Saatva HD vs. WinkBed Plus Mattress Comparison
Written by Loren Bullock, Lead Mattress Tester
The Saatva HD and WinkBed Plus are two examples of beds that are specifically designed for heavyweight sleepers. Wondering how they compare? We used our testing methodology to break down how these mattresses stack up.
Saatva HD vs. WinkBed Plus Overview
The Saatva and WinkBed are both good for heavyweight sleepers. But the Saatva pulls ahead if you have back pain, while the WinkBed can’t be beat for stomach sleepers.
| Saatva is best for… | WinkBed is best for… |
| Combination sleepers | Stomach sleepers |
| Hot sleepers | Folks on a budget |
| Sleepers with back pain | Those who prefer a firm bed |
Who Should Choose the Saatva HD Mattress?
- Combination sleepers: If you toss and turn throughout the night, the Saatva HD is likely a good fit for you.
- Hot sleepers: The materials that Saatva used in the HD mattress are designed to keep you cool.
- Sleepers with back pain: The Saatva HD promotes proper spinal alignment to improve pain in your back.
Who Should Choose the WinkBed Plus Mattress?
- Stomach sleepers: If you sleep only on your stomach, the WinkBed is ideal for you.
- Folks on a budget: The WinkBed is about $1,200 cheaper than the Saatva.
- Those who prefer a firmer bed: WinkBed has a firmer feel when compared to the Saatva.
Video Comparison: Saatva HD vs. WinkBed Plus
Saatva HD vs. WinkBed Plus: Top Similarities
- Made for plus-size sleepers: First up, the obvious: both beds were designed with supporting heavy people as their top priority.
- Good for hot sleepers: Next, both of these beds have breathable layers that should keep hot sleepers cool.
- Warranty: Finally, both beds come with a Lifetime warranty.
Saatva HD vs. WinkBed Plus: Top Differences
- Policies: Saatva comes with free white glove delivery, mattress setup, and old mattress removal, and a 365-night sleep trial period. WinkBed only offers you a 120-night trial and you have to set the mattress up yourself.
- Returns: Returns are free with the WinkBed. The same is not true for Saatva: They charge a $99 processing fee.
- Motion isolation: Saatva is the better choice for couples who prioritize sound sleep because it helps keep motion on one side of the bed.
Saatva HD vs. WinkBed Plus: Firmness & Feel Differences
Now what you came here for: I’ll tell you how each mattress feels to sleep on.
What’s the Firmness Of the Saatva HD & WinkBed Plus Mattresses?
On our 1 to 10 firmness scale, we rated the Saatva HD at a 6/10, which is medium firm and the universal firmness level. The WinkBed Plus received an 8/10, which we consider to be firm. If you sleep with a lighter-weight partner, keep in mind that they may feel each bed as firmer than normal because they don’t sink as deep into the layers.
What Do the Saatva HD & WinkBed Plus Mattresses Feel Like?
When you lie down on Saatva, it offers an initial soft feel followed by a deep cushion. There is still an overall sensation of support thanks to the dense foams and coils inside. The WinkBed gives you more of that bouncy, cushioning sensation. You stay elevated enough to be supported by the firm layers, but the pillowtop cradles you.
What’s It Like to Sleep On the Saatva HD & WinkBed Plus Mattresses?
If you’re a combination sleeper—meaning you change positions throughout the night—both mattresses will support combo sleepers, but it may be easier to move on the Saatva HD because it contains naturally responsive latex foam. The WinkBed HD is an especially good mattress for stomach sleepers. It’s both comfortable and supportive thanks to the polyfoam, gel, and coils layered in the mattress.
Both beds will work well for heavyweight back and side sleepers because they’re pillowtop layers cushion and hug the lower back while the support layers keep the spine in line.
