Beautyrest 2017 Comparison Guide

As you may have noticed, it’s difficult to comparison shop for mattresses between retailers because they often have different names for what seems to be the same exact mattress. Or, the retailer will claim their mattress is an exclusive, or their model has some feature that nobody else has that makes it different. How then will you take advantage of the price match guarantees that so many places offer? We’re here to help!

Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

Retail mattress stores often make it difficult to comparison shop mattresses. Each retailer will have a different name for the same (or almost the same) product. Furthermore, not every store lists detailed specs about whats in their mattresses, so it can be even more confusing. Sometimes, a mattress selling for about $1,000 at one store is going for over $2,000 at another store.

To help counter this, I’ve put together these two comparison charts for Simmons Beautyrest.

Have you considered an online brand?  Here are some of our favorites, or if you’d prefer scroll down to view the comparison chart.

Editors' Picks

Bang for the Buck

Leesa

Best Sleep Quality

Sapira

Our Top 10

The Quiz

Note: This chart is for the models that came out in 2017. Click here for my updated guide for 2018

Beautyrest has several different lineups. The “Silver” lineup is the entry level Beautyrest line. They have regular innerspring mattresses and “hybrid” mattresses which have a flatter top and thinner quilt layer, putting you closer to the foam layer. Older model years used to call this level “Classic” or “Recharge.”

There is also the “Platinum” level, which is their mid-range to higher end mattresses. These used to be called “World Class” in previous model years. These also come in regular innerspring models and hybrid models.

The two comparison charts below will help you compare those models at various retailers.

Beautyrest Silver

LineupOfficial NameUS MattressAmazonMacy'sSears
Silver (Level 1)
Tidewater PlushAdda PlushBeautyrest 500 PlushCove Point-
Open Seas Extra FirmKenosha Place Extra FirmBeautyrest 600 Extra Firm-Wavecrest Firm
Open Seas Luxury FirmKenosha Place Luxury FirmBeautyrest 600 Luxury FirmGolden Gate Luxury FirmBlue Springs Luxury Firm
Open Seas PlushKenosha Place PlushBeautyrest 600 Plush Golden Gate PlushBlue Springs Plush
Open Seas Luxury Firm PillowtopKenosha Place Luxury Firm PillowtopBeautyrest 700 Luxury FirmGolden Gate Luxury Firm PillowtopNavy Pier Luxury Firm Pillowtop
Open Seas Plush PillowtopKenosha Place Plush PillowtopBeautyrest 700 PlushGolden Gate Plush PillowtopNavy Pier Plush Pillowtop
Silver (Level 2)Charcoal Coast Extra FirmLydia Manor Extra FirmBeautyrest 800 Extra FirmWaterscape Extra FirmGrays Reef Extra Firm
Charcoal Coast Luxury FirmLydia Manor Luxury FirmBeautyrest 800 Luxury FirmWaterscape Luxury FirmGrays Reef Luxury Firm
Charcoal Coast PlushLydia Manor PlushBeautyrest 800 PlushWaterscape PlushGrays Reef Plush
Charcoal Coast Luxury Firm PillowtopLydia Manor Luxury Firm PillowtopBeautyrest 900 Luxury Firm PillowtopWaterscape Luxury Firm PillowtopHigh Tide Luxury Firm Pillowtop
Charcoal Coast Plush PillowtopLydia Manor Plush PillowtopBeautyrest 900 Plush PillowtopWaterscape Plush PillowtopHigh Tide Plush Pillowtop
Silver HybridBeachwood Luxury FirmSondra Luxury FirmBeautyrest Hybrid 1000 Luxury Firm-Palmer Island Luxury Firm
Austin Reef PlushSybel PlushBeautyrest Hybrid 2000 Plush-Bailey's Harbor Plush
Cascade Mist FirmTracy FirmBeautyrest Hybrid 3000 Firm -Grand Isle Firm
Harbour Beach Luxury FirmVivian Luxury FirmBeautyrest Hybrid 4000 Luxury Firm--
Harbour Beach Ultra PlushVivian Ultimate PlushBeautyrest Hybrid 4000 Ultimate Plush-Majestic Sound Ultimate Plush

