Casper Original, with the full Tempur-Pedic collection in this article for simplicity’s sake. Casper also offers hybrid mattress options, which we’ve outlined below.

Differences

• Return Policies—Tempur-Pedic charges a fee for returns within its 90-night sleep trial period (~$175), but returns to Casper are free within the company’s 100-night sleep trial period.
• Delivery—Tempur-Pedic offers White Glove Delivery with all of its three mattress lines, which is considered more of a premium service. The Casper mattress is shipped free as a bed-in-a-box, so it arrives rolled and compressed.
• Price—Tempur-Pedics come with a high price tag, while Casper is one of our picks for the best affordable mattresses
  
• Feel—Tempur-Pedic beds have a true, deep memory foam feel, while the Casper has a neutral feel that balances support and comfort.
• Selection—Casper makes just three beds (Casper Original, Casper Wave Hybrid, Casper Nova Hybrid), while Tempur-Pedic has three mattress lines with many beds in each collection.
• Firmness Levels—Within Tempur-Pedic’s three lines (Adapt, ProAdapt, LuxeAdapt), the company offers options ranging from very soft to firm. Casper makes different beds but does not offer as much variety when it comes to firmness setting. 
• Cooling Ability—Most Tempur-Pedic beds have a cooling cover that helps the bed regulate temperature, even though memory foam beds are known for sleeping hot.
• Suitability for Body Types—Tempur-Pedic hybrid mattress options will support  heavier people, while the Casper Original mattress is best for lightweight and average weight sleepers.

Related: Best Mattresses for Plus-Size Sleepers

Similarities

• Comfort Layer– Both mattresses provide targeted comfort layers to support hips and shoulders while conforming to softer areas like shoulders. 
• Trial Period—The companies offer similar sleep trial periods of roughly three months (90 days and 100 days).
• Warranty Coverage—Both mattress brands back their products with a 10-year warranty, although details of coverage vary.
• Availability—Both are available on their respective company websites, select third-party retailers (Amazon.com, Target, etc.), and in brick-and-mortar stores.

Who the Casper Mattress is Best For 

Best For…

• Sleepers who enjoy foam beds with a neutral, balanced feel
• All sleeping positions 
• Shoppers on a budget
• Lightweight and average weight sleepers

May Not be Best For…

• People who like a bouncy, responsive mattress
• Heavyweight sleepers
• People who like deep sinking and contouring

Read our full Casper mattress review to learn more! 

Who the Tempur-Pedic Mattress is Best For 

Best For…

• People who love a conforming, deep sinking memory foam feel 
• People who usually sleep hot on all-foam beds
• Shoppers with a large budget
• Those who value luxury shopping experiences (i.e. White Glove delivery)

Related: Best Luxury Mattresses

May Not be Best For…

• Shoppers with a small budget
• People who don’t like the feel of a memory foam mattress
• People who dislike off-gassing smells and odors 

Read our full Tempur-Pedic mattress review to learn more about the brand! 

Deciding Between Casper & Tempur-Pedic

Firmness / Feel

Both the Casper Original and Tempur-Pedic Adapt are available in just one firmness setting (6/10 and 5/10, respectively). Each brand also offers other foam and hybrid mattresses at other firmness settings, but for this review, we’ll focus on the Casper Original and the Tempur-Pedic Adapt.

The Casper has a balanced, neutral foam feel, which simply means that it won’t feel like you’re sleeping on clingy memory foam or on a too-firm-for-comfort surface. The Tempur-Adapt has a slightly softer feel overall, and its top memory foam layers are viscous, providing the deep, sinking cradle that memory foam lovers tend to seek out.

In general, we recommend that you steer toward Tempur-Pedic if you really love memory foam and have the money to spend on a new mattress. If you like foam but don’t love sinking into memory foam, you’ll probably enjoy the feel of the Casper more.

Related: Memory Foam vs Hybrid

Motion Isolation

The best mattresses for couples have the ability to isolate motion to ensure partners, pets and any co-sleeping children aren’t awakened (or don’t wake you) when tossing and turning at night. Both Casper and Tempur-Pedic mattresses excel at motion isolation. The foam layers in these mattresses absorb and minimize motion transfer to a significant extent, and we don’t think there’s a real “winner” in this category. People looking for a motion isolating mattress will find this quality in both the Casper Original and the Tempur-Pedic Adapt.

Edge Support

Over time, all mattresses are prone to sinking at the edges. A mattress’ ability to provide good edge support depends on how it’s made, its style, its usage and more. Edge support maximizes the area of the mattress you can sleep on and assists people as they get in and out of bed. The TEMPUR-Adapt will be susceptible to sinking around the edges over time. The Casper has above average edge support for an all-foam bed due to its tall core, but sinkage around the perimeter over time is likely. If you’re concerned about sagging, consider hybrid mattresses from these brands.

Pressure Relief 

Beds that conform closely to the sleeper’s body will cradle pressure points and will align the spine properly. Above-average pressure relief is important for people who wake up with aches and pains, have very physical jobs, or suffer from a chronic illness or issue, but every sleeper benefits from pressure relief in their sleeping position of choice. Both the Casper and Tempur-Pedic offer great pressure relief thanks to their layers of conforming memory foam and polyfoam.

