Best Memory Foam Mattress Toppers 2023
Memory foam toppers are among the most popular types of mattress toppers because they provide what people shopping for toppers are often interested in: close conforming, pressure relief, and comfort. Memory foam toppers also have other benefits, such as above-average motion isolation for couples.
If you’re considering adding a layer of memory foam to your sleeping surface to adjust its firmness and improve your sleep, keep reading to discover our top picks for the best memory foam toppers sold in 2023. We also include a brief buyer’s guide with tips on what to look for, important shopping considerations, and how to decide on the best topper for your mattress.
Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.
Best Memory Foam Mattress Toppers of 2023
- Saatva Mattress Topper – Editor’s Pick
- Layla Mattress Topper – Runner Up
- Lucid Mattress Topper – Best Value Memory Foam Mattress Topper
- TempurPedic Mattress Topper – Best Luxury Memory Foam Mattress Topper
- Nest Bedding Cooling Mattress Topper – Best Cooling Memory Foam Mattress Topper
- DreamFoam Mattress Topper – Best Enhancing Memory Foam Mattress Topper
Watch Our Roundup
Saatva Mattress Topper
Editor’s Pick
The Saatva memory foam mattress topper is our Editor’s Pick because we believe it to excel in cooling ability, durability, and comfort. While high-density foam and Talalay latex options do exist at Saatva, we’re huge fans of the memory foam version because of its plush, luxury feel.
Reason to Buy: The Saatva may not be the cheapest option on the market, but its high-quality materials should make it a great investment. It’s graphite-infused so you get cooling features not all memory foam toppers offer, and its height of three inches adds to how comfy this topper truly is. With excellent contouring abilities, you should sink in the way you’d want to with a memory foam topper; it provides a cushioning, hugging sensation. With the Saatva topper’s construction in mind, we recommend this product to side sleepers, who need pressure relief at the shoulders and hips, as well as lightweight back sleepers, who search for a balanced feel. The Saatva topper comes with a one-year warranty and a 180-night sleep trial.
Layla Mattress Topper
Runner Up
The Layla is a 2” memory foam topper that contains Layla’s signature copper-infused memory foam and has a medium soft (4/10) feel. It has a soft, quilted cover with Layla’s hexagonal gray design.
Reason to Buy: The Layla’s price point is a little higher than others, but we think you get what you pay for with this product. Not only is the foam actively cooling (copper draws heat away from the body), but the plush feel will contour closely to your body to help alleviate back pain, joint pain, pressure points, and aches. For more information on relieving pain during sleep, take a look at our pain and sleep guide. An added benefit of the copper infusion is that it may promote blood flow, which can help active individuals recover faster at night. As a bonus, the Layla’s foam is CertiPUR certified, which means that it’s made without ozone depleters, heavy metals, or formaldehyde. The Layla comes with a 5-year warranty and a 120-night sleep trial.
Lucid Mattress Topper
Best Value
The LUCID mattress topper is an affordable, 4” gel memory foam mattress topper that’s available in all mattress sizes and has special cooling features.
Reason to Buy: Sold on Amazon with an average of 4.1 stars, this topper costs less than $150 in all sizes. Designed to help keep you cool on memory foam, which normally traps heat, it features a ventilated design and cooling gel. With a below-average price point compared to other memory foam toppers, this topper has a soft firmness setting (4/10), which makes it great for side sleepers and lightweight sleepers. It’s available on Amazon and comes with free shipping.
TempurPedic Mattress Topper
Best Luxury
The TEMPUR-Adapt Topper by TempurPedic is made with the company’s TEMPUR material, has a removable cover, and is backed by a 10-year warranty.
Reason to Buy: If you’re looking to improve the feel of your mattress with the most luxurious topper available, we recommend the TEMPUR-Adapt. It’s made with 3” of TEMPUR foam, which is supportive yet pressure relieving, and it sleeps a little cooler than traditional memory foam. It also comes with a removable cover that can be machine washed, and the cover is also dust mite, allergen, and mold resistant. The TEMPUR-Adapt comes with free shipping and a 10-year limited warranty.
