Compare Stores

Sealy 2017 Mattress Comparison Guide

By Jack Mitcham

As you may have noticed, it’s difficult to comparison shop for mattresses between retailers because they often have different names for what seems to be the same exact mattress. Or, the retailer will claim their mattress is an exclusive, or their model has some feature that nobody else has that makes it different. How then will you take advantage of the price match guarantees that so many places offer? We’re here to help!

Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

Mattresses are sold under different names at different retailers, and Sealy is no exception. This can make it difficult to comparison shop a mattress you liked from one retailer at other retailers. It is especially difficult to make these comparisons when the retailer doesn’t list the specs of the mattress on their website. This is a guide to compare the models of Sealy mattresses that came out in 2017 or if you like to read otherwise, click here to read about current Sealy Mattress Reviews.

Sealy has a few different lineups. In the past, they had the “Sealy brand” lineup and then the “Posturepedic” lineup. This year, they seem to be moving away from that. Now, the mattresses are all “Sealy,” but the higher end ones (in the Performance and Premier collections) now say “with Posturepedic technology.”

Have you considered an online brand?  Here are some of our favorites, or if you’d prefer scroll down to view the comparison chart.

Editors' Picks

Editors' Pick

T&N Mint

Best Overall


Best Value


Our Top 10

As you compare names in the following chart, keep a couple things in mind.

  • Make sure you’re comparing prices for the same size and whether or not a boxspring is included
  • The mattresses might not be completely identical. Sometimes a retailer will have a negligible difference in the mattress, like a different cover, to claim it’s a different mattress

Sealy 2017 comparison chart

LineupUS MattressAmazonMacy'sSears
EssentialBale Firm-Blue Arbor Firm-
Castra FirmEssentials 8.5 inch firm--
Seward FirmEssentials 10" firmRustic Pass Firm-
Seward PlushEssentials 10.5" Plush--
Townhouse Cushion FirmEssentials 11" Cushion Firm-Cavell Cushion Firm
Townhouse Plush EurotopEssentials 11.5" Plush Eurotop--
Townhouse Plush PillowtopEssentials 13" Plush Pillowtop--
PerformanceSanta Paula Cushion FirmPerformance 12" Cushion FirmChase PointeKenney Firm
Santa Paula PlushPerformance 12" Plush--
Santa Paula Cushion Firm Eurotop--Kenney Cushion Firm Eurotop
Santa Paula Plush EurotopPerformance 13" Plush Eurotop--
Santa Paula Cushion Firm Pillowtop---
Santa Paula Plush Pillowtop---
Mountain Ridge Firm-Lawson Cushion FirmBenish Firm
Mountain Ridge Plush-Lawson Plush-
Mountain Ridge Cushion Firm Eurotop--Benish Cushion Firm Eurotop
Mountain Ridge Plush Eurotop---
Mountain Ridge Cushion Firm Pillowtop-Lawson Cushion Firm PillowtopMcCann Firm Pillowtop
Mountain Ridge Plush Pillowtop-Lawson Plush PillowtopMcCann Plush Pillowtop
Cooper Mountain FirmPerformance 12.5" FirmShore Drive Extra FirmDolby Ultra Firm
Cooper Mountain Cushion Firm--Dolby Cushion Firm
Cooper Mountain Plush--Dolby Plush
Cooper Mountain Cushion Firm Pillowtop-Shore Drive Cushion Firm PillowtopDolby Cushion Firm Pillowtop
Cooper Mountain Plush PillowtopPerformance 13.5" Plush pillowtopShore Drive Plush PillowtopDolby Plush Pillowtop
PremiumWarrenville Cushion Firm--Goldrick Cushion Firm
Warrenville Plush---
Warrenville Cushion Firm Pillowtop--Goldrick Firm Pillowtop
Warrenville Plush PillowtopPremium 14" Plush Pillowtop-Goldrick Cushion Firm Pillowtop
Barrett Court Ultra Firm--Rosati Ultra Firm
Barrett Court Cushion Firm---
Barrett Court Plush--Rosati Plush
Barrett Court Cushion Firm Pillowtop---
Barrett Court Plush Pillowtop--Rosati Plush Pillowtop

If the model you were looking for isn’t on the chart, contact me through the form on my Comparison Shopping page with the details of what you saw, or leave a comment below.

