Beautyrest 2017 Comparison Guide

Disclosure: This site receives a payment from US Mattress, Sears, Macy’s, or Amazon when you purchase a product using any links to that company in this article

Retail mattress stores often make it difficult to comparison shop mattresses. Each retailer will have a different name for the same (or almost the same) product. Furthermore, not every store lists detailed specs about whats in their mattresses, so it can be even more confusing. Sometimes, a mattress selling for about $1,000 at one store is going for over $2,000 at another store.

To help counter this, I’ve put together these two comparison charts for Simmons Beautyrest.

Beautyrest has several different lineups. The “Silver” lineup is the entry level Beautyrest line. They have regular innerspring mattresses and “hybrid” mattresses which have a flatter top and thinner quilt layer, putting you closer to the foam layer. Older model years used to call this level “Classic” or “Recharge.”

There is also the “Platinum” level, which is their mid-range to higher end mattresses. These used to be called “World Class” in previous model years. These also come in regular innerspring models and hybrid models.

The two comparison charts below will help you compare those models at various retailers.

Beautyrest Silver

LineupOfficial NameUS MattressAmazonSearsMacy's
Silver (Level 1)
Tidewater PlushAdda PlushBeautyrest 500 Plush-Cove Point
Open Seas Extra FirmKenosha Place Extra FirmBeautyrest 600 Extra FirmWavecrest Firm-
Open Seas Luxury FirmKenosha Place Luxury FirmBeautyrest 600 Luxury FirmBlue Springs Luxury FirmGolden Gate Luxury Firm
Open Seas PlushKenosha Place PlushBeautyrest 600 Plush Blue Springs PlushGolden Gate Plush
Open Seas Luxury Firm PillowtopKenosha Place Luxury Firm PillowtopBeautyrest 700 Luxury FirmNavy Pier Luxury Firm PillowtopGolden Gate Luxury Firm Pillowtop
Open Seas Plush PillowtopKenosha Place Plush PillowtopBeautyrest 700 PlushNavy Pier Plush PillowtopGolden Gate Plush Pillowtop
Silver (Level 2)Charcoal Coast Extra FirmLydia Manor Extra FirmBeautyrest 800 Extra FirmGrays Reef Extra FirmWaterscape Extra Firm
Charcoal Coast Luxury FirmLydia Manor Luxury FirmBeautyrest 800 Luxury FirmGrays Reef Luxury FirmWaterscape Luxury Firm
Charcoal Coast PlushLydia Manor PlushBeautyrest 800 PlushGrays Reef PlushWaterscape Plush
Charcoal Coast Luxury Firm PillowtopLydia Manor Luxury Firm PillowtopBeautyrest 900 Luxury Firm PillowtopHigh Tide Luxury Firm PillowtopWaterscape Luxury Firm Pillowtop
Charcoal Coast Plush PillowtopLydia Manor Plush PillowtopBeautyrest 900 Plush PillowtopHigh Tide Plush PillowtopWaterscape Plush Pillowtop
Silver HybridBeachwood Luxury FirmSondra Luxury FirmBeautyrest Hybrid 1000 Luxury FirmPalmer Island Luxury Firm-
Austin Reef PlushSybel PlushBeautyrest Hybrid 2000 PlushBailey's Harbor Plush-
Cascade Mist FirmTracy FirmBeautyrest Hybrid 3000 Firm Grand Isle Firm-
Harbour Beach Luxury FirmVivian Luxury FirmBeautyrest Hybrid 4000 Luxury Firm--
Harbour Beach Ultra PlushVivian Ultimate PlushBeautyrest Hybrid 4000 Ultimate PlushMajestic Sound Ultimate Plush-

