Nectar vs. Nectar Premier Mattress Comparison

Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

Deciding between the original Nectar and the upgraded Nectar Premier? Read on to see which Nectar mattress is best for you.

Nectar vs. Nectar Premier Overview

The Nectar Premier and the original Nectar are both all-foam mattresses with a similar construction. However, the Premier performs better for heavier sleepers and side sleepers, while the Nectar has more responsiveness and bouncy, for combination sleepers and couples.

Nectar is best for…Nectar Premier is best for…
Budget shoppersHot sleepers
CouplesHeavyweight sleepers
SeniorsCombination sleepers

Who Should Choose the Nectar Mattress?

  • Budget shoppers—When it comes to mattress shopping, money talks. If you’re looking for an affordable foam bed that’s great for you and your wallet, it’s worth considering that the original Nectar is almost $500 cheaper at a Queen size than the Premier.
  • Couples—Foam is known for their soft, absorbing feel, and this material works great for muffling unwanted motion and disturbance during the night. While both beds have above average motion isolation, the original Nectar is best for light sleepers and sleeping partners who toss and turn.
  • Seniors—For seniors, or sleepers who like to sit or lie along the edges of their bed, solid edge support is what keeps the mattress from warping and collapsing. Although foam beds aren’t known for being the sturdiest kind, the Nectar Original has above average edge support, meaning you’ll get full use out of the full mattress.

Who Should Choose the Nectar Premier Mattress?

  • Hot SleepersFoam mattresses unfortunately aren’t known for having great temperature control. This is because, as a material, foam absorbs and traps body heat. While this is true for both Nectar beds as well, the Premier is still the cooler of the two.
  • Heavyweight SleepersHeavyweight sleepers tend to need a more solid and supportive mattress that will stop them from sinking down. And, while the Premier is actually the softer mattress of the two, the bed’s denser construction works perfectly for heavyweight side sleepers.
  • Combination SleepersCombination sleepers, who change positions throughout the night, do best on mattresses that have some bounce. And, between these two Nectar beds, the Premier has that more bouncy and lifted feel.

Nectar vs. Nectar Premier Mattress Video Comparison

Want to see these Nectar beds put to the test? Join Loren and Adrienne in the Nerd Lab to learn more:

Nectar vs. Nectar Premier: Top Similarities 

  • Policies—Since these mattresses are both from Nectar, they have the exact same shipping, return, and warranty policies. Regardless of which bed you choose, you’ll get free shipping, a 365-night sleep trial, and a Lifetime warranty. 
  • Stomach Sleepers—Next up, if you’re a stomach sleeper unsure of which Nectar mattress to get, we’re about to make your choice even harder. Why? Well, both the original Nectar and the Premier perform the same for stomach sleepers. And, although neither mattress is great for stomach sleepers, lightweight stomach sleepers will do best on these Nectar beds.
  • Construction—You wouldn’t expect two all-foam beds made by the same company to be super different, and they aren’t. These mattresses essentially have identical cooling and support foam layers, but the Nectar Premier squeezes in an extra inch of support foam over the original Nectar.

Nectar vs. Nectar Premier: Top Differences 

  • Firmness—Although both beds have the classic, sinking memory foam feel, the original Nectar is a little bit firmer than the Premier, which falls more on the soft side. So, if you’re looking to get your hands on the softest mattress, the Premier is your best bet.
  • Temperature Control—The Nectar Premier is also your best bed if you prioritize cooling or you tend to overheat during the night. While both of these Nectar mattresses feature a breathable mattress cover, the Premier uses polyethylene fibers that are noticeably cooler to the touch.
  • Price—Like we said, the Premier is the softer of the two beds, but it’s definitely not the softest on your wallet. Regardless of which mattress you prefer, you’ll save a few hundred bucks just by going with the original Nectar.

Nectar vs. Nectar Premier: Firmness & Feel Differences

We’ve covered what kinds of sleepers each bed is best for you, but let’s get more into the actual feel and firmness of these two Nectar mattresses.