Nest Bedding Cooling Topper
Best Cooling Memory Foam Mattress Topper
The Nest topper is not only plush, but cooling, and this is where other memory foam toppers often miss the mark. While it doesn’t have the same huggable feel as typical memory foam, the Nest does offer the same contouring and pressure-relieving qualities that memory foam lovers enjoy.
Reason to Buy: The Nest Bedding Cooling topper, not surprisingly, sleeps extremely cool. With phase change material in its cover, this topper regulates body heat throughout the night. Its Energex Foam technology assists with moisture-wicking and breathability. The Nest also includes corner straps, which are great for keeping the topper in place, so between this and the endless comfort provided by the two inches of foam, you should sleep without worry. Side sleepers and lightweight sleepers of all sleeping positions should enjoy using this topper; they should find the right balance of cushioning and support for their body weight and sleeping preferences. For this topper, Nest offers a 30-night sleep trial and a limited two-year warranty.
DreamFoam Mattress Topper
Best Enhancing Memory Foam Mattress Topper
The DreamFoam is a 2” topper with a gel swirl infusion to draw heat away from the body, and it’s thick enough to improve the comfort of your bed without drastically altering its feel.
Reason to Buy: While some memory foam mattress toppers are designed to change the feel of your mattress altogether, others are meant to alter its feel only slightly. This gel swirl memory foam topper is one of those, with a thinner-than-average 2” construction that will add that little extra something to your current mattress. Its price point (under $110 in all sizes) makes it a good addition to an RV, dorm room, or new apartment as well. The DreamFoam mattress topper is available on Amazon in eight sizes and comes with a 3-year warranty.
How to Pick the Right Memory Foam Mattress Topper
Should you Buy a Mattress Pad or a Mattress Topper?
Mattress toppers, mattress pads, and even mattress protectors are often confused with one another. While all three are additions to an existing mattress, they each serve a specific purpose, so it’s important to be able to distinguish between them.
- A mattress topper is a layer of foam or another material (latex, etc.) that is placed on top of a new mattress or old mattress to add comfort and softness. Firmer toppers are available for people who find their existing mattress or new bed too soft. Most toppers measure anywhere from 2” to 5” thick. For more information about mattress toppers or to browse other topper styles, read our Guide to the Best Mattress Toppers of 2023.
- A mattress pad is thinner than a mattress topper and typically measures about 1” thick. Mattress pads are designed to add a little bit more cushioning but won’t significantly change the feel of the mattress.
- A mattress protector is often confused with a mattress pad because they are designed for two different purposes. However, a protector is more focused on protection from liquids. It typically features a thin design that’s waterproof in order to fight spills, urine, sweat, allergens and more.
Read more: Do I Need a Mattress Protector?
All in all, mattress toppers are best for sleepers who want to change the comfort level of their bed. Mattress pads and mattress protectors are best for people who want to alter their bed slightly and protect it.
Types of Mattress Toppers
Mattress toppers are available in all different sizes, constructions, and materials. Each material type has unique benefits and drawbacks. To help you understand the advantages and disadvantages of memory foam compared to the other types, here’s an overview of the types of mattress toppers.
- Convoluted Polyfoam—Sometimes referred to as eggshell foam or egg crate foam, convoluted polyfoam toppers have soft ridges that help the topper conform to the sleeper’s body. They’re more affordable than memory foam, but they’re not as durable. They’re a good option if you want to soften your mattress for a very low price.
- Latex—Latex toppers are more expensive than memory foam in most cases and offer comfort, pressure relief, and a more responsive feel. They’re also more inherently cooling than memory foam toppers. As a natural material that’s hypoallergenic and moisture-wicking, latex can work well for sleepers who are sensitive to off-gassing or don’t like that memory foam is a synthetic material.
- Wool—Wool toppers are less common, but the material is known for its year-round temperature neutrality and moisture-wicking abilities. A great option for people living in climates where summer is very hot and winter is very cold, wool toppers offer softness, warmth, and cooling just when you need it.
- Feather—Feather bed toppers are filled with duck or goose feathers and have a very thin, plush feel. Like a down pillow, they add a luxurious feel to your mattress, but they aren’t as effective as memory foam toppers when it comes to pressure relief and spinal support. Lightweight sleepers and side sleepers may benefit the most from this style because it’s so thin and plush.