Beautyrest Platinum

LineupOfficial NameUS MattressSearsAmazon
PlatinumAmberlyn Extra FirmSunfire extra firmKimi Extra FirmBadger Extra Firm
Brittany FirmSunland FirmMackenzie Ultra FirmFoxtail Firm
Brittany Luxury FirmToffee Luxury Firm-Foxtail Luxury Firm
Brittany PlushSunny Day Plush-Foxtail Plush
Gabriella Luxury Firm PillowtopTripp Luxury Firm PillowtopHailey Luxury FirmLedger Luxury Firm Pillowtop
Gabriella Plush PillowtopTreasure Plush PillowtopHailey Plush PillowtopLedger Plush Pillowtop
Katherine Luxury Firm PillowtopTulsa Luxury Firm PillowtopChloe Luxury Firm PillowtopMontego Luxury Firm Pillowtop
Katherine Plush PillowtopTrixie Plush Pillowtop-Montego Plush Pillowtop
Platinum HybridAustin Luxury FirmTyson Luxury FirmAdderly FirmQuentin Luxury Firm
Bryson PlushVanity Plush-Samson plush
Maddie Luxury FirmWaltz Luxury FirmFrances Luxury FirmArmand Luxury Firm
Quinn Ultra PlushWarrior Ultra PlushDelilah PlushScotty Ultimate Plush

A few notes:

  • The mattresses might not be identical, but they will be close. Some retailers will add a small “exclusive” feature which is generally cosmetic or minor to make it technically a different mattress
  • Macy’s doesn’t have the Platinum lineup. They still have ones they’re calling “World Class.” Their World Class models are similar to the Platinum ones, but have enough differences that I wasn’t comfortable putting them in the chart
  • When comparing prices, make sure you’re comparing apples to apples. Make sure that you’re comparing the same size, whether or not it has a boxspring, how much delivery is, etc.

If you see the mattress at a retailer not listed above, go to my Comparison Shopping request form and email me the details, and I’ll look it up for you!

Disclosure: This site receives a payment from US Mattress, Sears, Macy’s, or Amazon when you purchase a product using any links to that company in this article

Questions & Comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

MattressNerd Says

July 20, 2017 at 12:00 pm

I believe the Keaton is new, it's just using the same name as the old model. It's somewhat similar to the Platinum models, but there are a few differences in the comfort layers.

guido Says

July 20, 2017 at 11:18 am

I went to macy's yesterday and really loved the keaton world class luxury firm mattress. But from here I understand that it's an old mattress. What's the equivalent of it in the new collection. Also, how bad can it be to buy a previous model, if they are still selling it? are those models that people returned or they are brand new?? your website is very helpful. thanks!!

Mary Says

July 17, 2017 at 10:31 pm

Is the US Mattress Simmons Beautyrest Silver Hybrid Sybel III Plush the same as the Costco Simmons Beautyrest Silver Hybrid Salina Plush? Both are 13.5". https://www.costco.com/Simmons-Beautyrest-Salina-Silver-Hybrid-Plush-King-Mattress-Only.product.100361553.html http://www.us-mattress.com/simmons-beautyrest-silver-hybrid-sybel-iii-plush-mattress-king.html

MAts Says

July 17, 2017 at 12:08 pm

Macy’s doesn’t have the Platinum lineup. They still have ones they’re calling “World Class.” Their World Class models are similar to the Platinum ones, but have enough differences that I wasn’t comfortable putting them in the chart What are the major differences ? Or Which one is better the Macy's World Class or the Platinum models at other shops ?

MattressNerd Says

July 15, 2017 at 3:27 pm

Vanderbilt is the name of their entire mattress collection.

Sheri Barnett Says

July 15, 2017 at 7:42 am

Question: Macy's delivered a Beautyrest Silver Vanderbilt. My order slip and the one I tried in the store is Waterscape LXFPT. Are they the same? Or should I complain?

MattressNerd Says

July 12, 2017 at 7:07 am

Nothing will be exactly the same, since a lot has changed in 15 years. A model in the Platinum line will be the "spiritual successor," but it's not going to be the same mattress.

Tom Says

July 11, 2017 at 4:25 pm

We have a 15 year old Beautyrest World Class Serenity Pillowtop and I'm trying to tell if it's a Plush or Firm. Looking for a similar model, can you suggest a similar model from today's line. Much appreciated!

MattressNerd Says

July 10, 2017 at 7:18 am

The height is not a difference. 14.5 rounds up to 15. For the weight, I wonder if Sears made some kind of error in entering the information. They claim that their lower end mattress is heavier than their higher end one, which doesn't make sense, since the higher end one has more stuff in it. Looking at the specs, none of them look different, so I have no idea why there is a difference in weight. It would be interesting to call up Beautyrest and see what their official weights for those mattresses are.

