Bear vs. Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Comparison

Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

If you can’t decide between Bear and Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid mattress, there is no need to fret because we have your back. With the information provided here, you’ll be able to make a well-informed decision on which mattress is best for you by weighing each option’s features, benefits, and drawbacks. You can also see more of the client’s reviews on our testing methodology

Product
Firmness
Score
Bear Mattress
Medium-firm: 7/10
4.6/5
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress
Multiple firmness options
4.8/5
Product
Bear Mattress
Firmness
Medium-firm: 7/10
Score
4.6/5
Product
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress
Firmness
Multiple firmness options
Score
4.8/5

Bear vs. Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid Overview

Bear and Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid mattress can excel in various areas to give you a night of quality sleep. Check out more about the differences and similarities of their features from the reviews below.

Bear is best for…Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid is best for…
Lightweight stomach sleepersCombination sleepers
Back sleepers Any sleeping positions
People with active lifestyle Budget-conscious shoppers

Who Should Choose the Bear Mattress?

  • Lightweight stomach sleepers: Lighter-weight stomach sleepers will find sufficient support from the bed’s firmness, as would average-weight combination sleepers who spend some time sleeping on their stomach.
  • Back sleepers: The Bear’s supportive foundation layer and soft top layer make it an excellent choice for back sleepers.
  • People with an active lifestyle: Athletic and fitness enthusiasts may like the active recovery component of the Celliant cover.

Who Should Choose Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid Mattress?

  • Combination sleepers: The Signature Hybrid’s responsive foam top layers and buoyant coil base make it an adjustable mattress for combination sleepers.
  • Any sleeping positions: having options in soft, medium, and firm ensures that practically any sleeper can choose a mattress that suits their needs.
  • Budget-conscious shoppers:  One of the most significant values in hybrid mattresses, the Signature Hybrid features high-quality materials and meticulous craftsmanship at a lower price than the market average.

Bear vs. Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid Mattress Video Comparison

In this part, we will deconstruct the similarities and differences between Bear and Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid mattresses. Keep on reading to choose the best one for you.

Bear vs. Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid: Top Similarities 

  • Mattress Support: Both the Signature Hybrid and the Bear mattresses lift and support you, despite one being grounded by coils and the other by high-density foam. Those who sleep on their stomachs or backs and suffer back pain will find that helpful information.
  • Responsive: The Bear and the Signature Hybrid benefit from sensitive builds that make for excellent surface movement. These mattresses are great options for people who sleep in various positions throughout the night.
  • Warranty: Both these mattresses offer a 10-year warranty catering free of charge refunds within the 30 nights of sleep trial.

Bear vs. Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid: Top Differences 

  • Mattress Cover:  The Bear’s cover is made to transform your body heat into infrared energy, aiding in the repair of your muscles and allowing you to get a more restful night’s sleep. Whereas the Signature Hybrid has a straightforward, soft cotton cover.
  • Firmness Options: The Bear is only available in a medium-firm feel, while the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid offers three different firmness levels; soft, medium, and firm).
  • Mattress Feel: When compared to the Signature Hybrid, the Bear’s all-foam construction is firmer and denser, resulting in less sinkage. The Signature Hybrid, on the other hand, offers the springiness typical of a hybrid mattress constructed with coils.

Bear vs. Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid: Firmness & Feel Differences

Broaden your knowledge about the different firmness and feel of the Bear and Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid mattresses through the specific details below.

What’s the Firmness Of the Bear & Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid Mattresses? 

Light to average-weight back sleepers will feel the best sleeping in the Bear due to the medium-firmness of the mattress. It is soft while giving the right mattress firmness for back support, optimum support, and comfort. Heavyweight body frames may find the Signature Hybrid more customizable since it has three levels of mattress firmness, allowing you to decide better which one can give you more support. These options help you look for the perfect mattress fit for your sleeping position and body frame giving quality sleep ahead. 

What Do the Bear & Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid Mattresses Feel Like?

The Bear mattress has a light sinking sensation giving you that doughy feel. It can hug your body for heavyweight sleepers while also providing a cradling sense for light to average-weight sleepers. On the other hand, the neutral foam feel of the Signature Hybrid means that while it is soft and comfy to rest on, there is no memory foam effect. No matter what firmness level you go with, the soft foam comfort layers will make you feel lifted like you’re sleeping on top of the bed rather than having that body-hugging mattress feel.

What’s It Like to Sleep On the Bear & Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid Mattresses?