Beautyrest Platinum

LineupOfficial NameUS MattressAmazonSears
PlatinumAmberlyn Extra FirmSunfire extra firmBadger Extra FirmKimi Extra Firm
Brittany FirmSunland FirmFoxtail FirmMackenzie Ultra Firm
Brittany Luxury FirmToffee Luxury FirmFoxtail Luxury Firm-
Brittany PlushSunny Day PlushFoxtail Plush-
Gabriella Luxury Firm PillowtopTripp Luxury Firm PillowtopLedger Luxury Firm PillowtopHailey Luxury Firm
Gabriella Plush PillowtopTreasure Plush PillowtopLedger Plush PillowtopHailey Plush Pillowtop
Katherine Luxury Firm PillowtopTulsa Luxury Firm PillowtopMontego Luxury Firm PillowtopChloe Luxury Firm Pillowtop
Katherine Plush PillowtopTrixie Plush PillowtopMontego Plush Pillowtop-
Platinum HybridAustin Luxury FirmTyson Luxury FirmQuentin Luxury FirmAdderly Firm
Bryson PlushVanity PlushSamson plush-
Maddie Luxury FirmWaltz Luxury FirmArmand Luxury FirmFrances Luxury Firm
Quinn Ultra PlushWarrior Ultra PlushScotty Ultimate PlushDelilah Plush

A few notes:

  • The mattresses might not be identical, but they will be close. Some retailers will add a small “exclusive” feature which is generally cosmetic or minor to make it technically a different mattress
  • Mattress Firm has a lot of exclusives in the Beautyrest brand. See my article on comparison shopping at Mattress Firm for suggestions.
  • Macy’s doesn’t have the Platinum lineup. They still have ones they’re calling “World Class.” Their World Class models are similar to the Platinum ones, but have enough differences that I wasn’t comfortable putting them in the chart
  • When comparing prices, make sure you’re comparing apples to apples. Make sure that you’re comparing the same size, whether or not it has a boxspring, how much delivery is, etc.
  • If comparison shopping is too stressful, consider getting a Tomorrow Sleep, which is by the makers of Beautyrest. It’s a direct to consumer mattress by Simmons (technically Serta Simmons Bedding) with a free return policy. Read my Tomorrow Sleep review here.

If you see the mattress at a retailer not listed above, go to my Comparison Shopping request form and email me the details, and I’ll look it up for you!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Comments (249)

  1. Hi i have aa simmons beautyres cresccendo wagner in king size bought in 2012 had great sleep in this model but unfortunately it is starting to sag which model could be at least same or better in this year sept 2018 thank you for advice sleep is really essential !

  2. What beautyrest bed is most like the Heavenly Bed found at the Westin? Trying to avoid the large price tag on the heavenly bed. Thank you

  3. I am trying to find beauty rest recharge by Simmons hospitality. Had the best nights sleep at a holiday inn and took picture of their mattress tag. Can you tell me where I can find this mattress?

  4. What would be a comparable current model to theSimmons Beautyrest Do Not Disturb Majesty Mattress and Box Springs. It was purchased in 2001. We love the firmness! Thanks

  5. I went to Mattress Firm and saw a McFarland Firm Queen. Do you know if there are other names for this same mattress?

    Thank you!

  6. I went to Raymour and Flannigan and they had a mattress called the Silver Harper Extra firm. Is that their version of the Beautyrest extra firm 800 from Amazon?

    • First, I am an affiliate for Amazon, so my answer may be biased, but I wouldn’t be an affiliate for Amazon if I didn’t think it was safe. To say that Amazon is a large reputable company is an understatement. They’re famous for their customer service, so you should be fine.

  7. I am considering purchasing a clearance mattress that’s been on the floor “a couple of years”. It’s a Simmons Beautyrest Platinum Royal Star Pillowtop, I think. Salesman said it originally a $3,000 and now it’s $900. Does that sound like a deal, or a rip-off? Thanks

  8. Hello,
    My given a Simmons Beautyrest Pure Encouraging ST, full size. It is extremely comfortable. Is there any you would know the time period it was manufactured in original MSRP price? THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

  9. Hello Mattress Nerd,

    I am looking to get a new mattress similar to my old one which was a Beautyrest Anniversary purchased in March 2011. What is a comparable model today?

    Thanks,
    Pete

  10. Hello! Is there really a difference in feel between the beautyrest silver plush pillow top level 1 and level 2? I ordered level 2 but they accidentally brought level 1. Not sure if I should just keep it and skip the hassle. I do like it.