MattressNerd Says

July 10, 2017 at 7:10 am

Look at my 2015 comparison chart for those older models.

Joann Says

July 7, 2017 at 3:45 pm

Hello I am researching the Beautyrest Platinum Adderly and noticed the comparable Tyson has different specs. It is half and inch shorter in height and weighs about 40lbs less. Does this seem like a big difference too you? I loved the Adderly. But the Tyson is $500 less. Thanks!

Linda Says

July 7, 2017 at 8:38 am

I am looking at the Simmions B. R Platium Lux firm pillow top Hailey. can you tell me what it comparison to for other stores.

Jennifer Says

July 6, 2017 at 12:38 pm

Thanks for your reply! Any options we can try at Mattress Firm that would compare to Phillipsburg II Extra & Luxury Firm models? Bridgewater maybe?

MattressNerd Says

July 6, 2017 at 6:50 am

The extra firm will be similar. The Mackenzie will be a little firmer than the luxury firm Phillipsburg.

Jennifer Says

July 5, 2017 at 12:47 pm

I'm interested in Phillipsburg II, particularly the Extra Firm and Luxury Firm models. There's no Macy's in my area, but we do have Sears. Can I test Sear's Kimi and Mackenzie in store to get a feel for the Phillipsburg II models? I know they are different year models, but are they similar enough for testing purposes before buying Phillipsburg?

Alda Santoro Says

July 5, 2017 at 10:22 am

beautyrest waterscape queen size bed mattress box springs.. plush.. thoughts?

MattressNerd Says

July 3, 2017 at 4:17 pm

That's a lower end mattress. It's not a Simmons Beautyrest, for example. It's a "BeautySleep," which is their models more suited to guest rooms or temporary use. Not too many stores sell BeautySleep (at least nowhere near as many as Beautyrest). Here it is on US Mattress at least: Star Fall Plush Pillowtop However, I'd recommend getting one of the lower end Beautyrests. It will be a similar price, but a much better mattress.

Shanna Says

July 3, 2017 at 2:30 pm

Do you have a comparison for the Grays Harbor Luxury Pillowtop Mattress Set being sold on HSN.com?

MattressNerd Says

July 3, 2017 at 12:36 pm

Nothing is an exact match. Only Mattress Firm sells the Legend lineup. However, it's fairly similar to the Amberlyn Extra Firm and the ones in that row on the chart. It's also pretty similar in quality and feel to the Beautyrest Black Calista Extra Firm.

MattressNerd Says

July 3, 2017 at 12:35 pm

No national retailer will have an exact match. It is going to be similar to the Beachwood Luxury Firm, but it adds in the micro-coil layer in the center third found in the "Level 2" non-hybrid Silvers. Or put another way, it's like the Hybrid version of the Charcoal Coast Luxury Firm.

MattressNerd Says

July 3, 2017 at 9:33 am

They're similar, but different model years.

Mik Says

July 2, 2017 at 10:03 pm

Are the Macy's beautyrest Keaton and the Sears beautyrest kimi the same mattress

Linda Says

July 1, 2017 at 8:21 pm

Can you tell me what would compare to the Simmons B. R. Garrison Legends extra firm. My husband is having back surgery and we need a firm mattress with no pillow top and not to high looking for around 11in or so.

Keri Says

July 1, 2017 at 8:11 pm

Which mattress compares to Beautyrest Hybrid Orchard Lake Luxury Firm

MattressNerd Says

June 28, 2017 at 9:31 pm

That's the same as the Charcoal Coast Extra Firm and the ones in the same row.

beth Says

June 28, 2017 at 9:17 pm

trying desperately to find reviews for beautyrest silver MARLENE extra firm (at denver mattress). my sales guy says the old names are katherina extra firm (not katherine) & belton springs extra firm, but i cant find anything on these two names either. is the marlene somewhere on the chart by yet another name? thanks for any help!

MattressNerd Says

June 26, 2017 at 4:58 pm

Lydia Manor luxury firm. As you go down on the chart, you're going up in quality.

muriel honeycutt Says

June 26, 2017 at 1:33 pm

what is the next step up from the simmons beautyrest silver kenosha place III luxury firm? We want an innerspring mattress with no pillowtop.

