Puffy vs. Tempur-Pedic Mattress Comparison
Each of these mattresses have great reputations—so how do you know which one is best for you? We’ll show you in this easy-to-follow mattress review where we unpack the details of how each bed performs for different body types and sleeping preferences.
Puffy vs. Tempur-Pedic Overview
|Puffy is best for…||Tempur-Pedic is best for…|
|Light and average-weight side sleepers||Back and stomach sleepers|
|Budget shoppers||Heavyweight sleepers|
Who Should Choose the Puffy Mattress?
- Light and average-weight side sleepers: The Puffy’s soft foam comfort layers do a great job of relieving pressure from side sleepers under 230 pounds.
- Combination sleepers: This all-foam bed pops back into place quickly to keep you supported if you toss and turn.
- Budget shoppers: The Puffy mattress is a budget-friendly pick and comes with a lifetime warranty to make it a long-term investment.
Who Should Choose the Tempur-Pedic Mattress?
- Back and stomach sleepers: The TEMPUR-Cloud’s firm foam support provides an ideal balance of comfort and support for those who sleep on their stomachs or their backs.
- Couples: This bed’s thick foam layers muffle movements so you and your partner can sleep undisturbed.
- Heavyweight sleepers: The Tempur-Pedic bed is built with durable foam layers that are sturdy enough to support heavier bodyweights.
Puffy vs. Tempur-Pedic: Top Similarities
- Deep pressure relief: Both of these memory foam beds redistribute your weight along the length of the bed to keep pressure from building on your joints.
- Responsive: Although all-foam beds have a reputation for having a quicksand-like feel, but these two mattresses both respond quickly to your movements so you can respond easily across the mattress.
- Not ideal for hot sleepers: Memory foam mattresses can tend to trap heat, so neither of these beds is the best option for those looking for a cooling mattress. If you sleep hot, consider a hybrid or latex mattress.
Puffy vs. Tempur-Pedic: Top Differences
- Motion isolation: If you sleep with a partner, pet or kids, the TEMPUR-Cloud will absorb their movements so you won’t wake up in the middle of the night.
- Price: Puffy is less expensive than the TEMPUR-Cloud and comes with a lifetime warranty to protect your purchase.
- Durability: Both beds are high quality, but the TEMPUR-Cloud has stronger edge support and is made with more durable materials than the Puffy bed.
Puffy vs. Tempur-Pedic: Firmness & Feel Differences
Each of these two all-foam beds has a unique firmness level and feel.
What’s the Firmness Of the Puffy & Tempur-Pedic Mattresses?
At Mattress Nerd, we measure mattress firmness on a scale between 1-10. The softest mattress is a 1, while a 10 would feel like sleeping on a wooden plank. Both of these mattresses have a medium firmness level. The Puffy feels like a 6 out of 10, while the TEMPUR-Cloud is a slightly firmer 7 out of 10.
This firmness level generally works for most sleepers, although it may feel firmer to lightweight sleepers whose bodies aren’t heavy enough to sink fully into the comfort layers. Likewise, this bed may feel softer to heavyweight sleepers who will sink deeper into the mattress.
What Do the Puffy & Tempur-Pedic Mattresses Feel Like?
When you lay on the Puffy mattress, you’ll feel deep pressure relief around your joints and areas of the body that tend to push further into the bed. This cushioning is balanced with a supportive and responsive sensation that keeps the bed from feeling too doughy.
Unlike Puffy mattress’s instant pressure relief, the TEMPUR-Cloud feels a bit firmer when you first lay down. You’ll gradually sink into the bed and will feel the pressure-relieving qualities.
What’s It Like to Sleep On the Puffy & Tempur-Pedic Mattresses?
The Puffy mattress has a deep cushy surface that is well suited for side sleepers—the bed’s comfort layers cradle the shoulders and hips as they press into the mattress to prevent morning aches and pains. Light and average weight back sleepers may find the support they need in this mattress but stomach sleepers of all body types should steer clear.
The TEMPUR-Cloud bed has a firmer level of support that helps keep the spines of back and stomach sleepers in a healthy, neutral position throughout the night. Side sleepers, however, may feel some stiffness and misalingment because this bed doesn’t have enough give to provide the pressure relief they need.
The Puffy vs. Tempur-Pedic Mattresses By Body Type
Puffy Performance By Sleeping Position:
|Body Type:||BACK SLEEPERS||STOMACH SLEEPERS||SIDE SLEEPERS|
|Lightweight (< 130 lbs):||4||3||5|
|Average weight (130 – 230 lbs):||3||3||4|
|Heavyweight (> 230 lbs):||2||2||3|
Tempur-Pedic Performance By Sleeping Position:
|Body Type:||BACK SLEEPERS||STOMACH SLEEPERS||SIDE SLEEPERS|
|Lightweight (< 130 lbs):||5||5||3|
|Average weight (130 – 230 lbs):||5||5||4|
|Heavyweight (> 230 lbs):||4||4||4|
1 = Very poor, 2 = Not good, 3 = Fair, 4 = Good, 5 = Excellent
Average-Weight Sleepers (130–230 lbs)
Average-weight side sleepers who sleep on their sides should be able to get a good night’s sleep on the Puffy’s deeply cushioning surface, but back sleepers and stomach sleepers won’t like this bed unless they prefer an extra plush feel.
The TEMPUR-Cloud has a balanced level of support to keep back and stomach sleepers in a healthy posture while still gently conforming to their curves, but side sleepers should steer clear. This bed will likely feel a bit too firm on your shoulders and hips in the side sleeping position. Either of these mattresses will work for combination sleepers—they should go with the mattress that best suits their predominant sleeping position.
