Brooklyn Bedding vs. Nolah Mattress Comparison
Not sure which online mattress is the one for you? Find out how the fan-favorite Brooklyn Signature and Original Nolah mattresses compare.
Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.
The Brooklyn Bedding Signature is an affordable hybrid mattress with a luxury feel that comes in three firmness levels. The original Nolah mattress is an all-foam bed that has the pressure-relieving qualities of memory foam without the deep sink or heat retention. The Signature is better for bigger bodies and firm or soft mattress fans. Couples who sleep together may prefer the Nolah thanks to its impressive motion isolation properties.
In this mattress comparison, we put these two popular bed-in-a-box mattresses head to head. Once you know how their construction, feel, price point, and policies compare, you can choose the bed that best fits your needs.
Comparing the Brooklyn Signature Mattress & Nolah Mattress
Differences
- Body types supported: The Brooklyn Signature’s supportive steel coils—especially those in the firm model—are more durable than base foam, so it’s better than the Nolah for those with heavyweight body types.
- Construction: The Nolah is an all-foam mattress and the Signature is a hybrid bed that pairs comfort foam with pocketed coils.
- Firmness and feel: Because the Signature comes in three firmness options and the Nolah just one, the Signature is better for sleepers who like firmer or softer mattresses. Both have a medium-firm option for people who enjoy the standard universal firmness level.
Similarities
- Excellent responsiveness: Nolah’s proprietary foams respond nearly instantaneously to pressure, as do the Signature’s innerspring coils. This fast response helps people who toss and turn sleep with fewer interruptions.
- Great for side sleepers: Both beds have thick foam comfort layers that cradle pressure points, cushioning the hips and shoulders of side sleepers. For more options, check out the best mattresses for side sleepers.
- Minimal heat retention: Both mattresses facilitate generous airflow, whisking away body heat and keeping sleepers cool and dry.
Best for: people with back pain, combination sleepers, and soft and firm mattress fans. Best for: people with back pain, combination sleepers, and soft and firm mattress fans. Best for: people with back pain, combination sleepers, and soft and firm mattress fans.Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress
Material
Hybrid
Trial Period
120 nights
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Firmness
Multiple firmness options
Warranty
10-year warranty
Price Range
$$$$$
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress
Material
Hybrid
Warranty
10-year warranty
Firmness
Multiple firmness options
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Trial Period
120 nights
Price Range
$$$$$
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress
Material
Hybrid
Firmness
Multiple firmness options
Trial Period
120 nights
Warranty
10-year warranty
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Price Range
$$$$$
Who the Brooklyn Signature Mattress is Best For
Best For…
- People with back pain: The Signature’s three firmness options do an excellent job keeping the spine neutrally aligned in every sleeping position.
- Combination sleepers: The Signature’s springy coils and responsive polyfoams don’t make you feel stuck like you might on a bed with thick memory foam layers. Combination sleepers who toss and turn can move around easily on this bed. You can see more responsive mattresses on our list of best mattresses for combination sleepers.
- Soft and firm mattress fans: The Signature’s softest and firmest options are much softer and firmer than your average bed. These extremes suit people who like a cloud-like or ultra-firm feel.
May Not be Best For…
- People who like the memory foam “cradle”: The Signature mattress has conforming layers of foam, but there isn’t the dough-like cradle that beds with memory foam layers have.
- People who sit on the edges of their bed: The Signature doesn’t have the sturdiest edges. If you use the sides of your mattress to read, watch TV, or get ready in the morning, you might want something sturdier.
Read our full Brooklyn Signature Mattress Review to learn more!
Nolah Original 10" Mattress
Material
Foam
Trial Period
120 nights
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Firmness
Medium-firm: 6.5/10
Warranty
Lifetime warranty
Price Range
$$$$$
Nolah Original 10" Mattress
Material
Foam
Warranty
Lifetime warranty
Firmness
Medium-firm: 6.5/10
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Trial Period
120 nights
Price Range
$$$$$
Nolah Original 10" Mattress
Material
Foam
Firmness
Medium-firm: 6.5/10
Trial Period
120 nights
Warranty
Lifetime warranty
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Price Range
$$$$$
Who the Nolah Mattress is Best For
Best For…
- Side sleepers: The original Nolah mattress has a design made for side sleepers. Its foams remove pressure from the shoulders and hips, so side sleepers of every body weight (lightweight, average-weight, and heavyweight) are likely to find a comforting, balanced feel.