Comparison to last year’s models

If you’re comparing to models that came out in 2015, keep a few things in mind.

  • The Essentials collection was what they used to call “Sealy Brand” or the “Non-Posturepedic” Sealys.
  • The Performance collection is roughly equivalent in quality to the previous year’s “Posturepedic Plus” lineup
  • The Premium collection is replacing the “Posturepedic Select” lineup from before.

This year, they changed the coil system in the mattresses. They’re using more coils than before, but they’re shaped differently, so it’s not exactly an apples-to-apples comparison.


Every mattress company on the planet works every year to build a mattress that moves ever closer to delivering a perfect night’s sleep. Sealy is no different in that chase. Sealy’s 2017 offerings are upgrades from the 2015 models with different names but improved coil structures.

The 2015 versions have also been renamed: Sealy Brand or Non-Posturepedic is now Essentials. The Posturepedic Plus is now Performance. The Posturepedic Select is now Premium. All three collections include some combination of (1) thin comfort layers using poly or gel foam combined with increasingly luxe fabric covers and (2) an improved base layer of pocket coils.

One rule of thumb about the chart, Amazon will list the Sealy options using the same designations: Essentials, Performance or Premium. They will not offer as many firmness options, but at least you know the Sealy apple compares favorably to the Amazon apple.

Keep in mind that the higher end versions, regardless of the “line,” will include the “Posturepedic” technology. Sealy’s innovation specifically offers more support where most bodies are heaviest—in the center. It is meant to keep that heavier part to keep your spine aligned. That doesn’t guarantee better contouring from head to toe, but it does give you that firm support where you need it most.

Traditionally, Sealy has offered economical options to the masses that are consistently known for a firm and bouncy feel. After developing the posturepedic technology, it also offered a sturdier version less likely to prematurely begin sagging in the middle since the middle was reinforced.

When you’re a national player in the mattress retail world like Sealy is, you have to reinvent your mattresses every once in a while. That is what Sealy has done here for 2017. The fact that the mattresses are affordable and easy to find at retailers across the country is a major draw.


Comments (154)

  1. hi can you tell me what a comparable to the ” serta perfect sleeper caledonian ll model would be? big sandy sells it but i saw one at sams club that i thought looked identical?
    Thank you for your help & knowledge.
    Tamela Atwood

  2. I gave my old mattress away. I miss it so much! Can you help me find an equivalent one? It was a Savoie Plush PP from like 1994!

  3. We have located the Sealy Posturepedic Premium East Avenue Cushion Firm Pillowtop at Denver Mattress. Does this mattress go under a different name or model at different stores? Thank you for any help.

  4. Yeeeaaars ago, I fell in love with the Sealy Posturepedic Linwood Plush and not sure if the Posturepedic Chase Pointe LTD 11″ Cushion Firm is comparable?

  5. I want to replace Sealy Posturepedic St. James Pillowtop Plush with a like-mattress. What is the difference between Shore Drive Ltd and Lawson Ltd, other than one is 13.5″, the other is 14″ ?
    Thank you

  6. Costco offers the Sealy Response Premium WestSalem cushion firm Posturepedic. What is the comparison model for that, and is there a separate review? Is it a good mattres?

    • Try” Response Premium Warrenville IV”…
      I bought the West Salem at Costco and like it…especially at its present sale price. It seems pretty identical to the Warrenville IV”, to me. See Warrenville IV specs on US Mattress website and compare specs yourself. My opinion, of course

  7. I’m looking for the equivalent to a Sealy Posturepedic Welland Ultra Firm, which has been discontinued. The U.S. Mattress website says that the equivalent at that store is the Santa Paula IV Cushion Firm. Is there an equivalent mattress at Costco? Thanks!

  8. Ashley’s furniture sells Sealy Surrey Lane Plush Pillow Top. I am trying to find this hopefully at a better price. Any insight would be great

    • The Sealy Humboldt Ltd Cushion Firm is not in the chart above. What other name is it known by?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

By continuing to browse or by clicking “OK” you agree to the storing of first- and third-party cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Privacy Policy.