Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

Mattress Depot Review: Top Picks & Buyers Guide

In an effort to distinguish the company from other mattress retailers, Mattress Depot team members focus on providing value through local vendor shipping, bulk purchases of closeout models, and private labels.

Mattress Depot USA is a family-owned and operated mattress retailer based in Washington state with more than 30 locations in western and eastern Washington, in Oregon, and in Georgia. The company is the largest locally owned mattress retailer in the state of Washington and was founded after the owners, a couple from Washington, experienced discomfort with the traditional “bait and switch” sales tactics used in traditional mattress stores.

At Mattress Depot, you’ll find quality brand names (more than a dozen, to be exact) and a variety of styles, price points, and sizes. If you’re considering purchasing a mattress from Mattress Depot, our Mattress Depot review should help. In this article, we’re sharing our top five mattress brand picks from Mattress Depot. You’ll also find a list of online alternatives if you decide shopping in-store isn’t right for you, and a look into the pros and cons of shopping online versus in-store.

Mattress Depot carries more than one dozen mattress brands including Sealy, Serta, Simmons, and Aireloom in addition to mattresses from local manufacturers like Restonic, Easy Rest, and Americana. This means that the company has a wide selection of mattresses for any price range, whether you’re looking for a high-profile innerspring or a luxury foam mattress. These are our picks for the top five mattress brands to consider if you’re shopping at a Mattress Depot store.

Top 5 Mattresses at Mattress Depot


Editor's Pick

One of Mattress Depot’s most popular mattresses, the Nectar is a “catchall” bed that most buyers will be happy with. It has a reasonable price point, moderate firmness, and pressure-relieving construction.

Nectar Mattress

Reason to Buy

The Nectar is made with three layers of memory foam for pressure relief and excellent motion isolation and offers a mid-level firmness that suits most sleepers. Critics say that the Nectar offers a high-quality night’s sleep at a lower price point than competing models, making it one of Mattress Depot’s highest-value options.

Read our full Nectar Mattress Review to learn more! 

Simmons Beautyrest

Best Cooling

Beautyrest beds excel at temperature regulation thanks to their airflow and cooling BlackICE covers, and they also isolate motion better than other innerspring and hybrid models.

Beautyrest Black Mattress

Reason to Buy

A division under Simmons Bedding Co, Beautyrest offers mattresses in different thickness, firmness, and composition options. These options help ensure a suitable design for sleepers of various weights, sleeping positions, and budgets. If you tend to sleep hot, prefer thick mattresses (13” or more) and enjoy mattresses that conform closely to your body, consider a Beautyrest. 

Check out our full Simons Beautyrest Mattress Review for more information! 


Best Luxury

Aireloom mattresses are sold as part of four exclusive collections, and Mattress Depot sells three of them: Balboa, Montara, and Seaside. Some of the highest end mattresses on the market, this is our recommendation if you have a sizeable budget and want a refined look and feel.

Aireloom karpen sidestitch 2 1

Reason to Buy

Aireloom creates luxury innerspring, hybrid, and latex beds that are known for conforming comfort and durability. The hybrid and latex mattresses are constructed with horsehair and cashmere, and the variety of firmnesses offered accommodate most sleepers. However, little information is available about Aireloom mattresses online—we recommend heading into a Mattress Depot store to investigate this brand in-person.

To learn more read our full Aireloom Mattress Review


Most Variety

Sealy’s three product lines come in Essential, Performance, and Premium collections, which allow you to select the firmness level, price, and construction that’s best suited for your preferences and budget.

Sealy Posturepedic Hybrid Ability Firm

Reason to Buy

Sealy offers both innerspring and hybrid mattresses and has been in the bedding industry since 1881. The company is known for its posturepedic technology, which was created with the help of orthopedic professionals to provide spinal support. Mattress Depot carries 15 Sealy mattresses online and may carry more in stores. Sealy mattresses come in innerspring and hybrid models, with the innerspring options offering strong edge support and a cool sleep surface.

Read our full Sealy Mattress Review to learn more! 


Serta iComfort

Best Memory Foam

The Serta iComfort series offers memory foam mattresses with above-average edge support, motion isolation, and noise reduction. They’re our pick if you’re interested in a luxury memory foam model.


Reason to Buy

Serta offers memory foam mattresses, with the iComfort series featuring a total of seven memory foam mattresses with polyfoam support cores. These beds vary in their components, firmness ratings, and height. The Serta brand also offers innerspring and hybrid models, but Mattress Depot doesn’t carry them. 