Heavyweight Sleepers (> 230 lbs)
While the Puffy doesn’t have enough to keep sleepers over 230 lbs supported, the TEMPUR-Cloud is a solid pick for heavyweight sleepers in any sleep position. Side, back, and stomach sleepers alike will be both cushioned and supported by this medium-firm foam bed, and it’s durable layers will support heavier bodies over time.
Lightweight Sleepers (< 130 lbs)
Lightweight back sleepers and combination sleepers will be happy with either mattress, but side sleepers should stick with the soft Puffy bed to ensure they get the pressure relief they need on the hips and shoulders. Stomach sleepers should opt for the firmer TEMPUR-Cloud, which will keep the midsection cushioned without allowing uncomfortable sinkage throughout the night.
Differences In Mattress Construction
Even though both of these mattresses are built with memory foam, they have some unique materials that set them apart.
|Puffy Mattress Materials||Tempur-Pedic Mattress Materials|
|Polyester cover||Premium knit fabric layer|
|Cooling cloud foam||TEMPUR-ES foam|
|Climate-adaptive foam||Adaptable TEMPUR foam|
|Foam support layer||High-density foam|
The Puffy mattress comes wrapped in a stretchy thin polyester cover, while the TEMPUR-Cloud bed comes with an ultra-breathable moisture-wicking that you can remove and wash.
The Puffy bed has two comfort layers: a gel-infused Cooling Cloud layer, and a climate adaptive layer that helps provide consistent support in every season. The TEMPUR-Cloud has a layer of Tempur-ES comfort foam, which provides a balance of firm support and soft comfort as you lay on the bed.
The Puffy has a 6 inch layer of support foam at the base of the bed. The TEMPUR-Cloud also has a layer of firmer support foam to add extra stability and durability to the bed.
Puffy vs. Tempur-Pedic Pricing
|Size||Puffy Prices||TEMPUR-Cloud Prices|
For exclusive discounts, see our Puffy mattress coupons.
Puffy vs. Tempur-Pedic Mattress Performance Ratings & Differences
If you tend to sleep hot, neither of these memory foam beds will help cool you down. All-foam mattresses can tend to trap heat, so you should opt for an innerspring, hybrid or latex mattress if you need a cooling mattress.
When you sleep with a partner or a pet, you’ll want a bed that will help limit motion transfer so you won’t be disturbed if your sleepmate tends to move around at night. The Puffy’s thick layers do a great job of absorbing movements to help even light sleepers get a restful night’s sleep.
Edge support adds durability to the bed and prevents you from slipping off the sides if you like to perch at the end of the mattress or need extra support as you get in and out of bed. Neither of these all foam beds have above-average edge support.
If you have sore joints or sleep on your side, you’ll want a bed with ample pressure relief. The Puffy bed’s thick comfort layers go above and beyond in this department—they’ll cradle your curves and help redistribute your weight along the length of the bed to keep stress off pressure points. The TEMPUR-Cloud also has a moderate amount of pressure relief that will work for the average sleeper.
A bed that supports your sleep position and body type can help prevent pain. If you are a lightweight sleeper or sleep on your side and weigh under 230 lbs, the Puffy mattress’s fluffy sleeping surface may be a good fit to keep you comfortable. If you sleep on your stomach or are a heavyweight sleeper, the TTEMPUR-Cloud’s firmer level of support may be a better fit to help you wake up without aches and pains.
Both of these beds are made of high quality materials, but the TEMPUR-Cloud’s multi-layer construction will likely hold up for slightly longer.
Shipping, Returns, & Warranties
Puffy offers free shipping through FedEx for those in the contiguous United States, but you can have a Puffy bed delivered to Alaska or Hawaii for a fee. You’ll have a 101 night sleep trial to test the bed and a lifetime warranty if you decide to keep it.
The TEMPUR-Cloud also ships free within the contiguous United States and ships for a fee to Alaska and Hawaii. This bed comes with a 90 day sleep trial period and a 10-year warranty.
Other Models Available
Our Final Take
Each of these all-foam mattresses is suited to a different set of sleepers. If you have a lightweight body type, are a side sleeper under 230 lbs or prefer a fluffy and plush sleeping surface, the Puffy might be a good pick for you. If you like an all-foam feel but need a firmer level of support, the TEMPUR-Cloud is a good choice. Its firm support layer also makes it a good pick for stomach sleepers, heavyweight sleepers, and senior citizens.
Puffy & Tempu-pedic FAQs
Do I need to flip my Puffy mattress?
No. The Puffy mattress is designed so that the comfort layers are positioned closer to the surface of the bed and the support layers are close to the bottom. If you flip this bed, you won’t be able to benefit from the pressure relieving qualities of this mattress.
How long will it take for me to break in my memory foam mattress?
Both the Puffy mattress and the TEMPUR-Cloud mattress will have a break in period. It typically takes between 2-4 weeks for your mattress to break in and soften. Take advantage of your sleep trial period to completely break in your bed before you decide whether it is right for you.
What are the cons of a Tempur-Pedic mattress?
Tempur-Pedic’s great qualities make it one of the most popular mattresses on the market, but it does have a few cons. These mattresses are on the pricier side, and they don’t offer the deep and fluffy pressure relief that many expect from an all-foam mattress.
Puffy Mattress Comparison
Puffy prides itself on providing cloud-like mattresses that accommodate a wide range of sleepers. The Puffy mattress—their flagship model—is a supportive all-foam mattress, while the Puffy Lux and Puffy Royal are plush hybrid mattresses. In this mattress comparison, you’ll learn what makes each of these Puffy beds stand out from their competitors, and find the […]