The Saatva HD vs. WinkBed Plus Mattresses By Body Type
Saatva Performance By Sleeping Position:
| Body Type: | BACK SLEEPERS | STOMACH SLEEPERS | SIDE SLEEPERS |
| Lightweight (< 130 lbs): | 5 | 5 | 3 |
| Average weight (130 – 230 lbs): | 5 | 4 | 4 |
| Heavyweight (> 230 lbs): | 5 | 3 | 5 |
WinkBed Performance By Sleeping Position:
| Body Type: | BACK SLEEPERS | STOMACH SLEEPERS | SIDE SLEEPERS |
| Lightweight (< 130 lbs): | 4 | 5 | 3 |
| Average weight (130 – 230 lbs): | 5 | 5 | 4 |
| Heavyweight (> 230 lbs): | 5 | 5 | 5 |
1 = Very poor, 2 = Not good, 3 = Fair, 4 = Good, 5 = Excellent
Heavyweight Sleepers (> 230 lbs)
The Saatva HD is a good fit for heavyweight back and side sleepers because of the dual cushioning and support. This bed also promotes correct spinal alignment and provides pressure relief, especially for side sleepers. The WinkBed Plus is a good fit for heavyweight sleepers in all three sleeping positions because it lifts all along your body.
Average-Weight Sleepers (130–230 lbs)
If you are an average-weight sleeper, the Saatva HD accommodates every sleeping position, but it should feel especially good for back sleepers. The WinkBed Plus may be too firm for average-weight side sleepers. But back or stomach sleepers who prefer a mattress that feels more firm could benefit from the WinkBed.
Lightweight Sleepers (< 130 lbs)
The Saatva HD will likely feel too firm for lightweight side sleepers. If you sleep on your side, you might feel pain at pressure points; check out our pressure maps to see what we mean. The HD should be a better fit for lightweight stomach and back sleepers because they should maintain proper spinal alignment.
The WinkBed Plus may feel too firm for lightweight back and side sleepers because you won’t be able to feel the “cradling” aspect you need. Lightweight stomach sleepers may be better suited for this bed.
Differences In Mattress Construction
Both WinkBed and Saatva have very similar mattress constructions, but the Saatva HD is thicker at 15.5” tall; the WinkBed Plus is a little shorter at 13.5”.
| Saatva HD Materials | WinkBed Plus Materials |
| Euro Pillow Top with Organic Cotton Cover | TENCEL Cover |
| Five-Zone Talalay Latex | Euro-Pillow Top with Gel-Infused Foam |
| Durable Memory Foam | Latex Foam |
| High-Density Support Foam | Individually Wrapped Pocketed Coils |
| Durable Coil Base | Base Layer Foam |
| High-Density Foam Encasement | |
Cover
On the Saatva HD, you’ll find a hand-tufted organic cotton cover and a 3” foam pillow top. The WinkBed Plus cover is made of a moisture-wicking material called TENCEL.
Comfort Layers
The Saatva HD’s comfort layer includes memory foam for extra pressure relief. The WinkBed Plus includes gel-infused polyfoam in the cover to add comfort and prevent body impressions over time.
Support Layers
The Saatva HD uses a layer of extremely durable 12.5-gauge recycled steel coils to provide support. The WinkBed Plus has a support layer made of 7” tall pocketed coils, which are individually wrapped to help with motion isolation.
Saatva HD vs. WinkBed Plus Pricing
| Size | Saatva Prices | WinkBed Prices |
| Twin | $ | $ |
| Twin XL | $ | $ |
| Full | $ | $ |
| Queen | $ | $ |
| King | $ | $ |
| California King | $ | $ |
For exclusive discounts on both beds see our Saatva mattress coupons and WinkBed mattress coupons.
Saatva HD vs. WinkBed Plus Mattress Performance Ratings & Differences
Temperature
In this category, we gave both the Saatva HD and the WinkBed Plus a 5/5. Both mattresses feature materials like naturally cool latex foam, breathable cotton, gel-infused foam, and coils that provide tons of airflow. For similar options for hot sleepers, check out the best cooling mattresses.
Motion Transfer
The best mattresses for couples typically feature great motion isolation. Motion isolation is a bed’s ability to stifle movement at the source (e.g.: your partner tossing and turning) and keep it from transferring across the mattress and waking you up. Those thick layers of foam paid off for Saatva: It easily beat the WinkBed when it came to isolating motion.
Edge Support
Motion isolation and edge support are two key factors in determining whether or not a mattress will work for folks who sleep in pairs. Both beds have great edge support, even for heavyweight sleepers; you should be able to sit or lie near the edge of the mattress without a problem. But of course, Saatva’s edge support is always unmatched.
Pressure Relief
People with hip, shoulder, or low back pain most likely want a mattress that keeps pressure from building up in these areas. In this category, both the Saatva HD and the WinkBed Plus get a 4/5. Both mattresses relieve pressure really well for average to heavyweight sleepers, but lightweight side sleepers do see pressure buildup in the hips and shoulders.
Pain Relief
The Saatva HD is highly recommended for people with back pain. It promotes good spinal alignment, which could help ease pain. The WinkBed Plus also provides lumbar support to help prevent back pain. For similar options, check out the best mattresses for back pain.
Durability
In this category, the Saatva HD gets a 5 and the WinkBed Plus gets a 5. Since both beds are specially designed for heavier individuals, they use materials that are especially strong and durable and will last for many years. You should replace your mattress every 10 years, and both mattresses should last at least that long.
Shipping, Returns, & Warranties
Saatva
The Saatva HD has free white glove delivery, which means a team of professionals will come to your home, set your new mattress up, and remove your old mattress for free. The shipping time is about nine to 21 days. The bed also includes a Lifetime warranty and a 365-night sleep trial.
WinkBed Plus
The WinkBed Plus comes with free shipping in the contiguous U.S., with a shipping time within seven to 10 business days. The WinkBed Plus is also covered by a limited Lifetime warranty and comes with a shorter 120-night sleep trial.
Other Models Available
Our Final Take
Both the Saatva HD and WinkBed Plus are good options for heavyweight sleepers, with remarkably similar features. But if you’re a stomach sleeper or on a budget, we recommend the WinkBed; if you are a senior or sleep with a partner, the Saatva is the winner.
Saatva & WinkBed FAQs
How much does the Saatva HD weigh?
The Saatva HD, in a Queen size, weighs 135 pounds. If you’re wondering how much weight the HD can hold, the Saatva website states the mattress can hold people weighing up to 500 pounds—meaning a Queen size holds up to 1000 pounds of weight. So, if both you and your partner are heavyweight sleepers, the HD should be able to support you.
What is a WinkBed Plus?
The WinkBed Plus is a hybrid mattress that’s made by the WinkBed brand that’s designed specifically for heavier people. The mattress is extra thick and durable. Unlike the regular WinkBed, it contains latex foam, which is more cooling and durable than memory foam. This mattress also includes cooling features that should help if you sleep hot.
Does the Saatva HD mattress sag?
All mattresses sag over time, but the Saatva HD should last at least 10 years before it begins to break down and sag. This mattress is made for heavyweight sleepers, so it’s extra durable. The strong materials used in the mattress give the HD an excellent durability score. The latex foam inside is more resistant to body impressions and indentations than memory foam and the coils are thicker and more supportive.
Loren Bullock
Mattress & Bedding Expert
About Author
Loren is the Lead Mattress Reviewer at Mattress Nerd. She has prioritized sleeping for as long as she can remember, rarely deviating from seven to nine hours each night. As an editor on Mattress Nerd and a Certified Sleep Science Coach, Loren aims to help people achieve optimal sleep health and pick the best sleep accessories for their needs. You can find her testing mattresses, exploring the best sleep hacks, and telling you about her findings on Mattress Nerd’s YouTube channel and on TikTok.
Combination Sleeper