- Couples who share the bed: The Nolah’s all-foam build absorbs motion, so you won’t wake up every time your partner moves. And because the Nolah’s medium-firm feel works for most sleepers, both you and your partner are likely to find comfort.
- People with back pain: The Nolah mattress minimizes pressure and delivers adequate spinal support for back, side, and stomach sleepers weighing less than 230 lbs. This combination leads us to recommend the Nolah to people with back pain.
May Not be Best For…
- Plus-size stomach sleepers: The best mattresses for stomach sleepers keep the hips from dipping in too far. While the Nolah is sufficiently supportive for most stomach sleepers, those weighing more than 230 lbs may need something firmer.
- Those who like a springy feel: Even though the Nolah is very easy to move around on, it does not have the bouncy surface of an innerspring mattress.
Read our full Nolah Mattress Review to learn more!
Signature Mattress vs. Nolah Mattress Performance Differences
Firmness / Feel
Brooklyn Signature Performance By Sleeping Position:
| Body Type: | BACK SLEEPERS | STOMACH SLEEPERS | SIDE SLEEPERS |
| Lightweight (< 130 lbs): | 4 | 3 | 2 |
| Average weight (130 – 230 lbs): | 5 | 3 | 3 |
| Heavyweight (> 230 lbs): | 4 | 2 | 4 |
Nolah Performance By Sleeping Position:
| Body Type: | BACK SLEEPERS | STOMACH SLEEPERS | SIDE SLEEPERS |
| Lightweight (< 130 lbs): | 5 | 4 | 5 |
| Average weight (130 – 230 lbs): | 4 | 3 | 5 |
| Heavyweight (> 230 lbs): | 3 | 2 | 4 |
1 = Very poor, 2 = Not good, 3 = Fair, 4 = Good, 5 = Excellent
A mattress’s firmness is one of the most important aspects to consider when finding the right bed. At Mattress Nerd, we measure firmness on a 1 to 10 scale, with 1 being downy soft and 10 being rock-hard. Most side sleepers require a softer firmness for adequate pressure relief, while back and stomach sleepers usually prefer a medium-firm or firm feel that offers comfort and support.
The Nolah is a medium-firm mattress, falling at a 6/10 on the firmness scale. Because Nolah’s top layer contains a proprietary foam that excels at pressure relief, this firmness works for side, back, and stomach sleepers who like a bed with average support and softness. However, we don’t recommend the Nolah for most heavyweight people, especially stomach sleepers. The all-foam build and feel are a touch too soft for plus-size comfort and durability.
The Brooklyn Signature comes in three firmnesses—soft, medium, and firm. The soft registers as a 4/10, or medium-soft mattress, the medium a 6/10, or medium-firm bed, and the firm an 8/10, which is quite firm. This variability in plushness suits sleepers of every sleeping position and body size—although it may not provide sufficient firmness along the torso for heavyweight stomach sleepers.
Motion Isolation
Have you ever felt your sleeping partner moving on the other side of the bed? That wiggle is known as motion transfer, and it’s not something you want when trying to get a good night’s sleep. While both the Nolah and Signature beds do a good job minimizing motion transfer, the Nolah outperforms the Signature. This is because all-foam beds like the Nolah don’t have coils, the material responsible for most motion transfer in mattresses.
Edge Support
Sturdy edges provide a safe ledge for sitting and getting into and out of bed, and they allow couples to spread out without worrying about rolling off. When we tested the Nolah and Signature mattresses in our lab, neither of them wowed us with their edge support. Both are stable enough that you can sleep along the edges but not strong enough for sitting comfortably.
While neither mattress excels here, the Signature’s firm version has the sturdiest edges thanks to the firmer foam found along the surface.
Pressure Relief
Pressure relief ensures that areas that stick out—like the shoulders and hips—don’t experience too much pressure. By sinking at these sensitive pressure points, beds with good pressure-relieving properties help side sleepers and people with joint pain sleep better.
Both the Nolah and Brooklyn Signature have the pressure-relieving feel we look for when recommending mattresses to side sleepers. Between the two, the Signature’s soft option delivers the best pressure relief thanks to ultra-soft foams that cradle sensitive areas.