Considerations for Buying a Memory Foam Mattress Topper
Here are some important considerations to take into account when shopping for a memory foam topper.
- Price—The average price range for a Queen size memory foam mattress topper is between $100 and $250. Toppers outside of this price range are available but harder to find.
- Cooling Properties—Memory foam is known for its pressure relief, but it also sleeps hot. If you struggle with body heat throughout the night, look for toppers that can create a cooling effect. Hot sleepers should prioritize toppers with cooling effects, and terms like “cooling gel topper” and “gel memory foam mattress topper” are a good indication that the topper will sleep cool or at least temperature neutral.
- Ease of Cleaning—If you or the person you’re buying the mattress topper for struggle with sweating at night or are prone to spills, consider a topper with a washable, removable cover. Some covers can be removed but the brand recommends spot cleaning only, so your level of comfort with different cleaning methods should come into play here. If your mattress surface is suffering from spills, check out our guide on how to clean your mattress.
- Sleeping Position—Side sleepers require more contouring and pressure relief in the hips and shoulders, so a softer, lower-density topper like the Layla is appropriate. Back sleepers and stomach sleepers need firmer support to keep the hips and shoulders from sinking, so a firmer mattress topper works best. If you can’t find a memory foam topper that’s firm enough for your sleeping position, we recommend a latex mattress topper. Learn more about how sleeping positions impact the firmness level that’s right for your body in our mattress firmness guide.
- Firmness—Memory foam toppers come in all kinds of firmness settings, so make sure to read the company’s specs or reviews about firmness settings before making your purchase. If you want more cushioning, look for a medium or medium-soft topper. If you need contouring with more support, consider a medium-firm or firm topper. Keep in mind that how a topper feels will vary based on your body weight. Lighter weight sleepers experience firm mattresses as extra firm, for example.
- Dimensions—To the surprise of many shoppers, topper dimensions don’t always match the exact dimensions (width and length) of your size mattress. You’ll also want to consider that, after the addition of the topper, you may need to purchase a sheet set with deeper pockets to accommodate for the added height of the topper.
Pros and Cons of Memory Foam Mattress Toppers
PROS
- Capable of improving one’s sleep experience by softening the sleep surface or making it firmer.
- Available in a wide range of sizes, from Twin to California King.
- Many incorporate cooling features, which can help hot sleepers get a good night’s sleep.
- Motion transfer and noise won’t be an issue on memory foam toppers, which distill movement better than other types and are virtually silent when bearing weight.
CONS
- Memory foam is more prone to sagging and faster deterioration than other types.
- Memory foam retains more heat than other types, so the breathability of the mattress may be impaired.
- Combination sleepers may have trouble changing positions on a memory foam topper, which sinks underneath the body and is slower to respond.
- Memory foam toppers are more expensive than mixed-foam toppers, and some cost $300 or more.
FAQ
What's the best thickness for a memory foam mattress topper?
It depends on your sleep preferences and body type. Most mattress toppers are between 2" and 6". The thicker toppers (6") do well for heavier people who need a lot of room to sink into the memory foam. Around 4" will accommodate most sleepers looking to breath new life into and old mattress. The thinner toppers (2") do well for lightweight sleepers (less than 130 lbs) or people who simply want to add a touch of comfort to their bed.
Is memory foam the best material for mattress toppers?
Memory foam is a very common material for mattress toppers, and for good reason. It provides good pressure relief (an important factor for side sleepers) and motion isolation. Some toppers utilize latex, which can be a bit more expensive than memory foam but is naturally cooling and hypoallergenic, assuming it's natural latex.
Conclusion
The right memory foam topper for you will come down to your firmness preferences, goals, budget, and sleeping position. We recommend starting with your budget and narrowing down your options from there. If you simply want the best memory foam mattress topper available and aren’t hindered by cost, go with the TempurPedic. If you prefer a soft, cradling feel, opt for the Layla topper. For our budget shoppers, the Lucid topper is an excellent choice.