Light to average-weight back sleepers will find the Bear mattress supportive for their backs. It can even alleviate pains and provide spine alignment as it is not too soft in sinkage and too firm for a lifted feel. However, heavy-weight stomach and side sleepers may not get the support they seek from the Bear mattress as it can be too soft for these body types. On the flip side, since the Signature Hybrid mattress has three firmness options, back sleepers may find the right mattress to support their weight and be comfortable to sleep in. However, it may not be as supportive to side and stomach sleepers because this mattress can also be too soft, allowing more sinkage than support.

The Bear vs. Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid Mattresses By Body Type

Bear Mattress Performance By Body Type & Sleeping Position:

Body Type:BACK SLEEPERSSTOMACH SLEEPERSSIDE SLEEPERS
Lightweight (< 130 lbs): 543
Average-weight (130–230 lbs):533
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs): 422

Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid Mattress Performance By Body Type & Sleeping Position:

Body Type:BACK SLEEPERSSTOMACH SLEEPERSSIDE SLEEPERS
Lightweight (< 130 lbs): 432
Average-weight (130–230 lbs):533
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs): 424

1 = Very poor, 2 = Not good, 3 = Fair, 4 = Good, 5 = Excellent

Average-Weight Sleepers (130–230 lbs)

As mentioned a couple of times, average-weight back sleepers will find it best to sleep in the Bear mattress because of its medium-firm feel. You can also receive the right amount of sinkage while still being supported. However, stomach and side sleepers in this body frame may not have optimum sleep because it can be too firm for them, and thus, they do not get the proper support for these sleepers. This is also the same concern for the Signature Hybrid mattress.

Heavyweight Sleepers (> 230 lbs)

Heavyweight back sleepers may or may not get the supportive sensation from both mattresses due to the firmness of these two. These mattresses lean more towards providing that body-hugging feel, making it difficult for these body frames to get that support for their backs. If you are a stomach and side sleeper, you may also want to refrain from getting both mattresses unless you wish that cradling and doughy mattress sensation while sleeping.

Lightweight Sleepers (< 130 lbs)

Lightweight back sleepers can benefit from the Bear mattress thanks to its gel foam that alleviate back pain and gives more back support. The same goes for stomach sleepers who require more doughy sensations for quality and light sleep. On the flip side, lightweight sleepers may want to choose a different mattress than the Signature Hybrid because it may not have the sinkage you wish for support. The same goes for stomach sleepers that require a sinkage sensation from their mattresses.

Differences In Mattress Construction 

In this section, we will identify why each mattress is distinct in the comfort and support they provide from their materials.

Bear Mattress Materials ABC Mattress Materials
Quilted Celliant CoverCotton with Quilted Polyfoam
Cooling Graphite-Gel Memory FoamTitanFlex Comfort Foam
Responsive Transition PolyfoamVariFlex Foam
High-Density Support FoamAscension Pocketed Coils High-Density Polyfoam
10″11”

Cover

The Bear mattress has a polyester-blend cover that’s been laced with Celliant fibers. In contrast, the Signature Hybrid mattress is a hybrid design that combines a coil foundation with two layers of unique foam for maximum comfort and a quilted cotton cover.

Comfort Layers

The Bear mattress’s comfort layer comprises graphite- and cooling-gel-infused memory foam, dissipating excess body heat and preventing the mattress from being too hot. The TitanFlex foam of the Signature Hybrid mattress also has been enhanced with gel to make it even cooler to sleep in.

Support Layers

The High-Density Support foam used in the construction of the Bear mattress increases its longevity and ability to prevent motion transfer. The Signature Hybrid’s support layer comprises individually-wrapped coils, which reduce motion transmission and improve edge support.

Bear vs. Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid Mattress Pricing

SizeBear Mattress PricesBrooklyn Signature Hybrid Mattress Prices
Twin$748.00$699.00
Twin XL$811.00$799.00
Full$873.00$899.00
Queen$998.00$1249.00
King$1248.00$1499.00
California King$1248.00$1499.00

For exclusive discounts on both beds, see our Bear mattress coupons and Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid mattress coupons.

Bear vs. Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid Mattress Performance Ratings & Differences

In this section, let us compare and contrast Bear and Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid mattresses for extended support and comfort.

Temperature

Though the Bear’s Celliant cover and gel-infused memory foam help keep things cool, the mattress’s all-foam construction makes it more likely to trap heat. The Signature Hybrid mattress will do an excellent job of maintaining a comfortable temperature for hot sleepers. The coil system improves the bed’s airflow and breathability.

Motion Transfer

The Bear mattress, like other memory foam mattresses, has a layer of memory foam on top that reduces movement. While the thick comfort system and pocketed coils of the Signature Hybrid help it to decrease motion better than most hybrids, the Bear is the superior option if motion transfer is your primary concern.