What’s the Firmness Of the Nectar & Nectar Premier Mattresses? 

At Mattress Nerd, we like to test mattress firmness on a simple scale of 1–10, where a 1 is like sleeping on a cloud, and a 10 is harder than falling off that cloud and onto concrete.

With that said, the original Nectar mattress clocks in at a medium-firm 6/10, which is slightly on the firmer side for a foam mattress, but pretty average overall. Next, the Premier’s firmness measures in at a slightly softer 5.5/10. All things considered, these two firmness levels work for the average sleeper, although some heavyweight sleepers may want to up the firmness.

What Do the Nectar & Nectar Premier Mattresses Feel Like?

A couple key differences in feel between the Nectar and Nectar Premier is that the original is more supportive and responsive, while the Premier feels more contouring and sinking. Essentially, the Nectar Premier is more doughy and the original is more bouncy.

And, for temperature, the original Nectar feels cool to the touch along with the Premier, but the Premier’s mattress cover is more breathable, and it stays cooler for longer.

What’s It Like to Sleep On the Nectar & Nectar Premier Mattresses?

Firstly, due to firmness, the Nectar performs better for average-weight sleepers, while the Premier’s softer feel works better for lightweight sleepers. For sleeping position, stomach sleepers will get a similar experience on either bed, but side sleepers will prefer the Premier’s more cushioned feel. And, for back sleepers, the original Nectar is better for sleepers wanting more support, while the Premier feels more pressure-relieving for lightweight sleepers.

The Nectar vs. Nectar Premier Mattresses By Body Type

Nectar Performance By Body Type & Sleeping Position:

Lightweight (< 130 lbs): 433
Average-weight (130–230 lbs):425
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs): 223

Nectar Premier Performance By Body Type & Sleeping Position:

Lightweight (< 130 lbs): 533
Average-weight (130–230 lbs):424
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs): 325

1 = Very poor, 2 = Not good, 3 = Fair, 4 = Good, 5 = Excellent

Average-Weight Sleepers (130–230 lbs)

The original Nectar’s medium firmness works best for average-weight sleepers, so side sleepers will find a great balance of support and cushion. On the other hand, the Premier’s softer design lacks a little bit in support for side sleepers.

For average-weight back sleepers and stomach sleepers, both the Premier and the original Nectar perform similarly, with back sleepers getting a solid amount of support, but stomach sleepers not getting enough firmness to stop their hips from sinking.

Heavyweight Sleepers (> 230 lbs)

Although the Nectar Premier is actually softer than the original Nectar, the mattress’s denser construction works great for heavyweight side sleepers who need support without compromising on softness. However, for heavyweight back sleepers and stomach sleepers, neither bed is ideal. Both of these foam beds lack the support for heavyweight stomach sleepers who need the most firmness of any sleeper type. And, for heavier back sleepers, while neither option is ideal, the Premier will feel supportive.

Lightweight Sleepers (< 130 lbs)

For lightweight sleepers, having a mattress that is too firm can lead to pressure points building up. So, the Nectar Premier’s softer feel works best for lightweight back sleepers needing cushioning, but also support. Next, for stomach sleepers, both Nectar beds are firm enough for lightweight sleepers to get proper hip support, and both beds perform similarly for side sleepers too.

Differences In Mattress Construction 

The Nectar and Nectar Premier are both all-foam mattresses that feature a similar construction. A few key differences between these beds are that the Premier has a slightly thicker comfort layer, and it has better temperature regulation in its cover. Lastly, the Premier measures 13 inches tall, while the standard Nectar is a foot tall.

Nectar Mattress Materials Nectar Premier Mattress Materials
Memory Foam CoverCooling Cover
Cooling Memory Foam Comfort Layer—3”Cooling Memory Foam Comfort Layer—3”
Dynamic Support Layer—2”Dynamic Support Layer—3”
Foam Base Layer—7”Foam Base Layer—7”
nectar mattress construction


Both the Nectar and the Premier have a breathable foam mattress cover that feels cool to the touch, but the Premier’s mattress cover also includes polyurethane fibers that offer additional temperature regulation.