Spine Alignment 

Healthy spinal alignment is encouraged by mattresses that provide a flat, even sleeping surface that keeps the spine and pelvis in the same plane. When areas of the body sink, it throws the spine out of alignment and can cause back issues and pain. How well the Casper or Tempur-Pedic Adapt’s align your spine will depend on your sleeping position and body type. The Casper Original tends to provide adequate support for people of all sleeping positions who weigh less than 230 pounds, while the Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Adapt works best for average weight sleepers of any position.

Durability 

The average lifespan of a mattress is roughly seven years, and this will vary based on the style of the mattress, the quality of its materials and construction, and how it is cared for. The Casper has a strong support system that will give it a longer-than-expected lifespan for an all-foam mattress, and the TEMPUR-Adapt will also last at least seven years, which is in line with other Tempur-Pedic memory foam mattresses.

Temperature 

If you sleep hot and are choosing between the Casper Original and the TEMPUR-Adapt, we recommend the Casper. It absorbs minimal heat when compared to other memory foam mattresses. The Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Adapt absorbs your body heat, meaning it will sleep somewhat warm. If you’re interested in a Tempur-Pedic bed that sleeps cool, consider models that incorporate the company’s DualClimate cooling cover.

See: Best Cooling Mattresses

Casper vs. Tempur-Pedic Mattress Construction 

Casper Construction

The Casper Original is a mixed foam mattress with a balanced feel that provides both comfort and support. It measures 11” tall and combines polyfoam, memory foam, and a polyester-spandex blend cover with design features like zoned support that help set it apart from other reasonably priced foam mattresses on the market.

The cover of the Casper original features different materials on the top, bottom, and side panels. The top panel is 100% polyester, while the bottom and side panels feature a polyester-spandex blend that helps make the cover stretchy. The cover is removable and can be spot-cleaned.

The Casper has two comfort layers, including a 1.5” layer of polyfoam and a 2” layer of memory foam. The polyfoam layer gives the Casper a feel that’s more responsive than most beds that incorporate memory foam. The memory foam is zoned to provide targeted support to different body parts, with firmer support to the back and hips and softer support around the shoulders. It gives the bed a close conforming feel while still relieving pressure.

The comfort layers are followed by a support core of 7” of high-density polyfoam. This dense foam stabilizes the mattress and helps prevent some sagging. It’s also thicker than average, helping the Casper provide support to sleepers who are a little heavier, although it’s not supportive enough to support sleepers who fall squarely into the heavyweight category.

Tempur-Pedic Construction

TempurPedic mattresses vary in construction depending on the collection, firmness setting and style (foam or hybrid). Below, we share the construction of one of TempurPedic’s most popular models, the TEMPUR-Adapt (foam). Also, keep in mind that specific TempurPedic mattress specs and details (layer height, density, etc.) are not disclosed by the company. 

The TEMPUR-Adapt mattress has a polyester cover that is not removable. TempurPedic recommends spot cleaning and air drying if stains occur. It features two memory foam comfort layers that together measure 4” thick. These are followed by a 3” transitional layer of polyfoam, which is medium-density in the ProAdapt.

The support core of the TEMPUR-Adapt is dense polyfoam, but the bed can also be made as a hybrid, which features pocketed coils.  In the foam model, the comfort and transition layers are followed by a 5” support core of high-density polyfoam. The core stabilizes the mattress and helps prevent sagging long-term.

The TEMPUR-Adapt comes in one medium firmness setting and can be made as a foam or hybrid bed. 

Sizing & Price Comparisons 

Shipping and Returns for Casper & Tempur-Pedic

Casper

Casper offers free shipping for customers in the contiguous U.S. and Canada. Your Casper mattress will arrive rolled and compressed as a bed-in-a-box and typically takes just a couple of days to ship. When it arrives, you’ll need to remove the packaging and allow it to return to its original shape for about 48 hours. If you decide you don’t want the mattress during the 100-night sleep trial period, simply contact Casper and they’ll arrange for pickup at no cost to you. You’ll get a full refund, and the mattress will be donated to charity.

Tempur-Pedic

Tempur-Pedic ships to all 50 states and offers free White Glove Delivery in the contiguous U.S. If you live in Alaska, Hawaii, or another U.S. territory, you’ll be charged a $600 flat rate for delivery and setup. White Glove Delivery includes old mattress removal, and your Tempur-Pedic will arrive in a box (not rolled or compressed). Most mattresses are shipped and arrive within two weeks of order, and an adult must be present at your residence to receive the mattress. If you decide you don’t like the Tempur-Pedic within the 90-night sleep trial period, you can return it for a fee.

More Casper Mattresses

See our full Casper Element Mattress Review to learn more.

Check out our full Casper Nova Hybrid mattress review to learn more.

More Tempur-Pedic Mattresses

Read our full Tempur-Breeze Mattress Review to learn more.

Still Can’t Decide? Check out our other mattress comparisons:

Casper vs Layla

Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding

Casper vs Helix

Casper vs Purple

Casper vs Lull

Casper vs Nectar

TempurPedic vs Leesa

Our Casper vs. Tempur-Pedic Review

While the Casper Original and Tempur-Pedic mattresses share some qualities and are technically in the same category (foam beds), they vary drastically in many aspects. Casper is a more budget friendly option with a balanced feel, and TempurPedic offers the classic memory foam feel at a large price point. Both offer excellent pressure relief and are well-loved brands, but if you’re looking for exceptional cooling at a lower price point, go with Casper. If budget isn’t an issue for you and you love the sinking feeling of traditional memory foam, go with the Tempur-Adapt.