MattressNerd Says

June 25, 2017 at 3:49 pm

The Austin Reef and the other ones in that row.

BYRON KOOY Says

June 24, 2017 at 8:09 pm

beautyrest silver hybrid madeline island plush what comparison would this one be

MattressNerd Says

June 21, 2017 at 8:18 pm

That's an older model. It's on my 2015 comparison chart here.

Lisa Says

June 20, 2017 at 4:34 pm

I'm looking for the beauty rest recharge world classic keaton luxury firm. Is it available at Mattress firm?

MattressNerd Says

June 9, 2017 at 2:10 pm

The Black Hybrids are only sold at Mattress Firm. You can't comparison shop those elsewhere. Mattress Firm has a bunch of exclusive lines they negotiated with manufacturers, which is why it's so hard to comparison shop them. They hate being comparison shopped, so they create exclusive lines, and since they're so big, the manufacturers agree to do it for them.

John hughes Says

June 9, 2017 at 12:22 pm

Clermont queen beautyrest

MattressNerd Says

June 9, 2017 at 9:51 am

That's only sold at Mattress Firm. You cannot compare that same model elsewhere.

Sami Says

June 8, 2017 at 10:38 pm

I'm looking for a comparison to the beautyrest legend windward, firm, a mattress firm only model. Any suggestions?

MattressNerd Says

June 6, 2017 at 2:30 pm

A lot has changed in the lineup over the past few years, but a rough approximation would be one of the Platinum Hybrids, probably the Austin and the ones in the same row. But it won't be exact. Like I said, a lot has changed.

Kati Says

June 6, 2017 at 8:40 am

Hi! I currently have a queen 2013 Simmons Beautyrest truenergy noelle/brielle plush firm and I am wanting to upgrade to a king size. What would be a comparable model now? Thanks for your help! My research is just sending me in circles with all the different names and models!!

MattressNerd Says

June 5, 2017 at 8:39 am

I don't mention Raymour because they're a smaller regional retailer, and I have readers from across the country. Raymour is only in 6 states. I also don't list Nebraska Furniture Market or any number of other regional retailers either. There just isn't enough room on the chart for dozens of retailers. The Beautyrest Legend is only sold at Mattress Firm. You can't find that mattress elsewhere at a lower price. It's similar in quality to the lower end Beautyrest Black models. (I don't have a chart for those yet). The Franklyn Heights is the same as the ones in the row that starts with Amberlyn. The Serta Applause is going to be roughly the same quality as the Franklyn Heights.

Janet Sabel Says

June 4, 2017 at 10:04 pm

How would you compare the Beautyrest Legend Garrison (from Mattress Firm) and the Simmons Franklyn Heights Extra Firm from Raymour and Flanagan? And how would the Serta Appaluse II firm hybrid compare to both of these in quality? I notice you don't mention Raymour and Flanagan. Do you not recommend going there?

Shelly Says

June 2, 2017 at 2:26 am

I'm looking for the Beautyrest Recharge Danika Tight Top-King Do you have a replacement mattress for this model?

Mo Says

June 1, 2017 at 11:07 pm

Thank you for your quick response.

MattressNerd Says

June 1, 2017 at 11:00 pm

It's not that latex "stays cool." It's that it takes longer to warm up to your body temperature. In any case, both are innerspring mattresses. There is plenty of air flow throughout both mattresses, and I wouldn't expect sleeping hot to be an issue on either of those.

Mo Says

June 1, 2017 at 8:46 pm

I am considering the Beautyrest Black Vivianne Plush Pillowtop from Macy's or their Aireloom Vitagenic Hotel Collection -Holland Maid latex Cushion firm in king size. We sleep in several positions and don't favor one position. I am most concerned with "saying cool", motion transfer reduction, and reduced imprint over the years. Which would you suggest? Does the latex really keep you cooler and bounce back quicker?

MattressNerd Says

May 31, 2017 at 12:36 pm

Yes, they're the same. You can actually compare the specs line by line to confirm. Both Mancini's and US Mattress put the detailed specs on their respective websites.

MattressNerd Says

May 31, 2017 at 12:33 pm

I have no recommendation there, sorry.