Spine Alignment
To find the best mattress to keep your spine aligned, you should consider your sleeping position and body weight. For example, side sleepers need a softer surface that contours to their curves, stomach sleepers need a firm surface that limits hip sinkage, and back sleepers need a balance between softness and support to keep the spine’s natural S-curve. Also, the more you weigh, the firmer your mattress should be to ensure a healthy spine.
The Brooklyn Signature mattress is the overall winner for spinal alignment. Its three firmness options mean that most people can find a fit for their body type and sleep position. However, both beds do a good job supporting the spine for sleepers weighing less than 230 lbs.
Related: Best Mattresses for Back Sleepers
Durability
The thicker and more supportive Brooklyn Bedding Signature is likely to last longer than the Nolah. The Signature firm model is the most durable thanks to higher density foams that resist body impressions and softening for longer than the Nolah or softer Signature models.
Temperature
The Brooklyn Signature sleeps cooler than the Nolah, although both beds facilitate airflow for cool sleep. The Signature’s 8” layer of breathable coils doesn’t trap heat and helps body heat move away from the mattress surface. If you frequently wake up with night sweats, consider looking into the best cooling mattresses.
Brooklyn Signature Mattress Construction
| Cover | Quilted Cover—1” (Soft, Medium) or 0.5” (Firm) |
| Comfort Layer | TitanFlex Comfort Foam—1.5” (Soft/Medium) or 1” (Firm) |
| Transitional Layer | VariFlex Transition Foam—1” (Soft/Medium) or 2” (Firm) |
| Support Layer | Ascension Pocketed Coils (8”) High-Density Flex Base Foam (0.25”) |
| Mattress Thickness | 12″ |
The Signature Hybrid contains three layers of comfort foam atop a supportive base layer of thick, responsive pocketed coils. The composition of the top foam layers differs based on which firmness you choose—soft, medium, or firm. Each model provides excellent pressure relief and spinal alignment thanks to the variable foam layers and individually encased coil system. Because the Signature has airy coils and no memory foam, it sleeps cooler than most beds.
Related: Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Comparison
Nolah Mattress Construction
| Cover | White TENCEL Cover |
| Comfort Layer | Nolah AirFoam (2”) |
| Transitional Layer | High-Resilience Foam (1”) |
| Support Layer | High-Density Base Foam (7”) |
| Mattress Thickness | 10″ |
Every layer of the all-foam Nolah mattress supports cool sleep, pressure relief, and ease of movement. The top layer of Nolah AirFoam contains microscopic air pockets that contour to the body’s unique curves, no matter your sleeping position. These air pockets and proprietary foam transition layer adapt quickly to movement so that you won’t feel stuck. In addition, the Nolah foam mattress isolates motion so couples can enjoy deeper sleep.
Sizing & Price Comparisons
| Mattress Size | Brooklyn Bedding Signature Price | Nolah Original Price |
| Twin | $599 | $649 |
| Twin XL | $749 | $799 |
| Full | $899 | $899 |
| Queen | $1,124 | $1,149 |
| King | $1,374 | $1,249 |
| California King | $1,374 | $1,249 |
For seasonal or holiday discounts, check out Brooklyn Bedding coupons and Nolah coupons.
Shipping and Returns for Brooklyn Bedding & Nolah
Brooklyn Bedding:
Brooklyn Bedding mattresses ship via FedEx for free to the 48 continental U.S. Customers in Canada, Alaska, and Hawaii pay a non-refundable shipping fee. Most beds arrive within five business days.
From the day you receive your new mattress, you have 120 nights to give it a test run. If you decide to return it, you can do so for a full refund after a 30-day waiting period. Brooklyn Bedding helps you find a local charity to donate the bed, after which you must provide proof of donation to receive a refund.
The Signature mattress comes with an industry-standard 10-year warranty. Mattress warranties cover defects like body indentations and crumbling or cracking foam layers. We recommend using a mattress protector as damage to the bed, such as spills or mold, may void the warranty.
Related: Brooklyn Bedding Warranty page
Nolah:
Nolah only ships to customers living in the contiguous U.S. Because Nolah makes its beds to order, shipping time takes longer than most companies. You should receive your new bed in five to ten business days.