Online Alternatives

In today’s marketplace, a growing number of mattress brands and third-party retailers offer mattresses online. If heading to a brick-and-mortar store like Mattress Depot USA is out of the cards for you or sounds inconvenient, there’s never been a better time to shop for a mattress online from the comfort of your home. Plus, buying a mattress online generally means great prices (via discounts and special offers), and many high-quality options are available.

Here’s a list of online mattress shopping alternatives to consider:

  •—Mattress Depot sells mattresses, bed frames, pillows, and more online. Those local to the Pacific Northwest and other shoppers across the country have the opportunity to purchase bedding from this highly recommended store if they’re not able to go in-person. In the best-case scenario, shoppers can visit the store to test the beds they’re considering and then head home to make their purchase online.
  •—Known for its wide selection of furniture and home decor, Wayfair is a one-stop-shop for outfitting an entire bedroom. You can find a mattress, adjustable bases, bed frames, mattress protectors, headboard, duvets, sheets, and decorative throws and pillows in one place.
  •—This online shopping giant offers a great experience from start to finish. A well-designed search engine and plenty of customer reviews will guide you toward the mattress that’s best for you. Amazon offers selections from both high-end, luxury brands and affordable household names. Check out our picks for the Best Mattresses on Amazon
  •—If a mattress purchase from Costco seems strange, think again. This warehouse-style retailer carries excellent options in both its brick-and-mortar stores and online, and the shipping policies are generous.
  • Casper—Casper was founded in 2014 and sells both online direct to consumer and via third-party retailers like Target. This mixed-foam mattress has comfort layers that create a 12” thick profile and has earned quite a few accolades for its value and ability to accommodate sleepers of various sizes and sleeping positions.
  • Purple—For the ‘modern’ sleeper, Purple is known for its innovative grid technology that’s made from a proprietary material that conforms to the body and sleeps cool. These mattresses are sold online only and are an excellent choice for couples because they isolate motion transfer well. Read our full Purple Mattress Review to learn more. 
  • Leesa—Leesa offers a close-conforming, all-foam mattress that’s medium in firmness. They’re sold online and in some West Elm and Pottery Barn stores across the country. This means you could test out a Leesa at a brick-and-mortar store and then head home to take advantage of coupons and specials offered online. Check out our full Leesa Mattress Review for more info. 
  • Tuft & Needle—Tuft & Needle offers all-foam beds that provide a medium-firm feel and excellent pressure relief. They’re one of the most well-known bed-in-a-box brands and operate both a retail website and brick-and-mortar locations. Read our full Tuft & Needle Review to learn more about their offerings. 

Pro and Cons of Buying in a Store vs. Online

There are four ways to purchase a mattress in today’s market: direct from the mattress brand online, direct from the mattress brand at a brick-and-mortar location, through a third-party retailer online, and through a third-party retailer brick-and-mortar location. Generally, however, this breaks down into two choices: online and in-store.

Even locally-owned and operated mattress retailers like Mattress Depot USA offer the option to shop their mattresses in-store and online. Below, we highlight the pros and cons of shopping online and in-store in hopes of shedding light on which might be the best route for you.

Buying a Mattress In-Store


  • You’ll have the opportunity to test the mattresses you’re considering for yourself
  • Most mattress stores offer full-service delivery and setup, including old mattress removal
  • You can chat with a sales representative in person to receive guidance on which mattress is best for you


  • Mattress stores have been known to hire pushy salespeople who work for commission and lead customers towards expensive options and unnecessary bedding accessories
  • You won’t have the selection available online or the ability to easily comparison shop between dozens of styles

Buying a Mattress Online


  • Purchasing a mattress online is much more convenient and less time-consuming than shopping in-person
  • Mattresses sold online are usually less expensive thanks to coupons, discount codes, and the elimination of overhead costs associated with running a brick-and-mortar location
  • The satisfaction rates for online and brick-and-mortar mattress shoppers are almost identical
  • Most online mattress sellers include free delivery and returns
  • You won’t have to deal with pushy salespeople trying to pressure you


  • You won’t have the opportunity to test the mattress
  • Some mattress companies only provide front-door delivery service, meaning you’ll be responsible for moving the mattress inside and assembling it
  • Most online mattress retailers won’t remove your old mattress as part of the delivery
  • Most online mattress sellers don’t have personalized customer service, even if chat windows are offered
  • Mattress sellers and retailers can skew their ratings and reviews, hiding negative reviews from customers and only showing the positive ones