  11. Hello, I wonder if you can help me comparing the Beautyrest Platinum Holloway Extra Firm from MattressFirm to the Macy’s Beautyrest Platinum Chestnut Hill 12.5″ Extra Firm and the Beautyrest Platinum Spring Grove 13-inch Extra Firm on Overstock. The Macy’s one is by far the most expensive, but I’m not sure if its superior to the other two anyways, since it also says it has a “titanium mesh for 15% more lumbar support”. I got the MattressFirm guy to lower the King price to $500 below the Macy’s price, but my wife says she can feel the Macy’s one is better, and I seem to feel some difference as well and if there is anything to the titanium mesh for longevity and support and prevention of sagging…is there really anything to it?

    • There’s nothing to the titanium. Sticking a thin piece of metal under foam does not mean the foam won’t lose its resilience over time. That’s just a property of the foam.

  12. We bought a Beauty Rest Recharge St Caroline Luxery Firm mattress from Sears in 2016. We want to buy another one from Sears with their big sale but they have discontinued that model name. Do you know what they call that particular mattress now?
    Thanks, Dean Stone

  13. We bought a queen beautyrest Florence in 2007 and love it. Now we would like to upgrade to a king and just purchase the same mattress but of course they do not sell it anymore. Do you know of a comparable mattress we can focus on? Possibly a comparable one that is not as expensive. Thanks for your help.

  14. awesome man, you are genius and really helpful soul.
    I am sure you are also burdened and intimidated by the thought of buying right and expensive mattress.

    Thanks a lot for your help

  15. Raymour and Flanigan have the Beautyrest Silver “Florence” Luxury firm Pillow top, is it the same quality as the “Golden gate” Macy’s has??

  16. I live in Canada. I bought a Simmons Beautyrest Black -way too firm -my body was aching! Now I have Beautyrest Hotel 6 which is their ultra plush but is still too firm for me. What to do? I used to have a Searsopedic which aas nice & soft

  17. To Shan K.
    I like that type too. The Platinum Hybrids are a very similar feel. The Alcove is supposedly the medium firmness but feels soft to me. So maybe Luxury firm or plush would be close to Alcove. And they are last years models-can get a king for about $1575.

  18. I was interested in the Beautyrest Gladney or Alcove, but then I tried the Sears Beautyrest Delilah Plush and it felt so much “richer”. Is the construction better than the first 2 I mentioned? In the chart you say that the Delilah Plush is equal to the Quinn Ultra Plush, not the Bryson Plush. Us Mattress has an article that says Delilah equal to the Vanity/Bryson plush and I just want to clarify before I do an online order. Also, do you think I should wait for the Beautyrest Emerald falls-will it be “better” than the Delilah? I can’t find the exact foam specs on Delilah but its available on the other models.

    • The Delilah isn’t the same as either the Quinn or the Bryson. I had to make a judgment call about which is was most similar to. If you look at the weight of the mattress, it’s heavier than either, and it uses a layer of latex.

      So to the best of my knowledge, the Delilah was exclusive to Sears, and I figured the most comparable one in quality was the Quinn. They were not exact matches.

      The Emerald Falls has changed some things, but it doesn’t look clearly better or worse. I’m sure they made some minor upgrades, but it isn’t likely worth going crazy over.

  19. Love your site, very informative ( I hate mattress buying). I recently went to a store called Bedderest in Maine, that had a Simmons Beautyrest Silver model which on label says North Cape Luxury Firm Pillow Top. I coul dnot find anything on line regarding what this mattress is compared to or whether it isa newer or older version. Any info appreciated. Thanks

  20. I now have a Simmons Beautyrest Grand Luxe Pillow Top 24296 R mattress. I am looking for the same or one that is very close to it.

  21. I am looking for an equivalent mattress to the Beautyrest black ALCOVE sold at mattress firm. Any idea what would be the equivalent mattress at US-mattress or amazon for this one?

  22. Any idea what the return policy is like for mattress purchases from Amazon? I’m looking at the Beautyrest Plush Foxtail as compared to the SunnyDay from US Mattress. How do you feel about this comparison?

By continuing to browse or by clicking “OK” you agree to the storing of first- and third-party cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Privacy Policy.

OK