Sean Says

May 31, 2017 at 12:29 am

First off - thanks for the awesome site We're eyeing the Sunny Day Plush (USM) and wants to check it out at a local store. Is this comparable to Mancini's Fairview Plush https://www.sleepworld.com/mattress/beautyrest/3518767/?

Sha Says

May 30, 2017 at 7:30 pm

Thanks again. I guess I am stuck in the Analysis-Paralysis phase :( Any recommendation on the store itself - Macy's or Matteess Firm? Am I better off buying from one place versus the other?

Sue Street Says

May 30, 2017 at 7:00 pm

Is the Beautyrest Katrina the same as the Beautyrest Vivianne at MACY'S the same mattress? If not which one is better?

MattressNerd Says

May 30, 2017 at 2:20 pm

The Black and Legend lineups are roughly the same quality. They use different foams and different coils, but the overall effect is similar. You're correct that the Giada is the same as the Calista, but the Legend isn't the same as the Silver collection. The Legend is a slight step above the Platinum collection (or the older World Class models).

Sha Says

May 30, 2017 at 11:42 am

Thank you so much for your response! We are considering two mattresses - The Extra Firm Garrison at Mattress Firm which is from their Legend line which is only sold at Mattress Firm. The second is Giada Extra Firm at Macy's from the Black Collection of Beautyrest. We are getting both of them at a very similar price. They feel similar to us too. But what I am confused about is whether the Black Collection (Giada at Macy's) is a better/higher-end/more advanced mattress than the Legend Collection (Garrison at Mattress Firm) or not. In my comparison, the Legend Garrison at Mattress Firm is more like the Silver Collection (Charcoal Coast to be specific) and the Black Giada Extra Firm at Macy's is the Calista Extra Firm in the Black Collection. Would you agree with that assessment? And if so, isn't the Black Giada Extra Firm at Macy's a "better" mattress than the Legend Garisson at Mattress Firm? I really really appreciate your help with my dilemma.

MattressNerd Says

May 30, 2017 at 5:58 am

That one actually is exclusively for Mattress Firm. The Legend lineup uses a different coil system (called the Smart Response coil) than found at any other big retailer. (I think Art Van has a different lineup with a Smart Response coil, but that's about it). That said, the ones in the row that begin with Amberlyn Luxury Firm will feel almost the same. It won't be quite as high quality, but it'll be close. Otherwise, you can try to find a Beautyrest Black model in an Extra Firm feel for one that's about the same quality as the Legend. The "official" name would be the Calista Extra Firm. It uses different coils and different foams from the Legend, but it's a similar quality.

Sha Says

May 30, 2017 at 12:01 am

At Mattress Firm, we found an Extra Firm mattress (named Garrison) in their "Exclusively for Mattress Firm" line closed Beautyrest Legend. Do you know what is the closest official name for it is? Thank you so much for your help!!

MattressNerd Says

May 28, 2017 at 8:58 am

On their website, I only see the Silver Hybrids and the non-hybrid Platinums. I don't see any Platinum Hybrids.

andy barbusca Says

May 28, 2017 at 3:20 am

What about JC Penney. Do they have a beautyrest hybrid platinum lineup? I thought they had a hybrid too, and want to buy my mattress there.

MattressNerd Says

May 23, 2017 at 9:24 am

The Legends are only sold at Mattress Firm, so you can't comparison shop the same mattress elsewhere.. Other stores will have the Beautyrest Black lineup as their high end Beautyrest. They're similar quality to the Legend, but use different foams and different coils.

Bill Williamson Says

May 20, 2017 at 2:04 pm

Mattress Firm quote for what they call Beauty Rest Garrison Legends Extra Firm Matt Queen Prime $2249.99.

MattressNerd Says

May 14, 2017 at 10:17 am

The Classic models are most similar to the Silver models, but I don't know specifically which model the Bagnell Firm would be closest to (either the Level 1 Silver Firm or Luxury Firm). A lot has changed in the past 10 years, too, so it won't be the exact same mattress.

Rick Heinz Says

May 13, 2017 at 5:46 am

What is the current comparable series and model for a Beautyrest Classic Bagnell Firm. It was purchased about 10 years ago. I use a featherbed on top of it, so a lot of the enhancements in higher end models are not necessary for me.

Sign up for The Mattress Nerd newsletter: