Saatva HD vs. WinkBed Plus Mattress Comparison

The Saatva HD and WinkBed Plus are two examples of beds that are specifically designed for heavyweight sleepers. Wondering how they compare? We used our testing methodology to break down how these mattresses stack up.

Saatva HD vs. WinkBed Plus Overview

The Saatva and WinkBed are both good for heavyweight sleepers. But the Saatva pulls ahead if you have back pain, while the WinkBed can’t be beat for stomach sleepers.

Saatva is best for…	WinkBed is best for…
Combination sleepers	Edge support
Hot sleepers	Stomach sleepers
Sleepers with back pain	Some back sleepers

Who Should Choose the Saatva HD Mattress?

• Combination sleepers. If you toss and turn throughout the night, the Saatva HD is likely a good fit for you.
• Hot sleepers. The materials that Saatva used in the HD mattress are designed to keep you cool.
• Sleepers with back pain. The Saatva HD promotes proper spinal alignment to improve pain in your back.

Who Should Choose the WinkBed Plus Mattress?

• Edge support. The edge support and durability of the WinkBed Plus make it a good fit for heavyweight sleepers.
• Stomach sleepers. If you sleep only on your stomach, the WinkBed is ideal for you.
• Some back sleepers. Since the WinkBed Plus scored a 7.5/10 on our firmness scale, it’s good for back sleepers who like a firm, dense feel.

Saatva HD vs. WinkBed Plus: Top Similarities 

• Firmness. Both mattresses are ranked at or near a 7/10 on our 1-10 firmness scale.
• Cooling abilities. The Saatva HD and WinkBed Plus both use breathable materials so you won’t sleep hot.

Saatva HD vs. WinkBed Plus: Top Differences 

• Shipping. While the Saatva takes anywhere from 9-21 days to ship, you’ll receive your WinkBed in just 7-10 business days.
• Trial period. The Saatva HD comes with a full 365-night sleep trial. But the WinkBed Plus only offers a 120-night trial.

Saatva HD vs. WinkBed Plus: Firmness & Feel Differences

Both the Saatva HD and WinkBed are considered medium-firm.

What’s the Firmness Of the Saatva HD & WinkBed Plus Mattresses? 

On our 1 to 10 firmness scale, we rated the Saatva HD at a 7/10. The WinkBed Plus receives a 7.5/10.

What Do the Saatva HD & WinkBed Plus Mattresses Feel Like?

Average-weight sleepers (130 to 230 lbs) will likely feel comfortable and supported on the Saatva HD. But if you weigh over 230 lbs, the bed will feel softer.

The WinkBed Plus will also feel medium-firm. As a general rule of thumb, the lighter you are, the more firm a bed will feel. But the heavier you are, the softer a bed will feel.

What’s It Like to Sleep On the Saatva HD & WinkBed Plus Mattresses?

If you’re a combination sleeper — meaning you change positions throughout the night — the support and contouring offered by the Saatva HD should be a good fit. And since the bed was specifically designed for heavyweight sleepers, it will be ideal for anyone weighing over 230 lbs.

The WinkBed HD is an especially good fit for stomach sleepers. It’s both comfortable and supportive thanks to the polyfoam, gel, and coils layered in the mattress.

The Saatva HD vs. WinkBed Plus Mattresses By Body Type

Saatva Performance By Sleeping Position:

Body Type:	BACK SLEEPERS	STOMACH SLEEPERS	SIDE SLEEPERS
Lightweight (< 130 lbs):	3	4	1
Average weight (130 – 230 lbs):	4	4	2
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs):	5	5	4

WinkBed Performance By Sleeping Position:

Body Type:	BACK SLEEPERS	STOMACH SLEEPERS	SIDE SLEEPERS
Lightweight (< 130 lbs):	2	3	1
Average weight (130 – 230 lbs):	3	4	2
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs):	5	5	4

1 = Very poor, 2 = Not good, 3 = Fair, 4 = Good, 5 = Excellent

Average-Weight Sleepers (130–230 lbs)

If you are an average-weight back or stomach sleeper, the Saatva HD will probably feel too firm for you. Side sleepers tend to experience pain at their pressure points when sleeping on this bed. We also don’t necessarily recommend the Saatva HD for average-weight combination sleepers because it is too firm.

The WinkBed Plus is too firm for average-weight side sleepers. But back or stomach sleepers who prefer a mattress that feels more firm could benefit from the WinkBed. This bed is also a good fit for average-weight combination sleepers who mostly sleep on their stomach and back.

Heavyweight Sleepers (> 230 lbs)

The Saatva HD is a good fit for heavyweight back and stomach sleepers because of the dual cushioning and support. This bed also promotes correct spinal alignment and provides pressure relief for side sleepers. And we also recommend the HD for heavyweight combination sleepers since it was specifically made for larger sleepers. 

The WinkBed Plus is a good fit for heavyweight back sleepers and stomach sleepers because it lifts all along your body. However, heavyweight side sleepers might think this bed is a little too firm. The WinkBed is good for heavyweight combination sleepers who primarily sleep on their back or stomach.

Lightweight Sleepers (< 130 lbs)

The Saatva HD will likely feel too firm for lightweight stomach and back sleepers. If you sleep on your side, you might feel pain at pressure points. The HD is also not a good fit for lightweight combination sleepers.

The WinkBed Plus will probably feel too firm for lightweight back and side sleepers because you won’t be able to feel the “cradling” aspect you need. Lightweight stomach and combination sleepers may be better suited for this bed, but it’s still not ideal.

Differences In Mattress Construction 

The Saatva HD is 15.5” tall. The WinkBed Plus is a little shorter at 13.5” tall.

Saatva HD Materials	WinkBed Plus Materials
Euro Pillow Top with Organic Cotton Cover	TENCEL Cover
Five-Zone Talalay Latex	Euro-Pillow Top with Gel-Infused Foam
Durable Memory Foam	Latex Foam
High-Density Support Foam	Individually Wrapped Pocketed Coils
Durable Coil Base	Base Layer Foam
High-Density Foam Encasement

Cover

On the Saatva HD, you’ll find a hand-tufted organic cotton cover and a 3” foam pillow top. The WinkBed Plus cover is made of a moisture-wicking material called TENCEL.

Comfort Layers

The Saatva HD’s comfort layer includes memory foam for extra pressure relief. The WinkBed Plus includes gel-infused polyfoam in the cover to add comfort and prevent body impressions over time.

Support Layers

The Saatva HD uses a layer of extremely durable 12.5-gauge recycled steel coils to provide support. The WinkBed Plus has a support layer made of 7” tall pocketed coils, which are individually wrapped to help with motion isolation.

Saatva HD vs. WinkBed Plus Pricing

Size	Saatva Prices	WinkBed Prices
Twin	$1795.00	$1349.00
Twin XL	$1995.00	$1449.00
Full	$2595.00	$1699.00
Queen	$3195.00	$1999.00
King	$3695.00	$2199.00
California King	$3695.00	$2199.00

For exclusive discounts on both beds see our Saatva mattress coupons and WinkBed mattress coupons.

Saatva HD vs. WinkBed Plus Mattress Performance Ratings & Differences

Temperature

In this category, the Saatva HD gets a 5 and the WinkBed Plus gets a 4. In the Saatva, materials like latex and cotton promote breathability. The WinkBed Plus will also enable you to sleep either temperature neutral or a little cool.

Motion Transfer

In this category, the Saatva HD gets a 3 and the WinkBed Plus gets a 3. Neither bed has great motion isolation. You’ll likely feel a little movement from any partner or pet that sleeps with you.

Edge Support 

In this category, the Saatva HD gets a 5 and the WinkBed Plus gets a 5. Both beds have great edge support, even for heavyweight sleepers; you should be able to sit or lie near the edge of the mattress without a problem.

Pressure Relief 

In this category, the Saatva HD gets a 4 and the WinkBed Plus gets a 3. The Saatva does somewhat of a better job in this category for side sleepers. But we don’t recommend either bed for someone with joint pain or especially sensitive pressure points.

Pain Relief 

The Saatva HD comes highly recommended for people with back pain. It promotes good spinal alignment, which could help ease pain. The WinkBed Plus may also provide support to help prevent back pain.

Durability

In this category, the Saatva HD gets a 5 and the WinkBed Plus gets a 5. Since both beds are specially designed for heavier individuals, they use materials that are especially strong and durable and will last for many years.

Shipping, Returns, & Warranties 

Saatva 

The Saatva HD has free white glove delivery. The shipping time is 9 to 21 days. The bed also includes a lifetime warranty and a 365-night sleep trial.

WinkBed Plus

The WinkBed Plus comes with free shipping in the contiguous U.S., with a shipping time within 7-10 business days. The WinkBed Plus is covered by a Limited Lifetime Warranty. It comes with a 120-night sleep trial.

Other Models Available

Our Final Take

Both the Saatva HD and WinkBed Plus are good options for heavyweight sleepers, with remarkably similar features. But if you’re a stomach sleeper, we recommend the WinkBed — and for pain relief, the Saatva is the winner.

Saatva & WinkBed FAQs

How much does the Saatva HD weigh?

The Saatva HD in a queen size weighs 135 lbs. If you’re wondering how much weight the HD can hold, the Saatva website states the mattress can hold people weighing up to 500 lbs. This mattress is a great option for heavier folks.

What is a WinkBed Plus?

The WinkBed Plus is a hybrid mattress that’s made by the WinkBed brand and designed specifically for heavier people. The mattress is extra thick and durable, and it also includes cooling features that will help if you sleep hot.

Does the Saatva HD mattress sag?

The Saatva HD should not sag. This mattress is made for heavyweight sleepers, so it’s extra durable. The strong materials used in the mattress give the HD an excellent durability score — it should last you for many years of good sleep.