Because Nolah is a foam mattress, it has an odor when you first unbox it. This off-gassing scent comes from tiny particles escaping as the foam expands. Rest assured that Nolah uses CertiPUR-US certified foams, so this odor is nothing to be concerned about. It typically fades in a day or two.
Nolah offers a similar trial period as Brooklyn Bedding. During the 120-night trial, you may return your Nolah for a full refund after a 30-day break-in period. Contact Nolah during this window for instructions on how to have the bed donated or recycled.
Nolah mattresses have a generous Lifetime warranty covering similar defects as the Brooklyn Bedding warranty, including impressions deeper than 1”.
More Brooklyn Bedding Mattresses
Eco-conscious consumers looking for a non-toxic mattress should consider the Bloom. The Bloom is a hybrid bed crafted from natural materials like latex, organic cotton, and Joma wool. Eco-conscious consumers looking for a non-toxic mattress should consider the Bloom. The Bloom is a hybrid bed crafted from natural materials like latex, organic cotton, and Joma wool. Eco-conscious consumers looking for a non-toxic mattress should consider the Bloom. The Bloom is a hybrid bed crafted from natural materials like latex, organic cotton, and Joma wool.Brooklyn Bedding Bloom Hybrid Mattress
Material
Hybrid
Trial Period
120 nights
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Firmness
Multiple firmness options
Warranty
10-year warranty
Price Range
$$$$$
Brooklyn Bedding Bloom Hybrid Mattress
Material
Hybrid
Warranty
10-year warranty
Firmness
Multiple firmness options
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Trial Period
120 nights
Price Range
$$$$$
Brooklyn Bedding Bloom Hybrid Mattress
Material
Hybrid
Firmness
Multiple firmness options
Trial Period
120 nights
Warranty
10-year warranty
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Price Range
$$$$$
See our full Brooklyn Bloom Mattress Review to learn more.
The Brooklyn Bedding Titan is a mattress built for those with heavyweight body types. It has a firm feel that's best suited to back and stomach sleepers. We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types: Financing options are available for this mattress. The Brooklyn Bedding Titan is a mattress built for those with heavyweight body types. It has a firm feel that's best suited to back and stomach sleepers. We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types: Financing options are available for this mattress. The Brooklyn Bedding Titan is a mattress built for those with heavyweight body types. It has a firm feel that's best suited to back and stomach sleepers. We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types: Financing options are available for this mattress.Titan Firm Hybrid
Material
Hybrid
Trial Period
120 nights
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Firmness
Medium-firm: 6/10
Warranty
10-year warranty
Price Range
$$$$$
Couples
This bed has great motion isolation so you will not feel your partner tossing and turning at night.
Back Pain
This bed is perfect for anyone suffering from back pain.
Back Sleeping
Ideal for heavyweight back sleepers.
Stomach Sleeping
Ideal for heavyweight stomach sleepers.
Financing Options
Titan Firm Hybrid
Material
Hybrid
Warranty
10-year warranty
Firmness
Medium-firm: 6/10
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Trial Period
120 nights
Price Range
$$$$$
Couples
This bed has great motion isolation so you will not feel your partner tossing and turning at night.
Back Pain
This bed is perfect for anyone suffering from back pain.
Back Sleeping
Ideal for heavyweight back sleepers.
Stomach Sleeping
Ideal for heavyweight stomach sleepers.
Financing Options
Titan Firm Hybrid
Material
Hybrid
Firmness
Medium-firm: 6/10
Trial Period
120 nights
Warranty
10-year warranty
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Price Range
$$$$$
Couples
This bed has great motion isolation so you will not feel your partner tossing and turning at night.
Back Pain
This bed is perfect for anyone suffering from back pain.
Back Sleeping
Ideal for heavyweight back sleepers.
Stomach Sleeping
Ideal for heavyweight stomach sleepers.
Financing Options
See our full Brooklyn Titan Mattress Review to learn more.