Edge Support 

There is edge support near the Bear’s corners, but the area quickly sinks inwards. You can use the mattress for sleeping, but it isn’t the best place to take off your shoes or relax. It seems that the firmer the Signature Hybrid mattress, the better the edge support. To prevent excessive sagging, however, even the softer version has a fair amount of support around the edges.

Pressure Relief 

The Bear mattress does not have a particularly deep cradle, but the memory foam in its comfort section does provide some body contouring. While the Signature Hybrid is pleasant, its signature memory foam cradle is absent. If you’re a side sleeper, the soft option may feel the most comfortable, but no matter which firmness level you choose, you won’t be able to sink into the mattress completely.

Pain Relief 

If you suffer from acute pressure points or chronic aches and pains in your back, a mattress without a distinctive memory foam cradle may be too dense for you. The softness of both mattresses makes it possible that pain relief will be compromised.

Durability 

The Bear appears to have the same durability as other high-quality foam beds in this price range, lasting between six and seven years of regular use. The Signature Hybrid mattress, on the other hand, is an excellent buy since it is made with durable materials that are worth the price. It has a lifespan of eight to ten years. 

Shipping, Returns, & Warranties 

Bear 

The Bear is available for free shipping as a bed-in-a-box throughout the continental United States; however, shipping to Alaska and Hawaii may incur additional costs. A 100-night sleep trial period begins on the day of delivery and stipulates that you must use the mattress for at least 30 nights before requesting a full, no-hassle refund. A solid base is required for the mattress’s 10-year limited warranty to be valid, and it will cover only certain problems during that time.

Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid

The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid is delivered as a bed-in-a-box by Brooklyn Bedding for free throughout the 48 contiguous states; however, there is a shipping fee for addresses in Alaska and Hawaii. You may return it for a full refund after 30 nights of use as part of the 120-night sleep trial period that begins the day it arrives. Similarly, the Signature Hybrid offers a 10-year warranty against certain defects.

More Mattresses to Consider

Product
Firmness
Score
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe Mattress
Multiple firmness options
4.0/5
Brooklyn Bedding Plank Firm Mattress
Multiple firmness options
4.0/5
Brooklyn Bedding Bloom Hybrid Mattress
Multiple firmness options
4.8/5
Bear Hybrid Mattress
Medium-firm: 6/10
4.7/5
Bear Pro Mattress
Medium-firm: 6/10
4.9/5
Bear Elite Hybrid Mattress
Multiple firmness options
4.2/5
Product
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe Mattress
Firmness
Multiple firmness options
Score
4.0/5
Product
Brooklyn Bedding Plank Firm Mattress
Firmness
Multiple firmness options
Score
4.0/5
Product
Brooklyn Bedding Bloom Hybrid Mattress
Firmness
Multiple firmness options
Score
4.8/5
Product
Bear Hybrid Mattress
Firmness
Medium-firm: 6/10
Score
4.7/5
Product
Bear Pro Mattress
Firmness
Medium-firm: 6/10
Score
4.9/5
Product
Bear Elite Hybrid Mattress
Firmness
Multiple firmness options
Score
4.2/5

Haven’t made a decision yet? Check out these other comparisons:

Our Final Take

The main differences between the Bear and the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid come down to cost, feel, and firmness optionsIf you’re a value shopper looking for a great hybrid for the money, the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid is hard to beat with its high-quality materials and thoughtful design. It’s also our pick for shoppers who want multiple firmness options

If you’re an athlete or interested in the benefits of Celliant, the Bear could be a nice investment for you. If you want a memory foam feel and excellent motion isolation, we also recommend the Bear.

Bear & Brooklyn’s Signature Hybrid FAQs

I am a hot sleeper; which mattress is best for me?

While both mattresses have distinct cooling materials, the Signature Hybrid should maintain a comfortable temperature throughout the night. Its coil system allows for more airflow and better ventilation in the mattress, which can be more cooling to hot sleepers, especially at night.

Which mattress best suits my preference for having a firmer cushion?

Although both mattresses are soft, especially since the Signature Hybrid even offers firmness options, you might want to choose the Bear mattress because it is soft but does not have that doughy and body-hugging cushion. You will feel on top of the mattress rather than enclosed.

How do I know which mattress best suits my needs?

You want to know what type of body aches, your preferred sleeping position, and your body frame to get the right mattress. Knowing all this information but not understanding your body type and sleeping habit might affect your sleep quality, so ensure you bring up these details first.