Comfort Layers

Below the top cover, both the Premier and the original Nectar have a comfort layer that’s three inches of memory foam. This memory foam is designed to contour to the body and provide pressure relief. Additionally, both mattresses have cooling gel infused into this layer.

Support Layers

Next up is the foam dynamic support layer. The Nectar and the Premier both have this layer, but the Premier has an extra inch of dynamic support. Essentially, this support foam is designed to add more support and bounce to the bed, making the Premier slightly more responsive than the original.

Finally, at the bottom, both beds also have seven inches of high-density base foam. This support layer adds a base level of firmness to the bed and improves the mattress’s durability.

Nectar vs. Nectar Premier Pricing

SizeNectar PricesNectar Premier Prices
Twin XL$$
California King$$

For exclusive discounts on both beds see our Nectar mattress coupons.

Nectar vs. Nectar Premier Mattress Performance Ratings & Differences

Now that we’ve gone through every layer of the Nectar and the Nectar Premier, let’s see how each of these mattresses perform:


For sleepers who sweat or overheat during the night, temperature control can be especially important. And, although foam mattresses usually don’t offer the best cooling, the Premier’s mattress cover does win out over the original Nectar for breathability.

Motion Transfer

Since foam mattresses tend to absorb and muffle unwanted movement, they usually offer above average motion isolation—which is true for both of these Nectar beds. That said, the original Nectar’s motion isolation is marginally better than the Premier’s, despite being the thinner mattress.

Edge Support 

Next, for couples who like to spread out and use their entire bed, good edge support is key for making sure the bed doesn’t collapse at its edges. So, if edge support is a top priority for you, the Nectar Original’s firmer design should have you covered.

Pressure Relief 

If you’re a lightweight sleeper, or if you’re a side sleeper, the Nectar Premier’s softer design and thicker foam comfort layer will be ideal for reducing pressure on key areas like the shoulders and hips. On the other hand, average-weight and heavier sleepers will get better pressure relief on the original Nectar.

Pain Relief 

For sleepers managing with pain, memory foam mattress, especially softer ones, can be a great way to cushion and reduce pressure. For lightweight sleepers, the Premier offers more softness and deeper cushioning; however, stomach sleepers and heavier sleepers may want to opt for the original Nectar for better hip and back alignment.


Both Nectar mattresses have similar constructions, but the Premier is a slightly thicker mattress which works to its advantage for durability. That said, the original Nectar has great edge support, so neither mattress is noticeably more durable.

Shipping, Returns, & Warranties 

Nectar & Nectar Premier

As you might’ve guessed, since both mattresses are made by Nectar, you’ll be getting the same policies with either. Specifically, your new Nectar mattress will ship for free anywhere in the United States (excluding Hawaii and Alaska), and it should take about five to 10 business days to arrive. 

Once your new Nectar bed is home, you’ll also receive a 365-night trial that begins after a 30-day break-in period. During this trial, you can return your Nectar, free of charge, and the company will donate it if possible.

Lastly, if you do plan on keeping your Nectar, you’ll be entitled to a Lifetime warranty that covers any defects and repair fees for the first 10 years. That said, this warranty does not cover misuse of your mattress, and, after 10 years, repairs to your mattress will incur a fee.

Other Models Available

This mattress is no longer available for purchase. To help you find your next mattress, check out our list of the best mattresses available on the market now.

This mattress is no longer available for purchase. To help you find your next mattress, check out our list of the best mattresses available on the market now.

This mattress is no longer available for purchase. To help you find your next mattress, check out our list of the best mattresses available on the market now.

Our Final Take

Between these two Nectar beds, the original is ideal for budget shoppers and sleepers wanting more firmness and edge support. On the other hand, lightweight sleepers and side sleepers will prefer the Premier’s softer feel, along with hot sleepers wanting the more breathable memory foam mattress too.