The Plank is a flippable foam mattress that's great for firm mattress fans. With a firm and extra-firm side, the Plank is one of the firmest foam beds available. The Plank is a flippable foam mattress that's great for firm mattress fans. With a firm and extra-firm side, the Plank is one of the firmest foam beds available. The Plank is a flippable foam mattress that's great for firm mattress fans. With a firm and extra-firm side, the Plank is one of the firmest foam beds available.Brooklyn Bedding Plank Mattress
Material
Foam
Trial Period
120 nights
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Firmness
Multiple firmness options
Warranty
10-year warranty
Price Range
$$$$$
Brooklyn Bedding Plank Mattress
Material
Foam
Warranty
10-year warranty
Firmness
Multiple firmness options
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Trial Period
120 nights
Price Range
$$$$$
Brooklyn Bedding Plank Mattress
Material
Foam
Firmness
Multiple firmness options
Trial Period
120 nights
Warranty
10-year warranty
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Price Range
$$$$$
More Nolah Mattresses
The Nolah Signature is a flippable foam mattress with a soft side and a firm side. It has the same responsive, breathable foams as the Original Nolah. The Nolah Signature is a flippable foam mattress with a soft side and a firm side. It has the same responsive, breathable foams as the Original Nolah. The Nolah Signature is a flippable foam mattress with a soft side and a firm side. It has the same responsive, breathable foams as the Original Nolah.Nolah Original 10" Mattress
Material
Foam
Trial Period
120 nights
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Firmness
Medium-firm: 6.5/10
Warranty
Lifetime warranty
Price Range
$$$$$
Nolah Original 10" Mattress
Material
Foam
Warranty
Lifetime warranty
Firmness
Medium-firm: 6.5/10
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Trial Period
120 nights
Price Range
$$$$$
Nolah Original 10" Mattress
Material
Foam
Firmness
Medium-firm: 6.5/10
Trial Period
120 nights
Warranty
Lifetime warranty
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Price Range
$$$$$
See our full Nolah Signature Mattress Review to learn more.
The Nolah Evolution is a luxury hybrid that has a medium firmness. With tri-zoned support coils, this is the best Nolah mattress for stomach sleepers and people with back pain. The Nolah Evolution is a luxury hybrid that has a medium firmness. With tri-zoned support coils, this is the best Nolah mattress for stomach sleepers and people with back pain. The Nolah Evolution is a luxury hybrid that has a medium firmness. With tri-zoned support coils, this is the best Nolah mattress for stomach sleepers and people with back pain.Nolah Signature 12" Mattress
Material
Foam
Trial Period
120 nights
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Firmness
Soft: 5/10
Warranty
Lifetime warranty
Price Range
$$$$$
Nolah Signature 12" Mattress
Material
Foam
Warranty
Lifetime warranty
Firmness
Soft: 5/10
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Trial Period
120 nights
Price Range
$$$$$
Nolah Signature 12" Mattress
Material
Foam
Firmness
Soft: 5/10
Trial Period
120 nights
Warranty
Lifetime warranty
Shipping Method
Free shipping
Price Range
$$$$$
See our full Nolah Evolution Mattress Review to learn more.
Haven’t made a decision yet? Check out these other comparisons:
- Brooklyn Bedding vs. Avocado
- Brooklyn Bedding vs. Casper
- Brooklyn Bedding vs. GhostBed
- Brooklyn Bedding vs. Helix
- Brooklyn Bedding vs. Layla
- Brooklyn Bedding vs. Leesa
- Brooklyn Bedding vs. Lull
- Brooklyn Bedding vs. Nectar
- Brooklyn Bedding vs. Nolah
- Brooklyn Bedding vs. Puffy
- Brooklyn Bedding vs. Purple
- Brooklyn Bedding vs. Saatva
- Brooklyn Bedding vs. Tuft & Needle
- Compare Brooklyn Bedding Mattresses
- Titan Mattress Review
- Brooklyn Bedding Spartan Mattress Review
- Brooklyn Bedding Bloom Mattress Review
- Brooklyn Bedding Sedona Mattress Review
- Brooklyn Bedding Bowery Hybrid Mattress Review
- Brooklyn Bedding Plank Mattress Review
- Nolah vs. Bear
- Nolah vs. GhostBed
- Nolah vs. Layla
- Nolah vs. Leesa
- Nolah vs. Nectar
- Nolah vs. Puffy
- Nolah vs. Purple
Our Final Take
The Brooklyn Bedding Signature’s three firmness options fit the preferences of people who like soft, medium, and firm beds. We recommend the Signature for hot sleepers, back sleepers, and people with joint pain. The all-foam Nolah is an excellent choice for couples and those who co-sleep, thanks to a universal firmness level and superb motion isolation.
